Safety
Feasibility of Hydrogen Detection by the Use of Uncoated Silicon Microcantilever-based Sensors
Sep 2013
Publication
Hydrogen is a key parameter to monitor radioactive disposal facility such as the envisioned French geological repository for nuclear wastes. The use of microcantilevers as chemical sensors usually involves a sensitive layer whose purpose is to selectively sorb the analyte of interest. The sorbed substance can then be detected by monitoring either the resonant frequency shift (dynamic mode) or the quasi-static deflection (static mode). The objective of this paper is to demonstrate the feasibility of eliminating the need for the sensitive layer in the dynamic mode thereby increasing the long-term reliability. The microcantilever resonant frequency allows probing the mechanical properties (mass density and viscosity) of the surrounding fluid and thus to determine the concentration of a species in a binary gaseous. Promising preliminary work has allowed detecting concentration of 200 ppm of hydrogen in air with non-optimized geometry of silicon microcantilever with integrated actuation and read-out.
Impact Assessments on People and Buildings for Hydrogen Pipeline Explosions
Sep 2019
Publication
Hydrogen has the potential to act as the energy carrier of the future. It will be then produced in large amounts and will certainly need to be transported for long distances. The safest way to transport hydrogen is through pipelines. Failure of pipelines carrying gaseous hydrogen can have several effects some of which can pose a significant threat of damage to people and buildings in the immediate proximity of the failure location. This paper presents a probabilistic risk assessment procedure for the estimation of damage to people and buildings endangered by high-pressure hydrogen pipeline explosions. The procedure provides evaluation of annual probability of damage to people and buildings under an extreme event as a combination of the conditional probability of damage triggered by an explosion and the probability of occurrence of the explosion as a consequence of the pipeline failure. Physical features such as the gas jet release process flammable cloud size blast generation and explosion effects on people and buildings are considered and evaluated through the SLAB integral model TNO model Probit equations and Pressure-Impulse diagrams. For people both direct and indirect effects of overpressure events are considered. For buildings a comparison of the damage to different types of buildings (i.e. reinforced concrete buildings and tuff stone masonry buildings) is made. The probabilistic procedure presented may be used for designing a new hydrogen pipeline network and will be an advantageous tool for safety management of hydrogen gas pipelines.
Safety Issues of the Liquefaction, Storage and Transportation of Liquid Hydrogen
Sep 2013
Publication
The objectives of the IDEALHY project which receives funding from the European Union’s 7th Framework Programme (FP7/2007-2013) for the Fuel Cells and Hydrogen Joint Technology Initiative under grant agreement No. 278177 are to design a novel process that will significantly increase the efficiency of hydrogen liquefaction and be capable of delivering liquid hydrogen at a rate that is an order of magnitude greater than current plants. The liquid hydrogen could then be delivered to refueling stations in road tankers. As part of the project the safety management of the new large scale process and the transportation of liquid hydrogen by road tanker into urban areas are being considered. Effective safety management requires that the hazards are identified and well understood. This paper describes the scope of the safety work within IDEALHY and presents the output of the work completed so far. Initially a review of available experimental data on the hazards posed by releases of liquid hydrogen was undertaken which identified that generally there is a dearth of data relevant to liquid hydrogen releases. Subsequently HAZIDs have been completed for the new liquefaction process storage of liquid hydrogen and its transportation by road. This included a review of incidents relevant to these activities. The principal causes of the incidents have been analysed. Finally the remaining safety work for the IDEALHY project is outlined.
Detonation Wave Propagation in Semi-confined Layers of Hydrogen-air and Hydrogen-oxygen Mixtures
Oct 2015
Publication
This paper presents results of an experimental investigation on detonation wave propagation in semi-confined geometries. Large scale experiments were performed in layers up to 0.6 m filled with uniform and non-uniform hydrogen–air mixtures in a rectangular channel (width 3 m; length 9 m) which is open from below. A semi confined driver section is used to accelerate hydrogen flames from weak ignition to detonation. The detonation propagation was observed in a 7 m long unobstructed part of the channel. Pressure measurements ionization probes soot-records and high speed imaging were used to observe the detonation propagation. Critical conditions for detonation propagation in different layer thicknesses are presented for uniform H2/air-mixtures as well as experiments with uniform H2/O2 mixtures in a down scaled transparent channel. Finally detail investigations on the detonation wave propagation in H2/air-mixtures with concentration gradients are shown.
Boundary Layer Effects on the Critical Nozzle of Hydrogen Sonic Jet
Oct 2015
Publication
When hydrogen flows through a small finite length constant exit area nozzle the viscous effects create a fluid throat which acts as a converging-diverging nozzle and lead to Mach number greater than one at the exit if the jet is under-expanded. This phenomenon influences the mass flow rate and the dispersion cloud size. In this study the boundary layer effect on the unsteady hydrogen sonic jet flow through a 1 mm diameter pipe from a high pressure reservoir (up to 70 MPa) is studied using computational fluid dynamics with a large eddy simulation turbulence model. This viscous flow simulation is compared with a non-viscous simulation to demonstrate that the velocity is supersonic at the exit of a small exit nozzle and that the mass flow is reduced.
Experiments on Flame Acceleration and DDT for Stoichiometric Hydrogen/Air Mixture in a Thin Layer Geometry
Sep 2017
Publication
A series of experiments in a thin layer geometry performed at the HYKA test site of the KIT. The experiments on different combustion regimes for lean and stoichiometric H2/air mixtures were performed in a rectangular chamber with dimensions of 20 x 90 x h cm3 where h is the thickness of the layer (h = 1 2 4 6 8 10 mm). Three different layer geometries:
- a smooth channel without obstructions;
- the channel with a metal grid filled 25% of length and
- a metal grid filled 100% of length.
Development of a Model Evaluation Protocol for CFD Analysis of Hydrogen Safety Issues – The SUSANA Project
Oct 2015
Publication
The “SUpport to SAfety aNAlysis of Hydrogen and Fuel Cell Technologies (SUSANA)” project aims to support stakeholders using Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) for safety engineering design and assessment of FCH systems and infrastructure through the development of a model evaluation protocol. The protocol covers all aspects of safety assessment modelling using CFD from release through dispersion to combustion (self-ignition fires deflagrations detonations and Deflagration to Detonation Transition - DDT) and not only aims to enable users to evaluate models but to inform them of the state of the art and best practices in numerical modelling. The paper gives an overview of the SUSANA project including the main stages of the model evaluation protocol and some results from the on-going benchmarking activities.
Effects of Oxidants on Hydrogen Spontaneous Ignition: Experiments and Modelling
Sep 2017
Publication
Experiments were performed on the influence of oxidants (air pure oxygen O2 and pure nitrous oxide N2O at atmospheric pressure) in the straight expansion tube after the burst disk on the hydrogen spontaneous ignition. The lowest pressure at which the spontaneous ignition is observed has been researched for a 4 mm diameter tube with a length of 10 cm for the two oxidant gases. The ignition phenomenon is observed with a high speed camera and the external overpressures are measured. Numerical simulations have also been conducted with the high resolution CFD approach detailed chemistry formerly developed by Wen and co-workers. Comparison is made between the predictions and the experimental data.
Advancing the Hydrogen Safety Knowledge Base
Sep 2013
Publication
The International Energy Agency's Hydrogen Implementing Agreement (IEA HIA) was established in 1977 to pursue collaborative hydrogen research and development and information exchange among its member countries. Information and knowledge dissemination is a key aspect of the work within IEA HIA tasks and case studies technical reports and presentations/publications often result from the collaborative efforts. The work conducted in hydrogen safety under Task 31 and its predecessor Task 19 can positively impact the objectives of national programs even in cases for which a specific task report is not published. The interactions within Task 31 illustrate how technology information and knowledge exchange among participating hydrogen safety experts serve the objectives intended by the IEA HIA.
A Comparative CFD Assessment Study of Cryogenic Hydrogen and Liquid Natural Gas Dispersion
Sep 2017
Publication
The introduction of hydrogen to the commercial market as alternative fuel brings up safety concerns. Its storage in liquid or cryo-compressed state to achieve volumetric efficiency involves additional risks and their study is crucial. This work aims to investigate the behaviour of cryogenic hydrogen release and to study factors that affect the vapor dispersion. We focus on the effect of ambient humidity and air's components (nitrogen and oxygen) freezing in order to identify the conditions under which these factors have considerable influence. The study reveals that the level of influence depends highly on the release conditions and that humidity can reduce conspicuously the longitudinal distance of the Lower Flammability Limit (LFL). Low Froude (Fr) number (<1000) at the release allows the generated by the humidity phase change buoyancy to affect the dispersion while for higher Fr number - that usually are met in cryo-compressed releases - the momentum forces are the dominant forces and the buoyancy effect is trivial. Simulations with liquid methane release have been also performed and compared to the liquid hydrogen simulations in order to detect the differences in the behaviour of the two fuels as far as the humidity effect is concerned. It is shown that in methane spills the buoyancy effect in presence of humidity is smaller than in hydrogen spills and it can be considered almost negligible.
Risk Assessment on Life Safety and Financial Loss for Road Accident of Fuel Cell Vehicles
Sep 2017
Publication
Vehicular use of hydrogen is the first attempt to apply hydrogen energy in consumers’ environment in large scale and has raised safety concerns in both public authorities and private bodies such as fire services and insurance companies. This paper analyzes typical accident progressions of hydrogen fuel cell vehicles in a road collision accident. Major hydrogen consequences including impinging jet fires and catastrophic tank ruptures are evaluated separately in terms of accident duration and hazard distances. Results show that in a 70 MPa fuel cell car accident the hazards associated with hydrogen releases would normally last for no more than 1.5 min due to the empty of the tank. For the safety of general public a perimeter of 100 m is suggested in the accident scene if no hissing sound is heard. However the perimeter can be reduced to 10 m once the hissing sound of hydrogen release is heard. Furthermore risks of fatalities injuries and damages are all quantified in financial terms to assess the impacts of the accident. Results show that costs of fatalities and injuries contribute most to the overall financial loss indicating that the insurance premium of fatalities and injuries should be set higher than that of property loss.
JRC Reference Data from Experiments of Onboard Hydrogen Tanks Fast Filling
Sep 2013
Publication
At the JRC-IET on-board hydrogen tanks have been subjected to filling–emptying cycles to investigate their long-term mechanical and thermal behaviour and their safety performance. The local temperature history inside the tanks has been measured and compared with the temperatures outside and at the tank metallic bosses which is the measurement location identified by some standards. The outcome of these activities is a set of experimental data which will be made publicly available as reference for safety studies and validation of computational fluid dynamics.
Safe Operation of Natural Gas Appliances Fuelled with Hydrogen & Natural Gas Mixtures (Progress Obtained in the Naturalhy-Project)
Sep 2007
Publication
Considering the transition towards the hydrogen economy dependent on hydrogen penetration scenario the cost of a new hydrogen pipeline infrastructure in Europe may amount to several thousands of billions of EURO’s. Therefore the examination of the potential contribution of the existing natural gas assets is a practical and logical first step. As the physical and chemical properties of hydrogen differ significantly from those of natural gas it is not at all possible to simply exchange natural gas by hydrogen in the existing infrastructure. In this paper first a brief overview will be given of the NATURALHY-project. Further the focus will be on the impact of added hydrogen on the performance of existing natural gas domestic end user appliances which is related to the operation of the natural gas grid connecting the different types of appliance. The application of the fundamental insights and carefully designed experiments comparing the behaviour of gases using justified reference conditions have been shown to offer essential progress. The Wobbe index limits of the natural gas distributed pose a first limiting factor upon the maximum allowable hydrogen concentration. Constant-Wobbe index and decreasing-Wobbe index options of H2 admixture have been studied. Considering the appliance light back H2 limiting factor for domestic appliances fuel-rich appliances are the critical ones. Also taking into account stationary gas engines gas turbines industrial applications and natural gas grid management it is not yet justified to present statements on what level of hydrogen concentration could be safely allowed in which specific natural gas distribution region. But more clarity has been obtained on combustion safety aspects of existing domestic appliances on the connection with Wobbe distribution conditions and on the bottlenecks still to be handled.
