Netherlands
Comprehensive Review of Geomechanics of Underground Hydrogen Storage in Depleted Reservoirs and Salt Caverns
Sep 2023
Publication
Hydrogen is a promising energy carrier for a low-carbon future energy system as it can be stored on a megaton scale (equivalent to TWh of energy) in subsurface reservoirs. However safe and efficient underground hydrogen storage requires a thorough understanding of the geomechanics of the host rock under fluid pressure fluctuations. In this context we summarize the current state of knowledge regarding geomechanics relevant to carbon dioxide and natural gas storage in salt caverns and depleted reservoirs. We further elaborate on how this knowledge can be applied to underground hydrogen storage. The primary focus lies on the mechanical response of rocks under cyclic hydrogen injection and production fault reactivation the impact of hydrogen on rock properties and other associated risks and challenges. In addition we discuss wellbore integrity from the perspective of underground hydrogen storage. The paper provides insights into the history of energy storage laboratory scale experiments and analytical and simulation studies at the field scale. We also emphasize the current knowledge gaps and the necessity to enhance our understanding of the geomechanical aspects of hydrogen storage. This involves developing predictive models coupled with laboratory scale and field-scale testing along with benchmarking methodologies.
Multiperiod Modeling and Optimization of Hydrogen-Based Dense Energy Carrier Supply Chains
Feb 2024
Publication
The production of hydrogen-based dense energy carriers (DECs) has been proposed as a combined solution for the storage and dispatch of power generated through intermittent renewables. Frameworks that model and optimize the production storage and dispatch of generated energy are important for data-driven decision making in the energy systems space. The proposed multiperiod framework considers the evolution of technology costs under different levels of promotion through research and targeted policies using the year 2021 as a baseline. Furthermore carbon credits are included as proposed by the 45Q tax amendment for the capture sequestration and utilization of carbon. The implementation of the mixed-integer linear programming (MILP) framework is illustrated through computational case studies to meet set hydrogen demands. The trade-offs between different technology pathways and contributions to system expenditure are elucidated and promising configurations and technology niches are identified. It is found that while carbon credits can subsidize carbon capture utilization and sequestration (CCUS) pathways substantial reductions in the cost of novel processes are needed to compete with extant technology pathways. Further research and policy push can reduce the levelized cost of hydrogen (LCOH) by upwards of 2 USD/kg.
Stakeholder Perspectives on the Scale-up of Green Hydrogen and Electrolyzers
Nov 2023
Publication
Green hydrogen is a promising alternative to fossil fuels. However current production capacities for electrolyzers and green hydrogen are not in line with national political goals and projected demand. Considering these issues we conducted semi-structured interviews to determine the narratives of different stakeholders during this transformation as well as challenges and opportunities for the green hydrogen value chain. We interviewed eight experts with different roles along the green hydrogen value chain ranging from producers and consumers of green hydrogen to electrolyzer manufacturers and consultants as well as experts from the political sphere. Most experts see the government as necessary for scale-up by setting national capacity targets policy support and providing subsidies. However the experts also accuse the governments of delaying development through overregulation and long implementation times for regulations. The main challenges that were identified are the current lack of renewable electricity and demand for green hydrogen. Demand for green hydrogen is influenced by supply costs which partly depend on prices for electrolyzers. However one key takeaway of the interviews is the skeptical assessments by the experts on the currently discussed estimates for price reduction potential of electrolyzers. While demand supply and prices are all factors that influence each other they result in feedback loops in investment decisions for the energy and manufacturing industries. A second key takeaway is that according to the experts current investment decisions in new production capacities are not solely dependent on short-term financial gains but also based on expected first mover advantages. These include experience and market share which are seen as factors for opportunities for future financial gains. Summarized the results present several challenges and opportunities for green hydrogen and electrolyzers and how to address them effectively. These insights contribute to a deeper understanding of the dynamics of the emerging green hydrogen value chain.
