Canada
Simulations of Hydrogen Releases from a Storage Tanks- Dispersion and Consequences of Ignition
Sep 2005
Publication
We present results from hydrogen dispersion simulations from a pressurized reservoir at constant flow rate in the presence and absence of a wall. The dispersion simulations are performed using a commercial finite volume solver. Validation of the approach is discussed. Constant concentration envelopes corresponding to the 2% 4% and 15% hydrogen concentration in air are calculated for a subcritical vertical jet and for an equivalent subcritical horizontal jet from a high pressure reservoir. The consequences of ignition and the resulting overpressure are calculated for subcritical horizontal and vertical hydrogen jets and in the latter case compared to available experimental data.
PRD Hydrogen Release and Dispersion, a Comparison of CFD Results Obtained from Using Ideal and Real Gas Law Properties.
Sep 2005
Publication
In this paper CFD techniques were applied to the simulations of hydrogen release from a 400-bar tank to ambient through a Pressure Relieve Device (PRD) 6 mm (¼”) opening. The numerical simulations using the TOPAZ software developed by Sandia National Laboratory addressed the changes of pressure density and flow rate variations at the leak orifice during release while the PHOENICS software package predicted extents of various hydrogen concentration envelopes as well as the velocities of gas mixture for the dispersion in the domain. The Abel-Noble equation of state (AN-EOS) was incorporated into the CFD model implemented through the TOPAZ and PHOENICS software to accurately predict the real gas properties for hydrogen release and dispersion under high pressures. The numerical results were compared with those obtained from using the ideal gas law and it was found that the ideal gas law overestimates the hydrogen mass release rates by up to 35% during the first 25 seconds of release. Based on the findings the authors recommend that a real gas equation of state be used for CFD predictions of high-pressure PRD releases.
Feasibility Investigation of Hydrogen Refuelling Infrastructure for Heavy‐Duty Vehicles in Canada
Apr 2022
Publication
A potentially viable solution to the problem of greenhouse gas emissions by vehicles in the transportation sector is the deployment of hydrogen as alternative fuel. A limitation to the diffusion of the hydrogen‐fuelled vehicles option is the intricate refuelling stations that vehicles will require. This study examines the practical use of hydrogen fuel within the internal combustion engine (ICE)‐powered long‐haul heavy‐duty trucking vehicles. Specifically it appraises the techno‐ economic feasibility of constructing a network of long‐haul truck refuelling stations using hydrogen fuel across Canada. Hydrogen fuel is chosen as an option for this study due to its low carbon emissions rate compared to diesel. This study also explores various operational methods including variable technology integration levels and truck traffic flows truck and pipeline delivery of hydrogen to stations and the possibility of producing hydrogen onsite. The proposed models created for this work suggest important parameters for economic development such as capital costs for station construction the selling price of fuel and the total investment cost for the infrastructure of a nation‐ wide refuelling station. Results showed that the selling price of hydrogen gas pipeline delivery op‐ tion is more economically stable. Specifically it was found that at 100% technology integration the range in selling prices was between 8.3 and 25.1 CAD$/kg. Alternatively at 10% technology integration the range was from 12.7 to 34.1 CAD$/kg. Moreover liquid hydrogen which is delivered by trucks generally had the highest selling price due to its very prohibitive storage costs. However truck‐delivered hydrogen stations provided the lowest total investment cost; the highest is shown by pipe‐delivered hydrogen and onsite hydrogen production processes using high technology integration methods. It is worth mentioning that once hydrogen technology is more developed and deployed the refuelling infrastructure cost is likely to decrease considerably. It is expected that the techno‐economic model developed in this work will be useful to design and optimize new and more efficient hydrogen refuelling stations for any ICE vehicles or fuel cell vehicles.
Challenges and Important Considerations When Benchmarking Single-cell Alkaline Electrolyzers
Nov 2021
Publication
This study outlines an approach to identifying the difficulties associated with the bench-marking of alkaline single cells under real electrolyzer conditions. A challenging task in the testing and comparison of different catalysts is obtaining reliable and meaningful benchmarks for these conditions. Negative effects on reproducibility were observed due to the reduction in conditioning time. On the anode side a stable passivation layer of NiO can be formed by annealing of the Ni foams which is even stable during long-term operation. Electrical contact resistance and impedance measurements showed that most of the contact resistance derived from the annealed Ni foam. Additionally analysis of various overvoltages indicated that most of the total overvoltage comes from the anode and cathode activation overpotential. Different morphologies of the substrate material exhibited an influence on the performance of the alkaline single cell based on an increase in the ohmic resistance.
Vertical Turbulent Buoyant Helium Jet - CFD Modelling and Validation
Sep 2005
Publication
In this paper a vertical turbulent round jet of helium was studied numerically using the PHOENICS software package. The flow was assumed to be steady incompressible and turbulent. The jet discharge Froude number was 14000 and the turbulent Schmidt number was 0.7. The incompressible Reynolds average Navier-Stokes equations and helium transport equation expressed in 2-D axisymmetric domain were applied to model the underlying helium release. The k-e RNG turbulence model was used for the calculations of the corresponding turbulent viscosity diffusivity velocity and concentration fields in the domain. The simulation results are compared with the experimental measurements from the earlier published studies on helium jets in non-buoyant jet region (NBJ) intermediate region (I) and buoyant plume region (BP). The numerical results show that the radial profiles of mean velocity and mean concentration are consistent with the empirical data scaled by the effective diameter and density-ratio dependence. The mean velocity and concentration fields along the axis of the jet agree with the decay laws correlated from the previous experiments. The discrepancy between the numerical and experimental data is within 10% proving that the current CFD model for gas release and dispersion is robust accurate and reliable and that the CFD technique can be used as an alternative to the experiments with similar helium jets. The authors believe that the current CFD model is well validated through this study and can be further extended to predict similar hydrogen releases and dispersion if the model is properly applied with hydrogen properties.
Numerical Investigation of Subsonic Hydrogen Jet Release
Sep 2011
Publication
A buoyant round vertical hydrogen jet is investigated using Large Eddy Simulations at low Mach number (M = 0.3). The influence of the transient concentration fields on the extent of the gas envelope with concentrations within the flammability limits is analyzed and their structure are characterized. The transient flammable region has a complex structure that extends up to 30% beyond the time-averaged flammable volume with high concentration pockets that persist sufficiently long for potential ignition. Safety envelopes devised on the basis of simplified time-averaged simulations would need to include a correction factor that accounts for transient incursions of high flammability concentrations.
Quantitative Imaging of Multi-Component Turbulent Jets
Sep 2011
Publication
The integration of a hydrogen gas storage arrangement in vehicles has not been without its challenges. Gaseous state of hydrogen at ambient temperature combined with the fact that hydrogen is highly flammable results in the requirement of more robust high pressure storage systems that can meet modern safety standards. To develop these new safety standards and to properly predict the phenomena of hydrogen dispersion a better understanding of the resulting flow structures and flammable region from controlled and uncontrolled releases of hydrogen gas must be achieved. With the upper and lower explosive limits of hydrogen known the flammable envelope surrounding the site of a uncontrolled hydrogen release can be found from the concentration field. In this study the subsonic release of hydrogen was emulated using helium as a substitute working fluid. A sharp orifice round turbulent jet is used to emulate releases in which leak geometry is circular. Effects of buoyancy and crossflow were studied over a wide range of Froude numbers. The velocity fields of turbulent jets were characterized using particle image velocimetry (PIV). The mean and fluctuation velocity components were well quantified to show the effect of buoyancy due to the density difference between helium and the surrounding air. In the range of Froude numbers investigated (Fr = 1000 750 500 250 and 50) the increasing effects of buoyancy were seen to be proportional to the reduction of the Fr number. While buoyancy is experienced to have a negligible effect on centerline velocity fluctuations acceleration due to buoyancy in the other hand resulted in a slower decay of time-averaged axial velocity component along the centerline. The obtained results will serve as control reference values for further concentration measurement study and for computational fluid dynamics (CFD) validation.
The Role of Charging and Refuelling Infrastructure in Supporting Zero-emission Vehicle Sales
Mar 2020
Publication
Widespread uptake of battery electric plug-in hybrid and hydrogen fuel-cell vehicles (collectively zero-emissions vehicles or ZEVs) could help many regions achieve deep greenhouse gas mitigation goals. Using the case of Canada this study investigates the extent to which increasing ZEV charging and refuelling availability may boost ZEV sales relative to other ZEV-supportive policies. We adapt a version of the Respondent-based Preferences and Constraints (REPAC) model using 2017 survey data from 1884 Canadian new vehicle-buyers to simulate the sales impacts of increasing electric vehicle charging access at home work public destinations and on highways as well as increasing hydrogen refuelling station access. REPAC is built from a stated preference choice model and represents constraints in supply and consumer awareness as well as dynamics in ZEV policy out to 2030. Results suggest that new ZEV market share from 2020 to 2030 does not substantially benefit from increased infrastructure. Even when electric charging and hydrogen refuelling access are simulated to reach “universally” available levels by 2030 ZEV sales do not rise by more than 1.5 percentage points above the baseline trajectory. On the other hand REPAC simulates ZEV market share rising as high as 30% by 2030 with strong ZEV-supportive policies even without the addition of charging or refuelling infrastructure. These findings stem from low consumer valuation of infrastructure found in the stated preference model. Results suggest that achieving ambitious ZEV sale targets requires a comprehensive suite of policies beyond a focus on charging and refuelling infrastructure.
Determination of Clearance Distances for Venting of Hydrogen Storage
Sep 2005
Publication
This paper discusses the results of computational fluid dynamics (CFD) modelling of hydrogen releases and dispersion outdoors during venting of hydrogen storage in real environment and geometry of a hydrogen refuelling or energy station for a given flow rate and dimensions of vent stack. The PHOENICS CFD software package was used to solve the continuity momentum and concentration equations with the appropriate boundary conditions buoyancy model and turbulence models. Also thermal effects resulting from potential ignition of flammable hydrogen clouds were assessed using TNO “Yellow Book” recommended approaches. The obtained results were then applied to determine appropriate clearance distances for venting of hydrogen storage for contribution to code development and station design considerations. CFD modelling of hydrogen concentrations and TNO-based modelling of thermal effects have proven to be reliable effective and relatively inexpensive tools to evaluate the effects of hydrogen releases.
Fundamental Safety Testing and Analysis of Solid State Hydrogen Storage Materials and Systems
Sep 2007
Publication
Hydrogen is seen as the future automobile energy storage media due to its inherent cleanliness upon oxidation and its ready utilization in fuel cell applications. Its physical storage in light weight low volume systems is a key technical requirement. In searching for ever higher gravimetric and volumetric density hydrogen storage materials and systems it is inevitable that higher energy density materials will be studied and used. To make safe and commercially acceptable systems it is important to understand quantitatively the risks involved in using and handling these materials and to develop appropriate risk mitigation strategies to handle unforeseen accidental events. To evaluate these materials and systems an IPHE sanctioned program was initiated in 2006 partnering laboratories from Europe North America and Japan. The objective of this international program is to understanding the physical risks involved in synthesis handling and utilization of solid state hydrogen storage materials and to develop methods to mitigate these risks. This understanding will support ultimate acceptance of commercially high density hydrogen storage system designs. An overview of the approaches to be taken to achieve this objective will be given. Initial experimental results will be presented on environmental exposure of NaAlH4 a candidate high density hydrogen storage compound. The tests to be shown are based on United Nations recommendations for the transport of hazardous materials and include air and water exposure of the hydride at three hydrogen charge levels in various physical configurations. Additional tests developed by the American Society for Testing and Materials were used to quantify the dust cloud ignition characteristics of this material which may result from accidental high energy impacts and system breach. Results of these tests are shown along with necessary risk mitigation techniques used in the synthesis and fabrication of a prototype hydrogen storage system.
Synthesis and Performance of Photocatalysts for Photocatalytic Hydrogen Production: Future Perspectives
Dec 2021
Publication
Photocatalysis for “green” hydrogen production is a technology of increasing importance that has been studied using both TiO2–based and heterojunction composite-based semiconductors. Different irradiation sources and reactor units can be considered for the enhancement of photocatalysis. Current approaches also consider the use of electron/hole scavengers organic species such as ethanol that are “available” in agricultural waste in communities around the world. Alternatively organic pollutants present in wastewaters can be used as organic scavengers reducing health and environmental concerns for plants animals and humans. Thus photocatalysis may help reduce the carbon footprint of energy production by generating H2 a friendly energy carrier and by minimizing water contamination. This review discusses the most up-to-date and important information on photocatalysis for hydrogen production providing a critical evaluation of: (1) The synthesis and characterization of semiconductor materials; (2) The design of photocatalytic reactors; (3) The reaction engineering of photocatalysis; (4) Photocatalysis energy efficiencies; and (5) The future opportunities for photocatalysis using artificial intelligence. Overall this review describes the state-of-the-art of TiO2–based and heterojunction composite-based semiconductors that produce H2 from aqueous systems demonstrating the viability of photocatalysis for “green” hydrogen production.
Effects of Surface on the Flammable Extent of Hydrogen Jets
Sep 2009
Publication
The effect of surfaces on the extent of high pressure horizontal unignited jets of hydrogen and methane is studied using CFD numerical simulations performed with FLACS Hydrogen. Results for constant flow rate through a 6.35 mm PRD from 100 barg and 700 barg storage units are presented for horizontal hydrogen and methane jets. To quantify the effect of a horizontal surface on the jet the jet exit is positioned at various heights above the ground ranging from 0.1 m to 10 m. Free jet simulations are performed for comparison purposes.
Lagrangian Reaction-Diffusion Model for Predicting the Ignitability of Pressurized Hydrogen Releases
Sep 2009
Publication
Previous experiments demonstrated that the accidental release of high pressure hydrogen into air can lead to the possibility of spontaneous ignition. It is believed that this ignition is due to the heating of the mixing layer between hydrogen and air that is caused by the shock wave driven by the pressurized hydrogen during the release. Currently this problem is poorly understood and not amenable to direct numerical simulation. This is due to the presence of a wide range of scales between the sizes of the blast wave driven and the very thin mixing layer. The present study addresses this fundamental ignition problem and develops a solution framework in order to predict the ignition event for given hydrogen storage pressures and dimension of the release hole. In this problem only the mixing layer between the hydrogen and air is considered. This permits us to use much higher resolution than previous studies. This mixing layer at the jet head is advected as a Lagrangian fluid particle. The key physical processes in the problem are identified to be the mixing of the two gases at the mixing layer the initial heating by the shock wave and a cooling effect due to the expansion of the mixing layer. The results of the simulations indicate that for every storage pressure there exists a critical hole size below which ignition is prevented during the release process. Close inspection of the results indicate that this limit is due to the competition between the heating provided by the shock wave and the cooling due to expansion. Furthermore the results also indicate that the details of the mixing process do not play a significant role to leading order. The limiting ignition criteria were found to be well approximated by the Homogeneous Ignition Model of Cuenot and Poinsot supplemented by a heat loss term due to expansion. Therefore turbulent mixing occurring in reality is not likely to affect the ignition limits derived in the present study. Comparison with existing experiments showed very good agreement.