Prevention of Hydrogen Accumulation Inside the Vacuum Vessel Pressure Suppression System of the ITER Facility by Means of Passive Auto-catalytic Recombiners
Sep 2017
Publication
Hydrogen safety is a relevant topic for both nuclear fission and fusion power plants. Hydrogen generated in the course of a severe accident may endanger the integrity of safety barriers and may result in radioactive releases. In the case of the ITER fusion facility accident scenarios with water ingress consider the release of hydrogen into the suppression tank (ST) of the vacuum vessel pressure suppression system (VVPSS). Under the assumption of additional air ingress the formation of flammable gas mixtures may lead to explosions and safety component failure.<br/>The installation of passive auto-catalytic recombiners (PARs) inside the ST which are presently used as safety devices inside the containments of nuclear fission reactors is one option under consideration to mitigate such a scenario. PARs convert hydrogen into water vapor by means of passive mechanisms and have been qualified for operation under the conditions of a nuclear power plant accident since the 1990s.<br/>In order to support on-going hydrogen safety considerations simulations of accident scenarios using the CFD code ANSYS-CFX are foreseen. In this context the in-house code REKO-DIREKT is coupled to CFX to simulate PAR operation. However the operational boundary conditions for hydrogen recombination (e.g. temperature pressure gas mixture) of a fusion reactor scenario differ significantly from those of a fission reactor. In order to enhance the code towards realistic PAR operation a series of experiments has been performed in the REKO-4 facility with specific focus on ITER conditions. These specifically include operation under sub-atmospheric pressure (0.2–1.0 bar) gas compositions ranging from lean to rich H2/O2 mixtures and superposed flow conditions.<br/>The paper gives an overview of the experimental program presents results achieved and gives an outlook on the modelling approach towards accident scenario simulation.
European Hydrogen Safety Training Programme for First Responders: Hyresponse Outcomes and Perspectives
Sep 2017
Publication
The paper presents the outcomes of the HyResponse project i.e. the European Hydrogen Safety Training Programme for first responders. The threefold training is described: the content of the educational training is presented the operational training platform and its mock-up real scale transport and hydrogen stationary installations are detailed and the innovative virtual tools and training exercises are highlighted. The paper underlines the outcomes the three pilot sessions as well as the Emergency Response Guide available on the HyResponse’s public website. The next steps for widespread dissemination into the community are discussed.
The Pressure Peaking Phenomenon: Validation for Unignited Releases in Laboratory-scale Enclosure
Oct 2015
Publication
This study is aimed at the validation of the pressure peaking phenomenon against laboratory-scale experiments. The phenomenon was discovered recently as a result of analytical and numerical studies performed at Ulster University. The phenomenon is characterized by the existence of a peak on the overpressure transient in an enclosure with vent(s) at some conditions. The peak overpressure can significantly exceed the steady-state pressure and jeopardise a civil structure integrity causing serious life safety and property protection problems. However the experimental validation of the phenomenon was absent until recently. The validation experiments were performed at Karlsruhe Institute of Technology within the framework of the HyIndoor project. Tests were carried out with release of three different gases (air helium and hydrogen) within a laboratory-scale enclosure of about 1 m3 volume with a vent of comparatively small size. The model of pressure peaking phenomenon reproduced closely the experimental pressure dynamics within the enclosure for all three used gases. The prediction of pressure peaking phenomenon consists of two steps which are explained in detail. Examples of calculation for typical hydrogen applications are presented.
Dynamic Load Analysis of Explosion in Inhomogeneous Hydrogen-air Mixtures
Sep 2017
Publication
This paper presents results from experiments on gas explosions in inhomogeneous hydrogen-air mixtures. The experimental channel is 3 m with a cross section of 100 mm by 100 mm and a 0.25 mm ID nozzle for hydrogen release into the channel. The channel is open in one end. Spectral analysis of the pressure in the channel is used to determine dynamic load factors for SDOF structures. The explosion pressures in the channel will fluctuate with several frequencies or modes and a theoretical high DLF is seen when the pressure frequencies and eigen frequencies of the structure matches.
Development of a Generalized Integral Jet Model
Sep 2017
Publication
Integral type models to describe stationary plumes and jets in cross-flows (wind) have been developed since about 1970. These models are widely used for risk analysis to describe the consequences of many different scenarios. Alternatively CFD codes are being applied but computational requirements still limit the number of scenarios that can be dealt with using CFD only. The integral models however are not suited to handle transient releases such as releases from pressurized equipment where the initially high release rate decreases rapidly with time. Further on gas ignition a second model is needed to describe the rapid combustion of the flammable part of the plume (flash fire) and a third model has to be applied for the remaining jet fire. The objective of this paper is to describe the first steps of the development of an integral-type model describing the transient development and decay of a jet of flammable gas after a release from a pressure container. The intention is to transfer the stationary models to a fully transient model capable to predict the maximum extension of short-duration high pressure jets. The model development is supported by conducting a set of transient ignited and unignited spontaneous releases at initial pressures between 25bar and 400bar. These data forms the basis for the presented model development approach.
Hydrogen Risk Analysis for a Generic Nuclear Containment Ventilation System
Oct 2015
Publication
Hydrogen safety issue in a ventilation system of a generic nuclear containment is studied. In accidental scenarios a large amount of burnable gas mixture of hydrogen with certain amount of oxygen is released into the containment. In case of high containment pressure the combustible mixture is further ventilated into the chambers and the piping of the containment ventilation system. The burnable even potentially detonable gas mixture could pose a risk to the structures of the system once being ignited unexpectedly. Therefore the main goal of the study is to apply the computational fluid dynamics (CFD) computer code – GASFLOW to analyze the distribution of the hydrogen in the ventilation system and to find how sensitive the mixture is to detonation in different scenarios. The CFD simulations manifest that a ventilation fan with sustained power supply can extinguish the hydrogen risk effectively. However in case of station blackout with loss of power supply to the fan hydrogen/oxygen mixture could be accumulated in the ventilation system. A further study proves that steam injection could degrade the sensitivity of the hydrogen mixture significantly.
Effect of Expansion Ratio on Flame Acceleration During Hydrogen Fueled Gas Explosions
Sep 2019
Publication
A precise understanding of the flame turbulence induced by cellular instabilities is indispensable to perform an appropriate risk assessment of hydrogen fuelled gas explosion. In this research Darrieus Landau instability (DL instability) whose effect on gas explosion is remarkable was experimentally examined. The DL instability is essentially caused by a volumetric expansion of burned gas at flame front. Therefore in order to examine the effects of volumetric expansion ratio the experiments were conducted using H2-O2-N2-Ar gas mixtures of various volumetric expansion ratio conditions by changing N2-Ar ratio. When Ar content ratio is increased the flame temperature becomes higher and volumetric expansion ratio is increased owing to lower specific heat of Ar. The experiments were conducted in nearly unconfined conditions of laboratory-scale and large-scale. Gas mixtures were filled in a 10 cm diameter soap bubble for the laboratory-scale and in a plastic tent of thin vinyl sheet of 1m3 for the large-scale. The gas mixtures were ignited by an electric spark and blast wave and flame speed were measured simultaneously by using a pressure sensor and a high-speed video camera. The DL instability owing to volumetric expansion accelerates flame propagation. In addition the intensity of blast wave was greatly raised depending on flame acceleration which can be explained by an acoustic theory. The effects of expansion ratio and experimental scales on flame propagation and blast wave were analyzed in detail. These results are quite important to perform an appropriate consequence analysis of accidental explosion of hydrogen.
The Mitigation of Hydrogen Explosions Using Water Fog, Nitrogen Dilution and Chemical Additives
Sep 2013
Publication
This paper describes research work that has been performed at LSBU using both a laminar burning velocity rig and a small scale cylindrical explosion vessel to explore the use of very fine water fog nitrogen dilution and sodium hydroxide additives in the mitigation of hydrogen deflagrations. The results of the work suggest that using a combination of the three measures together produces the optimal mitigation performance and can be extremely effective in: inhibiting the burning velocity reducing the rate of explosion overpressure rise and narrowing the flammability limits of hydrogen-oxygen-nitrogen mixtures.
Delayed Explosion of Hydrogen High Pressure Jets in a Highly Obstructed Geometry
Sep 2017
Publication
Delayed explosions of accidental high pressure hydrogen releases are an important risk scenario in safety studies of production plants transportation pipelines and fuel cell vehicles charging stations. Such explosions were widely explored in multiple experimental and numerical investigations. Explosion of high pressure releases in highly obstructed geometries with high blockage ratio is a much more complicated phenomenon. This paper is dedicated to the experimental investigation of the influence of obstacles on a delayed deflagration of hydrogen jets. The computational fluid dynamics (CFD) code FLACS is used to reproduce experimental data. In the current study the computed overpressure signals are compared to the experimentally measured ones at different monitoring points. Simulations are in close agreement with experimental results and can be used to predict overpressure where experimental pressure detectors were saturated. For homogenous stationary clouds a new approach of equivalent mixture of H2/air (~16.5%) to stoichiometric mixture of CH4/air is suggested. This approach is validated versus experimental data from the literature in terms of overpressure maxima. A parametric study is performed using FLACS for various concentrations in the same geometry in order to identify a possible transition from deflagration to detonation.
Analysis of Acoustic Pressure Oscillation During Vented Deflagration
Oct 2015
Publication
In industrial buildings explosion relief panels or doors are often used to reduce damages caused by gas explosion. Decades of research produced a significant contribution to the understanding of the phenomena involved nevertheless among the aspects that need further research interaction between acoustic oscillation and the flame front is one of the more important. Interaction between the flame front and acoustic oscillation has raised technical problem in lots of combustion applications as well and had been studied theoretically and experimentally in such cases. Pressure oscillation had been observed in vented deflagration and in certain cases they are responsible for the highest pressure peak generated during the event. At Scalbatraio laboratory of Pisa University CVE test facility was built in order to investigate vented hydrogen deflagration. This paper is aimed to present an overview of the results obtained during several experimental campaigns which tests are analysed with the focus on the investigation of flame acoustic interaction phenomenon. Qualitative and quantitative analysis is presented and the possible physic generating the phenomenon investigated.
Application of the Validated 3D Multiphase-multicomponent CFD Model to an Accidental Liquid Hydrogen Release Scenario in a Liquefication Plant
Sep 2017
Publication
Hydrogen-air mixtures are flammable in a wide range of compositions and have a low ignition energy compared to gaseous hydrocarbons. Due to its low density high buoyancy and diffusivity the mixing is strongly enhanced which supports distribution into large volumes if accidentally released. Economically valuable discontinuous transportation over large distances is only expected using liquid hydrogen (LH2). Releases of LH2 at its low temperature (20.3 K at 0.1 MPa) have additional hazards besides the combustible character of gaseous hydrogen (GH2). Hazard assessment requires simulation tools capable of calculating the pool spreading as well as the gas distribution for safety assessments of existing the future liquid hydrogen facilities. Evaluating possible risks the following process steps are useful:
- Possible accident release scenarios need to be identified for a given plant layout.
- Environmental boundary conditions such as wind conditions and humidity need to be identified and worst case scenarios have to be identified.
- A model approach based on this information which is capable of simulating LH2 releases vaporization rates and atmospheric dispersion of the gaseous hydrogen.
- Evaluate and verify safety distances identify new risks and/or extract certain design rules.
Analysis of Transient Supersonic Hydrogen Release, Dispersion and Combustion
Sep 2017
Publication
A hydrogen leak from a facility which uses highly compressed hydrogen gas (714 bar 800 K) during operation was studied. The investigated scenario involves supersonic hydrogen release from a 10 cm2 leak of the pressurized reservoir turbulent hydrogen dispersion in the facility room followed by an accidental ignition and burn-out of the resulting H2-air cloud. The objective is to investigate the maximum possible flame velocity and overpressure in the facility room in case of a worst-case ignition. The pressure loads are needed for the structural analysis of the building wall response. The first two phases namely unsteady supersonic release and subsequent turbulent hydrogen dispersion are simulated with GASFLOW-MPI. This is a well validated parallel all-speed CFD code which solves the compressible Navier-Stokes equations and can model a broad range of flow Mach numbers. Details of the shock structures are resolved for the under-expanded supersonic jet and the sonic-subsonic transition in the release. The turbulent dispersion phase is simulated by LES. The evolution of the highly transient burnable H2-air mixture in the room in terms of burnable mass volume and average H2-concentration is evaluated with special sub-routines. For five different points in time the maximum turbulent flame speed and resulting overpressures are computed using four published turbulent burning velocity correlations. The largest turbulent flame speed and overpressure is predicted for an early ignition event resulting in 35–71 m/s and 0.13–0.27 bar respectively.