Hazard Identification of Hydrogen-Based Alternative Fuels Onboard Ships
Dec 2023
Publication
It is essential to use alternative fuels if we are to reach the emission reduction targets set by the IMO. Hydrogen carriers are classified as zero-emission while having a higher energy density (including packing factor) than pure hydrogen. They are often considered as safe alternative fuels. The exact definition of what safety entails is often lacking both for hydrogen carriers as well as for ship safety. The aim of this study is to review the safety of hydrogen carriers from two perspectives investigating potential connections between the chemical and maritime approaches to safety. This enables a reasoned consideration between safety aspects and other design drivers in ship design and operation. The hydrogen carriers AB NaBH4 KBH4 and two LOHCs (NEC and DBT) are taken into consideration together with a couple reference fuels (ammonia methanol and MDO). After the evaluation of chemical properties related to safety and the scope of the current IMO safety framework it can be concluded that safety remains a vague and non-explicit concept from both perspectives. Therefore further research is required to prove the safe application of hydrogen carriers onboard ships.
Lifetime Design, Operation, and Cost Analysis for the Energy System of a Retrofitted Cargo Vessel with Fuel Cells and Batteries
Oct 2024
Publication
Fuel cell-battery electric drivetrains are attractive alternatives to reduce the shipping emissions. This research focuses on emission-free cargo vessels and provides insight on the design lifetime operation and costs of hydrogen-hybrid systems which require further research for increased utilization. A representative round trip is created by analysing one-year operational data based on load ramps and power frequency. A low-pass filter controller is employed for power distribution. For the lifetime cost analysis 14 scenarios with varying capital and operational expenses were considered. The Net Present Value of the retrofitted fuel cell-battery propulsion system can be up to $ 2.2 million lower or up to $ 18.8 million higher than the original diesel mechanical configuration highly dependent on the costs of green hydrogen and carbon taxes. The main propulsion system weights and volumes of the two versions are comparable but the hydrogen tank (68 tons 193 m3 ) poses significant design and safety challenges.
Techno-economic Analysis of Underground Hydrogen Storage in Europe
Dec 2023
Publication
Hydrogen storage is crucial to developing secure renewable energy systems to meet the European Union’s 2050 carbon neutrality objectives. However a knowledge gap exists concerning the site-specific performance and economic viability of utilizing underground gas storage (UGS) sites for hydrogen storage in Europe. We compile information on European UGS sites to assess potential hydrogen storage capacity and evaluate the associated current and future costs. The total hydrogen storage potential in Europe is 349 TWh of working gas energy (WGE) with site-specific capital costs ranging from $10 million to $1 billion. Porous media and salt caverns boasting a minimum storage capacity of 0.5 TWh WGE exhibit levelized costs of $1.5 and $0.8 per kilogram of hydrogen respectively. It is estimated that future levelized costs associated with hydrogen storage can potentially decrease to as low as $0.4 per kilogram after three experience cycles. Leveraging these techno-economic considerations we identify suitable storage sites.
Impact on Canadian Residential End Use Appliances with the Introduction of Hydrogen into the Natural Gas Stream - An Application
Sep 2023
Publication
Canada’s commitment to be net-zero by 2050 combined with ATCO’s own Environmental Social and Governance goals has led ATCO to pursue hydrogen blending within the existing natural gas system to reduce CO2 emissions while continuing to provide safe reliable energy service to customers. Utilization of hydrogen in the distribution system is the least-cost alternative for decarbonizing the heating loads in jurisdictions like Alberta where harsh winter climates are encountered and low-carbon hydrogen production can be abundant. ATCO’s own Fort Saskatchewan Hydrogen Blending Project began blending 5% hydrogen by volume to over 2100 customers in the Fall of 2022 and plans to increase the blend rates to 20% hydrogen in 2023. Prior to blending ATCO worked together with DNV to examine the impact of hydrogen blended natural gas to twelve Canadian appliances: range/stove oven garage heater high and medium efficiency furnaces conventional and on demand hot water heaters barbeque clothes dryer radiant heater and two gas fireplaces. The tests were performed not only within the planned blend rates of 0-20% hydrogen but also to higher percentages to determine how much hydrogen can be blended into a system before appliance retrofits would be required. The testing was designed to get insights on safety-related combustion issues such as flash-back burner overheating flame detection and other performance parameters such as emissions and burner power. The experimental results indicate that the radiant heater is the most sensitive appliance for flashback observed at 30 vol% hydrogen in natural gas. At 50% hydrogen the range and the radiant burner of the barbeque tested were found to be sensitive to flashback. All other 9 appliances were found to be robust for flashback with no other short-term issues observed. This paper will detail the findings of ATCO and DNV’s appliance testing program including results on failure mechanisms and sensitivities for each appliance.
