Transmission, Distribution & Storage
Optimal Design and Analysis of a Hybrid Hydrogen Energy Storage System for an Island-Based Renewable Energy Community
Oct 2023
Publication
Installations of decentralised renewable energy systems (RES) are becoming increasing popular as governments introduce ambitious energy policies to curb emissions and slow surging energy costs. This work presents a novel model for optimal sizing for a decentralised renewable generation and hybrid storage system to create a renewable energy community (REC) developed in Python. The model implements photovoltaic (PV) solar and wind turbines combined with a hybrid battery and regenerative hydrogen fuel cell (RHFC). The electrical service demand was derived using real usage data from a rural island case study location. Cost remuneration was managed with an REC virtual trading layer ensuring fair distribution among actors in accordance with the European RED(III) policy. A multi-objective genetic algorithm (GA) stochastically determines the system capacities such that the inherent trade-off relationship between project cost and decarbonisation can be observed. The optimal design resulted in a levelized cost of electricity (LCOE) of 0.15 EUR/kWh reducing costs by over 50% compared with typical EU grid power with a project internal rate of return (IRR) of 10.8% simple return of 9.6%/year and return on investment (ROI) of 9 years. The emissions output from grid-only use was reduced by 72% to 69 gCO2 e/kWh. Further research of lifetime economics and additional revenue streams in combination with this work could provide a useful tool for users to quickly design and prototype future decentralised REC systems.
Hydrogen Gas Compression for Efficient Storage: Balancing Energy and Increasing Density
May 2024
Publication
This article analyzes the processes of compressing hydrogen in the gaseous state an aspect considered important due to its contribution to the greater diffusion of hydrogen in both the civil and industrial sectors. This article begins by providing a concise overview and comparison of diverse hydrogen-storage methodologies laying the groundwork with an in-depth analysis of hydrogen’s thermophysical properties. It scrutinizes plausible configurations for hydrogen compression aiming to strike a delicate balance between energy consumption derived from the fuel itself and the requisite number of compression stages. Notably to render hydrogen storage competitive in terms of volume pressures of at least 350 bar are deemed essential albeit at an energy cost amounting to approximately 10% of the fuel’s calorific value. Multi-stage compression emerges as a crucial strategy not solely for energy efficiency but also to curtail temperature rises with an upper limit set at 200 ◦C. This nuanced approach is underlined by the exploration of compression levels commonly cited in the literature particularly 350 bar and 700 bar. The study advocates for a three-stage compression system as a pragmatic compromise capable of achieving high-pressure solutions while keeping compression work below 10 MJ/kg a threshold indicative of sustainable energy utilization.
Energy Storage Strategy - Phase 3
Feb 2023
Publication
This report evaluates the main options to provide required hydrogen storage capacity including the relevant system-level considerations and provides recommendations for further actions including low-regrets actions that are needed in a range of scenarios.
Benchmark of J55 and X56 Steels on Cracking and Corrosion Effects Under Hydrogen Salt Cavern Boundary Conditions
Feb 2024
Publication
Salt caverns have great potential to store relevant amounts of hydrogen as part of the energy transition. However the durability and suitability of commonly used steels for piping in hydrogen salt caverns is still under research. In this work aging effects focusing on corrosion and cracking patterns of casing steel API 5CT J55 and “H2ready” pipeline steel API 5L X56 were investigated with scanning electron microscopy and energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy after accelerated stress tests with pressure/temperature cycling under hydrogen salt cavern-like conditions. Compared to dry conditions significant more corrosion by presence of salt ions was detected. However compared to X56 only for J55 an intensification of corrosion and cracking at the surface due to hydrogen atmosphere was revealed. Pronounced surface cracks were observed for J55 over the entire samples. Overall the results strongly suggest that X56 is more resistant than J55 under the conditions of a hydrogen salt cavern.