Numerical Investigation of Hydrogen Dispersion into Air
Sep 2009
Publication
Computational fluid dynamics (CFD) is used to numerically solve the sudden release of hydrogen from a high pressure tank (up to 70MPa) into air. High pressure tanks increase the risk of failure of the joints and pipes connected to the tank which results in release of Hydrogen. The supersonic flow caused by high pressure ratio of reservoir to ambient generates a strong Mach disk. A three dimensional in-house code is developed to simulate the flow. High pressure Hydrogen requires a real gas law because it deviates from ideal gas law. Firstly Beattie-Bridgeman and Abel-Noble real gas equation of states are applied to simulate the release of hydrogen in hydrogen. Then Abel-Noble is implied to simulate the release of hydrogen in air. Beattie-Bridgeman has stability problems in the case of hydrogen in air. A transport equation is used to solve the concentration of Hydrogen-air mixture. The code is second order accurate in space and first order in time and uses a modified Van Leer limiter. The fast release of Hydrogen from a small rupture needs a very small mesh therefore parallel computation is applied to overcome memory problems and to decrease the solution time. The high pressure ratio of the reservoir to ambient causes a very fast release which is accurately modelled by the code and all the shocks and Mach disk happening are observed in the results. The results show that the difference between real gas and ideal gas models cannot be ignored.
Shock Initiated Ignition for Hydrogen Mixtures of Different Concentrations
Sep 2011
Publication
The scenario of ignition of fuels by the passage of shock waves is relevant from the perspective of safety primarily because shock ignition potentially plays an important role in deflagration to detonation transition. Even in one dimension simulation of ignition between a contact surface or a flame and a shock moving into combustible mixture is difficult because of the singular nature of the initial conditions. Indeed initially as the shock starts moving away from the contact surface the region filled with shocked reactive mixture does not exist. In the current work the formulation is transformed using time and length over time as the independent variables. This transformation yields a finite domain from t = 0. In this paper the complete spatial and temporal ignition evolution of hydrogen combustible mixtures of different concentrations is studied numerically. Integration of the governing equations is performed using an Essentially Non-Oscillatory (ENO) algorithm in space and Runge-Kutta in time while the chemistry is modeled by a three-step chain-branching mechanism which appropriately mimics hydrogen combustion.
Experimental Results and Comparison with Simulated Data of a Low Pressure Hydrogen Jet
Sep 2011
Publication
Experiments with a hydrogen jet were performed at two different pressures 96 psig (6.6 bars) and 237 psig (16.3 bars). The hydrogen leak was generated at two different hole sizes 1/16 inch (1.6 mm) and 1/32 inch (0.79 mm). The flammable shape of the plume was characterised by numerous measurements of the hydrogen concentration inside of the jet. The effect of the nearby horizontal surface on the shape of the plume was measured and compared with results of CFD numerical simulations. The paper will present results and an interpretation on the nature of the plume shape.
Sizing and Operation of a Pure Renewable Energy Based Electric System through Hydrogen
Nov 2021
Publication
Today in order to reduce the increase of the carbon dioxide emissions a large number of renewable energy resources (RES) are already implemented. Considering both the intermittency and uncertainty of the RES the energy storage system (ESS) is still needed for balancing and stabilizing the power system. Among different existing categories of ESS the hydrogen storage systems (HSS) have the highest energy density and are crucial for the RES integration. In addition RES are located in faraway regions and are often transmitted to the terminal consumption center through HVDC (high voltage direct current) due to its lower power loss. In this paper we present a power supply system that achieves low-carbon emissions through combined HSS and HVDC technology. First the combined HSS and the HVDC model are established. Secondly the rule-based strategy for operating the HSS microgrid is presented. Then an operating strategy for a typical network i.e. the pure RES generation station-HVDC transmission-microgrids is demonstrated. Finally the best sizing capacities for all components are found by the genetic algorithm. The results prove the efficiency of the presented sizing approach for a pure RES electric system.
CFD Based Simulation of Hydrogen Release Through Elliptical Orifices
Sep 2013
Publication
Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) is applied to investigate the near exit jet behavior of high pressure hydrogen release into quiescent ambient air through different types of orifices. The size and geometry of the release hole can affect the possibility of auto-ignition. Therefore the effect of release geometry on the behavior and development of hydrogen jet issuing from non-axisymmetric (elliptical) and expanding orifices is investigated and compared with their equivalent circular orifices. A three-dimensional in-house code is developed using the MPI library for parallel computing to simulate the flow based on an inviscid approximation. Convection dominates viscous effects in strongly underexpanded supersonic jets in the vicinity of release exit justifying the use of the Euler equations. The transport (advection) equation is applied to calculate the concentration of hydrogen-air mixture. The Abel-Nobel equation of state is used because high pressure hydrogen flow deviates from the ideal gas assumption. This work effort is conducted to fulfill two objectives. First two types of circular and elliptic orifices with the same cross sectional area are simulated and the flow behavior of each case is studied and compared during the initial stage of release. Second the comparative study between expanding circular exit and its fixed counterpart is carried out. This evaluation is conducted for different sizes of nozzle with different aspect ratios.
A Dual Zone Thermodynamic Model for Refueling Hydrogen Vehicles
Sep 2017
Publication
With the simple structure and quick refuelling process the compressed hydrogen storage system is currently widely used. However thermal effects during charging-discharging cycle may induce temperature change in storage tank which has significant impact on the performance of hydrogen storage and the safety of hydrogen storage tank. To address this issue we once propose a single zone lumped parameter model to obtain the analytical solution of hydrogen temperature and use the analytical solution to estimate the hydrogen temperature but the effect of the tank wall is ignored. For better description of the heat transfer characteristics of the tank wall a dual zone (hydrogen gas and tank wall) lumped parameter model will be considered for widely representation of the reference (experimental or simulated) data. Now we extend the single zone model to the dual zone model which uses two different temperatures for gas zone and wall zone. The dual zone model contains two coupled differential equations. To solve them and obtain the solution we use the method of decoupling the coupled differential equations and coupling the solutions of the decoupled differential equations. The steps of the method include: (1) Decoupling of coupled differential equations; (2) Solving decoupled differential equations; (3) Coupling of solutions of differential equations; (4) Solving coupled algebraic equations. Herein three cases are taken into consideration: constant inflow/outflow temperature variable inflow/outflow temperature and constant inflow temperature and variable outflow temperature. The corresponding approximate analytical solutions of hydrogen temperature and wall temperature can be obtained. The hydrogen pressure can be calculated from the hydrogen temperature and the hydrogen mass using the equation of state for ideal gas. Besides the two coupled differential equations can also be solved numerically and the simulated solution can also be obtained. This study will help to set up a formula based approach of refuelling protocol for gaseous hydrogen vehicles.
Large Eddy Simulations of Asymmetric Turbulent Hydrogen Jets Issuing from Realistic Pipe Geometries
Sep 2017
Publication
In the current study a Large Eddy Simulation strategy is applied to model the dispersion of compressible turbulent hydrogen jets issuing from realistic pipe geometries. The work is novel as it explores the effect of jet densities and Reynolds numbers on vertical buoyant jets as they emerge from the outer wall of a pipe through a round orifice perpendicular to the mean flow within the pipe. An efficient Godunov solver is used and coupled with Adaptive Mesh Refinement to provide high resolution solutions only in areas of interest. The numerical results are validated against physical experiments of air and helium which allows a degree of confidence in analysing the data obtained for hydrogen releases. The results show that the jets investigated are always asymmetric. Thus significant discrepancies exist when applying conventional round jet assumptions to determine statistical properties associated with gas leaks from pipelines.
Hydrogen Strategy for Canada: Seizing the Opportunities for Hydrogen - A Call to Action
Dec 2020
Publication
For more than a century our nation’s brightest minds have been working on the technology to turn the invisible promise of hydrogen into tangible solutions. Canadian ingenuity and innovation has once again brought us to a pivotal moment. As we rebuild our economy from the impacts of COVID-19 and fight the existential threat of climate change the development of low-carbon hydrogen is a strategic priority for Canada. The time to act is now.<br/>The Hydrogen Strategy for Canada lays out an ambitious framework for actions that will cement hydrogen as a tool to achieve our goal of net-zero emissions by 2050 and position Canada as a global industrial leader of clean renewable fuels. This strategy shows us that by 2050 clean hydrogen can help us achieve our net-zero goal—all while creating jobs growing our economy and protecting our environment. This will involve switching from conventional gasoline diesel and natural gas to zero-emissions fuel sources taking advantage of new regulatory environments and embracing new technologies to give Canadians more choice of zero emission alternatives.<br/>As one of the top 10 hydrogen producers in the world today we are rich in the feedstocks that produce hydrogen. We are blessed with a strong energy sector and the geographic assets that will propel Canada to be a major exporter of hydrogen and hydrogen technologies. Hydrogen might be nature’s smallest molecule but its potential is enormous. It provides new markets for our conventional energy resources and holds the potential to decarbonize many sectors of our economy including resource extraction freight transportation power generation manufacturing and the production of steel and cement. This Strategy is a call to action. It will spur investments and strategic partnerships across the country and beyond our borders. It will position Canada to seize economic and environmental opportunities that exist coast to coast. Expanding our exports. Creating as many as 350000 good green jobs over the next three decades. All while dramatically reducing our greenhouse gas emissions. And putting a net-zero future within our reach.<br/>The importance of Canada’s resource industries and our clean technology sectors has been magnified during the pandemic. We must harness our combined will expertise and financial resources to fully seize the opportunities that hydrogen presents. This strategy is the product of three years of study and analysis including extensive engagement sessions where we heard from more than 1500 of our country’s leading experts and stakeholders. But its release is not the end of a process. This is only the beginning. Together we will use this Strategy to guide our actions and investments. By working with provinces and territories Indigenous partners and the private-sector and by leveraging our many advantages we will create the prosperity we all want protect the planet we all cherish and we will ensure we leave no one behind.
International Association for Hydrogen Safety ‘Research Priorities Workshop’, September 2018, Buxton, UK
Sep 2018
Publication
Hydrogen has the potential to be used by many countries as part of decarbonising the future energy system. Hydrogen can be used as a fuel ‘vector’ to store and transport energy produced in low-carbon ways. This could be particularly important in applications such as heating and transport where other solutions for low and zero carbon emission are difficult. To enable the safe uptake of hydrogen technologies it is important to develop the international scientific evidence base on the potential risks to safety and how to control them effectively. The International Association for Hydrogen Safety (known as IA HySAFE) is leading global efforts to ensure this. HSE hosted the 2018 IA HySAFE Biennial Research Priorities Workshop. A panel of international experts presented during nine key topic sessions: (1) Industrial and National Programmes; (2) Applications; (3) Storage; (4) Accident Physics – Gas Phase; (5) Accident Physics – Liquid/ Cryogenic Behaviour; (6) Materials; (7) Mitigation Sensors Hazard Prevention and Risk Reduction; (8) Integrated Tools for Hazard and Risk Assessment; (9) General Aspects of Safety.<br/>This report gives an overview of each topic made by the session chairperson. It also gives further analysis of the totality of the evidence presented. The workshop outputs are shaping international activities on hydrogen safety. They are helping key stakeholders to identify gaps in knowledge and expertise and to understand and plan for potential safety challenges associated with the global expansion of hydrogen in the energy system.
A Large-Scale Study on the Effect of Ambient Conditions on Hydrogen Recombiner Induced Ignition
Sep 2019
Publication
Hydrogen recombiners (known in the nuclear industry as passive autocatalytic recombiners-PARs) in general can be utilized for mitigation of hydrogen in controlled areas where there is potential for hydrogen release and ventilation is not practical. Recombiners are widely implemented in the nuclear industry however there are other applications of recombiners outside the nuclear industry that have not yet been explored practically. The most notable benefit of recombiners over conventional hydrogen mitigation measures is their passive capability where power or operator actions are not needed for the equipment to remove hydrogen when it is present.
One of most significant concerns regarding the use of hydrogen recombiners in industry is their potential to ignite hydrogen at elevated concentrations (>6 vol%). The catalyst heated by the exothermal H2–O2 reaction is known to be a potential ignition source to cause hydrogen burns. An experimental program utilizing a full-size PAR at the Large-Scale Vented Combustion Test Facility (LSVCTF) has been carried out by Canadian Nuclear Laboratories (CNL) to investigate and understand the behaviour of hydrogen combustion induced by a PAR on a large-scale basis. A number of parameters external to the PAR have been explored including the effect of ambient humidity (steam) and temperature. The various aspects of this investigation will be discussed in this paper and examples of results are provided.
One of most significant concerns regarding the use of hydrogen recombiners in industry is their potential to ignite hydrogen at elevated concentrations (>6 vol%). The catalyst heated by the exothermal H2–O2 reaction is known to be a potential ignition source to cause hydrogen burns. An experimental program utilizing a full-size PAR at the Large-Scale Vented Combustion Test Facility (LSVCTF) has been carried out by Canadian Nuclear Laboratories (CNL) to investigate and understand the behaviour of hydrogen combustion induced by a PAR on a large-scale basis. A number of parameters external to the PAR have been explored including the effect of ambient humidity (steam) and temperature. The various aspects of this investigation will be discussed in this paper and examples of results are provided.
Numerical Simulation of Combustion of Natural Gas Mixed with Hydrogen in Gas Boilers
Oct 2021
Publication
Hydrogen mixed natural gas for combustion can improve combustion characteristics and reduce carbon emission which has important engineering application value. A casing swirl burner model is adopted to numerically simulate and research the natural gas hydrogen mixing technology for combustion in gas boilers in this paper. Under the condition of conventional air atmosphere and constant air excess coefficient the six working conditions for hydrogen mixing proportion into natural gas are designed to explore the combustion characteristics and the laws of pollution emissions. The temperature distributions composition and emission of combustion flue gas under various working conditions are analyzed and compared. Further investigation is also conducted for the variation laws of NOx and soot generation. The results show that when the boiler heating power is constant hydrogen mixing will increase the combustion temperature accelerate the combustion rate reduce flue gas and CO2 emission increase the generation of water vapor and inhibit the generation of NOx and soot. Under the premise of meeting the fuel interchangeability it is concluded that the optimal hydrogen mixing volume fraction of gas boilers is 24.7%.
Compliance Measurements of Fuel Cell Electric Vehicle Exhaust
Sep 2019
Publication
The NREL Sensor Laboratory has been developing an analyzer that can verify compliance to the international United Nations Global Technical Regulation number 13 (GTR 13--Global Technical Regulation on Hydrogen and Fuel Cell Vehicles) prescriptive requirements pertaining to allowable hydrogen levels in the exhaust of fuel cell electric vehicles (FCEV) [1]. GTR 13 prescribes that the FCEV exhaust shall remain below 4 vol% H2 over a 3-second moving average and shall not at any time exceed 8 vol% H2 as verified with an analyzer with a response time (t90) of 300 ms or faster. GTR 13 has been implemented and is to serve as the basis for national regulations pertaining to hydrogen powered vehicle safety in the United States Canada Japan and the European Union. In the U.S. vehicle safety is overseen by the Department of Transportation (DOT) through the Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards (FMVSS) and in Canada by Transport Canada through the Canadian Motor Vehicle Safety Standard (CMVSS). The NREL FCEV exhaust analyzer is based upon a low-cost commercial hydrogen sensor with a response time (t90) of less than 250 ms. A prototype analyzer and gas probe assembly have been constructed and tested that can interface to the gas sampling system used by Environment and Climate Change Canada’s (ECCC) Emission Research and Measurement Section (ERMS) for the exhaust gas analysis. Through a partnership with Transport Canada ECCC will analyze the hydrogen level in the exhaust of a commercial FCEV. ECCC will use the NREL FCEV Exhaust Gas analyzer to perform these measurements. The analyzer was demonstrated on a FCEV operating under simulated road conditions using a chassis dynamometer at a private facility.
