Safety
Liquid Organic Hydrogen Carriers - A Technology to Overcome Common Risks of Hydrogen Storage
Sep 2021
Publication
In transport and storage of hydrogen the risks are mainly seen in its volatile nature its ability to form explosive mixtures with air and the harsh conditions (high pressure or low temperature) for efficient storage. The concept of Liquid Organic Hydrogen Carriers (LOHC) offers a technology to overcome the above mentioned threats. The present submission describes the basics of the LOHC technology. It contains a comparison of a selection of common LOHC materials with a view on physical properties. The advantages of a low viscosity at low temperatures and a high flash point are expressed. LOHCs are also discussed as a concept to import large amounts of energy/hydrogen. A closer look is taken on the environmental and safety aspects of hydrogen storage in LOHCs since here the main differences to pressurized and cryo-storage of hydrogen can be found. The aim of this paper is to provide an overview of the principles of the LOHC technology the different LOHC materials and their risks and opportunities and an impression of a large scale scenario on the basis of the LOHC technology.
Performance of Hydrogen Storage Tanks of Type IV in a Fire: Effect of the State of Charge
Sep 2021
Publication
The use of hydrogen storage tanks at 100% of nominal working pressure (NWP) is expected only after refuelling. Driving between refuellings is characterised by the state of charge SoC <100%. There is experimental evidence that Type IV tanks tested in a fire at initial pressures below 1/3 NWP leaked without rupture. This paper aims at understanding this phenomenon. The numerical research has demonstrated that the heat transfer from fire through the composite overwrap at storage pressures below NWP/3 is sufficient to melt the polymer liner. This melting initiates hydrogen microleaks through the composite before it loses the load-bearing ability. The fire-resistance rating (FRR) is defined as the time to rupture in a fire of a tank without or with blocked thermally activated pressure relief device. The dependence of a FRR on the SoC is demonstrated for the tanks with defined material properties and volumes in the range of 36–244 L. A composite wall thickness variation is shown to cause a safety issue by reducing the tank’s FRR and is suggested to be addressed by tank manufacturers and OEMs. The effect of a tank’s burst pressure ratio on the FRR is investigated. Thermal parameters of the composite wall i.e. decomposition heat and temperatures are shown in simulations of a tank failure in a fire to play an important role in its FRR.
Transient Reversible Solid Oxide Cell Reactor Operation – Experimentally Validated Modeling and Analysis
Oct 2018
Publication
A reversible solid oxide cell (rSOC) reactor can operate efficiently in both electrolysis mode and in fuel cell mode. The bidirectional operability enables rSOC reactors to play a central role as an efficient energy conversion system for energy storage and sector coupling for a renewable energy driven society. A combined system for electrolysis and fuel cell operation can result in complex system configurations that should be able to switch between the two modes as quickly as possible. This can lead to temperature profiles within the reactor that can potentially lead to the failure of the reactor and eventually the system. Hence the behavior of the reactor during the mode switch should be analyzed and optimal transition strategies should be taken into account during the process system design stage. In this paper a one dimensional transient reversible solid oxide cell model was built and experimentally validated using a commercially available reactor. A simple hydrogen based system model was built employing the validated reactor model to study reactor behavior during the mode switch. The simple design leads to a system efficiency of 49% in fuel cell operation and 87% in electrolysis operation where the electrolysis process is slightly endothermic. Three transient operation strategies were studied. It is shown that the voltage response to transient operation is very fast provided the reactant flows are changed equally fast. A possible solution to ensure a safe mode switch by controlling the reactant inlet temperatures is presented. By keeping the rate of change of reactant inlet temperatures five to ten times slower than the mode switch a safe transition can be ensured.
Examining the Role of Safety in Communication Concerning Emerging Hydrogen Technologies by Selected Groups of Stakeholders
Sep 2021
Publication
Governments and other stakeholders actively promote and facilitate the development and deployment of hydrogen and fuel cell technologies. Various strategy documents and energy forecasts outline the environmental and societal benefits of the prospective hydrogen economy. At the same time the safety related properties of hydrogen imply that it is not straightforward to achieve and document the same level of safety for hydrogen systems compared to conventional fuels. Severe accidents can have major impact on the development of energy technologies. The stakes will increase significantly as the use of hydrogen shifts from controlled environments in industrial facilities to the public domain and as the transport-related consumption extends from passenger cars and buses to trains ships and airplanes. Widespread deployment of hydrogen as an energy carrier in society will require massive investments. This implies commercial and political commitment involvement and influence on research priorities and decision-making. The legacy from accidents and the messages communicated by influential stakeholders impact not only how the public perceives hydrogen technologies but also governmental policies the development of regulations codes and standards (RCS) and ultimately the measures adopted for preventing and mitigating accidents. This paper explores whether and how selected aspects of safety are considered when distinct groups of stakeholders frame the hydrogen economy. We assess to what extent the communication is consistent with the current state-of-the-art in hydrogen safety and the contemporary strength of knowledge in risk assessments for hydrogen systems. The approach adopted entails semi-quantitative text analysis and close reading to highlight variations between diverse groups of stakeholders. The results indicate a bias in the framing of the safety-related aspects of the hydrogen economy towards procedural organisational and societal measures of risk reduction at the expense of well-known challenges and knowledge gaps associated with the implications of fundamental safety-related properties of hydrogen.
Simulation of Possible Fire and Explosion Hazards of Clean Fuel Vehicles in Garages
Nov 2021
Publication
Clean fuel is advocated to be used for sustainability. The number of liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) and hydrogen vehicles is increasing globally. Explosion hazard is a threat. On the other hand the use of hydrogen is under consideration in Hong Kong. Explosion hazards of these clean fuel (LPG and hydrogen) vehicles were studied and are compared in this paper. The computational fluid dynamics (CFD) software Flame Acceleration Simulator (FLACS) was used. A car garage with a rolling shutter as its entrance was selected for study. Dispersion of LPG from the leakage source with ignition at a higher position was studied. The same garage was used with a typical hydrogen vehicle leaking 3.4 pounds (1.5 kg) of hydrogen in 100 s the mass flow rate being equal to 0.015 kgs−1 . The hydrogen vehicle used in the simulation has two hydrogen tanks with a combined capacity of 5 kg. The entire tank would be completely vented out in about 333 s. Two scenarios of CFD simulation were carried out. In the first scenario the rolling shutter was completely closed and the leaked LPG or hydrogen was ignited at 300 s after leakage. The second scenario was conducted with a gap height of 0.3 m under the rolling shutter. Predicted results of explosion pressure and temperature show that appropriate active fire engineering systems are required when servicing these clean fuel vehicles in garages. An appropriate vent in an enclosed space such as the garage is important in reducing explosion hazards.
A Flammability Limit Model for Hydrogen-air-diluent Mixtures Based on Heat Transfer Characteristics in Flame Propagation
May 2019
Publication
Predicting lower flammability limits (LFL) of hydrogen has become an ever-important task for safety of nuclear industry. While numerous experimental studies have been conducted LFL results applicable for the harsh environment are still lack of information. Our aim is to develop a calculated non-adiabatic flame temperature (CNAFT) model to better predict LFL of hydrogen mixtures in nuclear power plant. The developed model is unique for incorporating radiative heat loss during flame propagation using the CNAFT coefficient derived through previous studies of flame propagation. Our new model is more consistent with the experimental results for various mixtures compared to the previous model which relied on calculated adiabatic flame temperature (CAFT) to predict the LFL without any consideration of heat loss. Limitation of the previous model could be explained clearly based on the CNAFT coefficient magnitude. The prediction accuracy for hydrogen mixtures at elevated initial temperatures and high helium content was improved substantially. The model reliability was confirmed for H2-air mixtures up to 300 C and H2-air-He mixtures up to 50 vol % helium concentration. Therefore the CNAFT model developed based on radiation heat loss is expected as the practical method for predicting LFL in hydrogen risk analysis.
The Effect of Hydrogen Containing Fuel Blends Upon Flashback in Swirl Burners
Feb 2011
Publication
Lean premixed swirl combustion is widely used in gas turbines and many other combustion Processes due to the benefits of good flame stability and blow off limits coupled with low NOx emissions. Although flashback is not generally a problem with natural gas combustion there are some reports of flashback damage with existing gas turbines whilst hydrogen enriched fuel blends especially those derived from gasification of coal and/or biomass/industrial processes such as steel making cause concerns in this area. Thus this paper describes a practical experimental approach to study and reduce the effect of flashback in a compact design of generic swirl burner representative of many systems. A range of different fuel blends are investigated for flashback and blow off limits; these fuel mixes include methane methane/hydrogen blends pure hydrogen and coke oven gas. Swirl number effects are investigated by varying the number of inlets or the configuration of the inlets. The well known Lewis and von Elbe critical boundary velocity gradient expression is used to characterise flashback and enable comparison to be made with other available data. Two flashback phenomena are encountered here. The first one at lower swirl numbers involves flashback through the outer wall boundary layer where the crucial parameter is the critical boundary velocity gradient Gf. Values of Gf are of similar magnitude to those reported by Lewis and von Elbe for laminar flow conditions and it is recognised that under the turbulent flow conditions pertaining here actual gradients in the thin swirl flow boundary layer are much higher than occur under laminar flow conditions. At higher swirl numbers the central recirculation zone (CRZ) becomes enlarged and extends backwards over the fuel injector to the burner baseplate and causes flashback to occur earlier at higher velocities. This extension of the CRZ is complex being governed by swirl number equivalence ratio and Reynolds Number. Under these conditions flashback occurs when the cylindrical flame front surrounding the CRZ rapidly accelerates outwards to the tangential inlets and beyond especially with hydrogen containing fuel mixes. Conversely at lower swirl numbers with a modified exhaust geometry hence restricted CRZ flashback occurs through the outer thin boundary layer at much lower flow rates when the hydrogen content of the fuel mix does not exceed 30%. The work demonstrates that it is possible to run premixed swirl burners with a wide range of hydrogen fuel blends so as to substantially minimise flashback behaviour thus permitting wider used of the technology to reduce NOx emissions.
Monte-Carlo-Analysis of Minimum Burst Requirements for Composite Cylinders for Hydrogen Service
Sep 2021
Publication
For achieving Net Zero-aims hydrogen is an indispensable component probably the main component. For the usage of hydrogen a wide acceptance is necessary which requires trust in hydrogen based on absence of major incidents resulting from a high safety level. Burst tests stand for a type of testing that is used in every test standard and regulation as one of the key issues for ensuring safety in use. The central role of burst and proof test is grown to historical reasons for steam engines and steel vessels but - with respect for composite pressure vessels (CPVs) - not due an extraordinary depth of outcomes. Its importance results from the relatively simple test process with relatively low costs and gets its importance by running of the different test variations in parallel. In relevant test und production standards (as e. g. ECE R134) the burst test is used in at least 4 different meanings. There is the burst test on a) new CPVs and some others b) for determining the residual strength subsequent to various simulations of ageing effects. Both are performed during the approval process on a pre-series. Then there is c) the batch testing during the CPVs production and finally d) the 100% proof testing which means to stop the burst test at a certain pressure level. These different aspects of burst tests are analysed and compared with respect to its importance for the resulting safety of the populations of CPVs in service based on experienced test results and Monte-Carlo simulations. As main criterial for this the expected failure rate in a probabilistic meaning is used. This finally ends up with recommendations for relevant RC&S especially with respect to GTR 13."
Safety Design and Engineering Solution of Fuel Cell Powered Ship in Inland Waterway of China
Oct 2021
Publication
From the perspective of risk control when hydrogen fuel and fuel cells are used on ships there is a possibility of low-flash fuel leakage leading to the risk of explosion. Since the fuel cell space (cabin for fuel cell installations) is an enclosed space any small amount of leakage must be handled properly. In ship design area classification is a method of analyzing and classifying the areas where explosive gas atmospheres may occur. If the fuel cell space is regarded as a hazardous area all the electrical devices inside it must be explosion-proof type which will make the ship’s design very difficult. This paper takes a Chinese fuel cell powered ship as an example to analyze its safety. Firstly the leakage rates of fuel cell modules valves and connectors are calculated. Secondly the IEC60079-10-1 algorithm is used to calculate the risk level of the fuel cell space. Finally the ship and fuel cells are optimized and redesigned and the risk level of the fuel cell space is recalculated and compared. The result shows that the optimized fuel space risk level could be reduced to the level of the non-hazardous zone.
On the Evaluation of ALD TiO 2 , ZrO 2 and HfO 2 Coatings on Corrosion and Cytotoxicity Performances
May 2021
Publication
Magnesium alloys have been widely studied as materials for temporary implants but their use has been limited by their corrosion rate. Recently coatings have been proven to provide an effective barrier. Though only little explored in the field Atomic Layer Deposition (ALD) stands out as a coating technology due to the outstanding film conformality and density achievable. Here we provide first insights into the corrosion behavior and the induced biological response of 100 nm thick ALD TiO2 HfO2 and ZrO2 coatings on AZ31 alloy by means of potentiodynamic polarization curves electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) hydrogen evolution and MTS colorimetric assay with L929 cells. All three coatings improve the corrosion behavior and cytotoxicity of the alloy. Particularly HfO2 coatings were characterized by the highest corrosion resistance and cell viability slightly higher than those of ZrO2 coatings. TiO2 was characterized by the lowest corrosion improvements and though generally considered a biocompatible coating was found to not meet the demands for cellular applications (it was characterized by grade 3 cytotoxicity after 5 days of culture). These results reveal a strong link between biocompatibility and corrosion resistance and entail the need of taking the latter into consideration in the choice of a biocompatible coating to protect degradable Mg-based alloys.
Numerical Simulations of Atmospheric Dispersion of Large-scale Liquid Hydrogen Releases
Sep 2021
Publication
Numerical simulations have been conducted for LH2 massive releases and the subsequent atmospheric dispersion using an in-house modified version of the open source computational fluid dynamics (CFD) code OpenFOAM. A conjugate heat transfer model has been added for heat transfer between the released LH2 and the ground. Appropriate interface boundary conditions are applied to ensure the continuities of temperature and heat fluxes. The significant temperature difference between the cryogenic hydrogen and the ground means that the released LH2 will instantly enter in a boiling state resulting in a hydrogen- air gaseous cloud which will initially behave like a dense gas. Numerical predictions have been conducted for the subsequent atmospheric dispersion of the vaporized LH2 for a series of release scenarios - with and without retention pits - to limit the horizontal spread of the LH2 on the ground. The considered cases included the instantaneous release of 1 10 and 50 tons of LH2 under neutral (D) and stable (F) weather conditions. More specifically 3F and 5D conditions were simulated with the former representing stable weather conditions under wind speed of 3 m/s at 10 m above the ground and the later corresponding to neutral weather conditions under 5 m/s wind speed (10 m above the ground). Specific numerical tests have also been conducted for selected scenarios under different ambient temperatures from 233 up to 313 K. According to the current study although the retention pit can extend the dispersion time it can significantly reduce the extent of hazards due to much smaller cloud size within both the flammability and explosion limits. While the former has negative impact on safety the later is beneficial. The use of retention pit should hence be considered with caution in practical applications.
Numerical Simulation of Hydrogen Leakage and Diffusion Process of Fuel Cell Vehicle
Oct 2021
Publication
Regarding the problem of hydrogen diffusion of the fuel cell vehicle (HFCV) when its hydrogen supply system leaks this research uses the FLUENT software to simulate numerical values in the process of hydrogen leakage diffusion in both open space and closed space. This paper analyzed the distribution range and concentration distribution characteristics of hydrogen in these two different spaces. Besides this paper also took a survey about the effects of leakage rate wind speed wind direction in open space and the role the air vents play on hydrogen safety in closed space which provides a reference for the hydrogen safety of HFCV. In conclusion the experiment result showed that: In open space hydrogen leakage rate has a great influence on its diffusion. When the leakage rate doubles the hydrogen leakage range will expand about 1.5 times simultaneously. The hydrogen diffusion range is the smallest when the wind blows at 90 degrees which is more conducive to hydrogen diffusion. However when the wind direction is against the direction of the leakage of hydrogen the range of hydrogen distribution is maximal. Under this condition the risk of hydrogen leakage is highest. In an enclosed space when the vent is set closest to the leakage position the volume fraction of hydrogen at each time is smaller than that at other positions so it is more beneficial to safety.
Why Ultrasonic Gas Leak Detection?