Techno-economic Analysis of Developing an Underground Hydrogen Storage Facility in Depleted Gas Field: A Dutch Case Study
Apr 2023
Publication
Underground hydrogen storage will be an essential part of the future hydrogen infrastructure to provide flexibility and security of supply. Storage in porous reservoirs should complement storage in salt caverns to be able to meet the projected high levels of required storage capacities. To assess its techno-economic feasibility a case study of hydrogen storage in a depleted gas field in the Netherlands is developed. Subsurface modelling is performed and various surface facility design concepts are investigated to calculate the levelized cost of hydrogen storage (LCOHS). Our base case with hydrogen as cushion gas results in an LCOHS of 0.79 EUR/kg (range of 0.58–1.04 EUR/kg). Increasing the number of full-cycle equivalents from 1 to 6 lowers the storage cost to 0.25 EUR/kg. The investment cost of the cushion gas represents 76% of the total cost. With nitrogen as cushion gas LCOHS is reduced to 0.49 EUR/kg (range of 0.42–0.56 EUR/kg).
Hydrogen Trapping and Embrittlement in Metals - A Review
Apr 2024
Publication
Hydrogen embrittlement in metals (HE) is a serious challenge for the use of high strength materials in engineering practice and a major barrier to the use of hydrogen for global decarbonization. Here we describe the factors and variables that determine HE susceptibility and provide an overview of the latest understanding of HE mechanisms. We discuss hydrogen uptake and how it can be managed. We summarize hydrogen trapping and the techniques used for its characterization. We also review literature that argues that hydrogen trapping can be used to decrease HE susceptibility. We discuss the future research that is required to advance the understanding of HE and hydrogen trapping and to develop HE-resistant alloys.
Biological Hydrogen Methanation with Carbon Dioxide Utilization: Methanation Acting as Mediator in the Hydrogen Economy
May 2023
Publication
Hydrogen is one of the main energy carriers playing a prominent role in the future decarbonization of the economy. However several aspects regarding the transport and storage of this gas are challenging. The intermediary conversion of hydrogen into high-density energy molecules may be a crucial step until technological conditions are ready to attain a significant reduction in fossil fuel use in transport and the industrial sector. The process of transforming hydrogen into methane by anaerobic digestion is reviewed showing that this technology is a feasible option for facilitating hydrogen storage and transport. The manuscript focuses on the role of anaerobic digestion as a technology driver capable of fast adaptation to current energy needs. The use of thermophilic systems and reactors capable of increasing the contact between the H2 -fuel and liquid phase demonstrated outstanding capabilities attaining higher conversion rates and increasing methane productivity. Pressure is a relevant factor of the process allowing for better hydrogen solubility and setting the basis for considering feasible underground hydrogen storage concomitant with biological methanation. This feature may allow the integration of sequestered carbon dioxide as a relevant substrate.
Magnesium-Based Hydrogen Storage Alloys: Advances, Strategies, and Future Outlook for Clean Energy Applications
May 2024
Publication
Magnesium-based hydrogen storage alloys have attracted significant attention as promising materials for solid-state hydrogen storage due to their high hydrogen storage capacity abundant reserves low cost and reversibility. However the widespread application of these alloys is hindered by several challenges including slow hydrogen absorption/desorption kinetics high thermodynamic stability of magnesium hydride and limited cycle life. This comprehensive review provides an in-depth overview of the recent advances in magnesium-based hydrogen storage alloys covering their fundamental properties synthesis methods modification strategies hydrogen storage performance and potential applications. The review discusses the thermodynamic and kinetic properties of magnesium-based alloys as well as the effects of alloying nanostructuring and surface modification on their hydrogen storage performance. The hydrogen absorption/desorption properties of different magnesium-based alloy systems are compared and the influence of various modification strategies on these properties is examined. The review also explores the potential applications of magnesium-based hydrogen storage alloys including mobile and stationary hydrogen storage rechargeable batteries and thermal energy storage. Finally the current challenges and future research directions in this field are discussed highlighting the need for fundamental understanding of hydrogen storage mechanisms development of novel alloy compositions optimization of modification strategies integration of magnesium-based alloys into hydrogen storage systems and collaboration between academia and industry.