Hydrogen Safety, Training and Risk Assessment System
Sep 2007
Publication
The rapid evolution of information related to hydrogen safety is multidimensional ranging from developing codes and standards to CFD simulations and experimental studies of hydrogen releases to a variety of risk assessment approaches. This information needs to be transformed into system design risk decision-making and first responder tools for use by hydrogen community stakeholders. The Canadian Transportation Fuel Cell Alliance (CTFCA) has developed HySTARtm an interactive Hydrogen Safety Training And Risk System. The HySTARtm user interacts with a Web-based 3-D graphical user interface to input hydrogen system configurations. The system includes a Codes and Standards Expert System that identifies the applicable codes and standards in a number of national jurisdictions that apply to the facility and its components. A Siting Compliance and Planning Expert System assesses compliance with clearance distance requirements in these jurisdictions. Incorporating the results of other CTFCA projects HySTARtm identifies stand-out hydrogen release scenarios and their corresponding release condition that serves as input to built-in consequence and risk assessment programs that output a variety of risk assessment metrics. The latter include on- and off-site individual risk probability of loss of life and expected number of fatalities. These results are displayed on the graphical user interface used to set up the facility. These content and graphical tools are also used to educate regulatory approval and permitting officials and build a first-responder training guide.
Kinetic Modeling and Quantum Yields: Hydrogen Production via Pd‐TiO2 Photocatalytic Water Splitting under Near‐UV and Visible Light
Jan 2022
Publication
A palladium (Pd) doped mesoporous titanium dioxide (TiO2) photocatalyst was used to produce hydrogen (H2) via water splitting under both near‐UV and visible light. Experiments were carried out in the Photo‐CREC Water‐II Reactor (PCW‐II) using a 0.25 wt% Pd‐TiO2 photocatalyst initial pH = 4 and 2.0 v/v% ethanol as an organic scavenger. After 6 h of near‐UV irradiation this photocatalyst yielded 113 cm3 STP of hydrogen (H2). Furthermore after 1 h of near‐UV photoreduc‐ tion followed by 5 h of visible light the 0.25 wt% Pd‐TiO2 photocatalyst yielded 5.25 cm3 STP of H2. The same photocatalyst photoreduced for 24 h under near‐UV and subsequently exposed to 5 h of visible light yielded 29 cm3 STP of H2. It was observed that the promoted redox reactions led to the production of hydrogen and by‐products such as methane ethane ethylene acetaldehyde carbon monoxide carbon dioxide and hydrogen peroxide. These redox reactions could be modeled using an “in series‐parallel” reaction network and Langmuir Hinshelwood based kinetics. The proposed rate equations were validated using statistical analysis for the experimental data and calculated kinetic parameters. Furthermore Quantum yields (QYୌ%) based on the H produced were also established at promising levels: (a) 34.8% under near‐UV light and 1.00 g L−1 photocatalyst concen‐ tration; (b) 8.8% under visible light and 0.15 g L−1. photocatalyst concentration following 24 h of near‐UV.
Safety and Risk Management in Nuclear-Based Hydrogen Production with Thermal Water Splitting
Sep 2013
Publication
The challenges and approaches of the safety and risk management for the hydrogen production with nuclear-based thermochemical water splitting have been far from sufficiently reported as the thermochemical technology is still at a fledgling stage and the linkage of a nuclear reactor with a hydrogen production plant is unprecedented. This paper focuses on the safety issues arising from the interactions between the nuclear heat source and thermochemical hydrogen production cycle as well between the proximate individual processes in the cycle. As steam is utilized in most thermochemical cycles for the water splitting reaction and heat must be transferred from the nuclear source to hydrogen production plant this paper particularly analyzes and quantifies the heat hazard for the scenarios of start-up and shutdown of the hydrogen production plant. Potential safety impacts on the nuclear reactor are discussed. It is concluded that one of the main challenges of safety and risk management is efficient rejection of heat in a shutdown accident. Several options for the measures to be taken are suggested. Copper-chlorine and sulphur-iodine thermochemical cycles are taken as two representative examples for the hazard analysis. It is expected that these newly reported challenges and approaches could help build the future safety and risk management codes and standards for the infrastructure of the thermochemical hydrogen production.
Hydrogen Deflagrations in Stratified Flat Layers in the Large-scale Vented Combustion Test Facility
Sep 2019
Publication
This paper examines the flame dynamics of vented deflagration in stratified hydrogen layers. It also compares the measured combustion pressure transients with 3D GOTHIC simulations to assess GOTHIC’s capability in simulating the associated phenomena. The experiments were performed in the Large-Scale Vented Combustion Test Facility at the Canadian Nuclear Laboratories. The stratified layer was formed by injecting hydrogen at a high elevation at a constant flow rate. The dominant parameters for vented deflagrations in stratified layers were investigated. The experimental results show that significant overpressures are generated in stratified hydrogen–air mixtures with local high concentration although the volume-averaged hydrogen concentration is non-flammable. The GOTHIC predictions capture the overall pressure dynamics of combustion very well but the peak overpressures are consistently over-predicted particularly with higher maximum hydrogen concentrations. The measured combustion overpressures are also compared with Molkov’s model prediction based on a layer-averaged hydrogen concentration.
Estimation of Filling Time for Compressed Hydrogen Refueling
Mar 2019
Publication
In order to facilitate the application of hydrogen energy and ensure its safety the compressed hydrogen storage tank on board needs to be full of hydrogen gas within 3 minutes. Therefore to meet this requirement the effects of refueling parameters on the filling time need to be investigated urgently. For the purpose of solving this issue a novel analytical solution of filling time is obtained from a lumped parameter model in this paper. According to the equation of state for real gas and dimensionless numbers Nu and Re the function relationships between the filling time and the refueling parameters are presented. These parameters include initial temperature initial pressure inflow temperature final temperature and final pressure. These equations are used to fit the reference data the results of fitting show good agreement. Then the values of fitting parameters are further utilized so as to verify the validity of these formulas. We believe this study can contribute to control the hydrogen filling time and ensure the safety during fast filling process.
Experimental Study on Accumulation of Helium Released into a Semi-confined Enclosure without Ventilation
Sep 2019
Publication
This paper examines the helium dispersion behaviour in a 16.6 m3 enclosure with a small opening in the floor and distributed leaks along the edges. Helium a simulant for hydrogen was injected near the center of the floor with an injection rate ranging from 2 to 50 standard liters per minute (Richardson number of 0.3–134) through an upward-facing nozzle. In a short-term transient the helium distribution predicted with the models of Baines & Turner (1969) and Worster & Huppert (1983) matched the measured distributions reasonably well. In a long-term transient the vertical helium profile always reached a steady state which consisted of a homogenous layer at the top overlaying a stratified layer at the bottom. The helium transients in the uniform layer predicted with the models of Lowesmith (2009) and Prasad & Yang (2010) assuming a vent was located in the ceiling were in good agreement with the measured transients.
Recyclable Metal Fuels for Clean and Compact Zero-carbon Power
Jun 2018
Publication
Metal fuels as recyclable carriers of clean energy are promising alternatives to fossil fuels in a future low-carbon economy. Fossil fuels are a convenient and widely-available source of stored solar energy that have enabled our modern society; however fossil-fuel production cannot perpetually keep up with increasing energy demand while carbon dioxide emissions from fossil-fuel combustion cause climate change. Low-carbon energy carriers with high energy density are needed to replace the multiple indispensable roles of fossil fuels including for electrical and thermal power generation for powering transportation fleets and for global energy trade. Metals have high energy densities and metals are therefore fuels within many batteries energetic materials and propellants. Metal fuels can be burned with air or reacted with water to release their chemical energy at a range of power-generation scales. The metal-oxide combustion products are solids that can be captured and then be recycled using zero-carbon electrolysis processes powered by clean energy enabling metals to be used as recyclable zero-carbon solar fuels or electrofuels. A key technological barrier to the increased use of metal fuels is the current lack of clean and efficient combustor/reactor/engine technologies to convert the chemical energy in metal fuels into motive or electrical power (energy). This paper overviews the concept of low-carbon metal fuels and summarizes the current state of our knowledge regarding the reaction of metal fuels with water to produce hot hydrogen on demand and the combustion of metal fuels with air in laminar and turbulent flames. Many important questions regarding metal-fuel combustion processes remain unanswered as do questions concerning the energy-cycle efficiency and life-cycle environmental impacts and economics of metals as recyclable fuels. Metal fuels can be an important technology option within a future low-carbon society and deserve focused attention to address these open questions.
Effect of Anion Exchange Ionomer Content on Electrode Performance in AEM Water Electrolysis
Aug 2020
Publication
Anion exchange membrane water electrolysis (AEMWE) has acquired substantial consideration as a cost-effective hydrogen production technology. The anion ionomer content in the catalyst layers during hydrogen and oxygen evolution reaction (HER and OER) is of ultimate significance. Herein an in-situ half-cell analysis with reference electrodes was carried out for simultaneous potential measurements and identification of the influence of the anion exchange ionomer (AEI) content on anode and cathode performance. The measured half-cell potentials proved the influence of AEI content on the catalytic activity of HER and OER which was supported by the rotating disk electrode (RDE) measurements. Cathode overpotential of Ni/C was not negligible and more affected by the AEI content than anode with the optimized AEI content of 10 wt% while NiO anode OER overpotential was independent of the AEI content. For the same AEI content PGM catalysts showed higher electroactivity than Ni-based catalysts for HER and OER and the cathode catalyst's intrinsic activity is of high importance in the AEM electrolysis operation. Post-mortem analysis by SEM mapping of both AEI and catalyst distributions on the electrode surface showed the effect of AEI loading on the catalyst morphology which could be related to the electrode performance.
Study on Temper Embrittlement and Hydrogen Embrittlement of a Hydrogenation Reactor by Small Punch Test
Jun 2017
Publication
The study on temper embrittlement and hydrogen embrittlement of a test block from a 3Cr1Mo1/4V hydrogenation reactor after ten years of service was carried out by small punch test (SPT) at different temperatures. The SPT fracture energy Esp (derived from integrating the load-displacement curve) divided by the maximum load (Fm) of SPT was used to fit the Esp/Fm versus-temperature curve to determine the energy transition temperature (Tsp) which corresponded to the ductile-brittle transition temperature of the Charpy impact test. The results indicated that the ratio of Esp/Fm could better represent the energy of transition in SPT compared with Esp. The ductile-to-brittle transition temperature of the four different types of materials was measured using the hydrogen charging test by SPT. These four types of materials included the base metal and the weld metal in the as-received state and the base metal and the weld metal in the de-embrittled state. The results showed that there was a degree of temper embrittlement in the base metal and the weld metal after ten years of service at 390 °C. The specimens became slightly more brittle but this was not obvious after hydrogen charging. Because the toughness of the material of the hydrogenation reactor was very good the flat samples of SPT could not characterize the energy transition temperature within the liquid nitrogen temperature. Additionally there was no synergetic effect of temper embrittlement and hydrogen embrittlement found in 3Cr1Mo1/4V steel.
Alberta Hydrogen Roadmap
Nov 2021
Publication
Alberta is preparing for a lower emission future. The Hydrogen Roadmap is a key part of that future and Alberta's Recovery Plan. The roadmap is our path to building a provincial hydrogen economy and accessing global markets. It contains several policy actions that will be introduced in the coming months and years and it provides support to the sector as technology and markets develop.<br/>Alberta is already the largest hydrogen producer in Canada. We have all the resources expertise and technology needed to quickly become a global supplier of clean low-cost hydrogen. With a worldwide market estimated to be worth over $2.5 trillion a year by 2050 hydrogen can be the next great energy export that fuels jobs investment and economic opportunity across our province.
Integration of Wind Energy, Hydrogen and Natural Gas Pipeline Systems to Meet Community and Transportation Energy Needs: A Parametric Study
Apr 2014
Publication
The potential benefits are examined of the “Power-to-Gas” (P2G) scheme to utilize excess wind power capacity by generating hydrogen (or potentially methane) for use in the natural gas distribution grid. A parametric analysis is used to determine the feasibility and size of systems producing hydrogen that would be injected into the natural gas grid. Specifically wind farms located in southwestern Ontario Canada are considered. Infrastructure requirements wind farm size pipeline capacity geographical dispersion hydrogen production rate capital and operating costs are used as performance measures. The model takes into account the potential production rate of hydrogen and the rate that it can be injected into the local gas grid. “Straw man” systems are examined centered on a wind farm size of 100 MW integrating a 16-MW capacity electrolysis system typically producing 4700 kg of hydrogen per day.
A Review of Heavy-Duty Vehicle Powertrain Technologies Diesel Engine Vehicles, Battery Electric Vehicles, and Hydrogen Fuel Cell Electric Vehicles
Jun 2021
Publication
Greenhouse gas emissions from the freight transportation sector are a significant contributor to climate change pollution and negative health impacts because of the common use of heavy-duty diesel vehicles (HDVs). Governments around the world are working to transition away from diesel HDVs and to electric HDVs to reduce emissions. Battery electric HDVs and hydrogen fuel cell HDVs are two available alternatives to diesel engines. Each diesel engine HDV battery-electric HDV and hydrogen fuel cell HDV powertrain has its own advantages and disadvantages. This work provides a comprehensive review to examine the working mechanism performance metrics and recent developments of the aforementioned HDV powertrain technologies. A detailed comparison between the three powertrain technologies highlighting the advantages and disadvantages of each is also presented along with future perspectives of the HDV sector. Overall diesel engine in HDVs will remain an important technology in the short-term future due to the existing infrastructure and lower costs despite their high emissions while battery-electric HDV technology and hydrogen fuel cell HDV technology will be slowly developed to eliminate their barriers including costs infrastructure and performance limitations to penetrate the HDV market.
CFD Model Based Ann Prediction of Flammable Vapor Colour Formed by Liquid Hydrogen Spill
Sep 2021
Publication
Unintended releases can occur during the production storage transportation and filling of liquid hydrogen which may cause devastating consequences. In the present work liquid hydrogen leak is modeled in ANSYS Fluent with the numerical model validated using the liquid hydrogen spill test data. A three-layer artificial neural network (ANN) model is built in which the wind speed ground temperature leakage time and leakage rate are taken as the inputs the horizontal diffusion distance and vertical diffusion distance of combustible gas as the outputs of the ANN. The representative sample data derived from the detailed calculation results of the numerical model are selected via the orthogonal experiment method to train and verify the back propagation (BP) neural network. Comparing the calculation results of the formula fitting with the sample data the results show that the established ANN model can quickly and accurately predict the horizontal and vertical diffusion distance of flammable vapor cloud relatively. The influences of four parameters on the horizontal hazard distance as well as vertical hazard height are predicted and analyzed in the case of continuous overflow of liquid hydrogen using the ANN model.
