Netherlands
Dynamic modelling of a direct internal reforming solid oxide fuel cell stack based on single cell experiments
May 2018
Publication
Direct internal reforming enables optimal heat integration and reduced complexity in solid oxide fuel cell (SOFC) systems but thermal stresses induced by the increased temperature gradients may inflict damage to the stack. Therefore the development of adequate control strategies requires models that can accurately predict the temperature profiles in the stack. A 1D dynamic modelling platform is developed in this study and used to simulate SOFCs in both single cell and stack configurations. The single cell model is used to validate power law and Hougen-Watson reforming kinetics derived from experiments in previous work. The stack model based on the same type of cells accounts for heat transfer in the inactive area and to the environment and is validated with data reported by the manufacturer. The reforming kinetics are then implemented in the stack model to simulate operation with direct internal reforming. Although there are differences between the temperature profiles predicted by the two kinetic models both are more realistic than assuming chemical equilibrium. The results highlight the need to identify rate limiting steps for the reforming and hydrogen oxidation reactions on anodes of functional SOFC assemblies. The modelling approach can be used to study off-design conditions transient operation and system integration as well as to develop adequate energy management and control strategies.
Statistics, Lessons Learned and Recommendations from Analysis of HIAD 2.0 Database
Mar 2022
Publication
The manuscript firstly describes the data collection and validation process for the European Hydrogen Incidents and Accidents Database (HIAD 2.0) a public repository tool collecting systematic data on hydrogen-related incidents and near-misses. This is followed by an overview of HIAD 2.0 which currently contains 706 events. Subsequently the approaches and procedures followed by the authors to derive lessons learned and formulate recommendations from the events are described. The lessons learned have been divided into four categories including system design; system manufacturing installation and modification; human factors and emergency response. An overarching lesson learned is that minor events which occurred simultaneously could still result in serious consequences echoing James Reason's Swiss Cheese theory. Recommendations were formulated in relation to the established safety principles adapted for hydrogen by the European Hydrogen Safety Panel considering operational modes industrial sectors and human factors. This work provide an important contribution to the safety of systems involving hydrogen benefitting technical safety engineers emergency responders and emergency services. The lesson learned and the discussion derived from the statistics can also be used in training and risk assessment studies being of equal importance to promote and assist the development of sound safety culture in organisations.
Safe Operation of Natural Gas Appliances Fuelled with Hydrogen & Natural Gas Mixtures (Progress Obtained in the Naturalhy-Project)
Sep 2007
Publication
Considering the transition towards the hydrogen economy dependent on hydrogen penetration scenario the cost of a new hydrogen pipeline infrastructure in Europe may amount to several thousands of billions of EURO’s. Therefore the examination of the potential contribution of the existing natural gas assets is a practical and logical first step. As the physical and chemical properties of hydrogen differ significantly from those of natural gas it is not at all possible to simply exchange natural gas by hydrogen in the existing infrastructure. In this paper first a brief overview will be given of the NATURALHY-project. Further the focus will be on the impact of added hydrogen on the performance of existing natural gas domestic end user appliances which is related to the operation of the natural gas grid connecting the different types of appliance. The application of the fundamental insights and carefully designed experiments comparing the behaviour of gases using justified reference conditions have been shown to offer essential progress. The Wobbe index limits of the natural gas distributed pose a first limiting factor upon the maximum allowable hydrogen concentration. Constant-Wobbe index and decreasing-Wobbe index options of H2 admixture have been studied. Considering the appliance light back H2 limiting factor for domestic appliances fuel-rich appliances are the critical ones. Also taking into account stationary gas engines gas turbines industrial applications and natural gas grid management it is not yet justified to present statements on what level of hydrogen concentration could be safely allowed in which specific natural gas distribution region. But more clarity has been obtained on combustion safety aspects of existing domestic appliances on the connection with Wobbe distribution conditions and on the bottlenecks still to be handled.
Requirements for the Safety Assessment for the Approval of a Hydrogen Refueling Station
Sep 2007
Publication
The EC 6th framework research project HyApproval will draft a Handbook which will describe all relevant issues to get approval to construct and operate a Hydrogen Refuelling Station (HRS) for hydrogen vehicles. In WP3 of the HyApproval project it is under investigation which safety information competent authorities require to give a licence to construct an operate an HRS. The paper describes the applied methodology to collect the information from the authorities in 5 EC countries and the USA. The results of the interviews and recommendations for the information to include in the Handbook are presented.