Subsurface Renewable Energy Storage Capcity for Hydrogen, Methane and Compress Air - A Performance Assessment Study from the North German Basin
Jul 2021
Publication
The transition to renewable energy sources to mitigate climate change will require large-scale energy storage to dampen the fluctuating availability of renewable sources and to ensure a stable energy supply. Energy storage in the geological subsurface can provide capacity and support the cycle times required. This study investigates hydrogen storage methane storage and compressed air energy storage in subsurface porous formations and quantifies potential storage capacities as well as storage rates on a site-specific basis. For part of the North German Basin used as the study area potential storage sites are identified employing a newly developed structural geological model. Energy storage capacities estimated from a volume-based approach are 6510 TWh and 24544 TWh for hydrogen and methane respectively. For a consistent comparison of storage capacities including compressed air energy storage the stored exergy is calculated as 6735 TWh 25795 TWh and 358 TWh for hydrogen methane and compressed air energy storage respectively. Evaluation of storage deliverability indicates that high deliverability rates are found mainly in two of the three storage formations considered. Even accounting for the uncertainty in geological parameters the storage potential for the three considered storage technologies is significantly larger than the predicted demand and suitable storage rates are achievable in all storage formations.
Review on the Thermal Neutrality of Application-orientated Liquid Organic Hydrogen Carrier for Hydrogen Energy Storage and Delivery
Aug 2023
Publication
The depletion and overuse of fossil fuels present formidable challenge to energy supply system and environment. The human society is in great need of clean renewable and sustainable energy which can guarantee the long-term utilization without leading to escalation of greenhouse effect. Hydrogen as an extraordinary secondary energy is capable of realizing the target of environmental protection and transferring the intermittent primary energy to the application terminal while its nature of low volumetric energy density and volatility need suitable storage method and proper carrier. In this context liquid organic hydrogen carrier (LOHC) among a series of storage methods such as compressed and liquefied hydrogen provokes a considerable amount of research interest since it is proven to be a suitable carrier for hydrogen with safety and stability. However the dehydrogenation of hydrogen-rich LOHC materials is an endothermic process and needs large energy consumption which hampers the scale up of the LOHC system. The heat issue is thus essential to be addressed for fulfilling the potential of LOHC. In this work several strategies of heat intensification and management for LOHC system including the microwave irradiation circulation of exhaust heat and direct LOHC fuel cell are summarized and analyzed to provide suggestions and directions for future research.
Use of Existing Gas Infrastructure in European Hydrogen Economy
Apr 2023
Publication
The rapidly increasing production volume of clean hydrogen creates challenges for transport infrastructure. This study improves understanding of hydrogen transport options in Europe and provides more detailed analysis on the prospects for hydrogen transport in Finland. Previous studies and ongoing pipeline projects were reviewed to identify potential and barriers to hydrogen transport. A fatigue life assessment tool was built because material challenges have been one of the main concerns of hydrogen transportation. Many European countries aim at utilizing existing gas infrastructure for hydrogen. Conducted studies and pilot facilities have provided promising results. Hydrogen reduces the fatigue life of the pipeline but existing pipelines can be used for hydrogen if pressure variation is maintained at a reasonable level and the maximum operation pressure is limited. Moreover the use of existing pipelines can reduce hydrogen transport costs but the suitability of every pipeline for hydrogen must be analyzed and several issues such as leakage leakage detection effects of hydrogen on pipeline assets and end users corrosion maintenance and metering of gas flow must be considered. The development of hydrogen transport will vary within countries depending on the structure of the existing gas infrastructure and on the future hydrogen use profile.