Decarbonization of Cement Production in a Hydrogen Economy
Apr 2022
Publication
The transition to net-zero emission energy systems creates synergistic opportunities across sectors. For example fuel hydrogen production from water electrolysis generates by-product oxygen that could be used to reduce the cost of carbon capture and storage (CCS) essential in the decarbonization of clinker production in cement making. To assess this opportunity a techno-economic assessment was carried out for the production of clinker using oxy-combustion in a natural gas-fueled plant coupled to CCS. Material and energy flows were assessed in a reference case for clinker production (oxygen from air no CCS) and compared to oxy-combustion clinker production from either an air separation unit (ASU 95% O2) or water electrolysis (100% O2) both coupled to CCS. Compared to the reference air-combusted clinker plant oxy-combustion increases thermal energy demand by 7% and electricity demand by 137% for ASU and 67% for electrolytic oxygen. The levelized cost of oxygen supply ranges from $49/tO2 for an on-site ASU to pipelined electrolytic O2 at $35/tO2 (200 km) or $13/t O2 (20 km). The cost of clinker for the reference plant without CCS increases linearly from $84/t clinker to $193/t clinker at a carbon price of $0/tCO2 to $150/tCO2 respectively. With oxy-combustion and CCS the clinker production cost ranges from $119 to $122/t clinker reflecting a breakeven carbon price of $39 to $53/tCO2 compared to the reference case. The lower cost for the electrolytic supply of by-product oxygen compared to ASU oxygen must be balanced against the reliability of supply the pipeline transport distance and the charges that may be added by the hydrogen producer.
The Role of the Argon and Helium Bath Gases on the Detonation Structure of H2/)2 Mixture
Sep 2021
Publication
Recent modeling efforts of non-equilibrium effects in detonations have suggested that hydrogen-based detonations may be affected by vibrational non-equilibrium of the hydrogen and oxygen molecules effects which could explain discrepancies of cell sizes measured experimentally and calculated without relaxation effects. The present study addresses the role of vibrational relaxation in 2H2/O2 detonations by considering two-bath gases argon and helium. These two gases have the same thermodynamic and kinetic effects when relaxation is neglected. However due to the bath gases differences in molecular weight and reduced mass differences which affect the molecular collisions relaxation rates can be changed by approximately 50-70%. Experiments were performed in a narrow channel in mixtures of 2H2/O2/7Ar and 2H2/O2/7He to evaluate the role of the bath gas on detonation cellular structures. The experiments showed differences in velocity deficits and cell sizes for experimental conditions keeping the induction zone length constant in each of the mixtures. These differences were negligible in sensitive mixtures but increased with the increase in velocity deficits while the cell sizes approaching the channel dimensions. Near the limits differences of cell size in two mixtures approached a factor of 2. These differences were however reconciled by accounting for the viscous losses to the tube walls evaluated using a modified version of Mirels' laminar boundary layer theory and generalized Chapman-Jouguet theory for eigenvalue detonations. The experiments suggest that there is an influence of relaxation effects on the cellular structure of detonations which is more sensitive to wall boundary conditions. However the previous works showed that the impact of vibrational non-equilibrium in a mixture of H2/Air is more visible due to the effects of N2 in the air slowest to relax. Previous discrepancies suggested to be indicative of relaxation effects should be reevaluated by the inclusion of wall loss effects.
Bayesian Inference and Uncertainty Quantification for Hydrogen-Enriched and Lean-Premixed Combustion Systems
May 2021
Publication
Development of probabilistic modelling tools to perform Bayesian inference and uncertainty quantification (UQ) is a challenging task for practical hydrogen-enriched and low-emission combustion systems due to the need to take into account simultaneously simulated fluid dynamics and detailed combustion chemistry. A large number of evaluations is required to calibrate models and estimate parameters using experimental data within the framework of Bayesian inference. This task is computationally prohibitive in high-fidelity and deterministic approaches such as large eddy simulation (LES) to design and optimize combustion systems. Therefore there is a need to develop methods that: (a) are suitable for Bayesian inference studies and (b) characterize a range of solutions based on the uncertainty of modelling parameters and input conditions. This paper aims to develop a computationally-efficient toolchain to address these issues for probabilistic modelling of NOx emission in hydrogen-enriched and lean-premixed combustion systems. A novel method is implemented into the toolchain using a chemical reactor network (CRN) model non-intrusive polynomial chaos expansion based on the point collocation method (NIPCE-PCM) and the Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) method. First a CRN model is generated for a combustion system burning hydrogen-enriched methane/air mixtures at high-pressure lean-premixed conditions to compute NOx emission. A set of metamodels is then developed using NIPCE-PCM as a computationally efficient alternative to the physics-based CRN model. These surrogate models and experimental data are then implemented in the MCMC method to perform a two-step Bayesian calibration to maximize the agreement between model predictions and measurements. The average standard deviations for the prediction of exit temperature and NOx emission are reduced by almost 90% using this method. The calibrated model then used with confidence for global sensitivity and reliability analysis studies which show that the volume of the main-flame zone is the most important parameter for NOx emission. The results show satisfactory performance for the developed toolchain to perform Bayesian inference and UQ studies enabling a robust and consistent process for designing and optimising low-emission combustion systems.
The ‘Green’ Ni-UGSO Catalyst for Hydrogen Production under Various Reforming Regimes
Jun 2021
Publication
A new spinelized Ni catalyst (Ni-UGSO) using Ni(NO3)2·6H2O as the Ni precursor was prepared according to a less material intensive protocol. The support of this catalyst is a negative-value mining residue UpGraded Slag Oxide (UGSO) produced from a TiO2 slag production unit. Applied to dry reforming of methane (DRM) at atmospheric pressure T = 810 °C space velocity of 3400 mL/(h·g) and molar CO2/CH4 = 1.2 Ni-UGSO gives a stable over 168 h time-on-stream methane conversion of 92%. In this DRM reaction optimization study: (1) the best performance is obtained with the 10–13 wt% Ni load; (2) the Ni-UGSO catalysts obtained from two different batches of UGSO demonstrated equivalent performances despite their slight differences in composition; (3) the sulfur-poisoning resistance study shows that at up to 5.5 ppm no Ni-UGSO deactivation is observed. In steam reforming of methane (SRM) Ni-UGSO was tested at 900 °C and a molar ratio of H2O/CH4 = 1.7. In this experimental range CH4 conversion rapidly reached 98% and remained stable over 168 h time-on-stream (TOS). The same stability is observed for H2 and CO yields at around 92% and 91% respectively while H2/CO was close to 3. In mixed (dry and steam) methane reforming using a ratio of H2O/CH4 = 0.15 and CO2/CH4 = 0.97 for 74 h and three reaction temperature levels (828 °C 847 °C and 896 °C) CH4 conversion remains stable; 80% at 828 °C (26 h) 85% at 847 °C (24 h) and 95% at 896 °C (24 h). All gaseous streams have been analyzed by gas chromatography. Both fresh and used catalysts are analyzed by scanning electron microscopy-electron dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (SEM-EDXS) X-ray diffraction (XRD) and thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) coupled with mass spectroscopy (MS) and BET Specific surface. In the reducing environment of reforming such catalytic activity is mainly attributed to (a) alloys such as FeNi FeNi3 and Fe3Ni2 (reduction of NiFe2O4 FeNiAlO4) and (b) to the solid solution NiO-MgO. The latter is characterized by a molecular distribution of the catalytically active Ni phase while offering an environment that prevents C deposition due to its alkalinity.
A Model for Hydrogen Detonation Diffraction or Transmission to a Non-confined Layer
Sep 2021
Publication
One strategy for arresting propagating detonation waves in pipes is by imposing a sudden area enlargement which provides a rapid lateral divergence of the gases in the reaction zone and attenuates the leading shock. For sufficiently small tube diameter the detonation decays to a deflagration and the shock decays to negligible strengths. This is known as the critical tube diameter problem. In the present study we provide a closed form model to predict the detonation quenching for 2D channels. This problem also applies to the transmission of a detonation wave from a confined layer to a weakly-confined layer. Whitham’s geometric shock dynamics coupled with a shock evolution law based on shocks sustained by a constant source obtained by the shock change equations of Radulescu is shown to capture the lateral shock dynamics response to the failure wave originating at the expansion corner. A criterion for successful detonation transmission to open space is that the lateral strain rate provided by the failure wave not exceed the critical strain rate of steady curved detonations. Using the critical lateral strain rate obtained by He and Clavin a closed form solution is obtained for the critical channel opening permitting detonation transmission. The predicted critical channel width is found in excellent agreement with our recent experiments and simulations of diffracting H2/O2/Ar detonations. Model comparison with available data for H2/air detonation diffraction into open space at ambient conditions or for transmission into a weakly confined layer by air is also found in good agreement within a factor never exceeding 2 for the critical opening or layer dimension.
Nickel-Based Electrocatalysts for Water Electrolysis
Feb 2022
Publication
Currently hydrogen production is based on the reforming process leading to the emission of pollutants; therefore a substitute production method is imminently required. Water electrolysis is an ideal alternative for large-scale hydrogen production as it does not produce any carbon-based pollutant byproducts. The production of green hydrogen from water electrolysis using intermittent sources (e.g. solar and eolic sources) would facilitate clean energy storage. However the electrocatalysts currently required for water electrolysis are noble metals making this potential option expensive and inaccessible for industrial applications. Therefore there is a need to develop electrocatalysts based on earth-abundant and low-cost metals. Nickel-based electrocatalysts are a fitting alternative because they are economically accessible. Extensive research has focused on developing nickel-based electrocatalysts for hydrogen and oxygen evolution. Theoretical and experimental work have addressed the elucidation of these electrochemical processes and the role of heteroatoms structure and morphology. Even though some works tend to be contradictory they have lit up the path for the development of efficient nickel-based electrocatalysts. For these reasons a review of recent progress is presented herein.
Techno-economic Assessment of Hydrogen Production from Seawater
Nov 2022
Publication
Population growth and the expansion of industries have increased energy demand and the use of fossil fuels as an energy source resulting in release of greenhouse gases (GHG) and increased air pollution. Countries are therefore looking for alternatives to fossil fuels for energy generation. Using hydrogen as an energy carrier is one of the most promising alternatives to replace fossil fuels in electricity generation. It is therefore essential to know how hydrogen is produced. Hydrogen can be produced by splitting the water molecules in an electrolyser using the abondand water resources which are covering around ⅔ of the Earth's surface. Electrolysers however require high-quality water with conductivity in the range of 0.1–1 μS/cm. In January 2018 there were 184 offshore oil and gas rigs in the North Sea which may be excellent sites for hydrogen production from seawater. The hydrogen production process reported in this paper is based on a proton exchange membrane (PEM) electrolyser with an input flow rate of 300 L/h. A financially optimal system for producing demineralized water from seawater with conductivity in the range of 0.1–1 μS/cm as the input for electrolyser by WAVE (Water Application Value Engine) design software was studied. The costs of producing hydrogen using the optimised system was calculated to be US$3.51/kg H2. The best option for low-cost power generation using renewable resources such as photovoltaic (PV) devices wind turbines as well as electricity from the grid was assessed considering the location of the case considered. All calculations were based on assumption of existing cable from the grid to the offshore meaning that the cost of cables and distribution infrastructure were not considered. Models were created using HOMER Pro (Hybrid Optimisation of Multiple Energy Resources) software to optimise the microgrids and the distributed energy resources under the assumption of a nominal discount rate inflation rate project lifetime and CO2 tax in Norway. Eight different scenarios were examined using HOMER Pro and the main findings being as follows:<br/>The cost of producing water with quality required by the electrolyser is low compared with the cost of electricity for operation of the electrolyser and therefore has little effect on the total cost of hydrogen production (less than 1%).<br/>The optimal solution was shown to be electricity from the grid which has the lowest levelised cost of energy (LCOE) of the options considered. The hydrogen production cost using electricity from the grid was about US$ 5/kg H2.<br/>Grid based electricity resulted in the lowest hydrogen production cost even when costs for CO2 emissions in Norway that will start to apply in 2025 was considered being approximately US$7.7/kg H2.<br/>From economical point of view wind energy was found to be a more economical than solar.
Boundary Layer Effects on the Critical Nozzle of Hydrogen Sonic Jet
Oct 2015
Publication
When hydrogen flows through a small finite length constant exit area nozzle the viscous effects create a fluid throat which acts as a converging-diverging nozzle and lead to Mach number greater than one at the exit if the jet is under-expanded. This phenomenon influences the mass flow rate and the dispersion cloud size. In this study the boundary layer effect on the unsteady hydrogen sonic jet flow through a 1 mm diameter pipe from a high pressure reservoir (up to 70 MPa) is studied using computational fluid dynamics with a large eddy simulation turbulence model. This viscous flow simulation is compared with a non-viscous simulation to demonstrate that the velocity is supersonic at the exit of a small exit nozzle and that the mass flow is reduced.
A Comparative Study of Detonability and Propensity to Sustain High-speed Turbulent Deflagrations in Hydrogen and Methane Mixtures
Sep 2013
Publication
We’ve studied the conditions enabling a detonation to be quenched when interacting with an obstruction and the propensity for establishing subsequent fast-flame. Oxy-hydrogen detonations were found quench more easily than oxy-methane detonations when comparing the ratio of gap size and the detonation cell size. High-speed turbulent deflagrations that re-accelerate back to a detonation were only observed in methane-oxygen mixtures. Separate hot-spot ignition calculations revealed that the higher detonability of methane correlates with its stronger propensity to develop localized hot-spots. The results suggest that fast-flames are more difficult to form in hydrogen than in methane mixtures.
Mesh-Independent Large-Eddy Simulation with Anisotropic Adaptive Mesh Refinement for Hydrogen Deflagration Prediction in Closed Vessels
Sep 2019
Publication
The use of high-fidelity simulation methods based on large-eddy simulation (LES) are proving useful for understanding and mitigating the safety hazards associated with hydrogen releases from nuclear power plants. However accurate modelling of turbulent premixed hydrogen flames via LES can require very high resolution to capture both the large-scale turbulence and its interaction with the flame fronts. Standard meshing strategies can result in impractically high computational costs especially for the thin fronts of hydrogen flames. For these reasons the use of a recently formulated integral length scale approximation (ILSA) subfilter-scale model in combination with an efficient anisotropic block-based adaptive mesh refinement (AMR) technique is proposed and examined herein for performing LES of turbulent premixed hydrogen flames. The anisotropic AMR method allows dynamic and solution-dependent resolution of flame fronts and the grid-independent properties of the ILSA model ensure that numerical errors associated with implicitly-filtered LES techniques in regions with varying resolution are avoided. The combined approach has the potential to allow formally converged LES solutions (direct numerical simulation results are typically reached in the limit of very fine meshes with standard subgrid models). The proposed LES methodology is applied to combustion simulations of lean premixed hydrogen-air mixtures within closed vessels: a problem relevant to hydrogen safety applications in nuclear facilities. A progress variable-based method with a multi-phenomena burning velocity model is used as the combustion model. The present simulation results are compared to the available experiment data for several previously studied THAI vessel cases and the capabilities of the proposed LES approach are assessed.
A Turbulent Combustion Model for Ignition of Rapidly Expanding Hydrogen Jets
Mar 2013
Publication
A turbulent combustion model based on the Linear Eddy Model for Large Eddy Simulation (LEM- LES) is currently proposed to study self-ignition events of rapidly expanding hydrogen jets. The model is a one-dimensional treatment of a diffusion-reaction system within each multi-dimensional LES cell. This reduces the expense of solving a complete multi-dimensional problem while preserving micro-scale hotspots and their effects on ignition. The current approach features a Lagrangian description of fluid particles on the sub-grid for increased accuracy. Also Adaptive Mesh Refinement (AMR) is implemented for increased computational efficiency. In this paper the model is validated for various inviscid laminar 1-D mixing and ignition problems shock tube problems flames and detonations.