Sep 2021
Publication
Technologies that have traditionally been used in fixed installations to detect hydrogen gas leaks such as Catalytic and Electrochemical Point Sensors have one limitation: in order for a leak to be detected the gas itself must either be in close proximity to the detector or within a pre-defined area. Unfortunately outdoor environmental conditions such as changing wind directions and quick dispersion of the gas cloud from a leaking outdoor installation often cause that traditional gas detection systems may not alert to the presence of gas simply because the gas never reaches the detector. These traditional gas detection systems need to wait for the gas to form a vapor cloud which may or may not ignite and which may or may not allow loss prevention by enabling shutting down the gas facility in time. Ultrasonic Gas Leak Detectors (UGLD) respond at the speed of sound at gas leak initiation unaffected by changing wind directions and dilution of the gas. Ultrasonic Gas Leak Detectors are based on robust microphone technology; they detect outdoor leaks by sensing the distinct high frequency ultrasound emitted by all high pressure gas leaks. With the ultrasonic sensing technology leaking gas itself does not have to reach the sensor – just the sound of the gas leaking. By adding Ultrasonic Gas Leak Detectors for Hydrogen leak detection faster response times and lower operation costs can be obtained.
Investigation into the Cross-sensitivity of Domestic Carbon Monoxide Alarms to Hydrogen
Sep 2021
Publication
Preliminary research suggests domestic carbon monoxide detectors with an electrochemical sensor are approximately 10 -20% sensitive to hydrogen atmospheres in their factory configuration. That is the display on a carbon monoxide detector would give a carbon monoxide reading of approximately 10-20% of the concentration of hydrogen it is exposed to. Current British standards require detectors to sound an alarm within three minutes when subjected to a continuous concentration of ≥ 300 ppm CO. This would equate to a concentration of 1500-3000 ppm hydrogen in air or approximately 3.75 – 7% %LEL. The current evacuation criteria for a natural gas leak in a domestic property is 20 %LEL indicating that standard carbon monoxide detectors could be used as cheap and reliable early warning systems for hydrogen leaks. Given the wide use of carbon monoxide detectors and the affordability of the devices the use of carbon monoxide detectors for hydrogen detection is of particular interest as the UK drives towards energy decarbonisation. Experiments to determine the exact sensitivity of a range of the most common domestic carbon monoxide detectors have been completed by DNV Spadeadam Research & Testing. Determining the effects of repeated exposure to varying concentrations of hydrogen in air on the sensitivity of electrochemical sensors allows recommendations to be made on their adoption as hydrogen detectors. Changing the catalysts used within the electrochemical cell would improve the sensitivity to hydrogen however simply calibrating the sensor to report a concentration of hydrogen rather than carbon monoxide would represent no additional costs to manufacturers. Having determined the suitability of such sensors at an early stage; the technology can then be linked with other technological developments required for the change to hydrogen for domestic heating (e.g. change in metering equipment and appliances). This report finds that from five simple and widely available carbon monoxide detectors the lowest sensitivity to hydrogen measured at the concentration required to sound an alarm within three minutes was approximately 10%. It was also discovered that as the hydrogen concentration was increased over the range tested the sensitivity to hydrogen also increased. It is proposed that coupling these devices with other elements of the domestic gas system would allow actions such as remote meter isolation or automatic warning signals sent to response services would provide a reliable and inherently safe system for protecting occupants as gas networks transition to net-zero greenhouse gas emissions. In this respect it is noted that wireless linking of smoke and heat detectors for domestic application is already widely available in low-cost devices. This could be extended to CO detectors adapted for hydrogen use.
The Effect of Symmetrically Tilt Grain Boundary of Aluminum on Hydrogen Diffusion
Feb 2022
Publication
High-strength aluminum alloys are widely used in industry. Hydrogen embrittlement greatly reduces the performance and service safety of aluminum alloys. The hydrogen traps in aluminum profoundly affect the hydrogen embrittlement of aluminum. Here we took a coincidence-site lattice (CSL) symmetrically tilted grain boundary (STGB) Σ5(120)[001] as an example to carry out molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of hydrogen diffusion in aluminum at different temperatures and to obtain results and rules consistent with the experiment. At 700 K three groups of MD simulations with concentrations of 0.5 2.5 and 5 atomic % hydrogen (at. % H) were carried out for STGB models at different angles. By analyzing the simulation results and the MSD curves of hydrogen atoms we found that in the low hydrogen concentration of STGB models the grain boundaries captured hydrogen atoms and hindered their movement. In high-hydrogen-concentration models the diffusion rate of hydrogen atoms was not affected by the grain boundaries. The analysis of the simulation results showed that the diffusion of hydro-gen atoms at the grain boundary is anisotropic.
Safety Planning for Hydrogen and Fuel Cell Projects
Jul 2019
Publication
The document provides information on safety planning monitoring and reporting for the concerned hydrogen and fuel cell projects and programmes in Europe. It does not replace or contradict existing regulations which prevails under all circumstances. Neither is it meant to conflict with relevant international or national standards or to replace existing company safety policies codes and procedures. Instead this guidance document aims to assist in identifying minimum safety requirements hazards and associated risks and in generating a quality safety plan that will serve as an assisting guide for the inherently safer conduct of all work related to the development and operation of hydrogen and fuel cell systems and infrastructure. A safety plan should be revisited periodically as part of an overall effort to pay continuous and priority attention to the associated safety aspects and to account for all modifications of the considered system and its operations. Potential hazards failure mechanisms and related incidents associated with any work process or system should always be identified analysed reported (recorded in relevant knowledge databases e.g. HIAD 2.0 or HELLEN handbooks papers etc.) and eliminated or mitigated as part of sound safety planning and comprehensive hydrogen safety engineering which extends beyond the recommendations of this document. All relevant objects or aspects that may be adversely affected by a failure should be considered including low frequency high consequences events. So the general protection objective is to exclude or at least minimise potential hazards and associated risks to prevent impacts on the following:
- People. Hazards that pose a risk of injury or loss of life to people must be identified and eliminated or mitigated. A complete safety assessment considers not only those personnel who are directly involved in the work but also others who are at risk due to these hazards.
- Property. Damage to or loss of equipment or facilities must be prevented or minimised. Damage to equipment can be both the cause of incidents and the result of incidents. An equipment failure can result in collateral damage to nearby equipment and property which can then trigger additional equipment failures or even lead to additional hazards and risks e.g. through the domino effect. Effective safety planning monitoring and reporting considers and minimises serious risk of equipment and property damage.
- Environment. Damage to the environment must be prevented. Any aspect of a natural or the built environment which can be harmed due to a hydrogen system or infrastructure failure should be identified and analysed. A qualification of the failure modes resulting in environmental damage must be considered.
Fire Safety of Hydrogen-Fuelled Vehicles- System-Level Bonfire Test
Sep 2005
Publication
The European Community requires a vehicle-level bonfire test for vehicles using plastic fuel tanks for conventional fuels (ECE R-34 Annex 5). A similar test could be applied to hydrogen-fuelled vehicles. It would test a realistic vehicle with its complete fuel and safety systems. An advantage of such a test is that the same test could be applied independent of the hydrogen storage technology (compressed gas liquid or hydride). There are currently standards for bonfire testing of a bare Compressed Natural Gas (CNG) tank and its Pressure Relief Device (PRD). This standard is FMVSS 304 in the U.S. and ISO 15869-1 in Europe. Japan has a similar standard. It requires that a bare tank and its associated PRD be subjected to a propane flame for 20 minutes. The tank must either survive or safely vent its contents. No modern composite wound tank is expected to survive for 20 minutes – so this is not a tank test but really a PRD test. The test procedure requires the PRD to be shielded from direct impingement of the flames – but the shield is not well specified. If it shields the PRD too well the PRD will not activate and the tank will burst. This paper describes the results of a CNG and a hydrogen tank burst from such tests. The mechanical energy released is enormous. It is simply unacceptable to allow the tank to burst – the PRD and venting system must work. Organizations in the U.S Europe and Japan are in the process of modifying the CNG tank bonfire test for compressed hydrogen storage. A bare tank with a single PRD is not a good simulation of a hydrogen fuel system installed in an actual vehicle. There will usually be multiple tanks plumbed together at either the tank pressure or at the intermediate pressure (after the pressure regulator). There may be more than one PRD. The tank may be shielded (from debris) or insulated to protect it from an underbody pool fire. Also the heat transfer from the simulated pool fire (propane flame) will be very different when mounted in a vehicle versus the bare tank test. A vehicle-level pool fire test will alleviate these problems. It is therefore recommended that the bare tank test be replaced by or augmented with a vehicle-level bonfire test similar to ECE R-34 Annex 5.
Australians’ Considerations for Use of Hydrogen in the Transport Sector
Sep 2019
Publication
Hydrogen fuel cells power a range of vehicles including cars buses trucks forklifts and even trains. As fuel cell electric vehicles emit no carbon emissions and only produce water vapor as a by-product they present an attractive option for countries who are experiencing high pollution from transport. This paper presents the findings of ten focus groups and a subset of a national survey which focused specifically on use of hydrogen in the transport sector (N=948). When discussing hydrogen transport options Australian focus group participants felt that rolling out hydrogen fuel cell buses as a first step for fuel cell electric vehicle deployment would be a good way to increase familiarity with the technology. Deploying hydrogen public transport vehicles before personal vehicles was thought to be a positive way to demonstrate the safe use of hydrogen and build confidence in the technology. At the same time it was felt it would allow any issues to be ironed out before the roll out of large-scale infrastructure on a to support domestic use. Long haul trucks were also perceived to be a good idea however safety issues were raised in the focus groups when discussing these vehicles. Survey respondents also expressed positive support for the use of hydrogen fuel cell buses and long-haul trucks. They reported being happy to be a passenger in a fuel cell bus. Safety and environmental benefits remained paramount with cost considerations being the third most important issue. Respondents supportive of hydrogen technologies were most likely to report purchasing a hydrogen vehicle over other options
Overview on Hydrogen Risk Research and Development Activities: Methodology and Open Issues
Jan 2015
Publication
During the course of a severe accident in a light water nuclear reactor large amounts of hydrogen can be generated and released into the containment during reactor core degradation. Additional burnable gases [hydrogen (H2) and carbon monoxide (CO)] may be released into the containment in the corium/concrete interaction. This could subsequently raise a combustion hazard. As the Fukushima accidents revealed hydrogen combustion can cause high pressure spikes that could challenge the reactor buildings and lead to failure of the surrounding buildings. To prevent the gas explosion hazard most mitigation strategies adopted by European countries are based on the implementation of passive autocatalytic recombiners (PARs). Studies of representative accident sequences indicate that despite the installation of PARs it is difficult to prevent at all times and locations the formation of a combustible mixture that potentially leads to local flame acceleration. Complementary research and development (R&D) projects were recently launched to understand better the phenomena associated with the combustion hazard and to address the issues highlighted after the Fukushima Daiichi events such as explosion hazard in the venting system and the potential flammable mixture migration into spaces beyond the primary containment. The expected results will be used to improve the modeling tools and methodology for hydrogen risk assessment and severe accident management guidelines. The present paper aims to present the methodology adopted by Institut de Radioprotection et de Suˆ rete Nucleaire to assess hydrogen risk in nuclear power plants in particular French nuclear power plants the open issues and the ongoing R&D programs related to hydrogen distribution mitigation and combustion.
Flame Acceleration and Deflagration-to-Detonation Transition in Hydrogen-Oxygen Mixture in a Channel with Triangular Obstacles
Sep 2021
Publication
Study of flame acceleration and deflagration-to-detonation transition (DDT) in obstructed channels is an important subject of research for hydrogen safety. Experiments and numerical simulations of DDT in channels equipped with triangular obstacles were conducted in this work. High-speed schlieren photography and pressure records were used to study the flame shape changes flame propagation and pressure build up in the experiments. In the simulations the fully compressible reactive Navier–Stokes equations coupled with a calibrated chemical-diffusion model for stoichiometric hydrogen-oxygen mixture were solved using a high-order numerical method. The simulations were in good agreement with the experiments. The results show that the triangular obstacles significantly promote the flame acceleration and provide conditions for the occurrence of DDT. In the early stages of flame acceleration vortices are generated in the gaps between adjacent obstacles which is the main cause for the flame roll-up and distortion. A positive feedback mechanism between the combustiongenerated flow and flame propagation results in the variations of the size and velocity of vortices. The flame-vortex interactions cause flame fragmentation and consequently rapid growth in flame surface area which further lead to flame acceleration. The initially laminar flame then develops into a turbulent flame with the creation of shocks shock-flame interactions and various flame instabilities. The continuously arranged obstacles interact with shocks and flames and help to create environments in which a detonation can develop. Both flame collision and flame-shock interaction can give rise to detonation in the channels with triangular obstacles.
Hy4Heat Domestic Hydrogen Purge Procedures - Work Package 4
Jun 2021
Publication
The aim of this project was to review the current purge standards for UK domestic installations in particular IGEM/UP/1B and carry out experiments to assess the validity of those standards for use in hydrogen in order to understand and recommend safe purge practices for hydrogen in a domestic environment.
This report provides the results and conclusions relating to the relative safety of purging domestic installations to hydrogen compared to Natural Gas and the implications of releasing any purged gas
into an enclosed volume representing a small room.
The two high-level findings from this work are:
The risks with hydrogen are associated with a wide range of flammability with methane the risks are smaller and mainly in lower concentrations of gas in air. Because of this it is particularly important to ensure hydrogen pipes are appropriately purged.
This report provides the results and conclusions relating to the relative safety of purging domestic installations to hydrogen compared to Natural Gas and the implications of releasing any purged gas
into an enclosed volume representing a small room.
The two high-level findings from this work are:
- changeover to hydrogen will result in an increased risk of flammability inside the installation pipework
- changeover to hydrogen will result in a reduced risk of a build-up of flammable gas in any room where purging occurs.
The risks with hydrogen are associated with a wide range of flammability with methane the risks are smaller and mainly in lower concentrations of gas in air. Because of this it is particularly important to ensure hydrogen pipes are appropriately purged.
Recent Progress in Hydrogen Flammability Prediction for the Safe Energy Systems
Nov 2020
Publication
Many countries consider hydrogen as a promising energy source to resolve the energy challenges over the global climate change. However the potential of hydrogen explosions remains a technical issue to embrace hydrogen as an alternate solution since the Hindenburg disaster occurred in 1937. To ascertain safe hydrogen energy systems including production storage and transportation securing the knowledge concerning hydrogen flammability is essential. In this paper we addressed a comprehensive review of the studies related to predicting hydrogen flammability by dividing them into three types: experimental numerical and analytical. While the earlier experimental studies had focused only on measuring limit concentration recent studies clarified the extinction mechanism of a hydrogen flame. In numerical studies the continued advances in computer performance enabled even multi-dimensional stretched flame analysis following one-dimensional planar flame analysis. The different extinction mechanisms depending on the Lewis number of each fuel type could be observed by these advanced simulations. Finally historical attempts to predict the limit concentration by analytical modelling of flammability characteristics were discussed. Developing an accurate model to predict the flammability limit of various hydrogen mixtures is our remaining issue.
Experimental Study and Model Predictions on Helium Release in an Enclosure with Single or Multiple Vents
Sep 2021
Publication
This paper presents experiments performed at Canadian Nuclear Laboratories (CNL) to examine the dispersion behaviour of helium in a polycarbonate enclosure that was representative of a residential parking garage. The purpose was to gain a better understanding of the effect of buoyancy- or winddriven natural ventilation on hydrogen dispersion behaviour. Although hydrogen dispersion studies have been reported extensively in the literature gaps still exist in predictive methods for hazard analysis. Helium a simulant for hydrogen was injected near the centre of the floor with a flow rate ranging from 5 to 75 standard litres per minute through an upward-facing nozzle resulting in an injection Richardson number ranging between 10-1 and 102. The location of the nozzle varied from the bottom of the enclosure to near the ceiling to examine the impact of the nozzle elevation on the development of a stratified layer in the upper region of the enclosure. When the injection nozzle was placed at a sufficiently low elevation the vertical helium profile always consisted of a homogenous layer at the top overlaying a stratified layer at the bottom. To simulate outdoor environmental conditions a fan was placed in front of each vent to examine the effect of opposing or assisting wind on the dispersion. The helium transients in the uniform layer predicted with analytical models were in good agreement with the measured transients for the tests with injection at lower elevations or with no wind. Model improvements are required for adequately predicting transients with significantly stratified profiles or with wind.