The Future Role of Offshore Renewable Energy Technologies in the North Sea Energy System
Jul 2024
Publication
Offshore renewables are expected to play a significant role in achieving the ambitious emission targets set by the North Sea countries. Among other factors energy technology costs and their cost reduction potential determine their future role in the energy system. While fixed-bottom offshore wind is well-established and competitive in this region generation costs of other emerging offshore renewable technologies remain high. Hence it is vital to better understand the future role of offshore renewables in the North Sea energy system and the impact of technological learning on their optimal deployments which is not well-studied in the current literature. This study implements an improved framework of integrated energy system analysis to overcome the stated knowledge gap. The approach applies detailed spatial constraints and opportunities of energy infrastructure deployment in the North Sea and also technology cost reduction forecasts of offshore renewables. Both of these parameters are often excluded or overlooked in similar analyses leading to overestimation of benefits and technology deployments in the energy system. Three significant conclusions are derived from this study. First offshore wind plays a crucial role in the North Sea power sector where deployment grows to a maximum of 498 GW by 2050 (222 GW of fixed-bottom and 276 GW of floating wind) from 100 GW in 2030 contributing up to 51% of total power generation and declining cumulative system cost of power and hydrogen system by 4.2% (approx. 40 billion EUR in cost savings) when compared with the slow learning and constrained space use case. Second floating wind deployment is highly influenced by its cost reduction trend and ability to produce hydrogen offshore; emphasizing the importance of investing in floating wind in this decade as the region lacks commercial deployments that would stimulate its cost reduction. Also the maximum floating wind deployment in the North Sea energy system declined by 70% (162 GW from 276 GW) when offshore hydrogen production was avoided while fixed-bottom offshore wind deployment remains unchanged. Lastly the role of other emerging offshore renewables remains limited in all scenarios considered as they are expensive compared to other technology choices in the system. However around 8 GW of emerging technologies was observed in Germany and the Netherlands when the deployment potential of fixed-bottom offshore wind became exhausted.
Towards Renewable Hydrogen-based Electrolysis: Alkaline vs Proton Exchange Membrane
Jul 2023
Publication
This paper focuses on the battle for a dominant design for renewable hydrogen electrolysis in which the designs alkaline and proton exchange membrane compete for dominance. First a literature review is performed to determine the most relevant factors that influence technology dominance. Following that a Best Worst Method analysis is conducted by interviewing multiple industry experts. The most important factors appear to be: Price Safety Energy consumption Flexibility Lifetime Stack size and Materials used. The opinion of experts on Proton Exchange Membrane and alkaline electrolyser technologies is slightly skewed in favour of alkaline technologies. However the margin is too small to identify a winner in this technology battle. The following paper contributes to the ongoing research on modelling the process of technology selection in the energy sector.
Impact of Large-scale Hydrogen Electrification and Retrofitting of Natural Gas Infrastructure on the European Power System
Nov 2023
Publication
In this paper we aim to analyse the impact of hydrogen production decarbonisation and electrification scenarios on the infrastructure development generation mix CO2 emissions and system costs of the European power system considering the retrofit of the natural gas infrastructure. We define a reference scenario for the European power system in 2050 and use scenario variants to obtain additional insights by breaking down the effects of different assumptions. The scenarios were analysed using the European electricity market model COMPETES including a proposed formulation to consider retrofitting existing natural gas networks to transport hydrogen instead of methane. According to the results 60% of the EU’s hydrogen demand is electrified and approximately 30% of the total electricity demand will be to cover that hydrogen demand. The primary source of this electricity would be non-polluting technologies. Moreover hydrogen flexibility significantly increases variable renewable energy investment and production and reduces CO2 emissions. In contrast relying on only electricity transmission increases costs and CO2 emissions emphasising the importance of investing in an H2 network through retrofitting or new pipelines. In conclusion this paper shows that electrifying hydrogen is necessary and cost-effective to achieve the EU’s objective of reducing long-term emissions.