CFD Modelling of Accidental Hydrogen Release from Pipelines
Sep 2005
Publication
Although today hydrogen is distributed mainly by trailers in the long terms pipeline distribution will be more suitable if large amounts of hydrogen are produced on industrial scale. Therefore from the safety point of view it is essential to compare hydrogen pipelines to natural gas pipelines which are well established today. Within the paper we compare safety implications in accidental situations. We do not look into technological aspects such as compressors or seals.<br/>Using a CFD (Computational Fluid Dynamics) tool it is possible to investigate the effects of different properties (density diffusivity viscosity and flammability limits) of hydrogen and methane on the dispersion process. In addition CFD tools allow studying the influence of different release scenarios geometrical configurations and atmospheric conditions. An accidental release from a pipeline is modelled. The release is simulated as a flow though a small hole between the high-pressure pipeline and the environment. A part of the pipeline is included in the simulations as high-pressure reservoir. Due to the large pressure difference between the pipeline and the environment the flow conditions at the release become critical.<br/>For the assumed scenarios larger amount of flammable mixture could be observed in case of hydrogen release. On the other hand because of buoyancy and a higher sonic speed at the release the hydrogen clouds are farther from the ground level or buildings than in case of the methane clouds decreasing the probability of ignition and reducing the flame acceleration due to obstacles in case of ignition. Results on the effect of wind in the release scenarios are also described.
The Safe Use of the Existing Natural Gas System for Hydrogen (Overview of the NATURALHY-Project)
Sep 2005
Publication
The transition period towards the situation in which hydrogen will become an important energy carrier will be lengthy (decades) costly and needs a significant R&D effort. It’s clear therefore that the development of a hydrogen system requires a practical strategy within the context of the existing assets. Examining the potential of the existing extensive natural gas chain (transmission - distribution - end user infrastructures and appliances) is a logical first step towards the widespread delivery of hydrogen.
The project will define the conditions under which hydrogen can be mixed with natural gas for delivery by the existing natural gas system and later withdrawn selectively from the pipeline system by advanced separation technologies. Membranes will be developed to enable this separation. The socio-economic and life cycle consequences of this hydrogen delivery approach will be mapped out. By adding hydrogen to natural gas the physical and chemical properties of the mixture will differ from “pure” natural gas. As this may have a major effect on safety issues and durability issues (which also have a safety component) related to the gas delivery and the performance of end use appliances these issues are particularly addressed in the project.
The project is executed by a European consortium of 39 partners (including 15 from the gas industry). In this project set up under the auspices of GERG The European Gas Research Group there are leading roles for N.V. Nederlandse Gasunie (NL) Gaz de France (F) TNO (NL) ISQ (P) the Universities of Loughborough and Warwick (UK) and Exergia (GR). Guidance will be provided by a Strategic Advisory Committee consisting of representatives from relevant (inter)national organizations.
The project started on 1st May 2004 and will run for 5 years. The European Commission has selected the Integrated Project NATURALHY for financial support within the Sixth Framework Programme.
The project will define the conditions under which hydrogen can be mixed with natural gas for delivery by the existing natural gas system and later withdrawn selectively from the pipeline system by advanced separation technologies. Membranes will be developed to enable this separation. The socio-economic and life cycle consequences of this hydrogen delivery approach will be mapped out. By adding hydrogen to natural gas the physical and chemical properties of the mixture will differ from “pure” natural gas. As this may have a major effect on safety issues and durability issues (which also have a safety component) related to the gas delivery and the performance of end use appliances these issues are particularly addressed in the project.
The project is executed by a European consortium of 39 partners (including 15 from the gas industry). In this project set up under the auspices of GERG The European Gas Research Group there are leading roles for N.V. Nederlandse Gasunie (NL) Gaz de France (F) TNO (NL) ISQ (P) the Universities of Loughborough and Warwick (UK) and Exergia (GR). Guidance will be provided by a Strategic Advisory Committee consisting of representatives from relevant (inter)national organizations.
The project started on 1st May 2004 and will run for 5 years. The European Commission has selected the Integrated Project NATURALHY for financial support within the Sixth Framework Programme.
Modelling of Lean Uniform and Non-Uniform Hydrogen-Air Mixture Explosions in a Closed Vessel
Sep 2009
Publication
Simulation of hydrogen-air mixture explosions in a closed large-scale vessel with uniform and nonuniform mixture compositions was performed by the group of partners within the EC funded project “Hydrogen Safety as an Energy Carrier” (HySafe). Several experiments were conducted previously by Whitehouse et al. in a 10.7 m3 vertically oriented (5.7-m high) cylindrical facility with different hydrogen-air mixture compositions. Two particular experiments were selected for simulation and comparison as a Standard Benchmark Exercise (SBEP) problem: combustion of uniform 12.8% (vol.) hydrogen-air mixture and combustion of non-uniform hydrogen-air mixture with average 12.6% (vol.) hydrogen concentration across the vessel (vertical stratification 27% vol. hydrogen at the top of the vessel 2.5% vol. hydrogen at the bottom of the vessel); both mixtures were ignited at the top of the vessel. The paper presents modelling approaches used by the partners comparison of simulation results against the experiment data and conclusions regarding the non-uniform mixture combustion modelling in real-life applications.