Current Research and Development Activities on Fission Products and Hydrogen Risk after the Accident at Fukushima Daiiichi Nuclear Power Station
Jan 2015
Publication
After the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power plant (NPP) accident new regulatory requirements were enforced in July 2013 and a backfit was required for all existing nuclear power plants. It is required to take measures to prevent severe accidents and mitigate their radiological consequences. The Regulatory Standard and Research Department Secretariat of Nuclear Regulation Authority (S/NRA/R) has been conducting numerical studies and experimental studies on relevant severe accident phenomena and countermeasures. This article highlights fission product (FP) release and hydrogen risk as two major areas. Relevant activities in the S/NRA/R are briefly introduced as follows: 1. For FP release: Identifying the source terms and leak mechanisms is a key issue from the viewpoint of understanding the progression of accident phenomena and planning effective countermeasures that take into account vulnerabilities of containment under severe accident conditions. To resolve these issues the activities focus on wet well venting pool scrubbing iodine chemistry (in-vessel and ex-vessel) containment failure mode and treatment of radioactive liquid effluent. 2. For hydrogen risk: because of three incidents of hydrogen explosion in reactor buildings a comprehensive reinforcement of the hydrogen risk management has been a high priority topic. Therefore the activities in evaluation methods focus on hydrogen generation hydrogen distribution and hydrogen combustion.
Hydrogeochemical Modeling to Identify Potential Risks of Underground Hydrogen Storage in Depleted Gas Fields
Nov 2018
Publication
Underground hydrogen storage is a potential way to balance seasonal fluctuations in energy production from renewable energies. The risks of hydrogen storage in depleted gas fields include the conversion of hydrogen to CH4(g) and H2S(g) due to microbial activity gas–water–rock interactions in the reservoir and cap rock which are connected with porosity changes and the loss of aqueous hydrogen by diffusion through the cap rock brine. These risks lead to loss of hydrogen and thus to a loss of energy. A hydrogeochemical modeling approach is developed to analyze these risks and to understand the basic hydrogeochemical mechanisms of hydrogen storage over storage times at the reservoir scale. The one-dimensional diffusive mass transport model is based on equilibrium reactions for gas–water–rock interactions and kinetic reactions for sulfate reduction and methanogenesis. The modeling code is PHREEQC (pH-REdox-EQuilibrium written in the C programming language). The parameters that influence the hydrogen loss are identified. Crucial parameters are the amount of available electron acceptors the storage time and the kinetic rate constants. Hydrogen storage causes a slight decrease in porosity of the reservoir rock. Loss of aqueous hydrogen by diffusion is minimal. A wide range of conditions for optimized hydrogen storage in depleted gas fields is identified.
A Model for Hydrogen Detonation Diffraction or Transmission to a Non-confined Layer
Sep 2021
Publication
One strategy for arresting propagating detonation waves in pipes is by imposing a sudden area enlargement which provides a rapid lateral divergence of the gases in the reaction zone and attenuates the leading shock. For sufficiently small tube diameter the detonation decays to a deflagration and the shock decays to negligible strengths. This is known as the critical tube diameter problem. In the present study we provide a closed form model to predict the detonation quenching for 2D channels. This problem also applies to the transmission of a detonation wave from a confined layer to a weakly-confined layer. Whitham’s geometric shock dynamics coupled with a shock evolution law based on shocks sustained by a constant source obtained by the shock change equations of Radulescu is shown to capture the lateral shock dynamics response to the failure wave originating at the expansion corner. A criterion for successful detonation transmission to open space is that the lateral strain rate provided by the failure wave not exceed the critical strain rate of steady curved detonations. Using the critical lateral strain rate obtained by He and Clavin a closed form solution is obtained for the critical channel opening permitting detonation transmission. The predicted critical channel width is found in excellent agreement with our recent experiments and simulations of diffracting H2/O2/Ar detonations. Model comparison with available data for H2/air detonation diffraction into open space at ambient conditions or for transmission into a weakly confined layer by air is also found in good agreement within a factor never exceeding 2 for the critical opening or layer dimension.
An Investigation into the Volumetric Flow Rate Requirement of Hydrogen Transportation in Existing Natural Gas Pipelines and Its Safety Implications
Oct 2021
Publication
As an alternative to the construction of new infrastructure repurposing existing natural gas pipelines for hydrogen transportation has been identified as a low-cost strategy for substituting natural gas with hydrogen in the wake of the energy transition. In line with that a 342 km 3600 natural gas pipeline was used in this study to simulate some technical implications of delivering the same amount of energy with different blends of natural gas and hydrogen and with 100% hydrogen. Preliminary findings from the study confirmed that a three-fold increase in volumetric flow rate would be required of hydrogen to deliver an equivalent amount of energy as natural gas. The effects of flowing hydrogen at this rate in an existing natural gas pipeline on two flow parameters (the compressibility factor and the velocity gradient) which are crucial to the safety of the pipeline were investigated. The compressibility factor behaviour revealed the presence of a wide range of values as the proportions of hydrogen and natural gas in the blends changed signifying disparate flow behaviours and consequent varying flow challenges. The velocity profiles showed that hydrogen can be transported in natural gas pipelines via blending with natural gas by up to 40% of hydrogen in the blend without exceeding the erosional velocity limits of the pipeline. However when the proportion of hydrogen reached 60% the erosional velocity limit was reached at 290 km so that beyond this distance the pipeline would be subject to internal erosion. The use of compressor stations was shown to be effective in remedying this challenge. This study provides more insights into the volumetric and safety considerations of adopting existing natural gas pipelines for the transportation of hydrogen and blends of hydrogen and natural gas.
Numerical Analysis for Hydrogen Flame Acceleration during a Severe Accident in the APR1400 Containment Using a Multi-Dimensional Hydrogen Analysis System
Nov 2020
Publication
Korea Atomic Energy Research Institute (KAERI) established a multi-dimensional hydrogen analysis system to evaluate hydrogen release distribution and combustion in the containment of a Nuclear Power Plant (NPP) using MAAP GASFLOW and COM3D. In particular KAERI developed an analysis methodology for a hydrogen flame acceleration on the basis of the COM3D validation results against measured data of the hydrogen combustion tests in the ENACCEF and THAI facilities. The proposed analysis methodology accurately predicted the peak overpressure with an error range of approximately ±10% using the Kawanabe model used for a turbulent flame speed in the COM3D. KAERI performed a hydrogen flame acceleration analysis using the multi-dimensional hydrogen analysis system for a severe accident initiated by a station blackout (SBO) under the assumption of 100% metal–water reaction in the Reactor Pressure Vessel (RPV) to evaluate an overpressure buildup in the containment of the Advanced Power Reactor 1400 MWe (APR1400). The magnitude of the overpressure buildup in the APR1400 containment might be used as a criterion to judge whether the containment integrity is maintained or not when the hydrogen combustion occurs during a severe accident. The COM3D calculation results using the established analysis methodology showed that the calculated peak pressure in the containment was lower than the fracture pressure of the APR1400 containment. This calculation result might have resulted from a large air volume of the containment a reduced hydrogen concentration owing to passive auto-catalytic recombiners installed in the containment during the hydrogen release from the RPV and a lot of stem presence during the hydrogen combustion period in the containment. Therefore we found that the current design of the APR1400 containment maintained its integrity when the flame acceleration occurred during the severe accident initiated by the SBO accident.
Direct Numerical Simulation of Hydrogen Combustion at Auto-ignitive Conditions Ignition, Stability and Turbulent Reaction-front Velocity
Mar 2021
Publication
Direct Numerical Simulations (DNS) are performed to investigate the process of spontaneous ignition of hydrogen flames at laminar turbulent adiabatic and non-adiabatic conditions. Mixtures of hydrogen and vitiated air at temperatures representing gas-turbine reheat combustion are considered. Adiabatic spontaneous ignition processes are investigated first providing a quantitative characterization of stable and unstable flames. Results indicate that in hydrogen reheat combustion compressibility effects play a key role in flame stability and that unstable ignition and combustion are consistently encountered for reactant temperatures close to the mixture’s characteristic crossover temperature. Furthermore it is also found that the characterization of the adiabatic processes is also valid in the presence of non-adiabaticity due to wall heat-loss. Finally a quantitative characterization of the instantaneous fuel consumption rate within the reaction front is obtained and of its ability at auto-ignitive conditions to advance against the approaching turbulent flow of the reactants for a range of different turbulence intensities temperatures and pressure levels.
Fundamentals and Principles of Solid-State Electrochemical Sensors for High Temperature Gas Detection
Dec 2021
Publication
The rapid development of science technology and engineering in the 21st century has offered a remarkable rise in our living standards. However at the same time serious environmental issues have emerged such as acid rain and the greenhouse effect which are associated with the ever-increasing need for energy consumption 85% of which comes from fossil fuels combustion. From this combustion process except for energy the main greenhouse gases-carbon dioxide and steam-are produced. Moreover during industrial processes many hazardous gases are emitted. For this reason gas-detecting devices such as electrochemical gas sensors able to analyze the composition of a target atmosphere in real time are important for further improving our living quality. Such devices can help address environmental issues and inform us about the presence of dangerous gases. Furthermore as non-renewable energy sources run out there is a need for energy saving. By analyzing the composition of combustion emissions of automobiles or industries combustion processes can be optimized. This review deals with electrochemical gas sensors based on solid oxide electrolytes which are employed for the detection of hazardous gasses at high temperatures and aggressive environments. The fundamentals the principle of operation and the configuration of potentiometric amperometric combined (amperometric-potentiometric) and mixed-potential gas sensors are presented. Moreover the results of previous studies on carbon oxides (COx) nitrogen oxides (NOx) hydrogen (H2 ) oxygen (O2 ) ammonia (NH3 ) and humidity (steam) electrochemical sensors are reported and discussed. Emphasis is given to sensors based on oxygen ion and proton-conducting electrolytes.
Validation of Leading Point Concept in RANS Simulations of Highly Turbulent Lean Syngas-air Flames with Well-pronounced Diffusional-thermal Effects
Jan 2021
Publication
While significant increase in turbulent burning rate in lean premixed flames of hydrogen or hydrogen-containing fuel blends is well documented in various experiments and can be explained by highlighting local diffusional-thermal effects capabilities of the vast majority of available models of turbulent combustion for predicting this increase have not yet been documented in numerical simulations. To fill this knowledge gap a well-validated Turbulent Flame Closure (TFC) model of the influence of turbulence on premixed combustion which however does not address the diffusional-thermal effects is combined with the leading point concept which highlights strongly perturbed leading flame kernels whose local structure and burning rate are significantly affected by the diffusional-thermal effects. More specifically within the framework of the leading point concept local consumption velocity is computed in extremely strained laminar flames by adopting detailed combustion chemistry and subsequently the computed velocity is used as an input parameter of the TFC model. The combined model is tested in RANS simulations of highly turbulent lean syngas-air flames that were experimentally investigated at Georgia Tech. The tests are performed for four different values of the inlet rms turbulent velocities different turbulence length scales normal and elevated (up to 10 atm) pressures various H2/CO ratios ranging from 30/70 to 90/10 and various equivalence ratios ranging from 0.40 to 0.80. All in all the performed 33 tests indicate that the studied combination of the leading point concept and the TFC model can predict well-pronounced diffusional-thermal effects in lean highly turbulent syngas-air flames with these results being obtained using the same value of a single constant of the combined model in all cases. In particular the model well predicts a significant increase in the bulk turbulent consumption velocity when increasing the H2/CO ratio but retaining the same value of the laminar flame speed.
Magneto-Electronic Hydrogen Gas Sensors: A Critical Review
Jan 2022
Publication
Devices enabling early detection of low concentrations of leaking hydrogen and precision measurements in a wide range of hydrogen concentrations in hydrogen storage systems are essential for the mass-production of fuel-cell vehicles and more broadly for the transition to the hydrogen economy. Whereas several competing sensor technologies are potentially suitable for this role ultralow fire-hazard contactless and technically simple magneto-electronic sensors stand apart because they have been able to detect the presence of hydrogen gas in a range of hydrogen concentrations from 0.06% to 100% at atmospheric pressure with the response time approaching the industry gold standard of one second. This new kind of hydrogen sensors is the subject of this review article where we inform academic physics chemistry material science and engineering communities as well as industry researchers about the recent developments in the field of magneto-electronic hydrogen sensors including those based on magneto-optical Kerr effect anomalous Hall effect and Ferromagnetic Resonance with a special focus on Ferromagnetic Resonance (FMR)-based devices. In particular we present the physical foundations of magneto-electronic hydrogen sensors and we critically overview their advantages and disadvantages for applications in the vital areas of the safety of hydrogen-powered cars and hydrogen fuelling stations as well as hydrogen concentration meters including those operating directly inside hydrogen-fuelled fuel cells. We believe that this review will be of interest to a broad readership also facilitating the translation of research results into policy and practice.
Critical Morphological Phenomena During Ultra-lean Hydrogen-air Combustion in Closed Horizontal Hele-Shaw Cell
Sep 2021
Publication
Free quasi-two-dimensional outward propagation of the ultra-lean hydrogen-air flames was studied in a horizontal closed flat channel in order to minimize the influences of gravity and natural convection. Experiments were carried out with a sequential change of initial hydrogen concentration in the premixed gaseous hydrogen-air mixtures in the range from 3 to 12 vol. % H2 under normal pressure and temperature conditions. Two types of critical (in term of concentration threshold behavior) morphological phenomena were observed - formation of a pre-flame kernel and primary bifurcation of the pre-flame kernel and the higher order (secondary tertiary etc.) bifurcations of the individual locally spherical and restricted in space flame fronts. For the given initial ambient conditions (channel thickness initial gas mixture pressure and temperature) variation of initial mixture stoichiometry results in a few substantial changes in overall flame shape. These changes were recorded at the specific concentration limits which delineate three characteristic macroscopic morphological forms (morphotypes) of the ultra-lean hydrogen-air flame's ""trails"" - ""ray-like"" ""dendritic"" and ""quasi-uniform"". Transitions between the revealed basic flame morphotypes took place in different ways. The ""pre-flame kernel-to- rays"" and ""rays-to-dendrites"" transitions were abrupt and resembled the first order transitions in physics. -to-quasi-uniform morphology"" were significantly blurred and can be regarded as analogue to the second order transitions.
Large-eddy Simulation of Tri-fuel Combustion: Diesel Spray Assisted Ignition of Methanol-hydrogen Blends
May 2021
Publication
Development of marine engines could largely benefit from the broader usage of methanol and hydrogen which are both potential energy carriers. Here numerical results are presented on tri-fuel (TF) ignition using large-eddy simulation (LES) and finite-rate chemistry. Zero-dimensional (0D) and three-dimensional (3D) simulations for n-dodecane spray ignition of methanol/hydrogen blends are performed. 0D results reveal the beneficial role of hydrogen addition in facilitating methanol ignition. Based on LES the following findings are reported: 1) Hydrogen promotes TF ignition significantly for molar blending ratios βX = [H2]/([H2]+[CH3OH]) ≥0.8. 2) For βX = 0 unfavorable heat generation in ambient methanol is noted. We provide evidence that excessive hydrogen enrichment (βX ≥ 0.94) potentially avoids this behavior consistent with 0D results. 3) Ignition delay time is advanced by 23–26% with shorter spray vapor penetrations (10–15%) through hydrogen mass blending ratios 0.25/0.5/1.0. 4) Last adding hydrogen increases shares of lower and higher temperature chemistry modes to total heat release.