Effects of Chemical Kinetics on Ignition of Hydrogen Jets
Sep 2013
Publication
During the early phase of the transient process following a hydrogen leak into the atmosphere a contact surface appears separating air heated by the leading shock from hydrogen cooled by expansion. Locally the interface is approximately planar. Diffusion leads to a temperature decrease on the air side and an increase in the hydrogen-filled region and mass diffusion of hydrogen into air and of air into hydrogen potentially resulting in ignition. This process was analyzed by Li ˜nan and Crespo [1] for unity Lewis number and Li ˜nan and Williams [2] for Lewis number less than unity. We included in the analysis the effect of a slow expansion [3 4] leading to a slow drop in temperature which occurs in transient jets. Chemistry being very temperature-sensitive the reaction rate peaks close to the hot side of the interface where only a small fuel concentration present close to the warm air-rich side which depends crucially upon the fuel Lewis number. For Lewis number unity the fuel concentration due to diffusion is comparable to the rate of consumption by chemistry. If the Lewis number is less than unity diffusion brings in more fuel than temperature-controlled chemistry consumes. For a Lewis number greater than unity diffusion is not strong enough to bring in as much fuel as chemistry would burn; combustion is controlled by fuel diffusion. If the temperature drop due to expansion associated with the multidimensional jet does not lower significantly the reaction rate up to that point analysis shows that ignition in the jet takes place. For fuel Lewis number greater than unity chemistry does not lead to a defined explosion so that eventually expansion will affect the process; ignition does not take place [3 4]. In the current paper these results are extended to consider multistep chemical kinetics but for otherwise similar assumptions. High activation energy is no longer applicable. Instead results are obtained in the short time limit still as a perturbation superimposed to the self-similar solution to the chemically frozen diffusion solution. In that approximation the initiation step which consumes fuel and oxidant is taken to be slow compared with steps that consume one of the reactants and an intermediate species. The formulation leads to a two point boundary value problem for set of coupled rate equations plus an energy equation for perturbations. These equations are linear with variable co-effcients. The coupled problem is solved numerically using a split algorithm in which chemical reaction is solved for frozen diffusion while diffusion is solved for frozen chemistry. At each time step the still coupled linear problem is solved exactly by projecting onto the eigenmodes of the stiff matrix so that the solution is unaffected by stiffness. Since in the short time limit temperature is only affected at the perturbation level the matrix depends only on the similarity variable x t but it is otherwise time-independent. As a result determination of the eigenvalues and eigenvectors is only done once (using Maple) for the entire range of discretized values of the similarity variable. The diffusion problem consists of a set of independent equations for each species. Each of these is solved using orthogonal decomposition onto Hermite polynomials for the homogeneous part plus a particular solution proportional to time for the non-homogeneous (source) terms. That approach can be implemented for different kinetic schemes.
Measurements of Flow Velocity and Scalar Concentration in Turbulent Multi-component Jets
Sep 2017
Publication
Buoyancy effects and nozzle geometry can have a significant impact on turbulent jet dispersion. This work was motivated by applications involving hydrogen. Using helium as an experimental proxy buoyant horizontal jets issuing from a round orifice on the side wall of a circular tube were analyzed experimentally using particle image velocimetry (PIV) and planar laser-induced fluorescence (PLIF) techniques simultaneously to provide instantaneous and time-averaged flow fields of velocity and concentration. Effects of buoyancy and asymmetry on the resulting flow structure were studied over a range of Reynolds numbers and gas densities. Significant differences were found between the centreline trajectory spreading rate and velocity decay of conventional horizontal round axisymmetric jets issuing through flat plates and the pipeline leak-representative jets considered in the present study. The realistic pipeline jets were always asymmetric and found to deflect about the jet axis in the near field. In the far field it was found that the realistic pipeline leak geometry causes buoyancy effects to dominate much sooner than expected compared to horizontal round jets issuing through flat plates.
State-of-the-Art and Research Priorities in Hydrogen Safety
Sep 2013
Publication
On October 16-17 2012 the International Association for Hydrogen Safety (HySafe) in cooperation with the Institute for Energy and Transport of the Joint Research Centre of the European Commission (JRC IET Petten) held a two-day workshop dedicated to Hydrogen Safety Research Priorities. The workshop was hosted by Federal Institute for Materials Research and Testing (BAM) in Berlin Germany. The main idea of the Workshop was to bring together stakeholders who can address the existing knowledge gaps in the area of the hydrogen safety including identification and prioritization of such gaps from the standpoint of scientific knowledge both experimental and theoretical including numerical. The experience highlighting these gaps which was obtained during both practical applications (industry) and risk assessment should serve as reference point for further analysis. The program included two sections: knowledge gaps as they are addressed by industry and knowledge gaps and state-of-the-art by research. In the current work the main results of the workshop are summarized and analysed.
Numerical and Experimental Investigation of Buoyant Gas Release
Sep 2009
Publication
Buoyant round vertical jet had been investigated using Large Eddy Simulations at low Mach number. For the purpose of comparison with in-house experimental data in the present work helium has been used as a substitute for hydrogen. The influence of the transient concentration fields on the volume of gas with concentration within flammability limits has been investigated and their evolution and relation with average fields ad been characterized. Transient concentration fields created during initial jet development had been considered. Numerical results have been compared with in-house experiments and data published in the literature.
Heat Transfer Analysis for Fast Filling of On-board Hydrogen Tank
Mar 2019
Publication
The heat transfer analysis in the filling process of compressed on-board hydrogen storage tank has been the focus of hydrogen storage research. The initial conditions mass flow rate and heat transfer coefficient have certain influence on the hydrogen filling performance. In this paper the effects of mass flow rate and heat transfer coefficient on hydrogen filling performance are mainly studied. A thermodynamic model of the compressed hydrogen storage tank was established by Matlab/Simulink. This 0D model is utilized to predict the hydrogen temperature hydrogen pressure tank wall temperature and SOC (State of Charge) during filling process. Comparing the simulated results with the experimental data the practicability of the model can be verified. The simulated results have certain meaning for improving the hydrogenation parameters in real filling process. And the model has a great significance to the study of hydrogen filling and purification.
Experimental Investigation of Spherical-flame Acceleration in Lean Hydrogen-air Mixtures
Oct 2015
Publication
Large-scale experiments examining spherical-flame acceleration in lean hydrogen-air mixtures were performed in a 64 m3 constant-pressure enclosure. Equivalence ratios ranging from 0.33 to 0.57 were examined using detailed front tracking for flame diameters up to 1.2 m through the use of a Background Oriented Schlieren (BOS) technique. From these measurements the critical radii for onset of instability for these mixtures on the order of 2–3 cm were obtained. In addition the laminar burning velocity and rate of flame acceleration as a function of radius were also measured.
Flammability Profiles Associated with High-pressure Hydrogen Jets Released in Close Proximity to Surfaces
Oct 2015
Publication
This paper describes experimental and numerical modelling results from an investigation into the flammability profiles associated with high pressure hydrogen jets released in close proximity to surfaces. This work was performed under a Transnational Access Agreement activity funded by the European Research Infrastructure project H2FC.<br/>The experimental programme involved ignited and unignited releases of hydrogen at pressures of 150 and 425 barg through nozzles of 1.06 and 0.64 mm respectively. The proximity of the release to a ceiling or the ground was varied and the results compared with an equivalent free-jet test. During the unignited experiments concentration profiles were measured using hydrogen sensors. During the ignited releases thermal radiation was measured using radiometers and an infra-red camera. The results show that the flammable volume and flame length increase when the release is in close proximity to a surface. The increases are quantified and the safety implications discussed.<br/>Selected experiments were modelled using the CFD model FLACS for validation purposes and a comparison of the results is also included in this paper. Similarly to experiments the CFD results show an increase in flammable volume when the release is close to a surface. The unstable atmospheric conditions during the experiments are shown to have a significant impact on the results.
Modelling Of Hydrogen Explosion on a Pressure Swing Adsorption Facility
Sep 2011
Publication
Computational fluid dynamic simulations have been performed in order to study the consequences of a hydrogen release from a pressure swing adsorption installation operating at 30 barg. The simulations were performed using FLACS-Hydrogen software from GexCon. The impact of obstruction partial confinement leak orientation and wind on the explosive cloud formation (size and explosive mass) and on explosion consequences is investigated. Overpressures resulting from ignition are calculated as a function of the time to ignition.
Experimental Study of the Spontaneous Ignition of Partly Confined Hydrogen Jets
Sep 2011
Publication
The current study addresses the spontaneous ignition of hydrogen jets released into a confined oxidizer environment experimentally. The experiments are conducted in a shock tube where hydrogen gas is shock-accelerated into oxygen across a perforated plate. The operating conditions and hole dimension of the plate were varied in order to identify different flow field and ignition scenarios. Time resolved Schlieren visualization permitted to reconstruct the gasdynamic evolution of the release and different shock interactions. Time resolved self-luminosity records permitted us to record whether ignition was achieved and also to record the dimension of the turbulent mixing layer. The ignition limits determined experimentally in good agreement with the 1D diffusion ignition model proposed by Maxwell and Radulescu. Nevertheless the experiments demonstrated that the mixing layer is two to three orders of magnitude thicker than predicted by molecular diffusion which can be attributed to the observed mixing layer instabilities and shock-mixing layer interactions which provide a much more intense mixing rate than anticipated from previous and current numerical predictions. These observations further clarify why releases through partly confined geometries are more conducive to jet ignition of the jets.
The Crucial Role of the Lewis Number in Jet Ignition
Sep 2011
Publication
During the early phase of the transient process following a hydrogen leak into the atmosphere a contact surface appears separating hot air from cold hydrogen. Locally the interface is approximately planar. Diffusion occurs potentially leading to ignition. This process was analyzed by Lin˜a´n and Crespo (1976) for Lewis number unity and Lin˜a´n and Williams (1993) for Lewis number less than unity. In addition to conduction these processes are affected by expansion due to the flow which leads to a temperature drop. If chemistry is very temperature-sensitive then the reaction rate peaks close to the hot region where relatively little fuel is present. Indeed the Arrhenius rate drops rapidly as temperature drops much more so than fuel concentration. However the small fuel concentration present close to the airrich side depends crucially upon the balance between fuel diffusion and heat diffusion hence the fuel Lewis number. For Lewis number unity the fuel concentration present due to diffusion is comparable to the rate of consumption due to chemistry. If the Lewis number is less than unity fuel concentration brought in by diffusion is large compared with temperature-controlled chemistry. For a Lewis number greater than unity diffusion is not strong enough to bring in as much fuel as chemistry would be able to burn and combustion is controlled by fuel diffusion. In the former case combustion occurs faster leading to a localized ignition at a finite time determined by the analysis. As long as the temperature drop due to the expansion associated with the multidimensional nature of the jet does not lower significantly the reaction rate up to that point ignition in the jet takes place. For fuel Lewis number greater than unity first the reaction rate is much lower. Second chemistry does not lead to a defined ignition. Eventually expansion will affect the process and ignition does not take place. In summary it appears that the reason why hydrogen is the only fuel for which jet ignition has been observed is a Lewis number effect coupled with a high speed of sound hence a high initial temperature discontinuity.
Simulation of Shock-Initiated Ignition
Sep 2009
Publication
The scenario of detonative ignition in shocked mixture is significant because it is a contributor to deflagration to detonation transition for example following shock reflections. However even in one dimension simulation of ignition between a contact surface or a flame and a shock moving into a combustible mixture is difficult because of the singular nature of the initial conditions. Initially as the shock starts moving into reactive mixture the region filled with reactive mixture has zero thickness. On a fixed grid the number of grid points between the shock and the contact surface increases as the shock moves away from the latter. Due to initial lack of resolution in the region of interest staircasing may occur whereby the resulting plots consist of jumps between few values a few grid points and these numerical artifacts are amplified by the chemistry which is very sensitive to temperature leading to unreliable results. The formulation is transformed replacing time and space by time and space over time as the independent variables. This frame of reference corresponds to the self-similar formulation in which the non-reactive problem remains stationary and the initial conditions are well-resolved. Additionally a solution obtained from short time perturbation is used as initial condition at a time still short enough for the perturbation to be very accurate but long enough so that there is sufficient resolution. The numerical solution to the transformed problem is obtained using an essentially non-oscillatory algorithm which is adequate not only for the early part of the process but also for the latter part when chemistry leads to appearance of a shock and eventually a detonation wave is formed. A validation study was performed and the results were compared with the literature for single step Arrhenius chemistry. The method and its implementation were found to be effective. Results are presented for values of activation energy ranging from mild to stiff.
High Pressure Hydrogen Jets in the Presence of a Surface
Sep 2009
Publication
The effect of surfaces on the extent of high pressure vertical and horizontal unignited jets is studied using CFD numerical simulations performed with FLACS Hydrogen and Phoenics. For a constant flow rate release of hydrogen from a 284 bar storage unit through a 8.5 mm orifice located 1 meter from the ground the maximum extent of the flammable cloud is determined as a function of time and compared to a free vertical hydrogen jet under identical release conditions. The results are compared to methane numerical simulations and to the predictions of the Birch correlations for the size of the flammable cloud. We find that the maximum extent of the flammable clouds of free jets obtained using CFD numerical simulations for both hydrogen and methane are in agreement with the Birch predictions. For hydrogen horizontal free jets there is strong buoyancy effect observed towards the end of the flammable cloud thus noticeably reducing its centreline extent. For methane horizontal free jets this effect is not observed. For methane the presence of the ground results in a pronounced increase in the extent of the flammable cloud compared to a free jet. The effects of a surface on vertical jets are also studied.
Risk-Informed Process and Tools for Permitting Hydrogen Fueling Stations
Sep 2007
Publication
The permitting process for hydrogen fueling stations varies from country to country. However a common step in the permitting process is the demonstration that the proposed fueling station meets certain safety requirements. Currently many permitting authorities rely on compliance with well known codes and standards as a means to permit a facility. Current codes and standards for hydrogen facilities require certain safety features specify equipment made of material suitable for hydrogen environment and include separation or safety distances. Thus compliance with the code and standard requirements is widely accepted as evidence of a safe design. However to ensure that a hydrogen facility is indeed safe the code and standard requirements should be identified using a risk-informed process that utilizes an acceptable level of risk. When compliance with one or more code or standard requirements is not possible an evaluation of the risk associated with the exemptions to the requirements should be understood and conveyed to the Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ). Establishment of a consistent risk assessment toolset and associated data is essential to performing these risk evaluations. This paper describes an approach for risk-informing the permitting process for hydrogen fueling stations that relies primarily on the establishment of risk-informed codes and standards. The proposed risk-informed process begins with the establishment of acceptable risk criteria associated with the operation of hydrogen fueling stations. Using accepted Quantitative Risk Assessment (QRA) techniques and the established risk criteria the minimum code and standard requirements necessary to ensure the safe operation of hydrogen facilities can be identified. Risk informed permitting processes exist in some countries and are being developed in others. To facilitate consistent risk-informed approaches the participants in the International Energy Agency (IEA) Task 19 on hydrogen safety are working to identify acceptable risk criteria QRA models and supporting data.