Modelling of Hydrogen Dispersion with Effects
Sep 2023
Publication
The paper shows the latest developments of Gexcon’s consequence modelling software EFFECTS with validation based on hydrogen experimental data for different storage conditions and scenarios including liquid hydrogen two-phase jet releases. The effect of atmospheric turbulence on the dispersion and potential worst-case scenarios of hydrogen which are very different from heavy gas releases are discussed. Beside validation for gaseous hydrogen releases a validation study for pressurised liquid hydrogen jet releases including a sensitivity analysis is performed and the results are compared with experimental data.
A Novel Sustainable Approach for Site Selection of Underground Hydrogen Storage in Poland Using Deep Learning
Jul 2024
Publication
This research investigates the potential of using bedded salt formations for underground hydrogen storage. We present a novel artificial intelligence framework that employs spatial data analysis and multi-criteria decision-making to pinpoint the most appropriate sites for hydrogen storage in salt caverns. This methodology incorporates a comprehensive platform enhanced by a deep learning algorithm specifically a convolutional neural network (CNN) to generate suitability maps for rock salt deposits for hydrogen storage. The efficacy of the CNN algorithm was assessed using metrics such as Mean Absolute Error (MAE) Mean Squared Error (MSE) Root Mean Square Error (RMSE) and the Correlation Coefficient (R2 ) with comparisons made to a real-world dataset. The CNN model showed outstanding performance with an R2 of 0.96 MSE of 1.97 MAE of 1.003 and RMSE of 1.4. This novel approach leverages advanced deep learning techniques to offer a unique framework for assessing the viability of underground hydrogen storage. It presents a significant advancement in the field offering valuable insights for a wide range of stakeholders and facilitating the identification of ideal sites for hydrogen storage facilities thereby supporting informed decisionmaking and sustainable energy infrastructure development.
Charting the Course: Navigating Decarbonisation Pathways in Greece, Germany, The Netherlands, and Spain’s Industrial Sectors
Jul 2024
Publication
In the quest for a sustainable future energy-intensive industries (EIIs) stand at the forefront of Europe’s decarbonisation mission. Despite their significant emissions footprint the path to comprehensive decarbonisation remains elusive at EU and national levels. This study scrutinises key sectors such as non-ferrous metals steel cement lime chemicals fertilisers ceramics and glass. It maps out their current environmental impact and potential for mitigation through innovative strategies. The analysis spans across Spain Greece Germany and the Netherlands highlighting sector-specific ecosystems and the technological breakthroughs shaping them. It addresses the urgency for the industry-wide adoption of electrification the utilisation of green hydrogen biomass bio-based or synthetic fuels and the deployment of carbon capture utilisation and storage to ensure a smooth transition. Investment decisions in EIIs will depend on predictable economic and regulatory landscapes. This analysis discusses the risks associated with continued investment in high-emission technologies which may lead to premature decommissioning and significant economic repercussions. It presents a dichotomy: invest in climate-neutral technologies now or face the closure and offshoring of operations later with consequences for employment. This open discussion concludes that while the technology for near-complete climate neutrality in EIIs exists and is rapidly advancing the higher costs compared to conventional methods pose a significant barrier. Without the ability to pass these costs to consumers the adoption of such technologies is stifled. Therefore it calls for decisive political commitment to support the industry’s transition ensuring a greener more resilient future for Europe’s industrial backbone.
Hydrogen Sampling Systems Adapted to Heavy-duty Refuelling Stations' Current and Future Specifications - A Review
Sep 2024
Publication
To meet the new regulation for the deployment of alternative fuels infrastructure which sets targets for electric recharging and hydrogen refuelling infrastructure by 2025 or 2030 a large infrastructure comprising trucksuitable hydrogen refuelling stations will soon be required. However further standardisation is required to support the uptake of hydrogen for heavy-duty transport for Europe’s green energy future. Hydrogen-powered vehicles require pure hydrogen as some contaminants can reduce the performance of the fuel cell even at very low levels. Even if previous projects have paved the way for the development of the European quality infrastructure for hydrogen conformity assessment sampling systems and methods have yet to be developed for heavy-duty hydrogen refuelling stations (HD-HRS). This study reviews different aspects of the sampling of hydrogen at heavy-duty hydrogen refuelling stations for purity assessment with a focus on the current and future specifications and operations at HD-HRS. This study describes the state-of-the art of sampling systems currently under development for use at HD-HRS and highlights a number of aspects which must be taken into consideration to ensure safe and accurate sampling: risk assessment for the whole sampling exercise selection of cylinders methods to prepare cylinders before the sampling filling pressure and venting of the sampling systems.