Construction of Natural Gas Energy-measuring System in China: A Discussion
Feb 2022
Publication
During the 13th Five-Year Plan China's natural gas industry developed rapidly and a diversified supply and marketing pattern was formed including domestic conventional gas unconventional gas (shale gas tight sandstone gas coalbed methane etc.) coal-based synthetic natural gas imported LNG and imported pipeline gas. The gross calorific value of gas sources ranged from 34 MJ/m3 to 43 MJ/m3 and the maximum difference of calorific value between different gas sources exceeded 20%. On May 24th 2019 the National Development and Reform Commission and other three ministries/commissions jointly issued the Supervision Regulation on the Fair Access of Oil and Gas Pipeline Network Facilities and required that a natural gas energy measuring and pricing system shall be established within 24 months from the implementation date of this Regulation. In order to speed up the construction of China's natural gas energy measuring system this paper summarizes domestic achievements in the construction of natural gas energy measuring system from the aspects of value traceability and energy measurement standard and analyzes natural gas flowrate measurement technology calorific value determination technology value traceability localization intelligentization and application technology of key energy measurement equipment natural gas pipeline network energy balancing technology based on big data analysis multi-source quality tracking and monitoring technology and energy measurement standard system the need of new energy detection and measurement technology and put forward strategy for the development of natural gas measuring in China. And the following research results are obtained. First China's natural gas energy measuring system can basically meet the requirements of implementing natural gas energy measurement but it still falls behind the international leading level in terms of calibration and application of high-level flowmeter (such as 0.5 class) high-accuracy gas reference material level of calorific value reference equipment and measurement standard system and needs to be further improved. Second it is necessary for China to speed up the research and application of the localization and intelligentization technologies of key energy measurement equipment. Third natural gas pipeline network shall be equipped with measurement check method energy balancing system based on big data analysis and multi-source quality tracking and monitoring system so that the energy transmission loss index of natural gas pipeline network can be superior to the international leading level (0.10%). Fourth to realize the large-scale application of hydrogen energy and bio-energy and the mixed transportation of hydrogen bio-methane and natural gas it is necessary to carry out research on new technology and standardization of hydrogen/bio-methane blended natural gas detection and measurement.
Hy4Heat Safety Assessment: Conclusions Report (Incorporating Quantitative Risk Assessment) - Work Package 7
May 2021
Publication
The Hy4Heat Safety Assessment has focused on assessing the safe use of hydrogen gas in certain types of domestic properties and buildings. The summary reports (the Precis and the Safety Assessment Conclusions Report) bring together all the findings of the work and should be looked to for context by all readers. The technical reports should be read in conjunction with the summary reports. While the summary reports are made as accessible as possible for general readers the technical reports may be most accessible for readers with a degree of technical subject matter understanding. All of the safety assessment reports have now been reviewed by the HSE.<br/><br/>A comparative risk assessment of natural gas versus hydrogen gas including a quantitative risk assessment; and identification of control measures to reduce risk and manage hydrogen gas safety for a community demonstration.
Hydrogen Wide Area Monitoring of LH2 Releases at HSE for the PRESLHY Project
Sep 2021
Publication
The characterization of liquid hydrogen (LH2) releases has been identified as an international research priority to facilitate the safe use of hydrogen as an energy carrier. Empirical field measurements such as those afforded by Hydrogen Wide Area Monitoring can elucidate the behavior of LH2 releases which can then be used to support and validate dispersion models. Hydrogen Wide Area Monitoring can be defined as the quantitative three-dimensional spatial and temporal profiling of planned or unintentional hydrogen releases. The NREL Sensor Laboratory developed a Hydrogen Wide Area Monitor (HyWAM) based upon a distributed array of hydrogen sensors. The NREL Sensor Laboratory and the Health and Safety Executive (HSE) formally committed to collaborate on profiling GH2 and LH2 releases which allowed for the integration of the NREL HyWAM into the HSE LH2 release behavior investigation supported by the FCH JU Prenormative Research for the Safe Use of Liquid Hydrogen (PRESLHY) program. A HyWAM system was deployed consisting of 32 hydrogen measurement points and co-located temperature sensors distributed downstream of the LH2 release apparatus developed by HSE. In addition the HyWAM deployment was supported by proximal wind and weather monitors. In a separate presentation at this conference “HSE Experimental Summary for the Characterisation Dispersion and Electrostatic Hazards of LH2 for the PRESLHY Project” HSE researchers summarize the experimental apparatus and protocols utilized in the HSE LH2 releases that were performed under the auspices of PRESLHY. As a supplement to the HSE presentation this presentation will focus on the spatial and temporal behavior LH2 releases as measured by the NREL HyWAM. Correlations to ambient conditions such as wind speed and direction plume temperature and hydrogen concentrations will be discussed in addition to the design and performance of the NREL HyWAM and its potential for improving hydrogen facility safety.
Differentiating Gas Leaks from Normal Appliance Use
Jun 2021
Publication
DNV has carried out an investigation into potential uses for smart gas meter data as part of Phase 1 of the Modernising Energy Data Applications competition as funded by UK Research & Innovation. In particular a series of calculations have been carried out to investigate the possibility of differentiating accidental gas leaks from normal appliance use in domestic properties. This is primarily with the aim of preventing explosions but the detection of leaks also has environmental and financial benefits.
Three gases have been considered in this study:
An examination of detailed historical incident information suggests that the explosions that lead to fatalities or significant damage to houses are typically of the type that would be more likely to be detected and prevented. It is estimated that between 25% and 75% of the more severe explosions could be prevented depending on which potential improvements are implemented.
Based on the conservative estimates of explosion prevention a cost benefit analysis suggests that it is justifiable to spend between around £1 and £10 per meter installed to implement the proposed technology. This is based purely on lives saved and does not take account of other benefits.
Three gases have been considered in this study:
- A representative UK natural gas composition.
- A blend of 80% natural gas and 20% hydrogen.
- Pure hydrogen.
- Small holes of up to 1 mm rarely reach flammable gas/air concentrations for any gas except under the most unfavourable conditions such as small volumes combined with low ventilation rates. These releases would likely be detected within 6 to 12 hours.
- Medium holes between 1 mm and 6 mm give outflow rates equivalent to a moderate to high level of gas use by appliances. The ability to detect these leaks is highly dependent on the hole size the time at which the leak begins and the normal gas use profile in the building. The larger leaks in this category would be detected within 30 to 60 minutes while the smaller leaks could take several hours to be clearly differentiated from appliance use. This is quick enough to prevent some explosions.
- Large holes of over 6 mm give leak rates greater than any gas use by appliances. These releases rapidly reach a flammable gas/air mixture in most cases but would typically be detected within the first 30-minute meter output period. Again some explosions could be prevented in this timescale.
An examination of detailed historical incident information suggests that the explosions that lead to fatalities or significant damage to houses are typically of the type that would be more likely to be detected and prevented. It is estimated that between 25% and 75% of the more severe explosions could be prevented depending on which potential improvements are implemented.
Based on the conservative estimates of explosion prevention a cost benefit analysis suggests that it is justifiable to spend between around £1 and £10 per meter installed to implement the proposed technology. This is based purely on lives saved and does not take account of other benefits.
Statistics, Lessons Learnt and Recommendations from the Analysis of the Hydrogen Incidents and Accidents Database (HIAD 2.0)
Sep 2021
Publication
The Hydrogen Incidents and Accidents Database (HIAD) is an international open communication platform collecting systematic data on hydrogen-related undesired incidents which was initially developed in the frame of HySafe an EC co-funded Network of Excellence in the 6th Frame Work Programme by the Joint Research Centre of the European Commission (EC-JRC). It was updated by JRC as HIAD 2.01 in 2016 with the support of the Fuel Cells and Hydrogen 2 Joint Undertaking (FCH 2 JU). Since the launch of the European Hydrogen Safety Panel2 (EHSP) initiative in 2017 by FCH 2 JU the EHSP has worked closely with JRC to upload additional/new incidents to HIAD 2.0 and analyze them to gather statistics lessons learnt and recommendations through Task Force 3. The first report to summarise the findings of the analysis was published by FCH 2 JU in September 2019. Since the publication of the first report the EHSP and JRC have continuously worked together to enlarge HIAD 2.0 by adding newly occurred incidents as well as quality historic incidents which were not previously uploaded to HIAD 2.0. This has facilitated the number of validated incidents in HIAD 2.0 to increase from 272 in 2018 to 593 in March 2021. This number is also dynamic and continues to increase as new incidents are being continuously added by both EHSP and JRC; and validated by JRC. The overall quality of the published incidents has also been improved whenever possible. For example additional information has been added to some existing incidents. Since mid-2020 EHSP Task Force TF3 has further analysed the 485 events which were in the database as of July 2020. For completeness of the statistics these include the events considered in our first report3 as well as the newly added/validated events since then. In this process the EHSP has also re-visited the lessons learnt in the first report to harmonise the approaches of analysis and improve the overall analysis. The analysis has comprehensively covered statistics lessons learnt and recommendations. The increased number of incidents has also made it viable to extract statistics from the available incidents at the time of the analysis including previously available incidents. It should be noted that some incidents reported is of low quality therefore it was not included in the statistical analysis.
Hydrogen as a Maritime Fuel–Can Experiences with LNG Be Transferred to Hydrogen Systems?
Jul 2021
Publication
As the use of fossil fuels becomes more and more restricted there is a need for alternative fuels also at sea. For short sea distance travel purposes batteries may be a solution. However for longer distances when there is no possibility of recharging at sea batteries do not have sufficient capacity yet. Several projects have demonstrated the use of compressed hydrogen (CH2) as a fuel for road transport. The experience with hydrogen as a maritime fuel is very limited. In this paper the similarities and differences between liquefied hydrogen (LH2) and liquefied natural gas (LNG) as a maritime fuel will be discussed based on literature data of their properties and our system knowledge. The advantages and disadvantages of the two fuels will be examined with respect to use as a maritime fuel. Our objective is to discuss if and how hydrogen could replace fossil fuels on long distance sea voyages. Due to the low temperature of LH2 and wide flammability range in air these systems have more challenges related to storage and processing onboard than LNG. These factors result in higher investment costs. All this may also imply challenges for the LH2 supply chain.
Experimental Study of the Explosion Severity of Vented Methane/Hydrogen Deflagrations
Sep 2021
Publication
Adding hydrogen to mains natural gas has been identified as one of the main strategies to reduce CO2 emissions in the United Kingdom. This work aims to characterise the explosion severity of 80:20 v./v. methane/hydrogen blends (‘a blend’) and methane vented deflagrations. The explosion severity of homogenous mixtures was measured in a 15 m3 cubic steel chamber in which the relief area was provided by four windows and a door covered with polypropylene sheet. The pressure increase over time was characterised using piezo-resistive pressure transducers and the flame speed was estimated using ionisation probes installed in the walls of the enclosure. The explosion severity of both mixtures was determined for different equivalence ratios from lean to rich mixtures. The pressure over time presented very similar behaviour for both mixtures comprising multiple peaks divided into three main stages: a first stage related to a spherical confined explosion until the opening of the vent a second stage generated by increased combustion during venting and an oscillatory peak generated by acoustic disturbances with the enclosure. A slight increase in the first stage overpressure was observed for the blend in comparison with methane regardless of the equivalence ratio but no general trend in pressure was observed for other stages of the propagation. The effect of the blockage ratio on explosion severity was studied by adding metallic elements representing furniture in a room.
Assessment and Lessons Learnt from HIAD 2.0 – Hydrogen Incidents and Accidents Database
Sep 2019
Publication
The Hydrogen Incidents and Accidents Database (HIAD) is an international open communication platform collecting systematic data on hydrogen-related undesired events (incidents or accidents). It was initially developed in the frame of the project HySafe an EC co-funded NoE of the 6th Frame Work Programme by the Joint Research Centre of the European Commission (EC-JRC) and populated by many HySafe partners. After the end of the project the database has been maintained and populated by JRC with publicly available events.<br/>Starting from June 2016 JRC has been developing a new version of the database (HIAD 2.01). With the support of the Fuel Cells and Hydrogen 2 Joint Undertaking (FCH 2 JU) the structure of the database and the web-interface have been redefined and simplified resulting in a streamlined user interface compared to the previous version of HIAD. The new version is mainly focused to facilitate the sharing of lessons learnt and other relevant information related to hydrogen technology; the database is publicly released and the events are anonymized. The database currently contains over 250 events. It aims to contribute to improve the safety awareness fostering the users to benefit from the experiences of others as well as to share information from their own experiences.<br/>The FCH 2 JU launched the European Hydrogen Safety Panel (EHSP2) initiative in 2017. The mission of the EHSP is to assist the FCH 2 JU at both programme and project level in assuring that hydrogen safety is adequately managed and to promote and disseminate hydrogen safety culture within and outside of the FCH 2 JU programme. Composed of a multidisciplinary pool of experts – 16 experts in 2018 - the EHSP is grouped in small ad-hoc working groups (task forces) according to the tasks to be performed and the expertise required. In 2018 Task Force 3 (TF3) of the ESHP has encompassed the analysis of safety data and events contained in HIAD 2.0 operated by JRC and supported by the FCH 2 JU. In close collaboration with JRC the EHSP members have systematically reviewed more than 250 events.<br/>This report summarizes the lessons learnt stemmed from this assessment. The report is self-explanatory and hence includes brief introduction about HIAD 2.0 the assessment carried out by the EHSP and the results stemmed from the joint assessment to enable new readers without prior knowledge of HIAD 2.0 to understand the rationale of the overall exercise and the lessons learnt from this effort. Some materials have also been lifted from the joint paper between JRC and EHSP which will also be presented at the International Conference on Hydrogen Safety (ICHS 2019) to provide some general and specific information about HIAD 2.0.
The Effect of Hydrogen Enrichment, Flame-flame Interaction, Confinement, and Asymmetry on the Acoustic Response of a Model Can Combustor
Apr 2022
Publication
To maximise power density practical gas turbine combustion systems have several injectors which can lead to complex interactions between flames. However our knowledge about the effect of flame-flame interactions on the flame response the essential element to predict the stability of a combustor is still limited. The present study investigates the effect of hydrogen enrichment flame-flame interaction confinement and asymmetries on the linear and non-linear acoustic response of three premixed flames in a simple can combustor. A parametric study of the linear response characterised by the flame transfer function (FTF) is performed for swirling and non-swirling flames. Flame-flame interactions were achieved by changing the injector spacing and the level of hydrogen enrichment by power from 10 to 50%. It was found that the latter had the most significant effect on the flame response. Asymmetry effects were investigated by changing one of the flames by using a different bluff-body to alter both the flame shape and flow field. The global flame response showed that the asymmetric cases can be reconstructed using a superposition of the two symmetric cases where all three bluff-bodies and flames are the same. Overall the linear response characterised by the flame transfer function (FTF) showed that the effect of increasing the level of hydrogen enrichment is more pronounced than the effect of the injector spacing. Increasing hydrogen enrichment results in more compact flames which minimises flame-flame interactions. More compact flames increase the cut-off frequency which can lead to self-excited modes at higher frequencies. Finally the non-linear response was characterised by measuring the flame describing function (FDF) at a frequency close to a self-excited mode of the combustor for different injector spacings and levels of hydrogen enrichment. It is shown that increasing the hydrogen enrichment leads to higher saturation amplitude whereas the effect of injector spacing has a comparably smaller effect.
Hydrogen Dispersion and Ventilation Effects in Enclosures under Different Release Conditions
Apr 2021
Publication
Hydrogen is an explosive gas which could create extremely hazardous conditions when released into an enclosure. Full-scale experiments of hydrogen release and dispersion in the confined space were conducted. The experiments were performed for hydrogen release outflow of 63 × 10−3 m3/s through a single nozzle and multi-point release way optionally. It was found that the hydrogen dispersion in an enclosure strongly depends on the gas release way. Significantly higher hydrogen stratification is observed in a single nozzle release than in the case of the multi-point release when the gas concentration becomes more uniform in the entire enclosure volume. The experimental results were confirmed on the basis of Froud number analysis. The CFD simulations realized with the FDS code by NIST allowed visualization of the experimental hydrogen dispersion phenomenon and confirmed that the varied distribution of hydrogen did not affect the effectiveness of the accidental mechanical ventilation system applied in the tested room.
Review on the Hydrogen Dispersion and the Burning Behavior of Fuel Cell Electric Vehicles
Oct 2022
Publication
The development of a hydrogen energy-based society is becoming the solution for more and more countries. Fuel cell electric vehicles are the best carriers for developing a hydrogen energy-based society. The current research on hydrogen leakage and the diffusion of fuel cell electric vehicles has been sufficient. However the study of hydrogen safety has not reduced the safety concerns for society and government management departments concerning the large-scale promotion of fuel cell electric vehicles. Hydrogen safety is both a technical and psychological issue. This paper aims to provide a comprehensive overview of fuel cell electric vehicles’ hydrogen dispersion and the burning behavior and introduce the relevant work of international standardization and global technical regulations. The CFD simulations in tunnels underground car parks and multistory car parks show that the hydrogen escape performance is excellent. At the same time the research verifies that the flow the direction of leakage and the vehicle itself are the most critical factors affecting hydrogen distribution. The impact of the leakage location and leakage pore size is much smaller. The relevant studies also show that the risk is still controllable even if the hydrogen leakage rate is increased ten times the limit of GTR 13 to 1000 NL/min and then ignited. Multi-vehicle combustion tests of fuel cell electric vehicles showed that adjacent vehicles were not ignited by the hydrogen. This shows that as long as the appropriate measures are taken the risk of a hydrogen leak or the combustion of fuel cell electric vehicles is controllable. The introduction of relevant standards and regulations also indirectly proves this point. This paper will provide product design guidelines for R&D personnel offer the latest knowledge and guidance to the regulatory agencies and increase the public’s acceptance of fuel cell electric vehicles.