Effectiveness of a Blower in Reducing the Hazard of Hydrogen Leaking from a Hydrogen-fueled Vehicle
Sep 2013
Publication
To handle a hydrogen fuel cell vehicle (HFCV) safely after its involvement in an accident it is necessary to provide appropriate emergency response information to the first responder. In the present study a forced wind of 10 m/s or faster with and without a duct was applied to a vehicle leaking hydrogen gas at a rate of 2000 NL/min. Then hydrogen concentrations were measured around the vehicle and an ignition test was conducted to evaluate the effectiveness of forced winds and the safety of emergency response under forced wind conditions. The results: 1) Forced winds of 10 m/s or faster caused the hydrogen concentrations in the vicinity of the vehicle to decline to less than the lower flammability limit and the hydrogen gas in the various sections of the vehicles were so diluted that even if ignition occurred the blast-wave pressure was moderate. 2) When the first responder had located the hydrogen leakage point in the vehicle it was possible to lower the hydrogen concentrations around the vehicle by aiming the wind duct towards the leakage point and blowing winds at 10 m/s from the duct exit.
Numerical Modelling of Flame Acceleration and Transition to Detonation in Hydrogen & Air Mixtures with Concentration Gradient
Sep 2017
Publication
Hydrogen gas explosions in homogeneous reactive mixtures have been widely studied both experimentally and numerically. However in practice combustible mixtures are usually inhomogeneous and subject to both vertical and horizontal concentration gradients. There is still very limited understanding of the hydrogen explosion characteristics in such situations. The present numerical investigation aims to study the effect of mixture concentration gradient on the process of Deflagration to Detonation Transition and the effect of different hydrogen concentration gradient in the obstructed channel of hydrogen/air mixtures. An obstructed channel with 30% blockage ratio (BR=30) and three different average hydrogen concentrations of 20 % 30% and 35% have been considered using a specially developed density-based solver within the OpenFOAM toolbox. A high-resolution grid was built with the using adaptive mesh refinement technique providing 10 grid points in half reaction length. The numerical results are in reasonably good agreement with the experimental observations [1]. These studies show that the concentration gradient has a considerable effect on the accelerated flame tip speed and the location of transition to detonation in the obstructed channel. In all the three cases the first localised explosion occurred near the bottom wall where the shock and flame interacted and the mixture was most lean; and the second localised explosion occurred at the top wall due to the reflection of shock and flame front and later develops to form the leading detonation wave. The increase in the fuel concentration was found to increase the flame acceleration (FA) and having a faster transition to detonation.
PIV-measurements of Reactant Flow in Hydrogen-air Explosions
Sep 2017
Publication
The paper present the work on PIV-measurements of reactant flow velocity in front of propagating flames in hydrogen-air explosions. The experiments was performed with hydrogen-air mixture at atmospheric pressure and room temperature. The experimental rig was a square channel with 45 × 20 mm2 cross section 300 mm long with a single cylindrical obstacle of blockage ratio 1/3. The equipment used for the PIV-measurements was a Firefly diode laser from Oxford lasers Photron SA-Z high-speed camera and a particle seeder producing 1 μm droplets of water. The gas concentrations used in the experiments was 14 and 17 vol% hydrogen in air. The resulting explosion can be characterized as slow since the maximum flow velocity of the reactants was 13 m/s in the 14% mixture and 23 m/s in the 17% mixture. The maximum flow velocities was measured during the flame-vortex interaction and at two obstacle diameters behind the obstacle. The flame-vortex interaction contributed to the flame acceleration by increasing the overall reaction rate and the flow velocity. The flame area as a function of position is the same for both concentrations as the flame passes the obstacle.
Modeling of Hydrogen Flame Dynamics in Narrow Gap with Bendable Walls
Sep 2017
Publication
A concept of volume porosity together with model of moving walls were elaborated and implemented into the COM3D code. Additionally to that a support of real-time data exchange with finite-element code ABAQUS - © Dassault Systèmes provided possibility to perform simulations of the gas-dynamic simultaneously with geometrical adaptation of environmental conditions. Based on the data obtained in the KIT combustion experiments in narrow gaps the authors performed a series of the simulation on the combustion in the corresponding conditions. Obtained numerical results demonstrated good agreement with the observed experimental data. These data were also compared with those obtained in the simulation without wall bending where simulation showed considerably different combustion regime. Application of the developed technique allows to obtain results unreachable without accounting on wall displacements which demonstrates massive over-estimation of the pressures observed during flame propagation.
Effects of the Injector Direction on the Temperature Distribution During Filling of Hydrogen Tanks
Sep 2017
Publication
The development of the temperature field in hydrogen tanks during the filling process has been investigated with Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD). Measurements from experiments undertaken at the JRC GasTef facility have been used to develop and validate the CFD modelling strategy; by means of the CFD calculations the effect of the injector direction on the temperature distribution has been analysed. It has been found that the dynamics of the temperature field including the development of potentially detrimental phenomena like thermal stratification and temperature inhomogeneity e.g. hot spots can be significantly affected by the injector orientation.
Modeling of Hydrogen Pressurization and Extraction in Cryogenic Pressure Vessels Due to Vacuum Insulation Failure
Sep 2017
Publication
We have analyzed vacuum insulation failure in an automotive cryogenic pressure vessel (also known as cryo-compressed vessel) storing hydrogen (H2). Vacuum insulation failure increases heat transfer into cryogenic vessels by about a factor of 100 potentially leading to rapid pressurization and venting to avoid exceeding maximum allowable working pressure (MAWP). H2 release to the environment may be dangerous if the vehicle is located in a closed space (e.g. a garage or tunnel) at the moment of insulation failure. We therefore consider utilization of the hydrogen in the vehicle fuel cell and electricity dissipation through operation of vehicle accessories or battery charging as an alternative to releasing hydrogen to the environment. We consider two strategies: initiating hydrogen extraction immediately after vacuum insulation failure or waiting until MAWP is reached before extraction. The results indicate that cryogenic pressure vessels have thermodynamic advantages that enable slowing down hydrogen release to moderate levels that can be consumed in the fuel cell and dissipated onboard the vehicle even in the worst case when the vacuum fails with a vessel storing hydrogen at maximum refuel density (70 g/L at 300 bar). The two proposed strategies are therefore feasible and the best alternative can be chosen based on economic and/or implementation constraints.
Blending Ammonia into Hydrogen to Enhance Safety through Reduced Burning Velocity
Sep 2019
Publication
Laminar burning velocities (SL) of hydrogen/ammonia mixtures in air at atmospheric pressure were studied experimentally and numerically. The blending of hydrogen with ammonia two fuels that have been proposed as promising carriers for renewable energy causes the laminar flame speed of the mixture SL to decrease significantly. However details of this have not previously available. Systematic measurements were therefore performed for a series of hydrogen/ammonia mixtures with wide ranges of mole fractions of blended ammonia (XNH3) and equivalence ratio using a heat flux method based on heat flux of a flat flame transferred to the burner surface. It was found that the mixture of XNH3 = 40% has a value of SL close to that of methane which is the dominant component of natural gas. Using three chemical kinetic mechanisms available in the literature i.e. the well-known GRI-Mech 3.0 mechanism and two mechanisms recently released SL were also modelled for the cases studied. However the discrepancies between the experimental and numerical results can exceed 50% with the GRI-Mech 3.0 mechanism. Discrepancies were also found between the numerical results obtained with different mechanisms. These results can contribute to an increase in both the safety and efficiency of the coutilization of these two types of emerging renewable fuel and to guiding the development of better kinetic models.
Sample Scale Testing Method to Prevent Collapse of Plastic Liners in Composite Pressure Vessels
Sep 2017
Publication
Type IV pressure vessels are commonly used for hydrogen on-board stationary or bulk storages. When pressurised hydrogen permeates through the materials and solves into them. Emptying then leads to a difference of pressure at the interface between composite and liner possibly leading to a permanent deformation of the plastic liner called “collapse” or “buckling”. This phenomenon has been studied through French funded project Colline allowing to better understand its initiation and long-term effects. This paper presents the methodology followed using permeation tests hydrogen decompression tests on samples and gas diffusion calculation in order to determine safe operating conditions such as maximum flow rate or residual pressure level.
Measurements of Flow Velocity and Scalar Concentration in Turbulent Multi-component Jets
Sep 2017
Publication
Buoyancy effects and nozzle geometry can have a significant impact on turbulent jet dispersion. This work was motivated by applications involving hydrogen. Using helium as an experimental proxy buoyant horizontal jets issuing from a round orifice on the side wall of a circular tube were analyzed experimentally using particle image velocimetry (PIV) and planar laser-induced fluorescence (PLIF) techniques simultaneously to provide instantaneous and time-averaged flow fields of velocity and concentration. Effects of buoyancy and asymmetry on the resulting flow structure were studied over a range of Reynolds numbers and gas densities. Significant differences were found between the centreline trajectory spreading rate and velocity decay of conventional horizontal round axisymmetric jets issuing through flat plates and the pipeline leak-representative jets considered in the present study. The realistic pipeline jets were always asymmetric and found to deflect about the jet axis in the near field. In the far field it was found that the realistic pipeline leak geometry causes buoyancy effects to dominate much sooner than expected compared to horizontal round jets issuing through flat plates.
Simulation of Thermal Radiation from Hydrogen Under-expanded Jet Fire
Sep 2017
Publication
Thermal hazards from an under-expanded (900 bar) hydrogen jet fire have been numerically investigated. The simulation results have been compared with the flame length and radiative heat flux measured for the horizontal jet fire experiment conducted at INERIS. The release blowdown characteristics have been modelled using the volumetric source as an expanded implementation of the notional nozzle concept. The CFD study employs the realizable k-ε model for turbulence and the Eddy Dissipation Concept for combustion. Radiation has been taken into account through the Discrete Ordinates (DO) model. The results demonstrated good agreement with the experimental flame length. Performance of the model shall be improved to reproduce the radiative properties dynamics during the first stage of the release (time < 10 s) whereas during the remaining blowdown time the simulated radiative heat flux at five sensors followed the trend observed in the experiment.
Fundamental Combustion Properties of Oxygen Enriched Hydrogen-air Mixtures Relevant to Safety Analysis Experimental and Simulation Study
Oct 2015
Publication
In order to face the coming shortage of fossil energies a number of alternative methods of energy production are being considered. One promising approach consists in using hydrogen in replacement of the conventional fossil fuels or as an additive to these fuels. In addition to conventional hydro-electric and fission-based nuclear plants electric energy could be obtained in the future using nuclear fusion as investigated within the framework of the ITER project International Thermonuclear Experimental Reactor. However the operation of ITER may rise safety problems including the formation of a flammable dust/hydrogen/air atmosphere. A first step towards the accurate assessment of accidental explosion in ITER consists in better characterizing the risk of explosion in gaseous hydrogen-containing mixtures. In the present study laminar burning speeds ignition delay-times behind reflected shock wave and detonation cell sizes were measured over wide ranges of composition and equivalence ratios. The performances of five detailed reaction models were evaluated with respect to the present data.
Hydrogen-air Vented Explosions- New Experimental Data
Sep 2013
Publication
The use of hydrogen as an energy carrier is a real perspective in Europe since a number of breakthroughs obtained in the last decades open the possibility to envision a deployment at the industrial scale if safety issues are duly accounted. However on this particular aspects experimental data are still lacking especially about the explosion dynamics in realistic dimensions. The purpose of this paper is to provide a set of totally new and well instrumented hydrogen - air vented explosions. Experiments were performed in a large explosion chamber within the scope of the DIMITRHY project (sponsored by the National French Agency for Research). The 4 m3 rectangular experimental chamber (2 m height 2 m width and 1 m depth) is equipped with transparent walls and is vented (0.25 and 0.5 m2 square vents).. Six pressure gauges were used to measure the overpressure evolution inside and outside the chamber. Six concentration gauges were used to control the hydrogen repartition in the vessel. The hydrogen-air cloud was seeded with micro particles of ammonium chloride to see the propagation of the flame the movement of the cloud inside and outside the chamber. The incidence of reactivity vent size ignition position and non homogenous repartition of hydrogen received a particular attention.
A Study of Hydrogen Flame Length with Complex Nozzle Geometry
Sep 2017
Publication
The growing number of hydrogen fillings stations and cars increases the need for accurate models to determine risk. The effect on hydrogen flame length was measured by varying the diameter of the spouting nozzle downstream from the chocked nozzle upstream. The results was compared with an existing model for flame length estimations. The experimental rig was setup with sensors that measured accurately temperature mass flow heat radiation and the pressure range from 0.1 to 11 MPa. The flame length was determined with an in-house developed image-processing tool which analyzed a high-speed film of the each experiment. Results show that the nozzle geometry can cause a deviation as high as 50% compared to estimated flame lengths by the model if wrong assumptions are made. Discharge coefficients for different nozzles has been calculated and presented.