Determining Onshore or Offshore Hydrogen Storage for Large Offshore Wind Parks: The North Sea Wind Power Hub Case
Aug 2024
Publication
The large-scale integration of renewable energy sources leads to daily and seasonal mismatches between supply and demand and the curtailment of wind power. Hydrogen produced from surplus wind power offers an attractive solution to these challenges. In this paper we consider a large offshore wind park and analyze the need for hydrogen storage at the onshore and offshore sides of a large transportation pipeline that connects the wind park to the mainland. The results show that the pipeline with line pack storage though important for day-to-day fluctuations will not offer sufficient storage capacity to bridge seasonal differences. Furthermore the results show that if the pipeline is sufficiently sized additional storage is only needed on one side of the pipeline which would limit the needed investments. Results show that the policy which determines what part of the wind power is fed into the electricity grid and what part is converted into hydrogen has a significant influence on these seasonal storage needs. Therefore investment decisions for hydrogen systems should be made by considering both the onshore and offshore storage requirements in combination with electricity transport to the mainland.
Simulation of DDT in Obstructed Channels: Wavy Channels vs. Fence-type Obstacles
Sep 2023
Publication
The capabilities of an OpenFOAM solver to reproduce the transition of stoichiometric H2-air mixtures to detonation in obstructed 2-D channels were tested. The process is challenging numerically as it involves the ignition of a flame kernel its subsequent propagation and acceleration interaction with obstacles formation of shock waves ahead and detonation onset (DO). Two different obstacle configurations were considered in 10-mm high × 1-m long channels: (i) wavy walls (WW) that mimic the behavior of fencetype obstacles but prevent abrupt area changes. In this case flame acceleration (FA) is strongly affected by shock-flame interactions and DO often results from the compression of the gas present between the accelerating flame front and a converging section of the channel. (ii) Fence-type (FT) obstacles. In this case FA is driven by the increase in flame surface area as a result of the interaction of the flame front with the unburned gas flow field ahead particularly downstream of obstacles; shock-flame interactions play a role at the later stages of FA and DO takes place upon reflection of precursor shocks from obstacles. The effect of initial pressure p0 = 25 50 and 100 kPa at constant blockage ratio (BR = 0.6) was investigated and compared for both configurations. Results show that for the same initial pressure (p0 = 50 kPa) the obstacle configurations could lead to different final propagation regimes: a quasi-detonation for WW and a choked-flame for FT due to the increased losses for the latter. At p0 = 25 kPa however while both configurations result in choked flames WW seem to exhibit larger velocity deficits than FT due to longer flame-precursor shock distances during quasi-steady propagation and to the increased presence of unburnt mixture downstream of the tip of the flame that homogeneously explodes providing additional support to the propagation of the flame.