Stochastic Low-order Modelling of Hydrogen Autoignition in a Turbulent Non-premixed Flow
Jul 2022
Publication
Autoignition risk in initially non-premixed flowing systems such as premixing ducts must be assessed to help the development of low-NOx systems and hydrogen combustors. Such situations may involve randomly fluctuating inlet conditions that are challenging to model in conventional mixture-fraction-based approaches. A Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD)-based surrogate modelling strategy is presented here for fast and accurate predictions of the stochastic autoignition behaviour of a hydrogen flow in a hot air turbulent co-flow. The variability of three input parameters i.e. inlet fuel and air temperatures and average wall temperature is first sampled via a space-filling design. For each sampled set of conditions the CFD modelling of the flame is performed via the Incompletely Stirred Reactor Network (ISRN) approach which solves the reacting flow governing equations in post-processing on top of a Large Eddy Simulation (LES) of the inert hydrogen plume. An accurate surrogate model namely a Gaussian Process is then trained on the ISRN simulations of the burner and the final quantification of the variability of autoignition locations is achieved by querying the surrogate model via Monte Carlo sampling of the random input quantities. The results are in agreement with the observed statistics of the autoignition locations. The methodology adopted in this work can be used effectively to quantify the impact of fluctuations and assist the design of practical combustion systems. © 2022 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Inc. on behalf of The Combustion Institute.
The Evolution and Structure of Ignited High-pressure Cryogenic Hydrogen Jets
Jun 2022
Publication
The anticipated upscaling of hydrogen energy applications will involve the storage and transport of hydrogen at cryogenic conditions. Understanding the potential hazard arising from leaks in high-pressure cryogenic storage is needed to improve hydrogen safety. The manuscript reports a series of numerical simulations with detailed chemistry for the transient evolution of ignited high-pressure cryogenic hydrogen jets. The study aims to gain insight of the ignition processes flame structures and dynamics associated with the transient flame evolution. Numerical simulations were firstly conducted for an unignited jet released under the same cryogenic temperature of 80 K and pressure of 200 bar as the considered ignited jets. The predicted hydrogen concentrations were found to be in good agreement with the experimental measurements. The results informed the subsequent simulations of the ignited jets involving four different ignition locations. The predicted time series snapshots of temperature hydrogen mass fraction and the flame index are analyzed to study the transient evolution and structure of the flame. The results show that a diffusion combustion layer is developed along the outer boundary of the jet and a side diffusion flame is formed for the near-field ignition. For the far-field ignition an envelope flame is observed. The flame structure contains a diffusion flame on the outer edge and a premixed flame inside the jet. Due to the complex interactions between turbulence fuel-air mixing at cryogenic temperature and chemical reactions localized spontaneous ignition and transient flame extinguishment are observed. The predictions also captured the experimentally observed deflagration waves in the far-field ignited jets.
Hydrogen Safety Challenges: A Comprehensive Review on Production, Storage, Transport, Utilization, and CFD-Based Consequence and Risk Assessment
Mar 2024
Publication
This review examines the central role of hydrogen particularly green hydrogen from renewable sources in the global search for energy solutions that are sustainable and safe by design. Using the hydrogen square safety measures across the hydrogen value chain—production storage transport and utilisation—are discussed thereby highlighting the need for a balanced approach to ensure a sustainable and efficient hydrogen economy. The review also underlines the challenges in safety assessments points to past incidents and argues for a comprehensive risk assessment that uses empirical modelling simulation-based computational fluid dynamics (CFDs) for hydrogen dispersion and quantitative risk assessments. It also highlights the activities carried out by our research group SaRAH (Safety Risk Analysis and Hydrogen) relative to a more rigorous risk assessment of hydrogenrelated systems through the use of a combined approach of CFD simulations and the appropriate risk assessment tools. Our research activities are currently focused on underground hydrogen storage and hydrogen transport as hythane.
Cold Hydrogen Blowdown Release: An Inter-comparison Study
Sep 2021
Publication
Hydrogen dispersion in stagnant environment resulting from blowdown of a vessel storing the gas at cryogenic temperature is simulated using different CFD codes and modelling strategies. The simulations are based on the DISCHA experiments that were carried out by Karlsruhe Institute of Technology (KIT) and Pro-Science (PS). The selected test for the current study involves hydrogen release from a 2.815 dm3 volume tank with an initial pressure of 200 barg and temperature 80 K. During the release the hydrogen pressure in the tank gradually decreased. A total of about 139 gr hydrogen is released through a 4 mm diameter. The temperature time series and the temperature decay rate of the minimum value predicted by the different codes are compared with each other and with the experimentally measured ones. Recommendations for future experimental setup and for modeling approaches for similar releases are provided based on the present analysis. The work is carried out within the EU-funded project PRESLHY.
Hydrogen Sensing Properties of UV Enhanced Pd-SnO2 Nano-Spherical Composites at Low Temperature
Sep 2021
Publication
Metal oxide semiconductor (MOS) is promising in developing hydrogen detectors. However typical MOS materials usually work between 200-500°C which not only restricts their application in flammable and explosive gases detection but also weakens sensor stability and causes high power consumption. This paper studies the sensing properties of UV enhanced Pd-SnO2 nano-spherical composites at 80-360 ℃. In the experiment Pd of different molar ratios (0.5 2.5 5.0 10.0) was doped into uniform spherical SnO2 nanoparticles by a hydrothermal synthesis method. A xenon lamp with a filter was used as the ultraviolet excitation light source to examine the response of the spherical Pd- SnO2 nanocomposite to 50-1000 ppm H2 gas. The influence of different intensities of ultraviolet light on the gas-sensing properties of composite materials compared with dark condition was analyzed. The experiments show that the conductivity of the composites can be greatly stabilized and the thermal excitation temperature can be reduced to 180 ℃ under the effect of UV enhancement. A rapid response (4.4/ 17.4 s) to 200 ppm of H2 at 330 °C can be achieved by the Pd-SnO2 nanocomposites with UV assistance. The mechanism may be attributed to light motivated electron-hole pairs due to built-in electric fields under UV light illumination which can be captured by target gases and lead to UV controlled gas sensing performance. Catalytic active sites of hydrogen are provided on the surface of the mixed material by Pd. The results in this study can be helpful in reducing the response temperature of MOS materials and improving the performance of hydrogen detectors."
Establishing the State of the Art for the Definition of Safety Distances for Hydrogen Refuelling Stations
Sep 2021
Publication
Hydrogen is widely considered a clean source of energy from the viewpoint of reduction in carbon dioxide emissions as a countermeasure against global warming and air pollution. Various efforts have been made to develop hydrogen as a viable energy carrier including the implementation of fuel cell vehicles (FCVs) and hydrogen refuelling stations (HRSs). A good network of hydrogen refuelling stations is essential for operating FCVs and several hydrogen refuelling stations have been constructed and are in operation worldwide [1]. However despite the potential benefits of hydrogen its flammability creates significant safety concerns. Furthermore even though the energy density of hydrogen is lower than that of gasoline and there is no carbon present which means the amount of radiant heat flux released during combustion is relatively small hydrogen must be handled at high pressure in order to make the cruising range of a fuel cell vehicle (FCV) equal to that of gasoline-powered vehicles. Therefore it is essential to properly evaluate these safety concerns and take reasonable and effective countermeasures. Approximately 50 accidents and incidents involving HRSs have been reported globally [2]. Sakamoto et al. [2] analysed accidents and incidents at HRSs in Japan and the USA to identify the safety issues. Most types of accidents and incidents are small leakages of hydrogen but some have led to serious consequences such as fire and explosion. Recently there was a serious incident in Norway at Kjørbo where a strong explosion was observed [3] – indeed this was within a short time of two other serious incidents in the USA and South Korea showing that the frequency of such incidents may be higher as deployments increase. Use of hydrogen forklifts (and the associated refuelling infrastructure) is another challenge to consider. Hydrogen refuelling stations are often installed in urban areas facing roads and are readily accessible to everyone. Therefore a key measure to approve the hydrogen refuelling stations is safety distances between the hydrogen infrastructure and the surrounding structures such as office buildings or residential dwellings. Whilst a lot of work has been carried out on safety distances (see e.g. [4-6) the accident scenario assumptions and safety distances varied widely in those studies. As a result no consensus has yet emerged on the safety distances to be used and efforts are still needed to bridge the gap between international standards and local regulations (see e.g. [7-8]). The paper analyses this issue and provides guidance on the way forward.
H21 Phase 2: Personal Protective Equipment
Dec 2020
Publication
This report is a detailed discussion related to safety shoes heat and flame personal protective equipment (PPE) and breathing apparatus (respiratory protective equipment RPE) required for working with natural gas (NG) and hydrogen (H2). This work was undertaken by HSE Science Division (SD) as part of Phase 2a of the H21 project. This report should be read alongside all the other relevant reports generated as part of this project. Recommendations made in this report are focused solely on the provision and use of PPE and should not be considered independently of recommendations made in the other relevant reports.<br/>Understanding the similarities and difference of PPE required for NG and H2 enables a deeper understanding of how the transition from NG to 100% H2 might change the way the gas distribution network is operated and managed.
Investigation of Hydrogen Leaks from Double Ferrule Fittings
Sep 2021
Publication
The use of hydrogen is expected to increase rapidly in the future. Leakage of hydrogen pipework are the main forms of safety problems in hydrogen utilization. In this paper a numerical model of hydrogen leakage and diffusion in pipe joints was established. The Schlieren + high-speed camera is used in experiments to observe the leakage of hydrogen in the pipe joints. In addition the shape and size of the scratches in the tube were statistically analyzed. Finally the leakage characteristics of double ferrule joints with scratches are experimentally analyzed. For the two scratch sizes the critical pressure values for the vortex transition are 0.2 MPa and 0.03 MPa. Through our experimental process some practical experience and suggestions are given.
Hydrogen Generation on Orkney: Integrating Established Risk Management Best Practice to Emerging Clean Energy Sector
Sep 2021
Publication
The European Marine Energy Centre’s (EMEC) ITEG project (Integrating Tidal Energy into the European Grid) funded by Interreg NWE combines a tidal energy and hydrogen production solution to address grid constraints on the island of Eday in Orkney. The project will install a 0.5MW electrolyser at EMEC’s existing hydrogen production plant. EMEC and Risktec collaboratively applied best practice risk assessment and management techniques to assess and manage hydrogen safety. Hazard identification (HAZID) workshops were conducted collaboratively with design engineers through which a comprehensive hazard register was developed. Risktec applied bowtie analysis to each major accident hazard identified from the hazard register via virtual workshop with design engineers. The bowties promoted a structured review of each hazard’s threat and consequence identifying and reviewing the controls in place against good practice standards. The process revealed some recommendations for further improvement and risk reduction exemplifying a systematic management of risks associated with hydrogen hazards to as low as reasonably practicable (ALARP). Hardware based barriers preventing or mitigating loss of control of these hazards were logged as safety critical elements (SCE) and procedural barriers as safety critical activities (SCA). To ensure that all SCEs and SCAs identified through the risk assessment process are managed throughout the facility’s operational lifetime a safety management system is created giving assurance of overall safety management system continued effectiveness. The process enables the demonstration that design risks are managed to ALARP during design and throughout operational lifetime. More importantly enabling ITEG to progress to construction and operation in 2021.
Numerical Study of Hydrogen Addition Effects on Aluminum Particle Combustion
Sep 2021
Publication
In this study the combustion of submicron-sized Al particles in air was studied numerically with a particular focus on the effect of hydrogen addition. Oxidation of the Al particles and the interaction with hydrogen-related intermediates were considered by regarding them as liquid-phase molecules initially. Zero- and One-dimensional numerical simulations were then carried out to investigate the effect of the hydrogen addition on fundamental combustion characteristics of the Al flame by calculating properties such as ignition delay time and flame speed. Our attention was paid to how the hydrogen chemistry is coupled with the Al oxidation process. Numerical results show that the hydrogen addition generally reduces the reactivity of Al such that the flame speed and temperature decrease while it can greatly shorten ignition delay times of the Al flame depending on initial temperatures.
The Influence of Grain Boundary and Hydrogen on the Indetation of Bi-crystal Nickel
Sep 2021
Publication
Three different types of symmetrical tilt grain boundaries Ȉ3 Ȉ11 and Ȉ27 were constructed to study the dislocation behavior under the indentation on bi-crystal nickel. After hydrogen charging the number of hydrogen atoms in the Ȉ3 sample is the smallest and gradually increases in Ȉ11 and Ȉ27 samples. The force-displacement curve of indentation shows that the deformation resistance of the Ȉ3 sample is significantly higher than that of Ȉ11 and Ȉ27 samples. With the presence of grain boundaries the deformation resistance of Ȉ11 and Ȉ27 samples is significantly improved while the deformation resistance of the Ȉ3 VDPSOH is weakened. The indentation depth during the formation of dislocations in single crystals is significantly greater than that of bi-crystals. Grain boundaries slow down the dislocation propagation speed. Compared with the bi-crystals without hydrogen the presence of hydrogen reduces the deformation resistance and accelerates the dislocation propagation.
Measurement and Modeling on Hydrogen Jet and Combustion from a Pressurize Vessel
Sep 2021
Publication
Hydrogen safety is an important topic for hydrogen energy application. Unintended hydrogen releases and combustions are potential accident scenarios which are of great interest for developing and updating the safety codes and standards. In this paper hydrogen releases and delayed ignitions were studied.
A Brief History of Process Safety Management
Sep 2021
Publication
Common root causes are often to be found in many if not most process safety incidents. Whilst largescale events are relatively rare such events can have devastating consequences. The subsequent investigations often uncover that the risks are rarely visible the direct causes are often hidden and that a ‘normalization of deviation’ is a common human characteristic. Process Safety Management (PSM) builds on the valuable lessons learned from past incidents to help prevent future recurrences. An understanding of how PSM originated and has evolved as a discipline over the past 200 years can be instructive when considering the safety implications of emerging technologies. An example is hydrogen production where risks must be effectively identified mitigated and addressed to provide safe production transportation storage and use .
Effects of Hydrogen and Carbon Dioxide on the Laminar Burning Velocities of Methane-air Mixtures
Sep 2021
Publication
The effects of different mole fractions of hydrogen and carbon dioxide on the combustion characteristics of a premixed methane–air mixture are experimentally and numerically investigated. The laminar burning velocity of hydrogen-methane-carbon dioxide-air mixture was measured using the spherically expanding flame method at the initial temperature and pressure of 283 K and 0.1 MPa respectively. Additionally numerical analysis is conducted under steady 1D laminar flow conditions to investigate the adiabatic flame temperature and dominant elementary reactions. The measured velocities correspond with those estimated numerically. The results show that increasing the carbon dioxide mole fraction decreases the laminar burning velocity attributed to the carbon dioxide dilution which decreases the thermal diffusivity and flame temperature. Conversely the velocity increases with the thermal diffusivity as the hydrogen mole fraction increases. Moreover the hydrogen addition leads to chain-branching reactions that produce active H O and OH radicals via the oxidation of hydrocarbons which is the rate-determining reaction.
Towards Unified Protocol for Par's Performance Rating and Safety Margins Assessment: Par Life-cycle Systemic Model
Sep 2021
Publication
Passive Autocatalytic Recombiners (PAR) is one of the important technical mitigation means for hydrogen combustion in the NPP containments under accident conditions. For the PWR/VVER/CANDU units the PARs execute functions important for safety - reduce the local hydrogen concentration to an acceptable level and provide the homogenization of gas composition and of temperature fields in the containment. Certification and licensing of PAR technology have been accepted for the different NPP types and in the different countries on the case-by-case basement. But a comprehensive and generally accepted terminology and procedures for PAR characterization and its performance and safety rating are still absent. As a next step in PAR's technology improvement and maturity it would be logical a development of their unified technical standardization and certification. Report is aimed to - 2) justify need in standardization of the PARs in the nuclear industry and in the hydrogen energy applications 2) define a minimal set of the notions which can be used for quantitative characterization of the of PARs throughout its life-cycle 3) formulate a systemic (generic state-machine or automata) model of PAR's states under the normal and accident conditions. After verification and validation of proposed PAR systemic model it can be used as one of ints for the development of an international standard for PAR performance and safety.