Humidity Tolerant Hydrogen-oxygen Recombination Catalysts for Hydrogen Safety Applications
Sep 2017
Publication
Catalytic hydrogen-oxygen recombination is a non-traditional method to limit hydrogen accumulation and prevent combustion in the hydrogen industry. Outside of conventional use in the nuclear power industry this hydrogen safety technology can be applied when traditional hydrogen mitigation methods (i.e. active and natural ventilation) are not appropriate or when a back-up system is required. In many of these cases it is desirable for hydrogen to be removed without the use of power or other services which makes catalytic hydrogen recombination attractive. Instances where catalytic recombination of hydrogen can be utilized as a stand-alone or back-up measure to prevent hydrogen accumulation include radioactive waste storage (hydrogen generated from water radiolysis or material corrosion) battery rooms hydrogen-cooled generators hydrogen equipment enclosures etc.<br/>Water tolerant hydrogen-oxygen recombiner catalysts for non-nuclear applications have been developed at Canadian Nuclear Laboratories (CNL) through a program in which catalyst materials were selected prepared and initially tested in a spinning-basket type reactor to benchmark the catalyst’s performance with respect to hydrogen recombination in dry and humid conditions. Catalysts demonstrating high activity for hydrogen recombination were then selected and tested in trickle-bed and gas phase recombiner systems to determine their performance in more typical deployment conditions. Future plans include testing of selected catalysts after exposure to specific poisons to determine the catalysts’ tolerance for such poisons.
Estimation of Final Hydrogen Temperature From Refueling Parameters
Oct 2015
Publication
Compressed hydrogen storage is currently widely used in fuel cell vehicles due to its simplicity in tank structure and refuelling process. For safety reason the final gas temperature in the hydrogen tank during vehicle refuelling must be maintained under a certain limit e.g. 85 °C. Many experiments have been performed to find the relations between the final gas temperature in the hydrogen tank and refueling conditions. The analytical solution of the hydrogen temperature in the tank can be obtained from the simplified thermodynamic model of a compressed hydrogen storage tank and it serves as function formula to fit experimental temperatures. From the analytical solution the final hydrogen temperature can be expressed as a weighted average form of initial temperature inflow temperature and ambient temperature inspired by the rule of mixtures. The weighted factors are related to other refuelling parameters such as initial mass initial pressure refuelling time refuelling mass rate average pressure ramp rate (APRR) final mass final pressure etc. The function formula coming from the analytical solution of the thermodynamic model is more meaningful physically and more efficient mathematically in fitting experimental temperatures. The simple uniform formula inspired by the concept of the rule of mixture and its weighted factors obtained from the analytical solution of lumped parameter thermodynamics model is representatively used to fit the experimental and simulated results in publication. Estimation of final hydrogen temperature from refuelling parameters based on the rule of mixtures is simple and practical for controlling the maximum temperature and for ensuring hydrogen safety during fast filling process.
Alloy and Composition Dependence of Hydrogen Embrittlement Susceptibility in High-strength Steel Fasteners
Jun 2017
Publication
High-strength steel fasteners characterized by tensile strengths above 1100 MPa are often used in critical applications where a failure can have catastrophic consequences. Preventing hydrogen embrittlement (HE) failure is a fundamental concern implicating the entire fastener supply chain. Research is typically conducted under idealized conditions that cannot be translated into know-how prescribed in fastener industry standards and practices. Additionally inconsistencies and even contradictions in fastener industry standards have led to much confusion and many preventable or misdiagnosed fastener failures. HE susceptibility is a function of the material condition which is comprehensively described by the metallurgical and mechanical properties. Material strength has a first-order effect on HE susceptibility which increases significantly above 1200 MPa and is characterized by a ductile--brittle transition. For a given concentration of hydrogen and at equal strength the critical strength above which the ductile–brittle transition begins can vary due to second-order effects of chemistry tempering temperature and sub-microstructure. Additionally non-homogeneity of the metallurgical structure resulting from poorly controlled heat treatment impurities and non-metallic inclusions can increase HE susceptibility of steel in ways that are measurable but unpredictable. Below 1200 MPa non-conforming quality is often the root cause of real-life failures.
Link to document download on Royal Society Website
Link to document download on Royal Society Website
The Hydrogen Executive Leadership Panel (HELP) Initiative for Emergency Responder Training
Sep 2007
Publication
In close cooperation with their Canadian counterparts United States public safety authorities are taking the first steps towards creating a proper infrastructure to ensure the safe use of the new hydrogen fuel cells now being introduced commercially. Currently public safety officials are being asked to permit hydrogen fuel cells for stationary power and as emergency power backups for the telecommunications towers that exist everywhere. Consistent application of the safety codes is difficult – in part because it is new – yet it is far more complex to train emergency responders to deal safely with the inevitable hydrogen incidents. The US and Canadian building and fire codes and standards are similar but not identical. The US and Canadian rules are unlikely to be useful to other nations without modification to suit different regulatory systems. However emergency responder safety training is potentially more universal. The risks strategies and tactics are unlikely to differ much by region. The Hydrogen Executive Leadership Panel (HELP) made emergency responder safety training its first priority because the transition to hydrogen depends on keeping incidents small and inoffensive and the public and responders safe from harm. One might think that advising 1.2 million firefighters and 800000 law enforcement officers about hydrogen risks is no more complicated than adding guidance to a website. One would be wrong. The term “training” has specific legal implications which may vary by state. For hazardous materials federal requirements apply. Insurance companies place training requirements on the policies they sell to fire departments including the thousands of small all-volunteer departments which may operate as private corporations. Union contracts may define training and promotions may be based on satisfactorily completed certain levels of training. Emergency responders could no sooner learn how to extinguish a<br/>hydrogen fire by reading a webpage than a person could learn to ride a bicycle by reading a book. Procedures must be learned by listening reading and then doing. Regular practice is necessary. As new hydrogen applications are commercialized additional responder training may be necessary. This highlights another obstacle emergency responders’ ability to travel distances and take the time to undergo training. Historically fire academies established adjunct instructor programs and satellite academies to bring the training to firefighters. The large well-equipped academies are typically used for specialized training. States rarely have enough instructors and instructors often must take the time to create a course outline research each point and produce a program that is informative useful and holds the attention of responders. The challenge of training emergency responders seems next to impossible but public safety authorities are asked to tackle the impossible every day and a model exists to move forward in the U.S. Over the past few years the National Association of State Fire Marshals and U.S. Department of Transportation enlisted the help of emergency responders and industry to create a standardized approach to train emergency responders to deal with pipeline incidents. A curriculum and training materials were created and more than 26000 sets have been distributed for free to public safety agencies nationwide. More than 8000 instructors have been trained to use these materials that are now part of the regular training in 23 states. Using this model HELP intends to ensure that all emergency responders are trained to address hydrogen risks. The model and the rigorous scenario analysis and review used to developing the operational and technical training is addressed in this paper.
Fire Protection Strategy for Compressed Hydrogen-Powered Vehicles
Sep 2007
Publication
Virtually all major automotive companies are currently developing hydrogen-powered vehicles. The vast majority of them employ compressed hydrogen tanks and components as a means of storing the fuel onboard. Compressed hydrogen vehicle fuel systems are designed in the same way as compressed natural gas vehicles (NGV) i.e. the high pressure (up to 70 MPa) fuel is always contained within the system under all conditions with the exception of vehicular fire. In the event of a vehicle fire the fuel system is protected using a non-reclosing thermally activated pressure relief device (PRD) which safely vents the contents. Hydrogen fuel system PRDs are presently qualified to the performance requirements specified in draft hydrogen standards such ANSI/CSA HPRD 1 and EIHP Rev. 12b. They are also qualified with individual fuel tank designs in accordance with the engulfing bonfire requirements in various published/draft tank standards such as CSA B51 Part 2 JARI S001 SAE TIR J2579 ANSI/CSA HGV 2 ISO DIS 15869.2 and EIHP Rev. 12b. Since 2000 there have been over 20 documented NGV tank failures in service 11 of which have been attributed to vehicle fires. This paper will examine whether currently proposed hydrogen performance standards and installation requirements offer suitable fuel system protection in the event of vehicular fires. A number of alternative fire protection strategies will be discussed including:
- The requirement of an engulfing and/or localized fire test for individual tanks fuel systems and complete vehicles;
- The advantages/disadvantages of point source- surface area- and/or fuse-based PRDs
- The use of thermal insulating coatings/blankets for fire protection resulting in the NONventing of the fuel
- The specification of appropriate fuel system installation requirements to mitigate the effect of vehicular fires.
Numerical Investigation of Hydrogen Release from Varying Diameter Exit
Sep 2011
Publication
Computational fluid dynamics is used to simulate the release of high pressure Hydrogen from a reservoir with an exit of increasing diameter. Abel-Noble real gas equation of state is used to accurately simulate this high pressure release. Parallel processing based on Message Passing Interface for domain decomposition is employed to decrease the solution time. The release exit boundary is increased in time to simulate a scenario when the exit area increases during the release. All nodes and elements are moved accordingly at each time step to maintain the quality of the mesh. Different speeds of increasing diameter are investigated to see the impact on this unsteady flow.
Development of Uniform Harm Criteria for Use in Quantitative Risk Analysis of the Hydrogen Infrastructure
Sep 2009
Publication
This paper discusses the preliminary results of the Risk Management subtask efforts within the International Energy Agency (IEA) Hydrogen Implementing Agreement (HIA) Task 19 on Hydrogen Safety to develop uniform harm criteria for use in the Quantitative Risk Assessments (QRAs) of hydrogen facilities. The IEA HIA Task 19 efforts are focused on developing guidelines and criteria for performing QRAs of hydrogen facilities. The performance of QRAs requires that the level of harm that is represented in the risk evaluation be established using deterministic models. The level of harm is a function of the type and level of hazard. The principle hazard associated with hydrogen facilities is uncontrolled accumulation of hydrogen in (semi) confined spaces and consecutive ignition. Another significant hazard is combustion of accidentally released hydrogen gas or liquid which may or may not happen instantaneously. The primary consequences from fire hazards consist of personnel injuries or fatalities or facility and equipment damage due to high air temperatures radiant heat fluxes or direct contact with hydrogen flames. The possible consequences of explosions on humans and structures or equipment include blast wave overpressure effects impact from fragments generated by the explosion the collapse of buildings and the heat effects from subsequent fire balls. A harm criterion is used to translate the consequences of an accident evaluated from deterministic models to a probability of harm to people structures or components. Different methods can be used to establish harm criteria including the use of threshold consequence levels and continuous functions that relate the level of a hazard to a probability of damage. This paper presents a survey of harm criteria that can be utilized in QRAs and makes recommendations on the criteria that should be utilized for hydrogen-related hazards.
Application of Risk Assessment Approach on a Hydrogen Station
Sep 2013
Publication
An accident modelling approach is used to assess the safety of a hydrogen station as part of a ground transportation network. The method incorporates prevention barriers associated to human factors management and organizational failures in a risk assessment framework. Failure probabilities of these barriers and end-states events are predicted using Fault Tree Analysis and Event Tree Analysis respectively. Results from the case study considered revealed the capability of the proposed method in estimating the likelihood of various outcomes as well as predicting the future probability. In addition the scheme offers opportunity to provide dynamic adjustment by updating the failure probability with actual plant data. Results from the analysis can be used to plan maintenance and management of change as required by the plant condition.
Evaluation of Hydrogen, Propane and Methane-air Detonations Instability and Detonability
Sep 2013
Publication
In this paper the detonation propensity of different compositions of mixtures of hydrogen propane and methane with air has been evaluated over a wide range of compositions. We supplement the conventional calculations of the induction delay with calculations of the characteristic acceleration parameter recently suggested by Radulescu Sharpeand Bradley(RSB) to characterize the instability of detonations. While it is well established that the ignition delay provides a good measure for detonability the RSB acceleration or its non-dimensionalform provides a further discriminant between mixtures with similar ignition delays. The present assessment of detonability reveals that while a stoichiometric mixture of hydrogen-air has an ignition delay one and two orders of magnitude shorter than respectively propane and methane hydrogen also has a parameter smaller by respectively one and two orders of magnitude. Its smaller propensity for instability is reflected by an RSB acceleration parameter similar to the two hydrocarbons. The predictions however indicate that lean hydrogen mixtures are likely to be much more unstable than stoichiometric ones. The relation between the parameter and potential to amplify an unstable transverse wave structure has been further determined through numerical simulation of decaying reactive Taylor-Sedov blast waves. Using a simplified two-step model calibrated for these fuels we show that methane mixtures develop cellular structures more readily than propane and hydrogen when observed on similar induction time scales. Future work should be devoted towards a quantitative inclusion of the RSB parameter in assessing the detonability of a given mixture.
Numerical Investigation of a Vertical Surface on the Flammable Extent of Hydrogen and Methane Vertical Jets
Sep 2011
Publication
The effect of vertical surface on the extent of high pressure unignited jets of both hydrogen and methane is studied using computer fluid dynamics simulations performed with FLACS Hydrogen. Results for constant flow rate through a 6.35 mm round leak orifice from 100 barg 250 barg 400 barg 550 barg and 700 barg compressed gas systems are presented for vertical jets. To quantify the effect of the surface on the jet the jet exit is positioned at various distances from the surface ranging from 0.029 m to 12 m. Free jets simulations are performed for comparison purposes.
Validation Testing In Support Of Hydrogen Codes and Standards Developments
Sep 2011
Publication
New codes and standards are being developed to facilitate the safe deployment of emerging hydrogen technologies. Hydrogen markets will benefit from standards that address the specific properties of hydrogen hydrogen effects on strength of materials and hydrogen compressed gas storage at pressures up to 70 MPa. The need for validation of new hydrogen requirements has been identified by codes and standards technical committees. The US Department of Energy (DOE) office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy (EERE) has tasked the National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) with the role of supporting hydrogen codes and standards research and development needs. NREL has provided validation test support to several new standards development efforts including pressure testing of 70 MPa on board vehicle storage systems flaw testing of stationary hydrogen tanks fill protocols for hydrogen fuel dispensing and hydrogen compatibility testing for hydrogen pressure relief devices (HPRD’s). Validation test results are presented for these four specific standards development needs.
CFD Simulations of the Effect of Ventilation on Hydrogen Release Behavior and Combustion in an Underground Mining Environment
Sep 2013
Publication
CFD simulations investigating the effect of ventilation airflow on hydrogen release behaviour in an underground mining tunnel were performed using FLACS hydrogen. Both dispersion and combustion scenarios of a hydrogen release coming from a severed distribution pipeline were investigated. Effects on the hydrogen dispersion such as ventilation strength and the mechanism of air flow supply (a pull or push fan) and mine opening surface roughness surface cavities and obstructions were explored. Results showing the effect of changing the position of the leak adding a cavity on the ceiling of the tunnel and changing the roughness of the walls are given. Overpressure sensitivity to the ignition delay was also considered. From the results for the varied ventilation regimes and spatial scenarios it is difficult to identify the optimal ventilation strategy giving the safest conditions for hydrogen distribution and refuelling in an underground mine.
Hydrogen Fueling Standardization: Enabling ZEVs with "Same as Today" Fueling and FCEV Range and Safety
Oct 2015
Publication
Zero Emission Vehicles (ZEVs) are necessary to help reduce the emissions in the transportation sector which is responsible for 40% of overall greenhouse gas emissions. There are two types of ZEVs Battery Electric Vehicles (BEVs) and Fuel Cell Electric Vehicles (FCEVs) Commercial Success of BEVs has been challenging thus far also due to limited range and very long charging duration. FCEVs using H2 infrastructure with SAE J2601 and J2799 standards can be consistently fuelled in a safe manner fast and resulting in a range similar to conventional vehicles. Specifically fuelling with SAE J2601 with the SAE J2799 enables FCEVs to fill with hydrogen in 3-5 minutes and to achieve a high State of Charge (SOC) resulting in 300+ mile range without exceeding the safety storage limits. Standardized H2 therefore gives an advantage to the customer over electric charging. SAE created this H2 fuelling protocol based on modelling laboratory and field tests. These SAE standards enable the first generation of commercial FCEVs and H2 stations to achieve a customer acceptable fueling similar to today's experience. This report details the advantages of hydrogen and the validation of H2 fuelling for the SAE standards.