Assessment of a CFD Model for Simulations of Fast Filling of Hydrogen Tanks with Pre-cooling
Sep 2013
Publication
High gas temperatures can be reached inside a hydrogen tank during the filling process because of the large pressure increase (up to 70-80 MPa) and because of the short time (~3 minutes) of the process. High temperatures can potentially jeopardize the structural integrity of the storage system and one of the strategies to reduce the temperature increase is to pre-cool the hydrogen before injecting it into the tank. Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) tools have the capabilities of capturing the flow field and the temperature rise in the tank. The results of CFD simulations of fast filling with pre-cooling are shown and compared with experimental data to assess the accuracy of the CFD model
Interaction of Hydrogen Jets with Hot Surfaces
Sep 2017
Publication
The formation of hydrogen jets from pressurized sources and its ignition when hitting hot devices has been studied by many projects. The transient jets evolve with high turbulence depending on the configuration of the nozzle and especially the pressure in the hydrogen reservoir. In addition the length of the jets and the flames generated by ignition at a hot surface varies. Parameters to be varied were initial pressure of the source (2.5 10 20 and 40 MPa) distance between the nozzle and the hot surface (3 5 and 7 m) and temperature of the hot surface (between 400 and 1000 K). The interaction of the hydrogen jets is visualized by high-speed cinematography techniques which allow analysing the jet characteristics. By combination of various methods of image processing the visibility of the phenomena on the videos taken at 15 000 fps was improved. In addition high-speed NIR spectroscopy was used to obtain temperature profiles of the expanding deflagrations. The jets ignite already above 450 K for conditions mainly from the tubular source at 40 MPa. In addition the propagation of the flame front depends on all three varied parameters: temperature of the hot surface pressure in the reservoir and distance between nozzle and hot surface. In most cases also upstream propagation occurs. A high turbulence seems to lead to the strong deflagrations. At high temperatures of the ignition sources the interaction leads to fast deflagration and speeds up- and downstream of the jet. The deflagration velocity is close to velocity of sound and emission of pressure waves occurs.
Fire Tests Carried Out in FCH JU FIRECOMP Project, Recommendations and Application to Safety of Gas Storage Systems
Sep 2017
Publication
In the event of a fire composite pressure vessels behave very differently from metallic ones: the material is degraded potentially leading to a burst without significant pressure increase. Hence such objects are when necessary protected from fire by using thermally-activated devices (TPRD) and standards require testing cylinder and TPRD together. The pre-normative research project FireComp aimed at understanding better the conditions which may lead to burst through testing and simulation and proposed an alternative way of assessing the fire performance of composite cylinders. This approach is currently used by Air Liquide for the safety of composite bundles carrying large amounts of hydrogen gas.
CFD Based Simulation of Hydrogen Release Through Elliptical Orifices
Sep 2013
Publication
Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) is applied to investigate the near exit jet behavior of high pressure hydrogen release into quiescent ambient air through different types of orifices. The size and geometry of the release hole can affect the possibility of auto-ignition. Therefore the effect of release geometry on the behavior and development of hydrogen jet issuing from non-axisymmetric (elliptical) and expanding orifices is investigated and compared with their equivalent circular orifices. A three-dimensional in-house code is developed using the MPI library for parallel computing to simulate the flow based on an inviscid approximation. Convection dominates viscous effects in strongly underexpanded supersonic jets in the vicinity of release exit justifying the use of the Euler equations. The transport (advection) equation is applied to calculate the concentration of hydrogen-air mixture. The Abel-Nobel equation of state is used because high pressure hydrogen flow deviates from the ideal gas assumption. This work effort is conducted to fulfill two objectives. First two types of circular and elliptic orifices with the same cross sectional area are simulated and the flow behavior of each case is studied and compared during the initial stage of release. Second the comparative study between expanding circular exit and its fixed counterpart is carried out. This evaluation is conducted for different sizes of nozzle with different aspect ratios.
Tokyo Gas’ Efforts Regarding Impact Assessment on Surroundings and Emergency Response Training
Sep 2017
Publication
In Japan 82 commercial Hydrogen Refuelling Stations (HRSs) were constructed as of March 1 2017 but few impact assessments have been reported on the surroundings at HRS. In addition as HRSs become more widespread the number of HRSs around narrow urban areas will also increase. Thus the necessity of impact assessments on the surroundings of HRSs is expected to increase. In order to confirm that the influence from our HRS is not problematic to the surrounding residences we conducted an impact assessment on the surroundings at HRS by using the actual HRS construction plan. Although safety is one of the objects of an impact assessment in Japan the safety of an HRS is guaranteed by observing the High Pressure Gas Safety Act its Technical Standards and other related regulations. On the other hand if an accident such as a hydrogen leak or hydrogen fire occurs at an HRS it becomes important to prevent secondary disasters and to minimize influence on the surroundings by means of an initial response by the operators of the HRS. Therefore we have conducted training to improve the emergency response capability of the HRS operators and to prevent secondary disasters. In this paper we describe the abovementioned information with regard to an impact assessment on the surroundings and for emergency response training.
Socio-economic Analysis and Quantitative Risk Assessment Methodology for Safety Design of Onboard Storage Systems
Sep 2017
Publication
Catastrophic rupture of onboard hydrogen storage in a fire is a safety concern. Different passive e.g. fireproofing materials the thermally activated pressure relief device (TPRD) and active e.g. initiation of TPRD by fire sensors safety systems are being developed to reduce hazards from and associated risks of high-pressure hydrogen storage tank rupture in a fire. The probability of such low-frequency highconsequences event is a function of fire resistance rating (FRR) i.e. the time before tank without TPRD ruptures in a fire the probability of TPRD failure etc. This safety issue is “confirmed” by observed recently cases of CNG tanks rupture due to blocked or failed to operate TPRD etc. The increase of FRR by any means decreases the probability of tank rupture in a fire particularly because of fire extinction by first responders on arrival at an accident scene.<br/>This study of socio-economic effects of safety applies a quantitative risk assessment (QRA) methodology to an example of hydrogen vehicles with passive tank protection system on roads in London.<br/>The risk is defined here through the cost of human loss per fuel cell hydrogen vehicle (FCHV) fire accident and fatality rate per FCHV per year. The first step in the methodology is the consequence analysis based on validated deterministic engineering tools to estimate the main identified hazards: overpressure in the blast wave at different distances and the thermal hazards from a fireball in the case of catastrophic tank rupture in a fire. The population can be exposed to slight injury serious injury and fatality after an accident. These effects are determined based on criteria by Health and Safety Executive (UK) and a cost metrics is applied to the number of exposed people in these three harm categories to estimate the cost per an accident. The second step in the methodology is either the frequency or the probability analysis. Probabilities of a vehicle fire and failure of the thermally activated pressure relief device are taken from published sources. A vulnerability probit function is employed to calculate the probability of emergency operations’ failure to prevent tank rupture as a function of a storage tank FRR and time of fire brigade arrival. These later results are integrated to estimate the tank rupture frequency and fatality rate. The risk is presented as a function of fire resistance rating.<br/>The QRA methodology allows to calculate the cost of human loss associated with an FCHV fire accident and demonstrates how the increase of FRR of onboard storage as a safety engineering measure would improve socio-economics of FCHV deployment and public acceptance of the technology.
Numerical Investigation on the Self-ignition Behavior of High Pressure Hydrogen Released from the Tube
Sep 2017
Publication
This paper shows the numerical investigation on the self-ignition behavior of high pressure hydrogen released from the tube. The present study aims to clarify the effect of parameters on the behavior and duration of self-ignition outside the tube using two-dimensional axisymmetric numerical simulation with detailed chemistry. The parameters in this study are release pressure tube diameter and tube length. The strength of the spherical shock wave to keep chemical reaction and expansion are important factors for self ignited hydrogen jet to be sustained outside the tube. The trend of strength of spherical shock wave is enhanced by higher release pressure and larger tube diameter. The chemical reaction weakens due to expansion and the degree of expansion becomes larger as the spherical shock wave propagates. The characteristic time for the chemical reaction becomes shorter in higher release pressure larger tube diameter and longer tube diameter cases from the induction time under constant volume assumption. The self ignited hydrogen jet released from the tube is sustained up to the distance where the characteristic time for chemical reaction is shorter than the characteristic time for the flow to expand and higher release pressure larger tube diameter and longer tube length expand the distance where the tip flame can propagate downstream. For the seed flame which is the key for jet fire the larger amount of the ignited volume when the shock wave reaches the tube exit contributes to the formation and stability of the seed flame. The amount of the ignited volume tends to be larger in the longer tube length higher release pressure and larger tube diameter cases.
Hydrogen Safety Sensor Performance and Use Gap Analysis
Sep 2017
Publication
Hydrogen sensors are recognized as an important technology for facilitating the safe implementation of hydrogen as an alternative fuel and there are numerous reports of a sensor alarm successfully preventing a potentially serious event. However gaps in sensor metrological specifications as well as in their performance for some applications exist. The U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) Fuel Cell Technologies Office published a short list of critical gaps in the 2007 and 2012 Multiyear Project Plans; more detailed gap analyses were independently performed by the Joint Research Centre (JRC) and the National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL). There have been however some significant advances in sensor technologies since these assessments including the commercial availability of hydrogen sensors with fast response times (t90 < 1 s which had been an elusive DOE target since 2007) improved robustness to chemical poisons improved selectivity and improved lifetime and stability. These improvements however have not been universal and typically pertain to select platforms or models. Moreover as hydrogen markets grow and new applications are being explored more demands will be imposed on sensor performance. The hydrogen sensor laboratories at NREL and the JRC are currently updating the hydrogen safety sensor gap analysis through direct interaction with international stakeholders in the hydrogen community especially end users. NREL and the JRC are currently organizing a series of workshops (in Europe and the United States) with sensor developers end-users and other stakeholders in 2017 to identify technology gaps and to develop a path forward to address them. One workshop was held on May 10 in Brussels Belgium at the Headquarters of the Fuel Cell and Hydrogen Joint Undertaking. A second workshop is planned at NREL in Golden CO USA. This paper reviews improvements in sensor technologies in the past 5 to 10 years identifies gaps in sensor performance and use requirements and identifies potential research strategies to address the gaps. The outcomes of the Hydrogen Sensors Workshops are also summarized.
Empirical Profiling of Cold Hydrogen Plumes Formed from Venting of LH2 Storage Vessels
Sep 2017
Publication
Liquid hydrogen (LH2) storage is viewed as a viable approach to assure sufficient hydrogen capacity at commercial fuelling stations. Presently LH2 is produced at remote facilities and then transported to the end-use site by road vehicles (i.e. LH2 tanker trucks). Venting of hydrogen to depressurize the transport storage tank is a routine part of the LH2 delivery and site transfer process. The behaviour of cold hydrogen plumes has not been well characterized because of the sparsity of empirical field data which can lead to overly conservative safety requirements. Committee members of the National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) Standard 2 [1] formed the Hydrogen Storage Safety Task Group which consists of hydrogen producers safety experts and computational fluid dynamics modellers has identified the lack of understanding of hydrogen dispersion during LH2 venting of storage vessels as a critical gap for establishing safety distances at LH2 facilities especially commercial hydrogen fuelling stations. To address this need the National Renewable Energy Laboratory Sensor Laboratory in collaboration with the NFPA Hydrogen Storage Task Group developed a prototype Cold Hydrogen Plume Analyzer to empirically characterize the hydrogen plume formed during LH2 storage tank venting. The prototype analyzer was field deployed during an actual LH2 venting process. Critical findings included
- Hydrogen above the lower flammable limit (LFL) was detected as much as 2 m lower than the release point which is not predicted by existing models.
- Personal monitors detected hydrogen at ground level although at levels below the LFL.
- A small but inconsistent correlation was found between oxygen depletion and the hydrogen concentration.
- A negligible to non-existent correlation was found between in-situ temperature measurements and the hydrogen concentration.
RBD-fast Based Sensitivity and Uncertainty Analysis on a Computational Hydrogen Recombiner Test Case
Sep 2017
Publication
Deflagration-to-Detonation Transition Ratio (DDTR) is an important parameter in measuring the hazard of hydrogen detonation at given thermodynamic conditions. It’s among the major tasks to evaluate DDTR in the study of hydrogen safety in a nuclear containment. With CFD tools detailed distribution of thermodynamic parameters at each instant can be simulated with considerable reliability. Then DDTR can be estimated using related CFD output. Forstochastic or epistemic reasons uncertainty always exists in input parameters during computations. This lack of accuracy can finally be reflected in the uncertainty of computation results e.g. DDTR in our consideration. The analysis of the influence of the input uncertainty is therefore a key step to understand the model’s response on the output and possibly to improve the accuracy. The increase of computational power makes it possible to perform statistics-based sensitivity and uncertainty (SU) analysis on CFD simulations. This paper aims at presenting some ideas on the procedure in safety analysis on hydrogen in nuclear containment. A hydrogen recombiner case is constructed and simulated with CFD method. DDTR at each instant is computed using a semi-empirical method. RBD-FAST based SU analysis is performed on the result.