Simulation of the Fast Filling of Hydrogen Tanks
Sep 2009
Publication
High pressure storage of hydrogen in tanks is a promising option to provide the necessary fuel for transportation purposes. The fill process of a high-pressure tank should be reasonably short but must be designed to avoid too high temperatures in the tank. The shorter the fill should be the higher the maximum temperature in the tank climbs. For safety reasons an upper temperature limit is included in the requirements for refillable hydrogen tanks (ISO 15869) which sets the limit for any fill optimization. It is crucial to understand the phenomena during a tank fill to stay within the safety margins.<br/>The paper describes the fast filling process of hydrogen tanks by simulations based on the Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) code CFX. The major result of the simulations is the local temperature distribution in the tank depending on the materials of liner and outer thermal insulation. Different material combinations (type III and IV) are investigated.<br/>Some measurements from literature are available and are used to validate the approach followed in CFX to simulate the fast filling of tanks. Validation has to be continued in future to further improve the predictability of the calculations for arbitrary geometries and material combinations.
Hydrogen Tank Filling Experiments at the JRC-IE Gastef Facility
Sep 2011
Publication
Storage of gases under pressure including hydrogen is a well-known technique. However the use in vehicles of hydrogen at pressures much higher than those applicable in natural gas cars still requires safety and performance studies with respect to the verification of the existing standards and regulations. The JRC-IE has developed a facility GasTeF for carrying out tests on full-scale high pressure vehicle’s tanks for hydrogen or natural gas. Typical tests performed in GasTeF are static permeation measurements of the storage system and hydrogen cycling in which tanks are fast filled and slowly emptied using hydrogen pressurised up to 70 MPa for at least 1000 times according to the requirements of the EU regulation on type-approval of hydrogen-powered motor vehicles. Moreover the temperature evolution of the gas inside and outside the tank is monitored using an ad-hoc designed thermocouples array system. This paper reports the first experimental results on the temperature distribution during hydrogen cycling tests.
Experimental Study of the Thermal Behaviour of Hydrogen Tanks During Hydrogen Cycling
Sep 2013
Publication
The thermal behaviour of several commercial hydrogen tanks has been studied during high pressure (70-84 MPa) hydrogen cycling. The temperature of the gas at different points inside the tank the temperature at the bosses and the tank outer wall temperature have been measured under different filling and emptying conditions. From the experimental results the effect of the filling rate (1.5-4 g/s) and the influence of the liner material in the thermal behaviour of the hydrogen tanks have been evaluated. Bosses thermal response under the different cycling conditions has also been investigated.
Development of a Model Evaluation Protocol for CFD Analysis of Hydrogen Safety Issues – The SUSANA Project
Oct 2015
Publication
The “SUpport to SAfety aNAlysis of Hydrogen and Fuel Cell Technologies (SUSANA)” project aims to support stakeholders using Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) for safety engineering design and assessment of FCH systems and infrastructure through the development of a model evaluation protocol. The protocol covers all aspects of safety assessment modelling using CFD from release through dispersion to combustion (self-ignition fires deflagrations detonations and Deflagration to Detonation Transition - DDT) and not only aims to enable users to evaluate models but to inform them of the state of the art and best practices in numerical modelling. The paper gives an overview of the SUSANA project including the main stages of the model evaluation protocol and some results from the on-going benchmarking activities.
Analysis of Out-of-spec Events During Refueling of On-board Hydrogen Tanks
Sep 2017
Publication
For refuelling on-board hydrogen tanks table-based or formula based protocols are commonly used. These protocols are designed to achieve a tank filling close to 100% SOC (State of Charge) in s safe way: without surpassing temperature (-40°C to 85°C) and pressure limits (125% Nominal Working Pressure NWP). The ambient temperature the initial pressure and the volume category of the (compressed hydrogen storage system CHSS are used as inputs to determine the final target pressure and the pressure ramp rate (which controls the filling duration). However abnormal out-of-spec events (e.g. misinformation of storage system status and characteristics of the storage tanks) may occur and result in a refuelling in which the safety boundaries are surpassed. In the present article the possible out of specification (out-of-spec) events in a refuelling station have been analyzed. The associated hazards when refuelling on-board hydrogen tanks have been studied. Experimental results of out-of-spec event tests performed on a type 3 tank are presented. The results show that on the type 3 tank the safety temperature limit of 85°C was only surpassed under a combination of events; e.g. an unnoticed stop of the cooling of the gas combined with a wrong input of ambient temperature at a very warm environment. On the other hand under certain events (e.g. cooling the gas below the target temperature) and in particular under cold environmental conditions the 100% SOC limit established in the fuelling protocols has been surpassed. Hydrogen safety on-board tanks refuelling protocols out-of-spec events.