Implementation of Large Scale Shadowgraphy in Hydrogen Safety Phenomena
Sep 2013
Publication
We have implemented a portable large-scale shadowgraph system for use in flow visualization relating to hydrogen safety. Previous large-scale shadowgraph and schlieren implementations have often been limited to background- oriented techniques which are subject to noise. The system built is based on a large-scale shadowgraph technique developed by Settles which allows for high-quality visualization. We have applied the shadowgraph system to complex phenomena and current issues in hydrogen safety including DDT in long channels jet releases and unconfined deflagrations. Shadowgrams taken are compared to a Z-schlieren system. This shadowgraph system allows analysis of these phenomena at longer length scales.
Comparative Assessment of Blue Hydrogen from Steam Methane Reforming, Autothermal Reforming, and Natural Gas Decomposition Technologies for Natural Gas-producing Regions
Jan 2022
Publication
Interest in blue hydrogen production technologies is growing. Some researchers have evaluated the environmental and/or economic feasibility of producing blue hydrogen but a holistic assessment is still needed. Many aspects of hydrogen production have not been investigated. There is very limited information in the literature on the impact of plant size on production and the extent of carbon capture on the cost and life cycle greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions of blue hydrogen production through various production pathways. Detailed uncertainty and sensitivity analyses have not been included in most of the earlier studies. This study conducts a holistic comparative cost and life cycle GHG emissions’ footprint assessment of three natural gas-based blue hydrogen production technologies – steam methane reforming (SMR) autothermal reforming (ATR) and natural gas decomposition (NGD) to address these research gaps. A hydrogen production plant capacity of 607 tonnes per day was considered. For SMR based on the percentage of carbon capture and capture points we considered two scenarios SMR-52% (indicates 52% carbon capture) and SMR-85% (indicates 85% carbon capture). A scale factor was developed for each technology to understand the hydrogen production cost with a change in production plant size. Hydrogen cost is 1.22 1.23 2.12 1.69 2.36 1.66 and 2.55 $/kg H2 for SMR ATR NGD SMR-52% SMR-85% ATR with carbon capture and sequestration (ATR-CCS) and NGD with carbon capture and sequestration (NGD-CCS) respectively. The results indicate that when uncertainty is considered SMR-52% and ATR are economically preferable to NGD and SMR-85%. SMR-52% could outperform ATR-CCS when the natural gas price decreases and the rate of return increases. SMR-85% is the least attractive pathway; however it could outperform NGD economically when CO2 transportation cost and natural gas price decrease. Hydrogen storage cost significantly impacts the hydrogen production cost. SMR-52% SMR-85% ATR-CCS and NGD-CCS have scale factors of 0.67 0.68 0.54 and 0.65 respectively. The hydrogen cost variation with capacity shows that operating SMR-52% and ATR-CCS above hydrogen capacity of 200 tonnes/day is economically attractive. Blue hydrogen from autothermal reforming has the lowest life cycle GHG emissions of 3.91 kgCO2eq/kg H2 followed by blue hydrogen from NGD (4.54 kgCO2eq/kg H2) SMR-85% (6.66 kgCO2eq/kg H2) and SMR-52% (8.20 kgCO2eq/kg H2). The findings of this study are useful for decision-making at various levels.
Transition of Future Energy System Infrastructure; through Power-to-Gas Pathways
Jul 2016
Publication
Power-to-gas is a promising option for storing interment renewables nuclear baseload power and distributed energy and it is a novel concept for the transition to increased renewable content of current fuels with an ultimate goal of transition to a sustainable low-carbon future energy system that interconnects power transportation sectors and thermal energy demand all together. The aim of this paper is to introduce different Power-to-gas “pathways” including Power to Hydrogen Power to Natural Gas End-users Power to Renewable Content in Petroleum Fuel Power to Power Seasonal Energy Storage to Electricity Power to Zero Emission Transportation Power to Seasonal Storage for Transportation Power to Micro grid Power to Renewable Natural Gas (RNG) to Pipeline (“Methanation”) and Power to Renewable Natural Gas (RNG) to Seasonal Storage. In order to compare the different pathways the review of key technologies of Power-to-gas systems are studied and the qualitative efficiency and benefits of each pathway is investigated from the technical points of view. Moreover different Power-to-gas pathways are discussed as an energy policy option that can be implemented to transition towards a lower carbon economy for Ontario’s energy systems
Design and Analysis of an Offshore Wind Power to Ammonia Production System in Nova Scotia
Dec 2022
Publication
Green ammonia has potential as a zero-emissions energy vector in applications such as energy storage transmission and distribution and zero-emissions transportation. Renewable energy such as offshore wind energy has been proposed to power its production. This paper designed and analyzed an on-land small-scale power-to-ammonia (P2A) production system with a target nominal output of 15 tonnes of ammonia per day which will use an 8 MW offshore turbine system off the coast of Nova Scotia Canada as the main power source. The P2A system consists of a reverse osmosis system a proton exchange membrane (PEM) electrolyser a hydrogen storage tank a nitrogen generator a set of compressors and heat exchangers an autothermal Haber-Bosch reactor and an ammonia storage tank. The system uses an electrical grid as a back-up for when the wind energy is insufficient as the process assumes a steady state. Two scenarios were analyzed with Scenario 1 producing a steady state of 15 tonnes of ammonia per day and Scenario 2 being one that switched production rates whenever wind speeds were low to 55% the nominal capacity. The results show that the grid connected P2A system has significant emissions for both scenarios which is larger than the traditional fossil-fuel based ammonia production when using the grid in provinces like Nova Scotia even if it is just a back-up during low wind power generation. The levelized cost of ammonia (LCOA) was calculated to be at least 2323 CAD tonne−1 for both scenarios which is not cost competitive in this small production scale. Scaling up the whole system reducing the reliance on the electricity grid increasing service life and decreasing windfarm costs could reduce the LCOA and make this P2A process more cost competitive.
Recovery Through Reform: Advancing a Hydrogen Economy While Minimizing Fossil Fuel Subsidies
Feb 2021
Publication
This brief explores recent momentum on hydrogen and evaluates potential implications for subsidies for fossil fuel-based hydrogen given the government's commitments on fossil fuel subsidies.
Spending on hydrogen has the potential to significantly influence the direction taken by the world’s energy systems. In December 2020 Canada unveiled a national hydrogen strategy following the announcement of a strengthened climate plan. The strategy emphasized both blue and green hydrogen. As the government considers whether to provide subsidies for hydrogen we recommend government:
This brief is one of three International Institute for Sustainable Development (IISD) policy briefs in its Recovery Through Reform series which assesses how efforts to achieve a green recovery from COVID-19 in Canada rely on—and can contribute to—fossil fuel subsidy reform.
Spending on hydrogen has the potential to significantly influence the direction taken by the world’s energy systems. In December 2020 Canada unveiled a national hydrogen strategy following the announcement of a strengthened climate plan. The strategy emphasized both blue and green hydrogen. As the government considers whether to provide subsidies for hydrogen we recommend government:
- Ensure that any subsidies for hydrogen are in line with the government’s commitments to phase out inefficient fossil fuel subsidies by 2025 and meet net-zero by 2050.
- Thoroughly evaluate the potential efficiency of subsidies for hydrogen against robust social environmental and economic criteria. • Improve transparency by publicly reporting on direct spending and tax expenditures for hydrogen production.
- Follow international best practices being set by Canada’s peers. For example Germany and Spain have laid out hydrogen strategies prioritizing green hydrogen.
This brief is one of three International Institute for Sustainable Development (IISD) policy briefs in its Recovery Through Reform series which assesses how efforts to achieve a green recovery from COVID-19 in Canada rely on—and can contribute to—fossil fuel subsidy reform.
A Manganese Hydride Molecular Sieve for Practical Hydrogen Storage Under Ambient Conditions
Dec 2018
Publication
A viable hydrogen economy has thus far been hampered by the lack of an inexpensive and convenient hydrogen storage solution meeting all requirements especially in the areas of long hauls and delivery infrastructure. Current approaches require high pressure and/or complex heat management systems to achieve acceptable storage densities. Herein we present a manganese hydride molecular sieve that can be readily synthesized from inexpensive precursors and demonstrates a reversible excess adsorption performance of 10.5 wt% and 197 kgH2 m-3 at 120 bar at ambient temperature with no loss of activity after 54 cycles. Inelastic neutron scattering and computational studies confirm Kubas binding as the principal mechanism. The thermodynamically neutral adsorption process allows for a simple system without the need for heat management using moderate pressure as a toggle. A storage material with these properties will allow the DOE system targets for storage and delivery to be achieved providing a practical alternative to incumbents such as 700 bar systems which generally provide volumetric storage values of 40 kgH2 m-3 or less while retaining advantages over batteries such as fill time and energy density. Reasonable estimates for production costs and loss of performance due to system implementation project total energy storage costs roughly 5 times cheaper than those for 700 bar tanks potentially opening doors for increased adoption of hydrogen as an energy vector.
Recovery Through Reform: Assessing the climate compatibility of Canada’s COVID-19 response in 2020
Feb 2021
Publication
Governments around the world are leveraging unprecedented amounts of capital to respond to the pandemic and bailing out struggling industries. Trends in energy-related spending indicate that despite the green push the world’s largest economies have still favoured fossil energy over clean energy.<br/><br/>We evaluate energy-related spending in Canada in 2020 (since the onset of COVID-19) using data from the Energy Policy Tracker. Trends in Canada are then compared to flagship policies in key jurisdictions with recent progressive climate policy announcements including France Germany and the United Kingdom. The brief ends with broad recommendations on how Canada can better align its recovery funding with climate action and fossil fuel subsidy reform.<br/><br/>This brief is one of three International Institute for Sustainable Development (IISD) policy briefs in its Recovery Through Reform series which assesses how efforts to achieve a green recovery from COVID-19 in Canada rely on—and can contribute to—fossil fuel subsidy reform.
Canadian Hydrogen Safety Program.
Sep 2005
Publication
This paper discusses the rationale structure and contents of the Canadian Hydrogen Safety Program developed by the Codes & Standards Working Group of the Canadian Transportation Fuel Cell Alliance consisting of representatives from industry academia government and regulators. The overall program objective is to facilitate acceptance of the products services and systems of the Canadian Hydrogen Industry by the Canadian Hydrogen Stakeholder Community to facilitate trade ensure fair insurance policies and rates ensure effective and efficient regulatory approval procedures and to ensure that the interests of the general public are accommodated. The Program consists of four projects including Comparative Quantitative Risk Assessment of Hydrogen and Compressed Natural Gas (CNG) Refuelling Stations; Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) Modelling Validation Calibration and Enhancement; Enhancement of Frequency and Probability Analysis and Consequence Analysis of Key Component Failures of Hydrogen Systems; and Fuel Cell Oxidant Outlet Hydrogen Sensor Project. The Program projects are tightly linked with the content of the IEA Task 19 Hydrogen Safety. The Program also includes extensive (destructive and non-destructive) testing of hydrogen components.
Defining Hazardous Zones – Electrical Classification Distances
Sep 2005
Publication
This paper presents an analysis of computational fluid dynamic models of compressed hydrogen gas leaks into the air under different conditions to determine the volume of the hydrogen/air mixture and the extents of the lower flammable limit. The necessary hole size was calculated to determine a reasonably expected hydrogen leak rate from a valve or a fitting of 5 and 20 cfm under 400 bars resulting in a 0.1 and 0.2 mm effective diameter hole respectively. The results were compared to calculated hypothetical volumes from IEC 60079-10 for the same mass flowrate and in most cases the CFD results produced significantly smaller hydrogen/air volumes than the IEC standard. Prescriptive electrical classification distances in existing standards for hydrogen and compressed natural gas were examined but they do not consider storage pressure and there appears to be no scientific basis for the distance determination. A proposed table of electrical classification distances incorporating hydrogen storage volume and pressure was produced based on the hydrogen LFL extents from a 0.2 mm diameter hole and the requirements of existing standards. The PHOENICS CFD software package was used to solve the continuity momentum and concentration equations with the appropriate boundary conditions buoyancy model and turbulence models. Numerical results on hydrogen concentration predictions were obtained in the real industrial environment typical for a hydrogen refuelling or energy station.<br/><br/>
CFD Modeling of Hydrogen Dispersion Experiments for SAE J2578 Test Methods Development
Sep 2007
Publication
This paper discusses the results of validation of Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) modelling of hydrogen releases and dispersion inside a metal container imitating a single car garage based on experimental results. The said experiments and modelling were conducted as part of activities to predict fuel cell vehicles discharge flammability and potential build-up of hydrogen for the development of test procedures for the Recommended Practice for General Fuel Cell Vehicle Safety SAE J2578. The experimental setup included 9 hydrogen detectors located in each corner and in the middle of the roof of the container and a fan to ensure uniform mixing of the released hydrogen. The PHOENICS CFD software package was used to solve the continuity momentum and concentration equations with the appropriate boundary conditions buoyancy effect and turbulence models. Obtained modelling results matched experimental data of a high-rate injection of hydrogen with fan-forced dispersion used to create near-uniform mixtures with a high degree of accuracy. This supports the conclusion that CFD modelling will be able to predict potential accumulation of hydrogen beyond the experimental conditions. CFD modelling of hydrogen concentrations has proven to be reliable effective and relatively inexpensive tool to evaluate the effects of hydrogen discharge from hydrogen powered vehicles or other hydrogen containing equipment.
Enhancing the Efficiency of Power- and Biomass-to-liquid Fuel Processes Using Fuel-assisted Solid Oxide Electrolysis Cells
Apr 2022
Publication
Power- and biomass-to-liquid fuel processes (PBtL) can utilize renewable energy and residual forestry waste to produce liquid synthetic fuels which have the potential to mitigate the climate impacts of the current transportation infrastructure including the long-haul aviation sector. In a previous study we demonstrated that implementing a solid oxide electrolysis cell (SOEC) in the PBtL process can significantly increase the energy efficiency of fuel production by supplying the produced hydrogen to a reverse water gas shift (RWGS) reactor to generate syngas which is then fed downstream to a Fischer–Tropsch (FT) reactor. The tail gas emitted from the FT reactor consists primarily of a mixture of hydrogen carbon monoxide and methane and is often recycled to the entrained flow gasifier located at the beginning of the process. In this analysis we investigate the efficiency gains of the PBtL process as a result of redirecting the tail gas of the FT reactor to the anode of an SOEC to serve as fuel. Supplying fuel to an SOEC can lower the electrical work input required to facilitate steam electrolysis when reacting electrochemically with oxide ions in the anode which in turn can reduce oxygen partial pressures and thus alleviate material degradation. Accordingly we develop a thermodynamic framework to reveal the performance limits of fuel-assisted SOECs (FASOECs) and provide strategies to minimize oxygen partial pressures in the SOEC anode. Additionally we elucidate how much fuel is required to match the heating demands of a cell when steam is supplied to the cathode over a broad range of inlet temperatures and demonstrate the influence of a set of reaction pathways of the supplied fuel on the operating potential of an FASOEC and the corresponding efficiency gain of the PBtL process. Based on preliminary calculations we estimate that implementing an FASOEC in the PBtL process can increase the energy efficiency of fuel production to more than 90% depending on the amount of FT tail gas available to the system.