Experimental Study of the Thermal Behaviour of Hydrogen Tanks During Hydrogen Cycling
Sep 2013
Publication
The thermal behaviour of several commercial hydrogen tanks has been studied during high pressure (70-84 MPa) hydrogen cycling. The temperature of the gas at different points inside the tank the temperature at the bosses and the tank outer wall temperature have been measured under different filling and emptying conditions. From the experimental results the effect of the filling rate (1.5-4 g/s) and the influence of the liner material in the thermal behaviour of the hydrogen tanks have been evaluated. Bosses thermal response under the different cycling conditions has also been investigated.
Modelling Liquid Hydrogen Release and Spread on Water
Sep 2017
Publication
Consequence modelling of high potential risks of usage and transportation of cryogenic liquids yet requires substantial improvements. Among the cryogenics liquid hydrogen (LH2) needs especial treatments and a comprehensive understanding of spill and spread of liquid and dispersion of vapor. Even though many of recent works have shed lights on various incidents such as spread dispersion and explosion of the liquid over land less focus was given on spill and spread of LH2 onto water. The growing trend in ship transportation has enhanced risks such as ships’ accidental releases and terrorist attacks which may ultimately lead to the release of the cryogenic liquid onto water. The main goal of the current study is to present a computational fluid dynamic (CFD) approach using OpenFOAM to model release and spread of LH2 over water substrate and discuss previous approaches. It also includes empirical heat transfer equations due to boiling and computation of evaporation rate through an energy balance. The results of the proposed model will be potentially used within another coupled model that predicts gas dispersion]. This work presents a good practice approach to treat pool dynamics and appropriate correlations to identify heat flux from different sources. Furthermore some of the previous numerical approaches to redistribute or in some extend manipulate the LH2 pool dynamic are brought up for discussion and their pros and cons are explained. In the end the proposed model is validated by modelling LH2 spill experiment carried out in 1994 at the Research Centre Juelich in Germany.
Effect of Rotation on Ignition Thresholds of Stoichiometric Hydrogen Mixtures
Sep 2017
Publication
Successful transition to a hydrogen economy calls for a deep understanding of the risks associated with its widespread use. Accidental ignition of hydrogen by hot surfaces is one of such risks. In the present study we investigated the effect that rotation has on the reported ignition thresholds by numerically determining the minimum surface temperature required to ignite stoichiometric hydrogen-air using a hot horizontal cylinder rotating at various angular velocities ω. Numerical experiments showed a weak but interesting dependence of the ignition thresholds on rotation: the ignition thresholds increased by 8 K from 931 K to 939 K with increasing angular velocity (0 ≤ ω ≤ 240 rad/s). A further increase to ω = 480 rad/s resulted in a decrease in ignition surface temperature to 935 K. Detailed analysis of the flow patterns inside the vessel and in close proximity to the hot surface brought about by the combined effect of buoyancy and rotation as well as of the distribution of the wall heat flux along the circumference of the cylinder support our previous findings in which regions where temperature gradients are small were found to be prone to ignition.
A Numerical Simulation of Hydrogen Diffusion for the Hydrogen Leakage from a Fuel Cell Vehicle in an Underground Parking Garage
Sep 2011
Publication
In the present study the diffusion process of hydrogen leaking from a FCV (Fuel Cell Vehicle) in an underground parking garage is analyzed by numerical simulations in order to assess the risk of a leakage accident. The temporal and spatial evolution of the hydrogen concentration as well as the flammable region in the parking garage was predicted numerically. The effects of the leakage flow rate and an additional ventilation fan were investigated to evaluate the ventilation performance to relieve the accumulation of the hydrogen gas. The volume of the flammable region shows a non-linear growth in time and rapidly increases eventually. The present numerical analysis can provide a physical insight and quantitative data for safety of various hydrogen applications.
Real World Hydrogen Technology Validation
Sep 2011
Publication
The Department of Energy the Department of Defense's Defense Logistics Agency and the Department of Transportation's Federal Transit Administration have funded learning demonstrations and early market deployments to provide insight into applications of hydrogen technologies on the road in the warehouse and as stationary power. NREL's analyses validate the technology in real-world applications reveal the status of the technology and facilitate the development of hydrogen and fuel cell technologies manufacturing and operations. This paper presents the maintenance safety and operation data of fuel cells in multiple applications with the reported incidents near misses and frequencies. NREL has analyzed records of more than 225000 kilograms of hydrogen that have been dispensed through more than 108000 hydrogen fills with an excellent safety record.
Time Response of Hydrogen Sensors
Sep 2013
Publication
The efficiency of gas sensor application for facilitating the safe use of hydrogen depends to a considerable extent on the response time of the sensor to change in hydrogen concentration. The response and recovery times have been measured for five different hydrogen sensors three commercially available and two promising prototypes which operate at room temperature. Experiments according to ISO 26142 show that most of the sensors surpass much for a concentration change from clean to hydrogen containing air the demands of the standard for the response times t(90) and values of 2 to 16 s were estimated. For an opposite shift to clean air the recovery times t(10) are from 7 to 70 s. Results of transient behaviour can be fitted with an exponential approach. It can be demonstrated that results on transient behaviour depend not only from investigation method and the experimental conditions like gas changing rate and concentration jump as well as from operating parameters of sensors. In comparison to commercial MOS and MIS-FET hydrogen sensors new sensor prototypes operating at room temperature possesses in particular longer recovery times.
In Situ X-ray Absorption Spectroscopy Study on Water Formation Reaction of Palladium Metal Nanoparticle Catalysts
Oct 2015
Publication
Proper management of hydrogen gas is very important for safety security of nuclear power plants. Hydrogen removal by water formation reaction on a catalyst is one of the candidates for creating hydrogen free system. We observed in situ and time-resolved structure change of palladium metal nanoparticle catalyst during the water formation reaction by using X-ray absorption spectroscopy technique. A poisoning effect by carbon monoxide on catalytic activity was also studied. We have found that the creation of oxidized surface layer on palladium metal nanoparticles plays an important role for the water formation reaction process.
Comparisons of Helium and Hydrogen Releases in 1 M3 and 2 M3 Two Vents Enclosures: Concentration Measurements at Different Flow Rates and for Two Diameters of Injection Nozzle
Oct 2015
Publication
This work presents a parametric study on the similitude between hydrogen and helium distribution when released in the air by a source located inside of a naturally ventilated enclosure with two vents. Several configurations were experimentally addressed in order to improve knowledge on dispersion. Parameters were chosen to mimic operating conditions of hydrogen energy systems. Thus the varying parameters of the study were mainly the source diameter the releasing flow rate the volume and the geometry of the enclosure. Two different experimental set-ups were used in order to vary the enclosure's height between 1 and 2 m. Experimental results obtained with helium and hydrogen were compared at equivalent flow rates determined with existing similitude laws. It appears for the plume release case that helium can suitably be used for predicting hydrogen dispersion in these operating designs. On the other hand – when the flow turns into a jet – non negligible differences between hydrogen and helium dispersion appear. In this case helium – used as a direct substitute to hydrogen – will over predict concentrations we would get with hydrogen. Therefore helium concentration read-outs should be converted to obtain correct predictions for hydrogen. However such a converting law is not available yet.
Experimental and Numerical Study on Spontaneous Ignition of Hydrogen-methane Jets in Air
Sep 2013
Publication
This paper is an investigation of the spontaneous ignition process of high-pressure hydrogen and hydrogen-methane mixtures injected into air. The experiments were conducted in a closed channel filled with air where the hydrogen or hydrogen–methane mixture depressurised through different tubes (diameters d = 6 10 and 14 mm and lengths L = 10 25 40 50 75 and 100 mm). The methane addition to the mixture was 5% and 10% vol. The results showed that only 5% methane addition may increase even 2.67 times the pressure at which the mixture may ignite in comparison to the pressure of the pure hydrogen flow. The 10% of methane addition did not provide an ignition for burst pressures up to 15.0 MPa in the geometrical configuration with the longest tube (100 mm). Additionally the simulations of the experimental configuration with pure hydrogen were performed with the use of KIVA numerical code with full kinetic reaction mechanism.
Pressure Peaking Phenomena: Unignited Hydrogen Releases in Confined Spaces – Large-scale Experiments
Sep 2020
Publication
The aim of this study was to validate a model for predicting overpressure arising from accidental hydrogen releases in areas with limited ventilation. Experiments were performed in a large-scale setup that included a steel-reinforced container of volume 14.9 m3 and variable ventilation areas and mass flow rates. The pressure peaking phenomenon characterized as transient overpressure with a characteristic peak in a vented enclosure was observed during all the experiments. The model description presented the relationship between the ventilation area mass flow rate enclosure volume and discharge coefficient. The experimental results were compared with two prediction models representing a perfect mix and the real mix. The perfect mix assumed that all the released hydrogen was well stirred inside the enclosure during the releases. The real mix prediction s used the hydrogen concentration and temperature data measured during experiments. The prediction results with both perfect mix and real mix showed possible hazards during unignited hydrogen releases.
Modelling of Ventilated Hydrogen Dispersion in Presence of Co-flow and Counter-flow
Sep 2021
Publication
In the framework of the EU-funded project HyTunnel-CS an inter-comparison among partners CFD simulations has been carried out. The simulations are based on experiments conducted within the project by Pro-Science and involve hydrogen release inside a safety vessel testing different ventilation configurations. The different ventilation configurations that were tested are co-flow counter-flow and cross-flow. In the current study co-flow and counter-flow tests along with the no ventilation test (m' = S g/s d = 4 mm ) are simulated with the aim to validate available and well-known CFD codes against such applications and to provide recommendations on modeling strategies. Special focus is given on modeling the velocity field produced by the fan during the experiments. The computational results are compared with the experimental results and a discussion follows regarding the efficiency of each ventilation configuration.
CFD Model Based Ann Prediction of Flammable Vapor Colour Formed by Liquid Hydrogen Spill
Sep 2021
Publication
Unintended releases can occur during the production storage transportation and filling of liquid hydrogen which may cause devastating consequences. In the present work liquid hydrogen leak is modeled in ANSYS Fluent with the numerical model validated using the liquid hydrogen spill test data. A three-layer artificial neural network (ANN) model is built in which the wind speed ground temperature leakage time and leakage rate are taken as the inputs the horizontal diffusion distance and vertical diffusion distance of combustible gas as the outputs of the ANN. The representative sample data derived from the detailed calculation results of the numerical model are selected via the orthogonal experiment method to train and verify the back propagation (BP) neural network. Comparing the calculation results of the formula fitting with the sample data the results show that the established ANN model can quickly and accurately predict the horizontal and vertical diffusion distance of flammable vapor cloud relatively. The influences of four parameters on the horizontal hazard distance as well as vertical hazard height are predicted and analyzed in the case of continuous overflow of liquid hydrogen using the ANN model.
Combustion Characteristics of Premixed Hydrogen/Air in an Undulate Microchannel
Jan 2022
Publication
This work reports a numerical investigation of microcombustion in an undulate microchannel using premixed hydrogen and air to understand the effect of the burner design on the flame in order to obtain stability of the flame. The simulations were performed for a fixed equivalence ratio and a hyperbolic temperature profile imposed at the microchannel walls in order to mimic the heat external losses occurred in experimental setups. Due to the complexity of the flow dynamics combined with the combustion behavior the present study focuses on understanding the effect of the fuel inlet rate on the flame characteristics keeping other parameters constant. The results presented stable flame structure regardless of the inlet velocity for this type of design meaning that a significant reduction in the heat flux losses through the walls occurred allowing the design of new simpler systems. The increase in inlet velocity increased the flame extension with the flame being stretched along the microchannel. For higher velocities flame separation was observed with two detected different combustion zones and the temperature profiles along the burner centerline presented a non-monotonic decrease due to the dynamics of the vortices observed in the convex regions of the undulated geometry walls. The geometry effects on the flame structure flow field thermal evolution and species distribution for different inlet velocities are reported and discussed.