Experimental Investigation on the Burning Behavior of Homogenous H2-CO-Air Mixtures in an Obstructed Semi-confined Channel
Sep 2021
Publication
In the current work the combustion behavior of hydrogen-carbon monoxide-air mixtures in semiconfined geometries is investigated in a large horizontal channel facility (dimensions 9 m x 3 m x 0.6 m (L x W x H)) as a part of a joint German nuclear safety project. In the channel with evenly distributed obstacles (blockage ratio 50%) and an open to air ground face homogeneous H2-CO-air mixtures are ignited at one end. The combustion behavior of the mixture is analyzed using the signals of pressure sensors modified thermocouples and ionization probes for flame front detection that are distributed along the channel ceiling. In the experiments various fuel concentrations (cH2 + cCO = 14 to 22 Vol%) with different H2:CO ratios (75:25 50:50 and 25:75) are used and the transition regions for a significant flame acceleration to sonic speed (FA) as well as to a detonation (DDT) are investigated. The conditions for the onset of these transitions are compared with earlier experiments performed in the same facility with H2-air mixtures. The results of this work will help to allow a more realistic estimation of the pressure loads generated by the combustion of H2-CO-air mixtures in obstructed semi-confined geometries.
Risk Assessment of a Gaseous Hydrogen Fueling Station (GHFs)
Sep 2021
Publication
Promoted by national and European investment plans promoting the use of hydrogen as energy carrier the number of Gaseous Hydrogen Fueling Station (or GHFS) has been growing up quite significantly over the past years. Considering the new possible hazards and the related accidents induced by these installations like seen in 2019 in Norway this paper presents a risk assessment of a typical GHFS using the same methodology as the one required in France by the authorities for Seveso facilities. The fact that a hydrogen fueling station could be used by a public not particularly trained to handle hydrogen underlines the importance of this risk assessment. In this article typical components related to GHFS (dispenser high pressure storage compressor low pressure storage) are listed and the hazard potentials linked to these components and the substances involved are identified. Based on these elements and an accidentology a risk analysis has been conducted in order to identify all accidental situations that could occur. The workflow included a detailed risk assessment consisting in modeling the thermal and explosion effects of all hazardous phenomena and in assessing the probability of occurrence for these scenarios. Regarding possible mitigation measures the study was based on an international benchmark for codes and standards made for GFHS. These preliminary outcomes of this study may be useful for any designer and/or owner of a GFHS.
CFD Simulation of Pressure Reduction Inside Large-scale Liquefied Hydrogen Tank
Sep 2021
Publication
Building the international hydrogen supply chain requires the large-scale liquefied hydrogen(LH2) carrier. During shipping LH2 with LH2 Carrier the tank is pressurized by LH2 evaporation due to heat ingress from outside. Before unloading LH2 at the receiving terminal reducing the tank pressure is essential for the safe tank operation. However pressure reduction might cause flashing leading to rapid vaporization of liquefied hydrogen liquid leakage. Moreover it was considered that pressure recovery phenomenon which was not preferred in terms of tank pressure management occurred at the beginning of pressure reduction. Hence the purpose of our research is to clarify the phenomenon inside the cargo tank during pressure reduction. The CFD analysis of the pressure reduction phenomenon was conducted with the VOF based in-house CFD code utilizing the C-CUP scheme combined with the hybrid Level Set and MARS method. In our previous research the pressure reduction experiments with the 30 m³ LH2 tank were simulated and the results showed that the pressure recovery was caused by the boiling delay and the tank pressure followed the saturation pressure after the liquid was fully stirred. In this paper the results were re-evaluated in terms of temperature. While pressure reduction was dominant the temperature of vapor-liquid interface decreased. Once the boiling bubble stirred the interface its temperature reached the saturation temperature after pressure recovery occurred. Moreover it was found that the liquid temperature during pressure reduction could not be measured because of the boiling from the wall of the thermometer. The CFD analysis on pressure reduction of 1250 m³ tank for the LH2 Carrier was also very could occur in the case of the 1250 m³ tank in a certain condition. These results provide new insight into the development of the LH2 carrier.
Siting and Co-location with Hydrogen: What are the Risks?
Sep 2021
Publication
The demand for hydrogen has grown more than threefold since 1975 [1] and price is expected to significantly decrease by 2030 [2] concluding in an expected continual increase in demand. HyLaw defined by Hydrogen Europe lays out recommendations for hydrogen applications using identified Legal and Administrative Processes (LAPs) across 18 European countries. Regarding site location HyLaw refers to the land use plan. This defines the production and storage of hydrogen as an industrial activity and therefore regardless of the specific site methods of production or use the hydrogen site must be within a permitted industrial zone or under specific condition commercial areas [3]. Local authorities fire departments and other concerned parties may need to be consulted on site suitability for the project. Risktec explores a range of considerations for siting and layout of hydrogen developments including co-location with other assets for example with renewable energy sources hazardous facilities or public structures. Good practice tools and assessment techniques are presented to mitigate the risks associated with the production storage and use of hydrogen not just the surrounding site and environment but the operatives of the facility.
Influence of Longitudinal Wind on Hydrogen Leakage and Hydrogen Concentration Sensor Layout of Fuel Cell Vehicles
Jul 2023
Publication
Hydrogen has the physical and chemical characteristics of being flammable explosive and prone to leakage and its safety is the main issue faced by the promotion of hydrogen as an energy source. The most common scene in vehicle application is the longitudinal wind generated by driving and the original position of hydrogen concentration sensors (HCSs) did not consider the influence of longitudinal wind on the hydrogen leakage trajectory. In this paper the computational fluid dynamics (CFD) software STAR CCM 2021.1 is used to simulate the hydrogen leakage and diffusion trajectories of fuel cell vehicles (FCVs) at five different leakage locations the longitudinal wind speeds of 0 km/h 37.18 km/h and 114 km/h and it is concluded that longitudinal wind prolongs the diffusion time of hydrogen to the headspace and reduces the coverage area of hydrogen in the headspace with a decrease of 81.35%. In order to achieve a good detection effect of fuel cell vehicles within the longitudinal wind scene based on the simulated hydrogen concentration–time matrix the scene clustering method based on vector similarity evaluation was used to reduce the leakage scene set by 33%. Then the layout position of HCSs was optimized according to the proposed multi-scene full coverage response time minimization model and the response time was reduced from 5 s to 1 s.
Risk Management of Energy Communities with Hydrogen Production and Storage Technologies
Jul 2023
Publication
The distributed integration of renewable energy sources plays a central role in the decarbonization of economies. In this regard energy communities arise as a promising entity to coordinate groups of proactive consumers (prosumers) and incentivize investment on clean technologies. However the uncertain nature of renewable energy generation residential loads and trading tariffs pose important challenges both at the operational and economic levels. We study how this management can be directly undertaken by an arbitrageur that making use of an adequate price-based demand response (real-time pricing) system serves as an intermediary with the central electricity market to coordinate different types of prosumers under risk aversion. In particular we consider a sequential futures and spot market where the aggregated shortage or excess of energy within the community can be traded. We aim to study the impact of new hydrogen production and storage technologies on community operation and risk management. These interactions are modeled as a game theoretical setting in the form of a stochastic two-stage bilevel optimization problem which is later reformulated without approximation as a single-level mixed-integer linear problem (MILP). An extensive set of numerical experiments based on real data is performed to study the operation of the energy community under different technical and economical conditions. Results indicate that the optimal involvement in futures and spot markets is highly conditioned by the community’s risk aversion and self-sufficiency levels. Moreover the external hydrogen market has a direct effect on the community’s internal price-tariff system and depending on the market conditions may worsen the utility of individual prosumers.
Development of Dispensing Hardware for Safe Fueling of Heavy Duty Vehicles
Sep 2021
Publication
The development of safe dispensing equipment for the fueling of heavy duty (HD) vehicles is critical to the expansion of this newly and quickly expanding market. This paper discusses the development of a HD dispenser and nozzles assembly (nozzle hose breakaway) for these new larger vehicles where flow rates are more than double compared to light duty (LD) vehicles. This equipment must operate at nominal pressures of 700 bar -40o C gas temperature and average flow rate of 5-10 kg/min at a high throughput commercial hydrogen fueling station without leaking hydrogen. The project surveyed HD vehicle manufacturers station developers and component suppliers to determine the basic specifications of the dispensing equipment and nozzle assembly. The team also examined existing codes and standards to determine necessary changes to accommodate HD components. From this information the team developed a set of specifications which will be used to design the dispensing equipment. In order to meet these goals the team performed computational fluid dynamic pressure modelling and temperature analysis in order to determine the necessary parameters to meet existing safety standards modified for HD fueling. The team also considered user operational and maintenance requirements such as freeze lock which has been an issue which prevents the removal of the nozzle from LD vehicles. The team also performed a failure mode and effects analysis (FMEA) to identify the possible failures in the design. The dispenser and nozzle assembly will be tested separately and then installed on an innovative HD fueling station which will use a HD vehicle simulator to test the entire system.
Safety Compliance Verification of Fuel Cell Electric Vehicle Exhaust
Sep 2021
Publication
NREL has been developing compliance verification tools for allowable hydrogen levels prescribed by the Global Technical Regulation Number 13 (GTR-13) for hydrogen fuel cell electric vehicles (FCEVs). As per GTR-13 FCEV exhaust is to remain below 4 vol% H2 over a 3-second moving average and shall not at any time exceed 8 vol% H2 and that this requirement is to be verified with an analyzer that has a response time of less than 300 ms. To be enforceable a means to verify regulatory requirements must exist. In response to this need NREL developed a prototype analyzer that meets the GTR metrological requirements for FCEV exhaust analysis. The analyzer was tested on a commercial fuel cell electric vehicle (FCEV) under simulated driving conditions using a chassis dynamometer at the Emissions Research and Measurement Section of Environment and Climate Change Canada and FCEV exhaust was successfully profiled. Although the prototype FCEV Exhaust Analyzer met the metrological requirements of GTR-13 the stability of the hydrogen sensor was adversely impacted by condensed water in the sample gas. FCEV exhaust is at an elevated temperature and nearly saturated with water vapor. Furthermore condensed water is present in the form of droplets. Condensed water in the sample gas collected from FCEV exhaust can accumulate on the hydrogen sensing element which would not only block access of hydrogen to the sensing element but can also permanently damage the sensor electronics. In the past year the design of the gas sampling system was modified to mitigate against the transport of liquid water to the sensing element. Laboratory testing confirmed the effectiveness of the modified sampling system water removal strategy while maintaining the measurement range and response time required by GTR-13. Testing of the upgraded analyzer design on an FCEV operating on a chassis dynamometer is scheduled for the summer of 2021.
A Catalyst Fusible Link for Hydrogen Detection and Activation of Passive Ventilation Systems
Sep 2021
Publication
This paper presents an experimental study of a hydrogen fusible link developed for use in the detection of hydrogen and in the activation of passive ventilation or other safety systems. Fusible links are commonly used to passively close fire dampers in the event of a fire; they generally consist of two pieces of metal joined together by a low temperature alloy to form a single device. When exposed to fire the link will heat up and eventually melt the alloy causing the metal pieces to separate. The same principle has been adopted for the hydrogen fusible link in which hydrogen recombiner catalyst was coated onto small rectangular brass plates. These plates were then soldered together to create prototypes of the hydrogen fusible link. When the resulting link is exposed to a hydrogen-air mixture an exothermic reaction occurs on the catalyst surface that will heat up the link and melt the solder separating the two sections of the hydrogen fusible link. A series of experiments was performed to characterize the thermal response of the hydrogen fusible links to various hydrogen-air mixtures. The effect of both hydrogen concentration and its rate of accumulation on the increase of catalyst temperature was examined. This study demonstrated the applicability of the hydrogen fusible link for managing hydrogen risk.
Hydrogen Safety Strategies and Risk Management in Equinor
Sep 2021
Publication
Equinor has in recent years focused on low carbon technologies in addition to conventional oil & gas technologies. Clear strategic directions have been set to demonstrate Equinor’s commitment to longterm value creation that supports the Paris Agreement. This includes acceleration of decarbonization by establishing a well-functioning market for carbon capture transport and storage (CCS) as well as development of competitive hydrogen-based value chains and solutions. The specific properties of hydrogen must be taken into account in order to ensure safe design and operation of hydrogen systems as these properties differ substantially from those of natural gas and other conventional oil & gas products. Development projects need to consider and mitigate the increased possibility of high explosion pressures or detonation if hydrogen releases accumulate in enclosed or congested areas. On the other hand hydrogen’s buoyant properties can be exploited by locating potential leak points in the open to avoid gas accumulation thereby reducing the explosion risk. The purpose of this paper is to introduce Equinor’s hydrogen-based value chain projects and present our approach to ensure safe and effective designs. Safety strategies constitute the basis for Equinor’s safety and risk management. The safety strategies describe the connection between the hazards and risk profiles on one hand and the safety barrier elements and their needed performance on the other as input to safe design. The safety strategies also form the basis for safe operation. Measures to control the risk through practical designs follow from these strategies.
Approaches and Methods to Demonstrate Repurposing of the UK's Local Transmission System (LTS) Pipelines for Transportation of Hydrogen
Sep 2021
Publication
Hydrogen has the potential as an energy solution to contribute to decarbonisation targets as it has the capability to deliver low-carbon energy at the scale required. For this to be realised the suitability of the existing natural gas pipeline networks for transporting hydrogen must be established. The current paper describes a feasibility study that was undertaken to assess the potential for repurposing the UK’s Local Transmission System (LTS) natural gas pipelines for hydrogen service. The analysis focused on SGN’s network which includes 3000 km of LTS pipelines in Scotland and the south of England. The characteristics of the LTS pipelines in terms of materials of construction and operation were first evaluated. This analysis showed that a significant percentage of SGN’s LTS network consists of lower strength grades of steel pipeline that operate at low stresses which are factors conducive to a pipeline’s suitability for hydrogen service. An assessment was also made of where existing approaches in pipeline operation may require modifications for hydrogen. The effects of changes in mechanical properties of steel pipelines on integrity and lifetime as a result of potential hydrogen degradation were demonstrated using fitness-for-purpose analysis. A review of pipeline risk assessment and Land-Use Planning (LUP) zone calculations for hydrogen was undertaken to identify any required changes. Case studies on selected sections of the LTS pipeline were then carried out to illustrate the potential changes to LUP zones. The work concluded with a summary of identified gaps that require addressing to ensure safe pipeline repurposing for hydrogen which cover materials performance inspection risk assessment land use planning and procedures.
Development of Technical Regulations for Fuel Cell Motorcycles in Japan—Hydrogen Safety
Jul 2019
Publication
Hydrogen fuel cell vehicles are expected to play an important role in the future and thus have improved significantly over the past years. Hydrogen fuel cell motorcycles with a small container for compressed hydrogen gas have been developed in Japan along with related regulations. As a result national regulations have been established in Japan after discussions with Japanese motorcycle companies stakeholders and experts. The concept of Japanese regulations was proposed internationally and a new international regulation on hydrogen-fueled motorcycles incorporating compressed hydrogen storage systems based on this concept are also established as United Nations Regulation No. 146. In this paper several technical regulations on hydrogen safety specific to fuel cell motorcycles incorporating compressed hydrogen storage systems are summarized. The unique characteristics of these motorcycles e.g. small body light weight and tendency to overturn easily are considered in these regulations.