Inspection of Coated Hydrogen Transportation Pipelines
Sep 2023
Publication
The growing need for hydrogen indicates that there is likely to be a demand for transporting hydrogen. Hydrogen pipelines are an economical option but the issue of hydrogen damage to pipeline steels needs to be studied and investigated. So far limited research has been dedicated to determining how the choice of inspection method for pipeline integrity management changes depending on the presence of a coating. Thus this review aims to evaluate the effectiveness of inspection methods specifically for detecting the defects formed uniquely in coated hydrogen pipelines. The discussion will begin with a background of hydrogen pipelines and the common defects seen in these pipelines. This will also include topics such as blended hydrogen-natural gas pipelines. After which the focus will shift to pipeline integrity management methods and the effectiveness of current inspection methods in the context of standards such as ASME B31.12 and BS 7910. The discussion will conclude with a summary of newly available inspection methods and future research directions.
CFD Thermo‑Hydraulic Evaluation of a Liquid Hydrogen Storage Tank with Different Insulation Thickness in a Small‑Scale Hydrogen Liquefier
Aug 2023
Publication
Accurate evaluation of thermo‑fluid dynamic characteristics in tanks is critically important for designing liquid hydrogen tanks for small‑scale hydrogen liquefiers to minimize heat leakage into the liquid and ullage. Due to the high costs most future liquid hydrogen storage tank designs will have to rely on predictive computational models for minimizing pressurization and heat leakage. Therefore in this study to improve the storage efficiency of a small‑scale hydrogen liquefier a three‑ dimensional CFD model that can predict the boil‑off rate and the thermo‑fluid characteristics due to heat penetration has been developed. The prediction performance and accuracy of the CFD model was validated based on comparisons between its results and previous experimental data and a good agreement was obtained. To evaluate the insulation performance of polyurethane foam with three different insulation thicknesses the pressure changes and thermo‑fluid characteristics in a partially liquid hydrogen tank subject to fixed ambient temperature and wind velocity were investigated nu‑ merically. It was confirmed that the numerical simulation results well describe not only the temporal variations in the thermal gradient due to coupling between the buoyance and convection but also the buoyancy‑driven turbulent flow characteristics inside liquid hydrogen storage tanks with differ‑ ent insulation thicknesses. In the future the numerical model developed in this study will be used for optimizing the insulation systems of storage tanks for small‑scale hydrogen liquefiers which is a cost‑effective and highly efficient approach.
Small-Scale High-Pressure Hydrogen Storage Vessels: A Review
Feb 2024
Publication
Nowadays high-pressure hydrogen storage is the most commercially used technology owing to its high hydrogen purity rapid charging/discharging of hydrogen and low-cost manufacturing. Despite numerous reviews on hydrogen storage technologies there is a relative scarcity of comprehensive examinations specifically focused on high-pressure gaseous hydrogen storage and its associated materials. This article systematically presents the manufacturing processes and materials used for a variety of high-pressure hydrogen storage containers including metal cylinders carbon fiber composite cylinders and emerging glass material-based hydrogen storage containers. Furthermore it introduces the relevant principles and theoretical studies showcasing their advantages and disadvantages compared to conventional high-pressure hydrogen storage containers. Finally this article provides an outlook on the future development of high-pressure hydrogen storage containers.
Prospectivity Analysis for Underground Hydrogen Storage, Taranaki Basin, Aotearoa New Zealand: A Multi-criteria Decision-making Approach
May 2024
Publication
Seasonal underground hydrogen storage (UHS) in porous media provides an as yet untested method for storing surplus renewable energy and balancing our energy demands. This study investigates the technical suitability for UHS in depleted hydrocarbon fields and one deep aquifer site in Taranaki Basin Aotearoa New Zealand. Prospective sites are assessed using a decision tree approach providing a “fast-track” method for identifying potential sites and a decision matrix approach for ranking optimal sites. Based on expert elicitation the most important factors to consider are storage capacity reservoir depth and parameters that affect hydrogen injectivity/withdrawal and containment. Results from both approaches suggest that Paleogene reservoirs from gas (or gas cap) fields provide the best option for demonstrating UHS in Aotearoa New Zealand and that the country’s projected 2050 hydrogen storage demand could be exceeded by developing one or two high ranking sites. Lower priority is assigned to heterolithic and typically finer grained labile and clay-rich Miocene oil reservoirs and to deep aquifers that have no proven hydrocarbon containment.