Hydrogen Safety Sensor Performance and Use Gap Analysis
Sep 2017
Publication
Hydrogen sensors are recognized as an important technology for facilitating the safe implementation of hydrogen as an alternative fuel and there are numerous reports of a sensor alarm successfully preventing a potentially serious event. However gaps in sensor metrological specifications as well as in their performance for some applications exist. The U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) Fuel Cell Technologies Office published a short list of critical gaps in the 2007 and 2012 Multiyear Project Plans; more detailed gap analyses were independently performed by the Joint Research Centre (JRC) and the National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL). There have been however some significant advances in sensor technologies since these assessments including the commercial availability of hydrogen sensors with fast response times (t90 < 1 s which had been an elusive DOE target since 2007) improved robustness to chemical poisons improved selectivity and improved lifetime and stability. These improvements however have not been universal and typically pertain to select platforms or models. Moreover as hydrogen markets grow and new applications are being explored more demands will be imposed on sensor performance. The hydrogen sensor laboratories at NREL and the JRC are currently updating the hydrogen safety sensor gap analysis through direct interaction with international stakeholders in the hydrogen community especially end users. NREL and the JRC are currently organizing a series of workshops (in Europe and the United States) with sensor developers end-users and other stakeholders in 2017 to identify technology gaps and to develop a path forward to address them. One workshop was held on May 10 in Brussels Belgium at the Headquarters of the Fuel Cell and Hydrogen Joint Undertaking. A second workshop is planned at NREL in Golden CO USA. This paper reviews improvements in sensor technologies in the past 5 to 10 years identifies gaps in sensor performance and use requirements and identifies potential research strategies to address the gaps. The outcomes of the Hydrogen Sensors Workshops are also summarized.
International Association for Hydrogen Safety ‘Research Priorities Workshop’, September 2018, Buxton, UK
Sep 2018
Publication
Hydrogen has the potential to be used by many countries as part of decarbonising the future energy system. Hydrogen can be used as a fuel ‘vector’ to store and transport energy produced in low-carbon ways. This could be particularly important in applications such as heating and transport where other solutions for low and zero carbon emission are difficult. To enable the safe uptake of hydrogen technologies it is important to develop the international scientific evidence base on the potential risks to safety and how to control them effectively. The International Association for Hydrogen Safety (known as IA HySAFE) is leading global efforts to ensure this. HSE hosted the 2018 IA HySAFE Biennial Research Priorities Workshop. A panel of international experts presented during nine key topic sessions: (1) Industrial and National Programmes; (2) Applications; (3) Storage; (4) Accident Physics – Gas Phase; (5) Accident Physics – Liquid/ Cryogenic Behaviour; (6) Materials; (7) Mitigation Sensors Hazard Prevention and Risk Reduction; (8) Integrated Tools for Hazard and Risk Assessment; (9) General Aspects of Safety.<br/>This report gives an overview of each topic made by the session chairperson. It also gives further analysis of the totality of the evidence presented. The workshop outputs are shaping international activities on hydrogen safety. They are helping key stakeholders to identify gaps in knowledge and expertise and to understand and plan for potential safety challenges associated with the global expansion of hydrogen in the energy system.
The New Oil? The Geopolitics and International Governance of Hydrogen
Jun 2020
Publication
While most hydrogen research focuses on the technical and cost hurdles to a full-scale hydrogen economy little consideration has been given to the geopolitical drivers and consequences of hydrogen developments. The technologies and infrastructures underpinning a hydrogen economy can take markedly different forms and the choice over which pathway to take is the object of competition between different stakeholders and countries. Over time cross-border maritime trade in hydrogen has the potential to fundamentally redraw the geography of global energy trade create a new class of energy exporters and reshape geopolitical relations and alliances between countries. International governance and investments to scale up hydrogen value chains could reduce the risk of market fragmentation carbon lock-in and intensified geo-economic rivalry.