Safety Assessment of Hydrogen Jet Fire Scenarios within Semi-Confined Spaces
Jan 2023
Publication
Hydrogen fuel cell vehicle (HFCV) technology poses great promise as an alternative to significantly reduce the environmental impact of the transport sector’s emissions. However hydrogen fuel cell technology is relatively new therefore confirmation of the reliability and safety analysis is still required particularly for fire scenarios within confined spaces such as tunnels. This study applied the computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulations in conjunction with probabilistic calculation methods to determine the associated thermal risk of a hydrogen jet fire in a tunnel and its dependency on scenarios with different tunnel slopes longitudinal and transverse ventilation velocities and fire positions. A large-scale model of 102 m in which the effects of outlined parameter variations on the severity of the fire incident were analysed. It is found that both tunnel ventilation techniques and slope were critical for the effective ejection of accumulated heat. With ventilation playing a primary role in the ejection of heat and gas and slope ensuring the stability of the ejected heat probabilities of thermal burns were found to be reduced by up to approximately 35% with a strong suggestion of critical combinations to further reduce the dangers of hydrogen tunnel fires.
Numerical Simulation of Hydrogen Leakage from Fuel Cell Vehicle in an Outdoor Parking Garage
Aug 2021
Publication
It is significant to assess the hydrogen safety of fuel cell vehicles (FCVs) in parking garages with a rapidly increased number of FCVs. In the present work a Flame Acceleration Simulator (FLACS) a computational fluid dynamics (CFD) module using finite element calculation was utilized to predict the dispersion process of flammable hydrogen clouds which was performed by hydrogen leakage from a fuel cell vehicle in an outdoor parking garage. The effect of leakage diameter (2 mm 3 mm and 4 mm) and parking configurations (vertical and parallel parking) on the formation of flammable clouds with a range of 4–75% by volume was considered. The emission was assumed to be directed downwards from a Thermally Activated Pressure Relief Device (TPRD) of a 70 MPa storage tank. The results show that the 0.7 m parking space stipulated by the current regulations is less than the safety space of fuel cell vehicles. Compared with a vertical parking configuration it is safer to park FCVs in parallel. It was also shown that release through a large TPRD orifice should be avoided as the proportion of the larger hydrogen concentration in the whole flammable domain is prone to more accidental severe consequences such as overpressure.
Combustion Regimes of Hydrogen-air-steam Mixtures
Sep 2021
Publication
In the case of a severe nuclear power plant accident hydrogen gas formation may occur from the core degradation and cooling water evaporation and subsequent oxidation of zircaloy. These phenomena increase the risk of hazardous combustion events in the reactor especially when combined with an ignition source. If not handled carefully these types of accidents can cause severe damage to the reactor building with potential radioactive effects on the environment. Although hydrogen-air combustion has been investigated before hydrogen-air-steam mixtures remain unstudied under reactor-like conditions. Thus this study investigated such mixtures’ combustion regimes. A closed tube of 318 liters (7.65m tall and 0.23m inner diameter) measures the flame speed flame propagation and shock wave behaviors for 11-15 %vol hydrogen mixtures combined with 0 20 or 30 %vol steam and air. Thus both the effect of steam and hydrogen content was investigated and compared. The experimental setup combined photomultiplier tubes pressure sensors and shock detectors to give a full view of the different combustion regimes. A number of obstacles changed the in-chamber turbulence during flame propagation to provide further reactor-like environments. This changed turbulence affected the combustion regimes and enhanced the flame speed for some cases. The results showed varying combustion behaviors depending on the water vapor concentration where a higher concentration meant a lower flame speed reduced pressure load and sometimes combustion extinction. At 0 %vol steam dilution the flame speed remained supersonic for all H2 concentrations while at 30 %vol steam dilution the flame speed remained subsonic for all H2 concentrations. Thus with high levels of steam dilution the risk for shock waves leading to potential reactor building destruction decreases."
Condensed Phase Explosions Involving Liquid Hydrogen
Sep 2021
Publication
Liquid hydrogen may have an important role in the storage and transportation of hydrogen energy. It may also provide the best option for some users of hydrogen energy notably the aviation sector. In the 1960’s liquid hydrogen spillages in open uncongested conditions sometimes produced violent condensed phase explosions as well as the familiar gas phase flash and sustained pool fire. Testing showed that burning mixtures of LH2 and solid oxygen/nitrogen readily transitioned to detonation for oxygen concentrations in the solid phase at or above 50%. Such explosive events have been observed in more recent research work on LH2 spillage and the pressure effects could be significant in some accident scenarios. There is a need to understand how solids are produced following spillage and what factors determine the level of oxygen enrichment. This paper describes the physical processes involved in the accumulation of solids during a horizontal discharge at ground level based on observations made in a recent HSE test that led to a condensed phase explosion. Areas where solids accumulated but remained in intimate contact with LH2 are identified. The paper also includes a thermodynamic and fluid mechanical analysis of the condensation process that includes the calculation of densities of mixtures of LH2 and air in different proportions. When the difference in flow speed between air and underlying LH2 is low a stable condensation layer can develop above the liquid where the temperature is just under the initial condensation point of air allowing sustained oxygen enrichment of condensate.
Using Multicriteria Decision Making to Evaluate the Risk of Hydrogen Energy Storage and Transportation in Cities
Jan 2023
Publication
Hydrogen is an environmentally friendly source of renewable energy. Energy generation from hydrogen has not yet been widely commercialized due to issues related to risk management in its storage and transportation. In this paper the authors propose a hybrid multiple-criteria decision-making (MCDM)-based method to manage the risks involved in the storage and transportation of hydrogen (RSTH). First we identified the key points of the RSTH by examining the relevant literature and soliciting the opinions of experts and used this to build a prototype of its decision structure. Second we developed a hybrid MCDM approach called the D-ANP that combined the decision-making trial and evaluation laboratory (DEMENTEL) with the analytic network process (ANP) to obtain the weight of each point of risk. Third we used fuzzy evaluation to assess the level of the RSTH for Beijing China where energy generation using hydrogen is rapidly advancing. The results showed that the skills of the personnel constituted the most important risk-related factor and environmental volatility and the effectiveness of feedback were root factors. These three factors had an important impact on other factors influencing the risk of energy generation from hydrogen. Training and technical assistance can be used to mitigate the risks arising due to differences in the skills of personnel. An appropriate logistics network and segmented transportation for energy derived from hydrogen should be implemented to reduce environmental volatility and integrated supply chain management can help make the relevant feedback more effective.
Numerical Modeling of a Moderate Hydrogen Leakage in a Typical Two-vented Fuel Cell Configuration
Sep 2021
Publication
Numerical results are presented from two direct numerical simulations (DNS) where a moderate hydrogen leakage is modeled in a typical two-vented fuel cell configuration. The study mimics one of the experimental investigations carried out on the 1 m3 enclosure with a leak flow rate of 10.4 Nl.min−1 [1]. The injection dimensionless Richardson number is at the order of unity and thus characterizes a plume flow which becomes turbulent due to gravitational accelerations. Two large exterior regions are added to the computational domain to model correctly the exchange between the in/out flows at both vents and the outer environment. Two meshes are used in this study; a first consisting of 250 million cells while the second has 2 billion cells to ensure the fine DNS resolution at the level of Kolmogorov and Batchelor length scales. The high performance computation (HPC) platform TRUST is employed where the computational domain is distributed up to 5.104 central processing unit (CPU) cores. A detailed description of the flow structure and the hydrogen dispersion is provided where the sharp effect of the cross-flow on the plume is analyzed. Comparisons versus the experimental measurements show a very good agreement where both the bi-layer Linden regime and the maximal concentration in the top homogeneous layer are correctly reproduced by the DNS. This result is extremely important and breaks the limitations shown previously with statistical RANS approaches and LES models. This study can be considered as a good candidate for any further improvements of the theoretical industrial plume models in general and for the estimation of the non-constant entrainment coefficient in particular.
Chemical Inhibition of Premixed Hydrogen-air Flames: Experimental Investigation using a 20-litre Vessel
Sep 2021
Publication
Throughout the history of the mining petroleum process and nuclear industries continuous efforts have been made to develop and improve measures to prevent and mitigate accidental explosions. Over the coming decades energy systems are expected to undergo a transition towards sustainable use of conventional hydrocarbons and an increasing share of renewable energy sources in the global energy mix. The variable and intermittent supply of energy from solar and wind points to energy systems based on hydrogen or hydrogen-based fuels as the primary energy carriers. However the safety-related properties of hydrogen imply that it is not straightforward to achieve and document the same level of safety for hydrogen systems compared to similar systems based on established fuels such as petrol diesel and natural gas. Compared to the conventional fuels hydrogen-air mixtures have lower ignition energy higher combustion reactivity and a propensity to undergo deflagration-to-detonation-transition (DDT) under certain conditions. To achieve an acceptable level of safety it is essential to develop effective measures for mitigating the consequences of hydrogen explosions in systems with certain degree of congestion and confinement. Extensive research over the last decade have demonstrated that chemical inhibition or partial suppression can be used for mitigating the consequences of vapour cloud explosions (VCEs) in congested process plants. Total and cooperation partners have demonstrated that solid flame inhibitors injected into flammable hydrocarbon-air clouds represent an effective means of mitigating the consequences of VCEs involving hydrocarbons. For hydrogen-air explosions these same chemicals inhibitors have not proved effective. It is however well-known that hydrocarbons can affect the burning velocity of hydrogen-air mixtures greatly. This paper gives an overview over previous work on chemical inhibitors. In addition experiments in a 20-litre vessel have been performed to investigate the effect of combinations of hydrocarbons and alkali salts on hydrogen/air mixtures.
Hydrogen Safety Prediction and Analysis of Hydrogen Refueling Station Leakage Accidents and Process Using Multi-Relevance Machine Learning
Oct 2021
Publication
Hydrogen energy vehicles are being increasingly widely used. To ensure the safety of hydrogenation stations research into the detection of hydrogen leaks is required. Offline analysis using data machine learning is achieved using Spark SQL and Spark MLlib technology. In this study to determine the safety status of a hydrogen refueling station we used multiple algorithm models to perform calculation and analysis: a multi-source data association prediction algorithm a random gradient descent algorithm a deep neural network optimization algorithm and other algorithm models. We successfully analyzed the data including the potential relationships internal relationships and operation laws between the data to detect the safety statuses of hydrogen refueling stations.
Analysis to Support Revised Distances between Bulk Liquid Hydrogen Systems and Exposures
Sep 2021
Publication
The minimum distances between exposures and bulk liquid hydrogen listed in the National Fire Protection Agency’s Hydrogen Technology Code NFPA 2 are based on historical consensus without a documented scientific analysis. This work follows a similar analysis as the scientific justification provided in NFPA 2 for exposure distances from bulk gaseous hydrogen storage systems but for liquid hydrogen. Validated physical models from Sandia’s HyRAM software are used to calculate distances to a flammable concentration for an unignited release the distance to critical heat flux values and the visible flame length for an ignited release and the overpressure that would occur for a delayed ignition of a liquid hydrogen leak. Revised exposure distances for bulk liquid hydrogen systems are calculated. These distances are related to the maximum allowable working pressure of the tank and the line size as compared to the current exposure distances which are based on system volume. For most systems the exposure distances calculated are smaller than the current distances for Group 1 they are similar for Group 2 while they increase for some Group 3 exposures. These distances could enable smaller footprints for infrastructure that includes bulk liquid hydrogen storage tanks especially when using firewalls to mitigate Group 3 hazards and exposure distances. This analysis is being refined as additional information on leak frequencies is incorporated and changes have been proposed to the 2023 edition of NFPA 2.
Hydrogen Component Leak Rate Quantification for System Risk and Reliability Assessment through QRA and PHM Frameworks
Sep 2021
Publication
The National Renewable Energy Laboratory’s (NREL) Hydrogen Safety Research and Development (HSR&D) program in collaboration with the University of Maryland’s Systems Risk and Reliability Analysis Laboratory (SyRRA) are working to improve reliability and reduce risk in hydrogen systems. This approach strives to use quantitative data on component leaks and failures together with Prognosis and Health Management (PHM) and Quantitative Risk Assessment (QRA) to identify atrisk components reduce component failures and downtime and predict when components require maintenance. Hydrogen component failures increase facility maintenance cost facility downtime and reduce public acceptance of hydrogen technologies ultimately increasing facility size and cost because of conservative design requirements. Leaks are a predominant failure mode for hydrogen components. However uncertainties in the amount of hydrogen emitted from leaking components and the frequency of those failure events limit the understanding of the risks that they present under real-world operational conditions. NREL has deployed a test fixture the Leak Rate Quantification Apparatus (LRQA) to quantify the mass flow rate of leaking gases from medium and high-pressure components that have failed while in service. Quantitative hydrogen leak rate data from this system could ultimately be used to better inform risk assessment and Regulation Codes and Standards (RCS). Parallel activity explores the use of PHM and QRA techniques to assess and reduce risk thereby improving safety and reliability of hydrogen systems. The results of QRAs could further provide a systematic and science-based foundation for the design and implementation of RCS as in the latest versions of the NFPA 2 code for gaseous hydrogen stations. Alternatively data-driven techniques of PHM could provide new damage diagnosis and health-state prognosis tools. This research will help end users station owners and operators and regulatory bodies move towards risk-informed preventative maintenance versus emergency corrective maintenance reducing cost and improving reliability. Predictive modelling of failures could improve safety and affect RCS requirements such as setback distances at liquid hydrogen fueling sites. The combination of leak rate quantification research PHM and QRA can lead to better informed models enabling data-based decision to be made for hydrogen system safety improvements.
Full-scale Tunnel Experiments for Fuel Cell Hydrogen Vehicles: Jat Fire and Explosions
Sep 2021
Publication
In the framework of the HYTUNNEL-CS European project sponsored by FCH-JU a set of preliminary tests were conducted in a real tunnel in France. These tests are devoted to safety of hydrogen-fueled vehicles having a compressed gas storage and Temperature Pressure Release Device (TPRD). The goal of the study is to develop recommendations for Regulations Codes and Standards (RCS) for inherently safer use of hydrogen vehicles in enclosed transportation systems. Two scenarios were investigated (a) jet fire evolution following the activation of TPRD due to conventional fuel car fire and (b) explosion of compressed hydrogen tank. The obtained experimental data are systematically compared to existing engineering correlations. The results will be used for benchmarking studies using CFD codes. The hydrogen pressure range in these preliminary tests has been lowered down to 20MPa in order to verify the capability of various large-scale measurement techniques before scaling up to 70 MPa the subject of the second experimental campaign.
Fuel-scale Tunnel Experiments for Fuel Cell Hydrogen Vehicles: Gas Dispersion
Sep 2021
Publication
In the framework of the HYTUNNEL-CS European project sponsored by FCH-JU a set of preliminary tests were conducted in a real tunnel in France. These tests are devoted to safety of hydrogen-fueled vehicles having a compressed gas storage and Temperature Pressure Release Device (TPRD). The goal of the study is to develop recommendations for Regulations Codes and Standards (RCS) for inherently safer use of hydrogen vehicles in enclosed transportation systems. In these preliminary tests the helium gas has been employed instead of hydrogen. Upward and downward gas releases following by TPRD activation has been considered. The experimental data describing local behavior (close to jet or below the chassis) as well as global behavior at the tunnel scale are obtained. These experimental data are systematically compared to existing engineering correlations. The results will be used for benchmarking studies using CFD codes. The hydrogen pressure range in these preliminary tests has been lowered down to 20MPa in order to verify the capability of various large-scale measurement techniques before scaling up to 70MPa the subject of the second campaign.
Safety and Other Considerations in the Development of a Hydrogen Fueling Protocol for Heavy-duty Vehicles
Sep 2021
Publication
Several manufacturers are developing heavy duty (HD) hydrogen stations and vehicles as zeroemissions alternatives to diesel and gasoline. In order to meet customer demands the new technology must be comparable to conventional approaches including safety reliability fueling times and final fill levels. For a large HD vehicle with a storage rated to 70 MPa nominal working pressure the goal to meet liquid fuel parity means providing 100 kg of hydrogen in 10 minutes. This paper summarizes the results to date of the PRHYDE project efforts to define the concepts of HD fueling which thereby lays the groundwork for the development of the safe and effective approach to filling these large vehicles. The project starts by evaluating the impact of several different assumptions such as the availability of static vehicle data (e.g. vehicle tank type and volume) and station data (e.g. expected station precooling capability) but also considers using real time dynamic data (e.g. vehicle tank gas temperature and pressure station gas temperature etc.) for optimisation to achieve safety and efficiency improvements. With this information the vehicle or station can develop multiple maps of fill time versus the hydrogen delivery temperature which are used to determine the speed of fueling. This will also allow the station or vehicle to adjust the rate of fueling as the station pre-cooling levels and other conditions change. The project also examines different steps for future protocol development such as communication of data between the vehicle and station and if the vehicle or station is controlling the fueling.