Storage Integrity During Underground Hydrogen Storage in Depleted Gas Reservoirs
Nov 2023
Publication
The transition from fossil fuels to renewable energy sources particularly hydrogen has emerged as a central strategy for decarbonization and the pursuit of net-zero carbon emissions. Meeting the demand for large-scale hydrogen storage a crucial component of the hydrogen supply chain has led to the exploration of underground hydrogen storage as an economically viable solution to global energy needs. In contrast to other subsurface storage options such as salt caverns and aquifers which are geographically limited depleted gas reservoirs have garnered increasing attention due to their broader distribution and higher storage capacity. However the safe storage and cycling of hydrogen in depleted gas reservoirs require the preservation of high stability and integrity in the caprock reservoir and wellbore. Nevertheless there exists a significant gap in the current research concerning storage integrity in underground hydrogen storage within depleted gas reservoirs and a systematic approach is lacking. This paper aims to address this gap by reviewing the primary challenges associated with storage integrity including geochemical reactions microbial activities faults and fractures and perspectives on hydrogen cycling. The study comprehensively reviews the processes and impacts such as abiotic and biotic mineral dissolution/precipitation reactivation and propagation of faults and fractures in caprock and host-rock wellbore instability due to cement degradation and casing corrosion and stress changes during hydrogen cycling. To provide a practical solution a technical screening tool has been developed considering controlling variables risks and consequences affecting storage integrity. Finally this paper highlights knowledge gaps and suggests feasible methods and pathways to mitigate these risks facilitating the development of large-scale underground hydrogen storage in depleted gas reservoirs.
Energy Storage Strategy - Phase 2
Feb 2023
Publication
This document is phase 2 of the energy storage strategy study and it covers the storage challenges of the energy transition. We start in section 3 by covering historical and current natural gas imports into the UK and what these could look like in the future. In section 4 we explore what demand for hydrogen could look like – this has a high level of uncertainty and future policy decisions will have significant impacts on hydrogen volumes and annual variations. We generated two hydrogen storage scenarios based on National Grid’s Future Energy Scenarios and the Climate Change Committee’s Sixth Carbon Budget to assess the future need for hydrogen storage in the UK. We also looked at an extreme weather scenario resulting from an area of high-pressure settled over the British Isles resulting in very low ambient temperatures an unusually high demand for heating and almost no wind generation. In section 5 we investigate options for hydrogen storage and build on work previously carried out by SGN. We discuss the differences between the properties of hydrogen and natural gas and how this affects line pack and depletion of line pack. We discuss flexibility on the supply and demand side and how this can impact on hydrogen storage. We provide a summary table which compares the various options for storage. In section 5 we explore hydrogen trade and options for import and export. Using information from other innovation projects we also discuss production of hydrogen from nuclear power and the impact of hybrid appliances on gas demand for domestic heat. In section 7 we discuss the outputs from a stakeholder workshop with about 40 stakeholders across industry academia and government. The workshop covered UK gas storage strategy to date hydrogen demand and corresponding storage scenarios to 2050 including consideration of seasonal variation and storage options.
Safe Pipelines for Hydrogen Transport
Jun 2024
Publication
The hydrogen compatibility of two X65 pipeline steels for transport of hydrogen gas is investigated through microstructural characterization hydrogen permeation measurements and fracture mechanical testing. The investigated materials are a quenched and tempered pipeline steel with a fine-grained homogeneously distributed ferrite-bainite microstructure and hot rolled pipeline steel with a ferrite-pearlite banded microstructure. All tests are performed both under electrochemical and gaseous hydrogen charging conditions. A correlation between electrochemical hydrogen charging and gaseous charging is determined. The results point to inherent differences in the interaction between hydrogen and the two material microstructures. Further research is needed to unveil the influence of material microstructure on hydrogen embrittlement.
No more items...