Government Strategy on Hydrogen - The Netherlands
Apr 2020
Publication
Low-carbon gases are indispensable to any energy system that is reliable clean affordable safe and is suited to spatial integration and zero-carbon hydrogen is a crucial link in that chain1. The most common element in the universe seems to have a highly bonding effect in the Netherlands – particularly as a result of the unique starting position of our country. This is made clear in the agreements of the National Climate Agreement which includes an ambitious target for hydrogen supported by a large and broad group of stakeholders. Industrial clusters and ports regard hydrogen as an indispensable part of their future and sustainability strategy. For the transport sector hydrogen (in combination with fuel cells) is crucial to achieving zero emissions transport. The agricultural sector has identified opportunities for the production of hydrogen and for its use. Cities regions and provinces are keen to get started on implementing hydrogen.<br/>The government embraces these targets and recognises the power of the framework for action demonstrated by so many parties. The focus on clean hydrogen in the Netherlands will lead to the creation of new jobs improvements to air quality and moreover is crucial to the energy transition.
Indoor Use of Hydrogen, Knowledge Gaps and Priorities for the Improvement of Current Standards on Hydrogen, a Presentation of HyIndoor European Project
Sep 2013
Publication
To develop safety strategies for the use of hydrogen indoors the HyIndoor project is studying the behaviour of a hydrogen release deflagration or non-premixed flame in an enclosed space such as a fuel cell or its cabinet a room or a warehouse. The paper proposes a safety approach based on safety objectives that can be used to take various scenarios of hydrogen leaks into account for the safe design of Hydrogen and Fuel Cell (HFC) early market applications. Knowledge gaps on current engineering models and unknown influence of specific parameters were identified and prioritized thereby re-focusing the objectives of the project test campaign and numerical simulations. This approach will enable the improvement of the specification of openings and use of hydrogen sensors for enclosed spaces. The results will be disseminated to all stakeholders including hydrogen industry and RCS bodies.
Effects of the Injector Direction on the Temperature Distribution During Filling of Hydrogen Tanks
Sep 2017
Publication
The development of the temperature field in hydrogen tanks during the filling process has been investigated with Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD). Measurements from experiments undertaken at the JRC GasTef facility have been used to develop and validate the CFD modelling strategy; by means of the CFD calculations the effect of the injector direction on the temperature distribution has been analysed. It has been found that the dynamics of the temperature field including the development of potentially detrimental phenomena like thermal stratification and temperature inhomogeneity e.g. hot spots can be significantly affected by the injector orientation.
Effect of Precooled Inlet Gas Temperature and Mass flow Rate on Final State of Charge During Hydrogen Vehicle Refueling
Mar 2015
Publication
Short refuelling time and high final state of charge are among the main hydrogen car user's requirements. To meet these requirements without exceeding the tank materials safety limits hydrogen precooling is needed. Filling experiments with different inlet gas temperatures and mass flow rates have been executed using two different types of on-board tanks (type 3 and 4). State of charge has a strong dependency on the inlet gas temperature. This dependency is more visible for type 4 tanks. Lowest precooling temperature (−40 °C) is not always required in order to meet user's requirements so energy savings can be achieved if the initial conditions of the tank are correctly identified. The results of the experiments performed have been compared with the SAE J2601 look-up tables for non-communication fillings. A big safety margin has been observed in these tables. Refuelling could be performed faster and with less demanding precooling requirements if the initial conditions and the configuration of the hydrogen storage system are well known.
Workshop Report: Summary & Outcomes, Putting Science into Standards Power-to-Hydrogen and HCNG
Oct 2014
Publication
The Joint Research Centre (JRC) of the European Commission together with the European Association of Research and Technology Organisations (EARTO) the European Standards Organisations (ESO) CEN and CENELEC and the European Commission Directorate-General Enterprise and Industry (ENTR) have launched an initiative within the context of the European Forum on Science and Industry to bring the scientific and standardization communities closer together. The second and very successful workshop in a series entitled “Putting Science into Standards" was held in at the Institute for Energy and Transport of the JRC in Petten on 21-22 October 2014.<br/>The workshop focused on Power to Hydrogen (P2H) and Hydrogen Compressed Natural Gas (HCNG) which represent a promising and major contribution to the challenging management of increased integration of renewable energy sources in the overall energy system. The workshop offered a platform to exchange ideas on technologies policy and standardization issues. The participation of major stakeholders from both industry and research to this event proved fruitful in moving towards consensus on the relevant technical issues involved and at identifying a common way forward to increase the maturity and market visibility of P2H components and systems. Other outcomes include a clarification of expectations of industry of where and how policy and standardization can contribute to a competitive development of P2H and related issues. The workshop results will be used to devise a roadmap on "Opportunities for Power to Hydrogen and HCNG" by CEN/CENELEC outlining the next steps of standardization activities.
No more items...