H-Mat Hydrogen Compatibility of NBR Elastomers
Sep 2021
Publication
The H2@Scale program of the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) Hydrogen and Fuel Cell Technologies Office (HFTO) is supporting work on the hydrogen compatibility of polymers to improve the durability and reliability of materials for hydrogen infrastructure. The hydrogen compatibility program (H-Mat) seeks “to address the challenges of hydrogen degradation by elucidating the mechanisms of hydrogen-materials interactions with the goal of providing science-based strategies to design materials (micro)structures and morphology with improved resistance to hydrogen degradation.” Previous work on ethylene propylene diene indicated hydrogen interaction with plasticizer increased its migration to the surface and coalescing within the elastomer compound. New research on nitrile butadiene (NBR) has found hydrogen and pressure interactions with a series model rubber-material compounds to behave similarly in some compounds and improved in other compounds that is demonstrated through volume change and compression-set differences in the materials. Further studies were conducted using a helium-ion microscope (HeIM) which revealed significant morphological changes in the plasticizer-incorporating compounds after static exposure and pressure cycling as evidenced by time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry. Additional studies using x-ray chromatography revealed that more micro-voids/-cracks developed after gas decompression in unfilled materials than in filled materials; transmission electron microscopy (TEM) probed at the nano-meter level showing change in filler distribution and morphology around Zinc-based particles.
Hydrogen Blowdown Release Experiments at Different Temperatures in the Discha-facility
Sep 2021
Publication
In this work experiments on horizontal hydrogen jet releases from a 2.815 dm³ volume tank to the ambience are described. For the main experimental series tank valve and release line were cooled down to a temperature of approx. 80 K in a bath of liquid nitrogen. As a reference similar experiments were also performed with the uncooled tank at ambient temperature. The releases were carried out through four nozzles with different circular orifice diameters from 0.5 to 4 mm and started from initial tank pressures from 0.5 to 20 MPa (rel.). During the releases pressures and temperatures inside the vessel as well as inside the release line were measured. Outside the nozzle further temperature and hydrogen concentration measurements were performed along and besides the jet axis. The electrostatic field builtup in the jet was monitored using two field meters in different distances from the release nozzle and optical observation via photo and video-cameras was performed for the visualization of the H2-jet via the BOS-method. The experiments were performed in the frame of the EU-funded project PRESHLY in which several tests of this program were selected for a comparative computational study the results of which will also be presented at this conference. So on the one hand the paper gives a comprehensive description of the facility on the other hands it also describes the experimental procedure and the main findings.
Heat Transfer Models for Refueling Safety of Hydrogen Vehicle
Sep 2021
Publication
Due to the simple structure and quick refueling process of the compressed hydrogen storage tank it is widely used in fuel cell vehicles at present. However temperature rise may lead to a safety problem during charging of a compressed hydrogen storage tank. To ensure the refueling safety the thermal effects need to be studied carefully during hydrogen refueling process. In this paper based on the mass and energy balance equations a general heat transfer model for refueling process of compressed hydrogen storage tank is established. According to the geometric model of the tank wall structure we have built three lumped parameter models: single-zone (hydrogen) dual-zone (hydrogen and tank wall) and triple-zone (hydrogen tank wall liner and shell) model. These three lumped parameter models are compared with U.S. Naval gas charging model and SAE MC method based refueling model. Under adiabatic and diathermic conditions four models are built in Matlab/Simulink software to simulate the hydrogen refueling process under corresponding conditions. These four models are: single-zone singletemperature (hydrogen) dual-zone single-temperature (hydrogen) dual-zone dual-temperature (hydrogen and tank wall temperatures) and triple-zone triple-temperature (hydrogen tank wall liner and tank wall shell temperatures). By comparing the analytical solution and numerical solution the temperature rise of the compressed hydrogen storage tank can be described. The analytical and numerical solutions on the heat transfer during hydrogen refueling process will provide theoretical guidance at actual refueling station so as to improve the refueling efficiency and to enhance the refueling safety.
Safe Ventilation Methods against Leaks in Hydrogen Fuel Cell Rooms in Homes
Jul 2022
Publication
Hydrogen which has a high energy density and does not emit pollutants is considered an alternative energy source to replace fossil fuels. Herein we report an experimental study on hydrogen leaks and ventilation methods for preventing damage caused by leaks from hydrogen fuel cell rooms in homes among various uses of hydrogen. This experiment was conducted in a temporary space with a volume of 11.484 m3 . The supplied pressure leak-hole size and leakage amount were adjusted as the experimental conditions. The resulting hydrogen concentrations which changed according to the operation of the ventilation openings ventilation fan and supplied shutoff valve were measured. The experimental results showed that the reductions in the hydrogen concentration due to the shutoff valve were the most significant. The maximum hydrogen concentration could be reduced by 80% or more if it is 100 times that of the leakage volume or higher. The shutoff valve ventilation fan and ventilation openings were required to reduce the concentrations of the fuel cell room hydrogen in a spatially uniform manner. Although the hydrogen concentration in a small hydrogen fuel cell room for home use can rapidly increase a rapid reduction in the concentration of hydrogen with an appropriate ventilation system has been experimentally proven.
Gas Turbine Enclosures: Determining Ventilation Safety Criteria using Hydrogen Explosion Modelling
Sep 2021
Publication
Dilution ventilation is the current basis of safety following a flammable gas leak within a gas turbine enclosure and compliance requirements are defined for methane fuels in ISO 21789. These requirements currently define a safety criteria of a maximum flammable gas cloud size within an enclosure. The requirements are based on methane explosion tests conducted during a HSE Joint Industry Project which identified typical pressures associated with a range of gas cloud sizes. The industry standard approach is to assess the ventilation performance of specific enclosure designs against these requirements using CFD modelling. Gas turbine manufacturers are increasingly considering introducing hydrogen/methane fuel mixtures and looking towards operating with hydrogen alone. It is therefore important to review the applicability of current safety standards for these new fuels as the pressure resulting from a hydrogen explosion is expected to be significantly higher than that from a methane explosion. In this paper we replicate the previous methane explosion tests for hydrogen and hydrogen/methane fuel mixtures using the explosion modelling tool FLACS CFD. The results are used to propose updated limiting safety criteria for hydrogen fuels to support ventilation CFD analysis for specific enclosure designs. It is found that significantly smaller gas cloud sizes are likely to be acceptable for gas turbines fueled by hydrogen however significantly more hydrogen than methane is required per unit volume to generate a stoichiometric cloud (as hydrogen has a lower stoichiometric air fuel ratio than methane). This effect results in the total quantity of gas in the enclosure (and as such detectability of the gas) being broadly similar when operating gas turbines on hydrogen when compared to methane.
Annealing Effects on SnO2 Thin Film for H2 Gas Sensing
Sep 2022
Publication
Hydrogen (H2 ) is attracting attention as a renewable energy source in various fields. However H2 has a potential danger that it can easily cause a backfire or explosion owing to minor external factors. Therefore H2 gas monitoring is significant particularly near the lower explosive limit. Herein tin dioxide (SnO2 ) thin films were annealed at different times. The as-obtained thin films were used as sensing materials for H2 gas. Here the performance of the SnO2 thin film sensor was studied to understand the effect of annealing and operating temperature conditions of gas sensors to further improve their performance. The gas sensing properties exhibited by the 3-h annealed SnO2 thin film showed the highest response compared to the unannealed SnO2 thin film by approximately 1.5 times. The as-deposited SnO2 thin film showed a high response and fast response time to 5% H2 gas at 300 ◦C of 257.34% and 3 s respectively.
Assessing Damaged Pipelines Transporting Hydrogen
Jun 2022
Publication
There is worldwide interest in transporting hydrogen using both new pipelines and pipelines converted from natural gas service. Laboratory tests investigating the effect of hydrogen on the mechanical properties of pipeline steels have shown that even low partial pressures of hydrogen can substantially reduce properties such as reduction in area and fracture toughness and increase fatigue crack growth rates. However qualitative arguments suggest that the effects on pipelines may not be as severe as predicted from the small scale tests. If the trends seen in laboratory tests do occur in service there are implications for the assessment of damage such as volumetric corrosion dents and mechanical interference. Most pipeline damage assessment methods are semi-empirical and have been calibrated with data from full scale tests that did not involve hydrogen. Hence the European Pipeline Research Group (EPRG) commissioned a study to investigate damage assessment methods in the presence of hydrogen. Two example pipeline designs were considered both were assessed assuming a modern high performance material and an older material. From these analyses the numerical results show that the high toughness material will tolerate damage even if the properties are degraded by hydrogen exposure. However low toughness materials may not be able to tolerate some types of severe damage. If the predictions are realistic operators may have to repair more damage or reduce operating pressures. Furthermore damage involving cracking may not Page 2 of 22 satisfy the ASME B31.12 requirements for preventing time dependent crack growth. Further work is required to determine if the effects predicted using small scale laboratory test data will occur in practice.
CFD Simulations of the Refueling of Long Horizontal H2 Tanks
Sep 2021
Publication
The understanding of physical phenomena occurring during the refueling of H2 tanks used for hydrogen mobility applications is the key point towards the most optimal refueling protocol. A lot of experimental investigations on tank refueling were performed in the previous years for different types and sizes of tank. Several operating conditions were tested through these experiments. For instance the HyTransfer project gave one of the major outputs on the understanding of the physical phenomena occurring during a tank refueling. From a numerical perspective the availability of accurate numerical tools is another key point. Such tools could be used instead of the experimental set-ups to test various operating conditions or new designs of tanks and injectors. The use of these tools can reduce the cost of the refueling protocol development in the future. However they first need to be validated versus experimental data. This work is dedicated to CFD (Computational Fluid Dynamics) modeling of the hydrogen refueling of a long horizontal 530L type IV tank. As of now the number of available CFD simulations for such a large tank is low as the computational cost is significant which is often considered as a bottleneck for this approach. The simulated operating conditions correspond to one of the experimental campaigns performed in the framework of the HyTransfer project. The 3D CFD model is presented. In a first validation step the CFD results are compared with experimental data. Then a deeper insight into the physics predicted by the CFD is provided. Finally two other methodologies with the aim to reduce the computational cost have been tested.
On Board 70 MPA Hydrogen Composite Pressure Vessel Safety Factor
Sep 2021
Publication
The safety factor of a composite structure in relation to its mechanical rupture is an important criterion for the safety of a 70 MPa composite pressure vessel for hydrogen storage particularly for on-board applications (car bus truck train…). After an introduction of Type IV technology the contribution of carbon fibre composite material structure manufacturing process of pressure vessels and environmental effects on the safety factor are commented. Thanks to an experimental-based evaluation on composite material and H2 composite pressure vessel the safety margins are addressed.
Hy4Heat Annex To Site Specific Safety Case for Hydrogen Community Demonstration - Work Package 7
May 2021
Publication
The Hy4Heat Safety Assessment has focused on assessing the safe use of hydrogen gas in certain types of domestic properties and buildings. The summary reports (the Precis and the Safety Assessment Conclusions Report) bring together all the findings of the work and should be looked to for context by all readers. The technical reports should be read in conjunction with the summary reports. While the summary reports are made as accessible as possible for general readers the technical reports may be most accessible for readers with a degree of technical subject matter understanding. All of the safety assessment reports have now been reviewed by the HSE<br/>Annex prepared to support Site Specific Safety Cases for hydrogen gas community demonstrations based on work undertaken by the Hy4Heat programme. It covers a collection of recommended risk reduction measures for application downstream of the Emergency Control Valve (ECV)
Review of the Durability of Polymer Electrolyte Membrane Fuel Cell in Long-Term Operation: Main Influencing Parameters and Testing Protocols
Jul 2021
Publication
Durability is the most pressing issue preventing the efficient commercialization of polymer electrolyte membrane fuel cell (PEMFC) stationary and transportation applications. A big barrier to overcoming the durability limitations is gaining a better understanding of failure modes for user profiles. In addition durability test protocols for determining the lifetime of PEMFCs are important factors in the development of the technology. These methods are designed to gather enough data about the cell/stack to understand its efficiency and durability without causing it to fail. They also provide some indication of the cell/stack’s age in terms of changes in performance over time. Based on a study of the literature the fundamental factors influencing PEMFC long-term durability and the durability test protocols for both PEMFC stationary and transportation applications were discussed and outlined in depth in this review. This brief analysis should provide engineers and researchers with a fast overview as well as a useful toolbox for investigating PEMFC durability issues.
Improved Monitoring and Diagnosis of Transformer Solid Insulation Using Pertinent Chemical Indicators
Jul 2021
Publication
Transformers are generally considered to be the costliest assets in a power network. The lifetime of a transformer is mainly attributable to the condition of its solid insulation which in turn is measured and described according to the degree of polymerization (DP) of the cellulose. Since the determination of the DP index is complex and time-consuming and requires the transformer to be taken out of service utilities prefer indirect and non-invasive methods of determining the DP based on the byproduct of cellulose aging. This paper analyzes solid insulation degradation by measuring the furan concentration recently introduced methanol and dissolved gases like carbon oxides and hydrogen in the insulating oil. A group of service-aged distribution transformers were selected for practical investigation based on oil samples and different kinds of tests. Based on the maintenance and planning strategy of the power utility and a weighted combination of measured chemical indicators a neural network was also developed to categorize the state of the transformer in certain classes. The method proved to be able to improve the diagnostic capability of chemical indicators thus providing power utilities with more reliable maintenance tools and avoiding catastrophic failure of transformers.
Risk Assessment Method Combining Independent Protection Layers (IPL) of Layer of Protection Analysis (LOPA) and RISKCURVES Software: Case Study of Hydrogen Refueling Stations in Urban Areas
Jul 2021
Publication
The commercialization of eco-friendly hydrogen vehicles has elicited attempts to expand hydrogen refueling stations in urban areas; however safety measures to reduce the risk of jet fires have not been established. The RISKCURVES software was used to evaluate the individual and societal risks of hydrogen refueling stations in urban areas and the F–N (Frequency–Number of fatalities) curve was used to compare whether the safety measures satisfied international standards. From the results of the analysis it was found that there is a risk of explosion in the expansion of hydrogen refueling stations in urban areas and safety measures should be considered. To lower the risk of hydrogen refueling stations this study applied the passive and active independent protection layers (IPLs) of LOPA (Layer of Protection Analysis) and confirmed that these measures significantly reduced societal risk as well as individual risk and met international standards. In particular such measures could effectively reduce the impact of jet fire in dispensers and tube trailers that had a high risk. Measures employing both IPL types were efficient in meeting international standard criteria; however passive IPLs were found to have a greater risk reduction effect than active IPLs. The combination of RISKCURVES and LOPA is an appropriate risk assessment method that can reduce work time and mitigate risks through protective measures compared to existing risk assessment methods. This method can be applied to risk assessment and risk mitigation not only for hydrogen facilities but also for hazardous materials with high fire or explosion risk.
Results of the Pre-normative Research Project PRESLHY for the Safe Use of Liquid Hydrogen
Sep 2021
Publication
Liquid hydrogen (LH2) compared to compressed gaseous hydrogen offers advantages for large-scale transport and storage of hydrogen with higher densities. Although the gas industry has good experience with LH2 only little experience is available for the new applications of LH2 as an energy carrier. Therefore the European FCH JU funded project PRESLHY conducted pre-normative research for the safe use of cryogenic LH2 in non-industrial settings. The central research consisted of a broad experimental program combined with analytical work modelling and simulations belonging to the three key phenomena of the accident chain: release and mixing ignition and combustion. The presented results improve the general understanding of the behavior of LH2 in accidents and provide some design guidelines and engineering tools for safer use of LH2. Recommendations for improvement of current international standards are derived.
Hy4Heat Safety Assessment: Precis - Work Package 7
May 2021
Publication
The Hy4Heat Safety Assessment has focused on assessing the safe use of hydrogen gas in certain types of domestic properties and buildings. The summary reports (the Precis and the Safety Assessment Conclusions Report) bring together all the findings of the work and should be looked to for context by all readers. The technical reports should be read in conjunction with the summary reports. While the summary reports are made as accessible as possible for general readers the technical reports may be most accessible for readers with a degree of technical subject matter understanding. All of the safety assessment reports have now been reviewed by the HSE.<br/><br/>This document is an overview of the Safety Assessment work undertaken as part of the Hy4Heat programme
No more items...