Energy Use and Greenhouse Gas Emissions of Traction Alternatives for Regional Railways
Feb 2024
Publication
This paper presents a method for estimating Well-to-Wheel (WTW) energy use and greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions attributed to the advanced railway propulsion systems implemented in conjunction with different energy carriers and their production pathways. The analysis encompasses diesel-electric multiple unit vehicles converted to their hybrid-electric plug-in hybrid-electric fuel cell hybrid-electric or battery-electric counterparts combined with biodiesel or hydrotreated vegetable oil (HVO) as the first and second generation biofuels liquefied natural gas (LNG) hydrogen and/or electricity. The method is demonstrated using non-electrified regional railway network with heterogeneous vehicle fleet in the Netherlands as a case. Battery-electric system utilizing green electricity is identified as the only configuration leading to emission-free transport while offering the highest energy use reduction by 65–71% compared to the current diesel-powered hybrid-electric system. When using grey electricity based on the EU2030 production mix these savings are reduced to about 27–39% in WTW energy use and around 68–73% in WTW GHG emissions. Significant reductions in overall energy use and emissions are obtained for the plug-in hybrid-electric concept when combining diesel LNG or waste cooking oil-based HVO with electricity. The remaining configurations that reduce energy use and GHG emissions are hybrid-electric systems running on LNG or HVO from waste cooking oil. The latter led to approximately 88% lower WTW emissions than the baseline for each vehicle type. When produced from natural gas or EU2030-mix-based electrolysis hydrogen negatively affected both aspects irrespective of the prime mover technology. However when produced via green electricity it offers a GHG reduction of approximately 90% for hybrid-electric and fuel cell hybrid-electric configurations with a further reduction of up to 92–93% if combined with green electricity in plug-in hybrid-electric systems. The results indicate that HVO from waste cooking oil could be an effective and instantly implementable transition solution towards carbon–neutral regional trains allowing for a smooth transition and development of supporting infrastructure required for more energy-efficient and environment-friendly technologies.
Hydrogen Storage Solutions for Residential Heating: A Thermodynamic and Economic Analysis with Scale-up Potential
Jul 2024
Publication
The study presents a thermodynamic and economic assessment of different hydrogen storage solutions for heating purposes powered by PV panels of a 10-apartment residential building in Milan and it focuses on compressed hydrogen liquid hydrogen and metal hydride. The technical assessment involves using Python to code thermodynamic models to address technical and thermodynamic performances. The economic analysis evaluates the CAPEX the ROI and the cost per unit of stored hydrogen and energy. The study aims to provide an accurate assessment of the thermodynamic and economic indicators of three of the storage methods introduced in the literature review pointing out the one with the best techno-economic performance for further development and research. The performed analysis shows that compressed hydrogen represents the best alternative but its cost is still too high for small residential applications. Applying the technology to a big system case would enable the solution making it economically feasible.
Benchmark of J55 and X56 Steels on Cracking and Corrosion Effects Under Hydrogen Salt Cavern Boundary Conditions
Feb 2024
Publication
Salt caverns have great potential to store relevant amounts of hydrogen as part of the energy transition. However the durability and suitability of commonly used steels for piping in hydrogen salt caverns is still under research. In this work aging effects focusing on corrosion and cracking patterns of casing steel API 5CT J55 and “H2ready” pipeline steel API 5L X56 were investigated with scanning electron microscopy and energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy after accelerated stress tests with pressure/temperature cycling under hydrogen salt cavern-like conditions. Compared to dry conditions significant more corrosion by presence of salt ions was detected. However compared to X56 only for J55 an intensification of corrosion and cracking at the surface due to hydrogen atmosphere was revealed. Pronounced surface cracks were observed for J55 over the entire samples. Overall the results strongly suggest that X56 is more resistant than J55 under the conditions of a hydrogen salt cavern.
Analysing the Prospects of Grid-connected Green Hydrogen Production in Predominantly Fossil-based Countries - A Case Study of South Africa
Aug 2024
Publication
Importing substantial amount of green hydrogen from countries like South Africa which have abundant solar and wind potentials to replace fossil fuels has attracted interest in developed regions. This study analyses South African strategies for improving and decarbonizing the power sector while also producing hydrogen for export. These strategies include the Integrated Resource Plan the Transmission Development Plan Just Energy Transition and Hydrogen Society Roadmap for grid connected hydrogen production in 2030. Results based on an hourly resolution optimisation in Plexos indicate that annual grid-connected hydrogen production of 500 kt can lead to a 20–25% increase in the cost of electricity in scenarios with lower renewable energy penetration due to South African emission constraints by 2030. While the price of electricity is still in acceptable range and the price of hydrogen can be competitive on the international market (2–3 USD/kgH2 for production) the emission factor of this hydrogen is higher than the one of grey hydrogen ranging from 13 to 24 kgCO2/kgh2. When attempting to reach emission factors based on EU directives the three policy roadmaps become unfeasible and free capacity expansion results in significant sixteen-fold increase of wind and seven-fold increase in solar installations compared to 2023 levels by 2030 in South Africa.
No more items...