Safety Standard for Hydrogen and Hydrogen Systems Guidelines for Hydrogen System Design, Materials Selection, Operations, Storage and Transportation
Jan 1997
Publication
The NASA Safety Standard which establishes a uniform process for hydrogen system design materials selection operation storage and transportation is presented. The guidelines include suggestions for safely storing handling and using hydrogen in gaseous (GH2) liquid (LH2) or slush (SLH2) form whether used as a propellant or non-propellant. The handbook contains 9 chapters detailing properties and hazards facility design design of components materials compatibility detection and transportation. Chapter 10 serves as a reference and the appendices contained therein include: assessment examples; scaling laws explosions blast effects and fragmentation; codes standards and NASA directives; and relief devices along with a list of tables and figures abbreviations a glossary and an index for ease of use. The intent of the handbook is to provide enough information that it can be used alone but at the same time reference data sources that can provide much more detail if required.
Health and safety in the new energy economy
Dec 2010
Publication
Over the next decade and beyond the UK is set to take significant steps towards a new energy economy. This will be an economy where the technologies meeting<br/>our electricity heat and fuel needs have to deliver against three key criteria: sustainability security and affordability.<br/><br/>In this context a wide range of emerging energy technologies are expected to play an important role in reshaping the way we satisfy our energy requirements. The extent to which they do so however will depend fundamentally on their ability to be harnessed safely.<br/><br/>Compiled by HSE’s Emerging Energy Technologies Programme this report provides a current assessment of the health and safety hazards that key emerging energy technologies could pose both to workers and to the public at large. (Nuclear energy technologies fall outside the scope of this report.) But it also highlights how an appropriate framework can be and is being put in place to help ensure that these hazards are managed and controlled effectively – an essential<br/>element in enabling the technologies to make a major contribution to the UK’s energy future.
Releases of Unignited Liquid Hydrogen
Jan 2014
Publication
If the hydrogen economy is to progress more hydrogen fuelling stations are required. In the short term in the absence of a hydrogen distribution network these fuelling stations will have to be supplied by liquid hydrogen road tanker. Such a development will increase the number of tanker offloading operations significantly and these may need to be performed in close proximity to the general public.<br/>The aim of this work is to identify and address hazards relating to the storage and transport of bulk liquid hydrogen (LH2) that are associated with hydrogen refuelling stations located in urban environments. Experimental results will inform the wider hydrogen community and contribute to the development of more robust modelling tools. The results will also help to update and develop guidance for codes and standards.<br/>The first phase of the project was to develop an experimental and modelling strategy for the issues associated with liquid hydrogen spills; this was documented in HSL report XS/10/06[1].<br/>The second phase of the project was to produce a position paper on the hazards of liquid hydrogen which was published in 2009 XS/09/72[2]. This was also published as a HSE research report RR769 in 2010[3].<br/>This report details experiments performed to investigate spills of liquid hydrogen at a rate of 60 litres per minute. Measurements were made on unignited releases which included concentration of hydrogen in air thermal gradient in the concrete substrate liquid pool formation and temperatures within the pool. Computational modelling of the unignited releases has been undertaken at HSL and reported in MSU/12/01 [4]. Ignited releases of hydrogen have also been performed as part of this project; the results and findings from this work are reported in XS/11/77[5].
Removing the Disrupting Wind Effect in Single Vented Enclosure Exposed to External Wind
Oct 2015
Publication
We are addressing hydrogen release into a single-vented facility with wind blowing onto the opposite side of the vent wall. Earlier work based on tests performed by HSL with wind (within the HyIndoor project) and comparative CFD simulations with and without wind ([1]within the H2FC project) has shown that the hydrogen concentrations inside the enclosure are increased compared to the case with no wind. This was attributed to the fact that wind is disrupting the passive ventilation. The present work is based on the GAMELAN tests (within the HyIndoor project) performed with one vent and no wind. For this enclosure simulations were performed with and without wind and reproduced the disrupting wind effect. In order to remove this effect and enhance the ventilation additional simulations were performed by considering different geometrical modifications near the vent. A simple geometrical layout around the vent is here proposed that leads to elimination of the disrupting wind effect. The analysis has been performed using the ADREA-HF code earlier validated both for the HSL and the GAMELAN tests. The current work was performed partly within HyIndoor project
A Study on the Effectivity of Hydrogen Leakage Detection for Hydrogen Fuel Cell
Sep 2017
Publication
Unlike four-wheel fuel-cell vehicles fuel-cell motorcycles have little semi-closure space corresponding to the engine compartment of four-wheel fuel-cell vehicles. Furthermore motorcycles may fall while parked or running. We conducted hydrogen concentration measurement and ignition tests to evaluate the feasibility of detecting leaks when hydrogen gas leaked from a fuel-cell motorcycle as well as the risk of ignition. We found that the installation of hydrogen leak detectors is effective because it is possible to detect minute hydrogen leaks by installing leak detectors at appropriate points on the fuel cell motorcycle and risks can be reduced by interrupting the hydrogen leak immediately after detection.
Mixing and Warming of Cryogenic Hydrogen Releases
Sep 2017
Publication
Laboratory measurements were made on the concentration and temperature fields of cryogenic hydrogen jets. Images of spontaneous Raman scattering from a pulsed planar laser sheet were used to measure the concentration and temperature fields from varied releases. Jets with up to 5 bar pressure with near-liquid temperatures at the release point were characterized in this work. This data is relevant for characterizing unintended leaks from piping connected to cryogenic hydrogen storage tanks such as might be encountered at a hydrogen fuel cell vehicle fuelling station. The average centerline mass fraction was observed to decay at a rate similar to room temperature hydrogen jets while the half-width of the Gaussian profiles of mass fraction were observed to spread more slowly than for room temperature hydrogen. This suggests that the mixing and models for cryogenic hydrogen may be different than for room temperature hydrogen. Results from this work were also compared to a one-dimensional (streamwise) model. Good agreement was seen in terms of temperature and mass fraction. In subsequent work a validated version of this model will be exercised to quantitatively assess the risk at hydrogen fuelling stations with cryogenic hydrogen on-site.
Optimizing Mixture Properties for Accurate Laminar Flame Speed Measurement from Spherically Expanding Flame: Application to H2/O2/N2/He Mixtures
Sep 2019
Publication
The uncertainty on the laminar flame speed extracted from spherically expanding flames can be minimized by using large flame radius data for the extrapolation to zero stretch-rate. However at large radii the hydrodynamic and thermo-diffusive instabilities induce the formation of a complex cellular flame front and limit the range of usable data. In the present study we have employed the flame stability theory of Matalon to optimize the properties of the initial mixture so that transition to cellularity may occur at a pre-determined large radius. This approach was employed to measure the laminar flame speeds of H2/O2/N2/He mixtures with equivalence ratios from 0.6 to 2.0 at pressures of 50/80/100 kPa and a temperature of 300 K. For all the performed experiments the uncertainty related to the extrapolation to zero stretch-rate (performed with the linear curvature model) was below 2% as shown by the position of the data points in the (Lb/Rf;U Lb/Rf;L) plan where Lb is the burned Markstein length; and Rf;L and Rf;U are the flame radii at the lower and upper bounds of the extrapolation range. Comparison of the predictions of four chemical mechanisms with the present unstretched laminar flame speed data indicated an error below 10% for most conditions. In addition unsteady 1-D simulations performed with A-SURF demonstrated that the flame dynamical response to stretch rate could not be captured by the mechanisms. The present work indicates that although the stability theory of Matalon provides a well defined framework to optimize the mixture properties for improved flame speed measurement the uncertainty of some of the required parameters can result in largely over-estimated critical radius for cellularity onset which compromise the accuracy of the optimization procedure.
Risk Based Safety Distances for Hydrogen Refuelling Stations
Sep 2017
Publication
This paper introduces a risk-based methodology for hydrogen refuelling stations. Momentarily four stations are present in the Netherlands. This number is expected to increase to around twenty in the next years. For these stations a quantitative risk analysis (QRA) must be carried out to account for spatial planning. The presented method identifies the loss of containment scenarios and failure frequencies. Additionally the results of this study may be used in legislative context in the form of fixed generic safety distances. Using the risk analysis tool Safeti-NL safety distances are determined for three different kinds of hydrogen refuelling stations distinguished by the supply method of the hydrogen. For the hydrogen refuelling stations a maximum safety distance of 35 m is calculated. However despite the relatively small safety distances the maximum effect distances (distance to 1% lethality) can be very large especially for stations with a supply and storage of liquid hydrogen. The research was overseen by an advisory committee which also provided technical information on the refuelling stations.
A Simple Model for Calculating Peak Pressure in Vented Explosions of Hydrogen and Hydrocarbons
Apr 2019
Publication
The authors presented a basic mathematical model for estimating peak overpressure attained in vented explosions of hydrogen in a previous study (Sinha et al. [1]). The model focussed on idealized cases of hydrogen and was not applicable for realistic accidental scenarios like presence of obstacles initial turbulent mixture etc. In the present study the underlying framework of the model is reformulated to overcome these limitations. The flame shape computations are simplified. A more accurate and simpler formulation for venting is also introduced. Further by using simplifying assumptions and algebraic manipulations the detailed model consisting of several equations is reduced to a single equation with only four parameters. Two of these parameters depend only on fuel properties and a standard table provided in the Appendix can be used. Therefore to compute the overpressure only the two parameters based on enclosure geometry need to be evaluated. This greatly simplifies the model and calculation effort. Also since the focus of previous investigation was hydrogen properties of hydrocarbon fuels which are much more widely used were not accounted for. The present model also accounts for thermo-physical properties of hydrocarbons and provides table for fuel parameters to be used in the final equation for propane and methane. The model is also improved by addition of different sub-models to account for various realistic accidental scenarios. Moreover no adjustable parameters are used; the same equation is used for all conditions and all gases. Predictions from this simplified model are compared with experimentally measured values of overpressure for hydrogen and hydrocarbons and found to be in good agreement. First the results from experiments focussing on idealized conditions of uniformly mixed fuel in an empty enclosure under quiescent conditions are considered. Further the model applicability is also tested for realistic conditions of accidental explosion consisting of obstacles inside the enclosure non-uniform fuel distribution initial turbulent mixture etc. For all the cases tested the new simple model is found to produce reasonably good predictions.
Numerical and Experimental Investigation of H2-air and H2-O2 Detonation Parameters in a 9 m Long Tube, Introduction of a New Detonation Model
Sep 2017
Publication
Experimental and numerical investigation of hydrogen-air and hydrogen-oxygen detonation parameters was performed. A new detonation model was introduced and validated against the experimental data. Experimental set-up consisted of 9 m long tube with 0.17 m in diameter where pressure was measured with piezoelectric transducers located along the channel. Numerical simulations were performed within OpenFoam code based on progress variable equation where the detonative source term accounts for autoignition effects. Autoignition delay times were computed at a simulation run-time with the use of a multivariate regression model where independent variables were: pressure temperature and fuel concentration. The dependent variable was the autoignition delay time. Range of the analyzed gaseous mixture composition varied between 20% and 50% of hydrogen-air and 50%–66% of hydrogen in oxygen. Simulations were performed using LES one-equation eddy viscosity turbulence model in 2D and 3D. Calculations were validated against experimental data.
A New Approach to Vented Deflagration Modeling
Sep 2017
Publication
In the present work CFD simulations of a hydrogen deflagration experiment are performed. The experiment carried out by KIT was conducted in a 1 m3 enclosure with a square vent of 0.5 m2 located in the center of one of its walls. The enclosure was filled with homogeneous hydrogen-air mixture of 18% v/v before ignition at its back-wall. As the flame propagates away from the ignition point unburned mixture is forced out through the vent. This mixture is ignited when the flame passes through the vent initiating a violent external explosion which leads to a rapid increase in pressure. The work focuses on the modeling of the external explosion phenomenon. A new approach is proposed in order to predict with accuracy the strength of external explosions using Large Eddy Simulation. The new approach introduces new relations to account for the interaction between the turbulence and the flame front. CFD predictions of the pressure inside and outside the enclosure and of the flame front shape are compared against experimental measurements. The comparison indicates a much better performance of the new approach compared to the initial model.
The Residual Strength of Automotive Hydrogen Cylinders After Exposure to Flames
Sep 2017
Publication
Fuel cell vehicles and some compressed natural gas vehicles are equipped with carbon fiber reinforced plastic (CFRP) composite cylinders. Each of the cylinders has a pressure relief device designed to detect heat and release the internal gas to prevent the cylinder from bursting in a vehicle fire accident. Yet in some accident situations the fire may be extinguished before the pressure relief device is activated leaving the high-pressure fuel gas inside the fire-damaged cylinder. To handle such a cylinder safely after an accident it is necessary that the cylinder keeps a sufficient post-fire strength against its internal gas pressure but in most cases it is difficult to accurately determine cylinder strength at the accident site. One way of solving this problem is to predetermine the post-fire burst strengths of cylinders by experiments. In this study automotive CFRP cylinders having no pressure relief device were exposed to a fire to the verge of bursting; then after the fire was extinguished the residual burst strengths and the overall physical state of the test cylinders were examined. The results indicated that the test cylinders all recorded a residual burst strength at least twice greater than their internal gas pressure for tested cylinders with new cylinder burst to nominal working pressure in the range 2.67–4.92 above the regulated ratio of 2.25.