Development of Risk Mitigation Guidance for Sensor Placement Inside Mechanically Ventilated Enclosures – Phase 1
Sep 2019
Publication
Guidance on Sensor Placement was identified as the top research priority for hydrogen sensors at the 2018 HySafe Research Priority Workshop on hydrogen safety in the category Mitigation Sensors Hazard Prevention and Risk Reduction. This paper discusses the initial steps (Phase 1) to develop such guidance for mechanically ventilated enclosures. This work was initiated as an international collaborative effort to respond to emerging market needs related to the design and deployment equipment for hydrogen infrastructure that is often installed in individual equipment cabinets or ventilated enclosures. The ultimate objective of this effort is to develop guidance for an optimal sensor placement such that when integrated into a facility design and operation will allow earlier detection at lower levels of incipient leaks leading to significant hazard reduction. Reliable and consistent early warning of hydrogen leaks will allow for the risk mitigation by reducing or even eliminating the probability of escalation of small leaks into large and uncontrolled events. To address this issue a study of a real-world mechanically ventilated enclosure containing GH2 equipment was conducted where CFD modelling of the hydrogen dispersion (performed by AVT and UQTR and independently by the JRC) was validated by the NREL Sensor laboratory using a Hydrogen Wide Area Monitor (HyWAM) consisting of a 10-point gas and temperature measurement analyzer. In the release test helium was used as a hydrogen surrogate. Expansion of indoor releases to other larger facilities (including parking structures vehicle maintenance facilities and potentially tunnels) and incorporation into QRA tools such as HyRAM is planned for Phase 2. It is anticipated that results of this work will be used to inform national and international standards such as NFPA 2 Hydrogen Technologies Code Canadian Hydrogen Installation Code (CHIC) and relevant ISO/TC 197 and CEN documents.
Numerical Solution for Thermodynamic Model of Charge-discharge Cycle in Compressed Hydrogen Tank
Mar 2019
Publication
The safety and convenience of hydrogen storage are significant for fuel cell vehicles. Based on mass conservation equation and energy conservation equation two thermodynamic models (single zone model and dual zone model) have been established to study the hydrogen gas temperature and tank wall temperature for compressed hydrogen storage tank. With two models analytical solution and Euler solution for single zone (gas zone) charge-discharge cycle have been compared Matlab/Simulink solution and Euler solution for dual zone (gas zone wall zone) charge-discharge cycle have been compared. Three charge-discharge cycle cases (Case 1 constant inflow temperature; Case 2 variable inflow temperature; Case 3 constant inflow temperature variable outflow temperature) and two compressed hydrogen tanks (Type III 25L Type IV 99L) charge-discharge cycle are studied by Euler method. Results show Euler method can well predict hydrogen temperature and tank wall temperature.
Simulation of Detonation after an Accidental Hydrogen Release in Enclosed Environments
Sep 2007
Publication
An accidental hydrogen release in equipment enclosures may result in the presence of a detonable mixture in a confined environment. Numerical simulation is potentially a useful tool for damage assessment in these situations. To assess the value of CFD techniques numerical simulation of detonation was performed for two realistic scenarios. The first scenario starts with a pipe failure in an electrolyzer resulting in a leak of 42 g of hydrogen. The second scenario deals with a failure in a reformer where 84 g of hydrogen is released. In both cases dispersion patterns were first obtained from separate numerical simulation and were then used as initial condition in a detonation simulation based upon the reactive Euler's equations. Energy was artificially added in a narrow region to simulate detonative ignition. In the electrolyzer ignition was assumed to occur 500 ms after beginning of the release. Results show a detonation failing on the top and bottom side but propagating left and right before eventually failing also. Average impulse was 500 Ns/m². For the reformer three cases were simulated with ignition 1.0 1.4 and 2.0 seconds after the beginning of the release. In two cases the detonation wave failed everywhere except in the direction of the release in which it continued propagating until reaching the side wall. In the third the detonation failed everywhere at first but later a deflagration to detonation transition occurred resulting in a strong wave that propagated rapidly toward the side wall. In all three cases the consequences are more serious than in the electrolyzer.
Ignition Experiments of Hydrogen Mixtures by Different Methods and Description of the DRDC Test Facilities
Sep 2009
Publication
The paper will present results of hydrogen/oxygen mixtures ignited by using electric sparks electrostatic discharges a heating element and a flame. Measurements of the lower flammability limit (LFL) was done for each ignition method. The hydrogen mixtures of different concentrations were ignited at the bottom of a combustion chamber leading to an upward propagation of the resulting flame. At some level of concentration the combustion was partial due to the limited upward propagation. The complete combustion of the whole mixture was observed at concentration limits higher than the known LFL of 4% vol. for hydrogen in air. The paper will describe the test facilities and the resulting ignition probabilities for different ignition methods.
HIAD – Hydrogen Incident and Accident Database
Sep 2011
Publication
The Hydrogen Incident and Accident Database (HIAD) is being developed as a repository of systematic data describing in detail hydrogen-related undesired events (incidents or accidents). It is an open web-based information system serving various purposes such as a data source for lessons learnt risk communication and partly risk assessment. The paper describes the features of the three HIAD modules – the Data Entry Module (DEM) the Data Retrieval Module (DRM) and the Data Analysis Module (DAM) – and the potential impact the database may have on hydrogen safety. The importance of data quality assurance process is also addressed.
Review of Solid State Hydrogen Storage Methods Adopting Different Kinds of Novel Materials
Aug 2015
Publication
Overview of advances in the technology of solid state hydrogen storage methods applying different kinds of novel materials is provided. Metallic and intermetallic hydrides complex chemical hydride nanostructured carbon materials metal-doped carbon nanotubes metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) metal-doped metal organic frameworks covalent organic frameworks (COFs) and clathrates solid state hydrogen storage techniques are discussed. The studies on their hydrogen storage properties are in progress towards positive direction. Nevertheless it is believed that these novel materials will offer far-reaching solutions to the onboard hydrogen storage problems in near future. The review begins with the deficiencies of current energy economy and discusses the various aspects of implementation of hydrogen energy based economy.
New Integrated Process for the Efficient Production of Methanol, Electrical Power, and Heating
Jan 2022
Publication
In this paper a novel process is developed to cogenerate 4741 kg/h of methanol 297.7 kW of electricity and 35.73 ton/h of hot water including a hydrogen purification system an absorption– compression refrigeration cycle (ACRC) a regenerative Organic Rankine Cycle (ORC) and parabolic solar troughs. The heat produced in the methanol reactor is recovered in the ORC and ACRC. Parabolic solar troughs provide thermal power to the methanol distillation tower. Thermal efficiencies of the integrated structure and the liquid methanol production cycle are 78.14% and 60.91% respectively. The process’s total exergy efficiency and irreversibility are 89.45% and 16.89 MW. The solar thermal collectors take the largest share of exergy destruction (34%) followed by heat exchangers (30%) and mixers (19%). Based on the sensitivity analysis D17 (mixture of H2 and low-pressure fuel gas before separation) was the most influential stream affecting the performance of the process. With the temperature decline of stream D17 from −139 to −149 °C the methanol production rate and the total thermal efficiency rose to 4741.2 kg/h and 61.02% respectively. Moreover the growth in the hydrogen content from 55% to 80% molar of the feed gas the flow rate of liquid methanol and the total exergy efficiency declined to 4487 kg/h and 86.05%.
Quantification of Temperature Dependence of Hydrogen Embrittlement in Pipeline Steel
Feb 2019
Publication
The effects of temperature on bulk hydrogen concentration and diffusion have been tested with the Devanathan–-Stachurski method. Thus a model based on hydrogen potential diffusivity loading frequency and hydrostatic stress distribution around crack tips was applied in order to quantify the temperature’s effect. The theoretical model was verified experimentally and confirmed a temperature threshold of 320 K to maximize the crack growth. The model suggests a nanoscale embrittlement mechanism which is generated by hydrogen atom delivery to the crack tip under fatigue loading and rationalized the ΔK dependence of traditional models. Hence this work could be applied to optimize operations that will prolong the life of the pipeline.
Electrification Opportunities in the Medium- and Heavy-Duty Vehicle Segment in Canada
Jun 2021
Publication
The medium- and heavy-duty (MD/HD) vehicle sector is a large emitter of greenhouse gases. It will require drastic emissions reductions to realize a net-zero carbon future. This study conducts fourteen short feasibility investigations in the Canadian context to evaluate the merits of battery electric or hydrogen fuel cell alternatives to conventional city buses inter-city buses school buses courier vehicles (step vans) refuse trucks long-haul trucks and construction vehicles. These “clean transportation alternatives” were evaluated for practicality economics and emission reductions in comparison to their conventional counterparts. Conclusions were drawn on which use cases would be best suited for accelerating the transformation of the MD/HD sector.
Valorization and Sequestration of Hydrogen Gas from Biomass Combustion in Solid Waste Incineration NaOH Oxides of Carbon Entrapment Model (SWI-NaOH-OCE Model)
Dec 2019
Publication
The valorization of biomass-based solid wastes for both geotechnical engineering purposes and energy needs has been reviewed to achieve eco-friendly eco-efficient and sustainable engineering and reengineering of civil engineering materials and structures. The objective of this work was to review the procedure developed by SWI-NaOH-OCE Model for the valorization of biomass through controlled direct combustion and the sequestration of hydrogen gas for energy needs. The incineration model gave a lead to the sequestration of emissions released during the direct combustion of biomass and the subsequent entrapment of oxides of carbon and the eventual release of abundant hydrogen gas in the entrapment jar. The generation of geomaterials ash for the purpose of soil stabilization concrete and asphalt modification has encouraged greenhouse emissions but eventually the technology that has been put in place has made it possible to manage and extract these emissions for energy needs. The contribution from researchers has shown that hydrogen sequestration from other sources requires high amount of energy because of the lower energy states of the compounds undergoing thermal decomposition. But this work has presented a more efficient approach to release hydrogen gas which can easily be extracted and stored to meet the energy needs of the future as fuel cell batteries to power vehicles mobile devices robotic systems etc. More so the development of MXene as an exfoliated two-dimensional nanosheets with permeability and filtration selectivity properties which are connected to its chemical composition and structure used in hydrogen gas extraction and separation from its molecular combination has presented an efficient procedure for the production and management of hydrogen gas for energy purposes.
A Review of Recent Advances on the Effects of Microstructural Refinement and Nano-Catalytic Additives on the Hydrogen Storage Properties of Metal and Complex Hydrides
Dec 2010
Publication
The recent advances on the effects of microstructural refinement and various nano-catalytic additives on the hydrogen storage properties of metal and complex hydrides obtained in the last few years in the allied laboratories at the University of Waterloo (Canada) and Military University of Technology (Warsaw Poland) are critically reviewed in this paper. The research results indicate that microstructural refinement (particle and grain size) induced by ball milling influences quite modestly the hydrogen storage properties of simple metal and complex metal hydrides. On the other hand the addition of nanometric elemental metals acting as potent catalysts and/or metal halide catalytic precursors brings about profound improvements in the hydrogen absorption/desorption kinetics for simple metal and complex metal hydrides alike. In general catalytic precursors react with the hydride matrix forming a metal salt and free nanometric or amorphous elemental metals/intermetallics which in turn act catalytically. However these catalysts change only kinetic properties i.e. the hydrogen absorption/desorption rate but they do not change thermodynamics (e.g. enthalpy change of hydrogen sorption reactions). It is shown that a complex metal hydride LiAlH4 after high energy ball milling with a nanometric Ni metal catalyst and/or MnCl2 catalytic precursor is able to desorb relatively large quantities of hydrogen at RT 40 and 80 °C. This kind of behavior is very encouraging for the future development of solid state hydrogen systems.
Experimental Study and Model Predictions on Helium Release in an Enclosure with Single or Multiple Vents
Sep 2021
Publication
This paper presents experiments performed at Canadian Nuclear Laboratories (CNL) to examine the dispersion behaviour of helium in a polycarbonate enclosure that was representative of a residential parking garage. The purpose was to gain a better understanding of the effect of buoyancy- or winddriven natural ventilation on hydrogen dispersion behaviour. Although hydrogen dispersion studies have been reported extensively in the literature gaps still exist in predictive methods for hazard analysis. Helium a simulant for hydrogen was injected near the centre of the floor with a flow rate ranging from 5 to 75 standard litres per minute through an upward-facing nozzle resulting in an injection Richardson number ranging between 10-1 and 102. The location of the nozzle varied from the bottom of the enclosure to near the ceiling to examine the impact of the nozzle elevation on the development of a stratified layer in the upper region of the enclosure. When the injection nozzle was placed at a sufficiently low elevation the vertical helium profile always consisted of a homogenous layer at the top overlaying a stratified layer at the bottom. To simulate outdoor environmental conditions a fan was placed in front of each vent to examine the effect of opposing or assisting wind on the dispersion. The helium transients in the uniform layer predicted with analytical models were in good agreement with the measured transients for the tests with injection at lower elevations or with no wind. Model improvements are required for adequately predicting transients with significantly stratified profiles or with wind.
Solar Hydrogen Production via a Samarium Oxide-Based Thermochemical Water Splitting Cycle
Apr 2016
Publication
The computational thermodynamic analysis of a samarium oxide-based two-step solar thermochemical water splitting cycle is reported. The analysis is performed using HSC chemistry software and databases. The first (solar-based) step drives the thermal reduction of Sm2O3 into Sm and O2. The second (non-solar) step corresponds to the production of H2 via a water splitting reaction and the oxidation of Sm to Sm2O3. The equilibrium thermodynamic compositions related to the thermal reduction and water splitting steps are determined. The effect of oxygen partial pressure in the inert flushing gas on the thermal reduction temperature (TH) is examined. An analysis based on the second law of thermodynamics is performed to determine the cycle efficiency (ηcycle) and solar-to-fuel energy conversion efficiency (ηsolar´to´fuel) attainable with and without heat recuperation. The results indicate that ηcycle and ηsolar´to´fuel both increase with decreasing TH due to the reduction in oxygen partial pressure in the inert flushing gas. Furthermore the recuperation of heat for the operation of the cycle significantly improves the solar reactor efficiency. For instance in the case where TH = 2280 K ηcycle = 24.4% and ηsolar´to´fuel = 29.5% (without heat recuperation) while ηcycle = 31.3% and ηsolar´to´fuel = 37.8% (with 40% heat recuperation).
A New Energy System Based on Biomass Gasification for Hydrogen and Power Production
Apr 2020
Publication
In this paper a new gasification system is developed for the three useful outputs of electricity heat and hydrogen and reported for practical energy applications. The study also investigates the composition of syngas leaving biomass gasifier. The composition of syngas is represented by the fractions of hydrogen carbon dioxide carbon monoxide and water. The integrated energy system comprises of an entrained flow gasifier a Cryogenic Air Separation (CAS) unit a double-stage Rankine cycle Water Gas Shift Reactor (WGSR) a combined gas–steam power cycle and a Proton Exchange Membrane (PEM) electrolyzer. The whole integrated system is modeled in the Aspen plus 9.0 excluding the PEM electrolyzer which is modeled in Engineering Equation Solver (EES). A comprehensive parametric investigation is conducted by varying numerous parameters like biomass flow rate steam flow rate air input flow rate combustion reactor temperature and power supplied to the electrolyzer. The system is designed in a way to supply the power produced by the steam Rankine cycle to the PEM electrolyzer for hydrogen production. The overall energy efficiency is obtained to be 53.7% where the exergy efficiency is found to be 45.5%. Furthermore the effect of the biomass flow rate is investigated on the various system operational parameters.
No more items...