Simulation-based Safety Investigation of a Hydrogen Fueling Station with an On-site Hydrogen Production System Involving Methylcyclohexane
Jan 2017
Publication
Adequate safety measures are crucial for preventing major accidents at hydrogen fuelling stations. In particular risk analysis of the domino effect at hydrogen fuelling stations is essential because knock-on accidents are likely to intensify the consequences of a relatively small incident. Several risk assessment studies have focused on hydrogen fuelling stations but none have investigated accidental scenarios related to the domino effect at such stations. Therefore the purpose of this study is to identify a domino effect scenario analyze the scenario by using simulations and propose safety measures for preventing and mitigating of the scenario. In this hazard identification study we identified the domino effect scenario of a hydrogen fuelling station with an on-site hydrogen production system involving methylcyclohexane and investigated through simulations of the scenario. The simulations revealed that a pool fire of methylcyclohexane or toluene can damage the process equipment and that thermal radiation may cause the pressurized hydrogen tanks to rupture. The rupture-type vent system can serve as a critical safety measure for preventing and mitigating the examined scenario.
Understanding and Mitigating Hydrogen Embrittlement of Steels: A Review of Experimental, Modelling and Design Progress from Atomistic to Continuum
Feb 2018
Publication
Hydrogen embrittlement is a complex phenomenon involving several lengthand timescales that affects a large class of metals. It can significantly reduce the ductility and load-bearing capacity and cause cracking and catastrophic brittle failures at stresses below the yield stress of susceptible materials. Despite a large research effort in attempting to understand the mechanisms of failure and in developing potential mitigating solutions hydrogen embrittlement mechanisms are still not completely understood. There are controversial opinions in the literature regarding the underlying mechanisms and related experimental evidence supporting each of these theories. The aim of this paper is to provide a detailed review up to the current state of the art on the effect of hydrogen on the degradation of metals with a particular focus on steels. Here we describe the effect of hydrogen in steels from the atomistic to the continuum scale by reporting theoretical evidence supported by quantum calculation and modern experimental characterisation methods macroscopic effects that influence the mechanical properties of steels and established damaging mechanisms for the embrittlement of steels. Furthermore we give an insight into current approaches and new mitigation strategies used to design new steels resistant to hydrogen embrittlement.<br/>*Correction published see Supplements section
Hydrogen Dispersion in a Closed Environment
Sep 2017
Publication
The highly combustible nature of hydrogen poses a great hazard creating a number of problems with its safety and handling. As a part of safety studies related to the use of hydrogen in a confined environment it is extremely important to have a good knowledge of the dispersion mechanism.<br/>The present work investigates the concentration field and flammability envelope from a small scale leak. The hydrogen is released into a 0.47 m × 0.33 m x 0.20 m enclosure designed as a 1/15 – scale model of a room in a nuclear facility. The performed tests evaluates the influence of the initial conditions at the leakage source on the dispersion and mixing characteristics in a confined environment. The role of the leak location and the presence of obstacles are also analyzed. Throughout the test during the release and the subsequent dispersion phase temporal profiles of hydrogen concentration are measured using thermal conductivity gauges within the enclosure. In addition the BOS (Background Oriented Schlieren) technique is used to visualise the cloud evolution inside the enclosure. These instruments allow the observation and quantification of the stratification effects.
Performance Evaluation of Empirical Models for Vented Lean Hydrogen Explosions
Sep 2017
Publication
Explosion venting is a method commonly used to prevent or minimize damage to an enclosure caused by an accidental explosion. An estimate of the maximum overpressure generated though explosion is an important parameter in the design of the vents. Various engineering models (Bauwens et al. 2012 Molkov and Bragin 2015) and European (EN 14994 ) and USA standards (NFPA 68) are available to predict such overpressure. In this study their performance is evaluated using a number of published experiments. Comparison of pressure predictions from various models have also been carried out for the recent experiments conducted by GexCon using a 20 feet ISO container. The results show that the model of Bauwens et al. (2012) predicts well for hydrogen concentration between 16% and 21% and in the presence of obstacles. The model of Molkov et al. (2015) is found to work well for hydrogen concentrations between 10% and 30% without obstacles. In the presence of obstacles as no guidelines are given to set the coefficient for obstacles in the model it was necessary to tune the coefficient to match the experimental data. The predictions of the formulas in NFPA 68 show a large scatter across different tests. The current version of both EN 14994 and NFPA 68 are found to have very limited range of applicability and can hardly be used for vent sizing of hydrogen-air deflagrations. Overall the accuracy of all the engineering models was found to be limited. Some recommendations concerning their applicability will be given for vented lean-hydrogen explosion concentrations of interest to practical applications.
Non-steady Characteristics of Dispersion and Ignitability for High-pressurized Hydrogen Jet Discharged From a Pinhole
Sep 2017
Publication
Hydrogen gas concentrations and jet velocities were measured downstream by a high response speed flame ionization detector and PIV (Particle Image Velocimetry) in order to investigate the characteristics of dispersion and ignitability for 40–82 MPa high-pressurized hydrogen jet discharged from a nozzle with 0.2 mm diameter. The light emitted from both OH radical and water vapor species yielded from hydrogen combustion ignited by an electric spark were recorded by two high speed cameras. From the results the empirical formula concerning the relationships for time-averaged concentrations concentration fluctuations and ignition probability were obtained to suggest that they would be independent of hydrogen discharge pressure.
Response Time Measurement of Hydrogen Sensors
Sep 2017
Publication
The efficiency of gas sensor application for facilitating the safe use of hydrogen depends considerably on the sensor response to a change in hydrogen concentration. Therefore the response time has been measured for five different-type commercially available hydrogen sensors. Experiments showed that all these sensors surpass the ISO 26142 standard; for the response times t90 values of 2 s to 16 s were estimated. Results can be fitted with an exponential or sigmoidal function. It can be demonstrated that the results on transient behaviour depend on both the operating parameters of sensors and investigation methods as well as on the experimental conditions: gas change rate and concentration jump.
Ignited Releases of Liquid Hydrogen
Jan 2014
Publication
If the hydrogen economy is to progress more hydrogen fuelling stations are required. In the short term in the absence of a hydrogen distribution network these fuelling stations will have to be supplied by liquid hydrogen (LH2) road tanker. Such a development will increase the number of tanker offloading operations significantly and these may need to be performed in close proximity to the general public.<br/>Several research projects have been undertaken already at HSL with the aim of identifying and addressing hazards relating to the storage and transport of bulk LH2 that are associated with hydrogen refuelling stations located in urban environments.<br/>The first phase of the research was to produce a position paper on the hazards of LH2 (Pritchard and Rattigan 2009). This was published as an HSE research report RR769 in 2010. <br/>The second phase developed an experimental and modelling strategy for issues associated with LH2 spills and was published as an internal report HSL XS/10/06. The subsequent experimental work is a direct implementation of that strategy. LH2 was first investigated experimentally (Royle and Willoughby 2012 HSL XS/11/70) as large-scale spills of LH2 at a rate of 60 litres per minute. Measurements were made on unignited releases which included the concentration of hydrogen in air thermal gradients in the concrete substrate liquid pool formation and temperatures within the pool. Computational modelling on the un-ignited spills was also performed (Batt and Webber 2012 HSL MSU/12/01).<br/>The experimental work on ignited releases of LH2 detailed in this report is a direct continuation of the work performed by Royle and Willoughby.<br/>The aim of this work was to determine the hazards and severity of a realistic ignited spill of LH2 focussing on; flammability limits of an LH2 vapour cloud flame speeds through an LH2 vapour cloud and subsequent radiative heat and overpressures after ignition. The results of the experimentation will inform the wider hydrogen community and contribute to the development of more robust modelling tools. The results will also help to update and develop guidance for codes and standards.
Test Methodologies for Hydrogen Sensor Performance Assessment: Chamber vs. Flow-through Test Apparatus
Sep 2017
Publication
Certification of hydrogen sensors to meet standards often prescribes using large-volume test chambers. However feedback from stakeholders such as sensor manufacturers and end-users indicates that chamber test methods are often viewed as too slow and expensive for routine assessment. Flow-through test methods are potentially an efficient and cost-effective alternative for sensor performance assessment. A large number of sensors can be simultaneously tested in series or in parallel with an appropriate flow-through test fixture. The recent development of sensors with response times of less than 1s mandates improvements in equipment and methodology to properly capture the performance of this new generation of fast sensors; flow methods are a viable approach for accurate response and recovery time determinations but there are potential drawbacks. According to ISO 26142 flow-through test methods may not properly simulate ambient applications. In chamber test methods gas transport to the sensor is dominated by diffusion which is viewed by some users as mimicking deployment in rooms and other confined spaces. Conversely in flow-through methods forced flow transports the gas to the sensing element. The advective flow dynamics may induce changes in the sensor behaviour relative to the quasi-quiescent condition that may prevail in chamber test methods. The aim of the current activity in the JRC and NREL sensor laboratories is to develop a validated flow-through apparatus and methods for hydrogen sensor performance testing. In addition to minimizing the impact on sensor behaviour induced by differences in flow dynamics challenges associated with flow-through methods include the ability to control environmental parameters (humidity pressure and temperature) during the test and changes in the test gas composition induced by chemical reactions with upstream sensors. Guidelines on flow-through test apparatus design and protocols for the evaluation of hydrogen sensor performance have been developed. Various commercial sensor platforms (e.g. thermal conductivity catalytic and metal semiconductor) were used to demonstrate the advantages and issues with the flow-through methodology.
The Hydrogen Economy - Evaluation of the Materials Science and Engineering Issues
Jan 2005
Publication
The main objectives were to identify materials issues relating to the widespread use of hydrogen as a fuel.
MAIN FINDINGS
MAIN FINDINGS
- Hydrogen is seen by many as the answer to the environmental problems of reliance on fossil fuels for energy needs. A great deal of effort is currently being invested in research into all areas of the hydrogen economy such as fuel cells hydrogen generation transportation and storage.
- Fuel cells have the potential to provide power for a very wide range of applications ranging from small portable electronics devices to large stationary electricity production and vehicles covering the whole range of road vehicles and possibly extending to rail marine and even aviation.
- The main obstacles to achieving a viable hydrogen economy are costs of producing hydrogen from renewable sources issues relating to transportation and storage due to the low energy density of hydrogen gas and the cost and reliability of fuel cells.
- The main material considerations relating to the use of hydrogen are hydrogen embrittlement material properties at cryogenic temperatures (due to use of liquid hydrogen) and permeability.
- A number of new materials are likely to come to prominence in a hydrogen economy; high performance composites are likely to be used extensively for high pressure hydrogen cylinders new materials or combinations of materials may be used for hydrogen pipelines and a range of new materials are currently being considered for hydrogen storage such as metal hydrides and carbon nanotubes.
- Due to the effect of hydrogen on materials it is important to test any materials in the environment in which they would be used. Depending on the type of test this could require the use of very specialist expensive equipment.
Leakage-type-based Analysis of Accidents Involving Hydrogen Fueling Stations in Japan and USA
Aug 2016
Publication
To identify the safety issues associated with hydrogen fuelling stations incidents at such stations in Japan and the USA were analyzed considering the regulations in these countries. Leakage due to the damage and fracture of main bodies of apparatuses and pipes in Japan and the USA is mainly caused by design error that is poorly planned fatigue. Considering the present incidents in these countries adequate consideration of the usage environment in the design is very important. Leakage from flanges valves and seals in Japan is mainly caused by screw joints. If welded joints are to be used in hydrogen fuelling stations in Japan strength data for welded parts should be obtained and pipe thicknesses should be reduced. Leakage due to other factors e.g. external impact in Japan and the USA is mainly caused by human error. To realize self-serviced hydrogen fuelling stations safety measures should be developed to prevent human error by fuel cell vehicle users.
Hot Surface Ignition in Flowing Streams of Hydrogen-Air Mixtures
Sep 2019
Publication
A set of original experiments is presented covering the topic of hydrogen-air mixture ignition by a hot surface. The hot surface is a 30 mm long/10 mm diameter heated coil which temperature is controlled by IR techniques. The coil is placed into the flowing stream of hydrogen air mixtures. The variable parameters are the composition of the flammable atmosphere (4 to 75% H2 v/v) the flow speed (from 0.5 m/s to 30 m/s) and its temperature (from -110°C to ambient). The experimental techniques and results are presented and a tentative interpretation is proposed based on ignition theories and highspeed video recordings. It is shown that the ignition temperature (600°C) is insensitive to flowing conditions which is a very unexpected result.
A Comparison Study into Low Leak Rate Buoyant Gas Dispersion in a Small Fuel Cell Enclosure Using Plain and Louvre Vent Passive Ventilation Schemes
Sep 2017
Publication
The development of a ‘Hydrogen Economy’ will see hydrogen fuel cells used in transportation and the generation of power for buildings as part of a decentralised grid with low power units used in domestic and commercial environmental situations. Low power fuel cells will be housed in small protective enclosures which must be ventilated to prevent a build-up of hydrogen gas produced during normal fuel cell operation or a supply pipework leak. Hydrogen’s flammable range (4-75%) is a significant safety concern. With poor enclosure ventilation a low-level leak (below 10 lpm) could quickly create a flammable mixture with potential for an explosion. Mechanical ventilation is effective at managing enclosure hydrogen concentrations but drains fuel cell power and is vulnerable to failure. In many applications (e.g. low power and remote installation) this is undesirable and reliable passive ventilation systems are preferred. Passive ventilation depends upon buoyancy driven flow with the size and shape of ventilation openings critical for producing predictable flows and maintaining low buoyant gas concentrations. Environmentally installed units use louvre vents to protect the fuel cell but the performance of these vents compared to plain vertical vents is not clear. Comparison small enclosure tests of ‘same opening area’ louvre and plain vents with leak rates from 1 to 10 lpm were conducted. A displacement ventilation arrangement was installed on the test enclosure with upper and lower opposing openings. Helium gas was released from a 4mm nozzle at the base of the enclosure to simulate a hydrogen leak. The tests determined that louvre vents increased average enclosure hydrogen concentrations by approximately 10% across the leak range tested but regulated the flow. The test data was used in a SolidWorks CFD simulation model validation exercise. The model provided a good qualitative representation of the flow behaviour but under predicted average concentrations.
Development of a Realistic Hydrogen Flammable Atmosphere Inside a 4-m3 Enclosure
Sep 2017
Publication
To define a strategy of mitigation for containerized hydrogen systems (fuel cells for example) against explosion the main characteristics of flammable atmosphere (size concentration turbulence…) shall be well-known. This article presents an experimental study on accidental hydrogen releases and dispersion into an enclosure of 4 m3 (2 m x 2 m x 1 m). Different release points are studied: two circular releases of 1 and 3 mm and a system to create ring-shaped releases. The releases are operated with a pressure between 10 and 40 bars in order to be close to the process conditions. Different positions of the release inside the enclosure i.e. centred on the floor or along a wall are also studied. A specific effort is made to characterize the turbulence in the enclosure during the releases. The objectives of the experimental study are to understand and quantify the mechanisms of formation of the explosive atmosphere taking into account the geometry and position of the release point and the confinement. Those experimental data are analyzed and compared with existing models and could bring some new elements to improve them.
The Role of the Flow Field Generated by Venting Process on the Pressure Time History of a Vented Deflagration
Sep 2017
Publication
Vented deflagrations are one of the most challenging phenomenon to be replicated numerically in order to predict its resulting pressure time history. As a matter of fact a number of different phenomena can contribute to modify the burning velocity of a gas mixture undergoing a deflagration especially when the flame velocity is considerably lower than the speed of sound. In these conditions acceleration generated by both the flow field induced by the expanding flame and from discontinuities as the vent opening and the venting of the combustion products affect the burning velocity and the burning behaviour of the flame. In particular the phenomena affecting the pressure time history of a deflagration after the flame front reaches the vent area such as flame acoustic interaction and local pressure peaks seem to be closely related to a change in the burning behaviour induced by the venting process. Flame acoustic interaction and local pressure peaks arise as a consequence of the change in the burning behaviour of the flame. This paper analyses the video recording of the flame front produced during the TP experimental campaign performed by UNIPI in the project HySEA to analyse qualitatively the contribution of the generated flow field in a vented deflagration in its pressure-time history.
Numerical study of the release and dispersion of a light gas using 3D CFD code GASFLOW-MPI
Sep 2017
Publication
With the development of the hydrogen economy it requires a better understanding of the potential for fires and explosions associated with the unintended release of hydrogen within a partially confined space. In order to mitigate the hydrogen fire and explosion risks effectively accurate predictions of the hydrogen transport and mixing processes are crucial. It is well known that turbulence modelling is one of the key elements for a successful simulation of gas mixing and transport. GASFLOW-MPI is a scalable CFD software solution used to predict fluid dynamics conjugate heat and mass transfer chemical kinetics aerosol transportation and other related phenomena. In order to capture more turbulence information the Large Eddy Simulation (LES) model and LES/RANS hybrid model Detached Eddy Simulation (DES) have been implemented and validated in 3-D CFD code GASFLOW-MPI. The standard Smagorisky SGS model is utilized in LES turbulence model. And the k-epsilon based DES model is employed. This paper assesses the capability of algebraic k-epsilon DES and LES turbulence model to simulate the mixing and transport behavior of highly buoyant gases in a partially confined geometry. Simulation results agree well with the overall trend measured in experiments conducted in a reduced scale enclosure with idealized leaks which shows that all these four turbulent models are validated and suitable for the simulation of light gas behavior. Furthermore the numerical results also indicate that the LES and DES model could be used to analysis the turbulence behavior in the hydrogen safety problems.
On the Response of a Lean-premixed Hydrogen Combustor to Acoustic and Dissipative-dispersive Entropy Waves
May 2019
Publication
Combustion of hydrogen or hydrogen containing blends in gas turbines and industrial combustors can activate thermoacoustic combustion instabilities. Convective instabilities are an important and yet less investigated class of combustion instability that are caused by the so called “entropy waves”. As a major shortcoming the partial decay of these convective-diffusive waves in the post-flame region of combustors is still largely unexplored. This paper therefore presents an investigation of the annihilating effects due to hydrodynamics heat transfer and flow stretch upon the nozzle response. The classical compact analysis is first extended to include the decay of entropy waves and heat transfer from the nozzle. Amplitudes and phase shifts of the responding acoustical waves are then calculated for subcritical and supercritical nozzles subject to acoustic and entropic forcing. A relation for the stretch of entropy wave in the nozzle is subsequently developed. It is shown that heat transfer and hydrodynamic decay can impart considerable effects on the entropic response of the nozzle. It is further shown that the flow stretching effects are strongly frequency dependent. The results indicate that dissipation and dispersion of entropy waves can significantly influence their conversion to sound and therefore should be included in the entropy wave models.
Evaluating Uncertainty in Accident Rate Estimation at Hydrogen Refueling Station Using Time Correlation Model
Nov 2018
Publication
Hydrogen as a future energy carrier is receiving a significant amount of attention in Japan. From the viewpoint of safety risk evaluation is required in order to increase the number of hydrogen refuelling stations (HRSs) implemented in Japan. Collecting data about accidents in the past will provide a hint to understand the trend in the possibility of accidents occurrence by identifying its operation time However in new technology; accident rate estimation can have a high degree of uncertainty due to absence of major accident direct data in the late operational period. The uncertainty in the estimation is proportional to the data unavailability which increases over long operation period due to decrease in number of stations. In this paper a suitable time correlation model is adopted in the estimation to reflect lack (due to the limited operation period of HRS) or abundance of accident data which is not well supported by conventional approaches. The model adopted in this paper shows that the uncertainty in the estimation increases when the operation time is long owing to the decreasing data.
Syngas Explosion Reactivity in Steam Methane Reforming Process
Sep 2013
Publication
During the synthesis of hydrogen by methane steam reforming mixtures composed of H2 CH4 CO and CO2 are produced in the process. In this work the explosion reactivity of these mixtures on the basis of detonation cell size and laminar flame speed is calculated using a reactant assimilation simplification and a kinetic approach. The detonation cells width are calculated using the Cell_CH Kurchatov institute method and the laminar flame velocities are calculated with Chemkin Premix using different detailed chemical kinetic mechanisms. These calculations are used to define if these mixtures could be considered having a medium or a high reactivity for risk assessment in case of leak in the hydrogen plants.
Investigation of Turbulent Premixed Methane/Air and Hydrogen-enriched Methane/Air Flames in a Laboratory-scale Gas Turbine Model Combustor
Feb 2021
Publication
Methane and hydrogen-enriched (25 vol% and 50 vol% H2 -enriched CH4) methane/air premixed flames were investigated in a gas turbine model combustor under atmospheric conditions. The flame operability ranges were mapped at different Reynold numbers (Re) showing the dependence on Re and H2 concentrations. The effects of equivalence ratio (Φ) Re and H2 enrichment on flame structure were examined employing OH-PLIF measurement. For CH4/air cases the flame was stabilized with an M shape; while for H2 -enriched cases the flame transitions to a П shape above a specific Φ. This transition was observed to influence significantly the flashback limits. The flame shape transition is most likely a result of H2 enrichment occurring due to the increase in flame speed higher resistance of the flame to the strain rate and change in the inner recirculation zone. Flow fields of CH4/air flames were compared between low and high Re cases employing high-speed PIV. The flashback events led by two mechanisms (combustion-induced vortex breakdown CIVB and boundary-layer flashback BLF) were observed and recorded using high-speed OH chemiluminescence imaging. It was found that the CIVB flashback occurred only for CH4 flames with M shape whereas the BLF occurs for all H2 -enriched flames with П shape.
Flammability Reduction in a Pressurised Water Electrolyser Based on a Thin Polymer Electrolyte Membrane through a Pt-alloy Catalytic Approach
Jan 2019
Publication
Various Pt-based materials (unsupported Pt PtRu PtCo) were investigated as catalysts for recombining hydrogen and oxygen back into water. The recombination performance correlated well with the surface Pt metallic state. Alloying cobalt to platinum was observed to produce an electron transfer favouring the occurrence of a large fraction of the Pt metallic state on the catalyst surface. Unsupported PtCo showed both excellent recombination performance and dynamic behaviour. In a packed bed catalytic reactor when hydrogen was fed at 4% vol. in the oxygen stream (flammability limit) 99.5% of the total H2 content was immediately converted to water in the presence of PtCo thus avoiding safety issues. The PtCo catalyst was thus integrated in the anode of the membrane-electrode assembly of a polymer electrolyte membrane electrolysis cell. This catalyst showed good capability to reduce the concentration of hydrogen in the oxygen stream under differential pressure operation (1–20 bar) in the presence of a thin (90 μm) Aquivion® membrane. The modified system showed lower hydrogen concentration in the oxygen flow than electrolysis cells based on state-of-the-art thick polymer electrolyte membranes and allowed to expand the minimum current density load down to 0.15 A cm−2 . This was mainly due to the electrochemical oxidation of permeated H2 to protons that were transported back to the cathode. The electrolysis cell equipped with a dual layer PtCo/IrRuOx oxidation catalyst achieved a high operating current density (3 A cm−2 ) as requested to decrease the system capital costs under high efficiency conditions (about 77% efficiency at 55 °C and 20 bar). Moreover the electrolysis system showed reduced probability to reach the flammability limit under both high differential pressure (20 bar) and partial load operation (5%) as needed to properly address grid-balancing service
H21- Phase 1 Technical Summary Report
May 2021
Publication
The UK Government signed legislation on 27th June 2019 committing the UK to a legally binding target of Net Zero emissions by 2050. Climate change is one of the most significant technical economic social and business challenges facing the world today.
The H21 NIC Phase 1 project delivered an optimally designed experimentation and testing programme supported by the HSE Science Division and DNV GL with the aim to collect quantifiable evidence to support that the UK distribution network of 2032 will be comparably as safe operating on 100% hydrogen as it currently is on
natural gas. This innovative project begins to fill critical safety evidence gaps surrounding the conversion of the UK gas network to 100% hydrogen. This will facilitate progression towards H21 Phase 2 Operational Safety Demonstrations and the H21 Phase 3 Live Trials to promote customer acceptability and ultimately aid progress towards a government policy decision on heat.
DNV GL and HSE Science Division were engaged to undertake the experimentation testing and QRA update programme of work. DNV GL and HSE Science Division also peer reviewed each other’s programme of work at various stages throughout the project undertaking a challenge and review of the experimental data and results to provide confidence in the conclusions.
A strategic set of tests was designed to cover the range of assets represented across the Great Britain gas distribution networks. The assets used in the testing were mostly recovered from the distribution network as part of the ongoing Iron Mains Risk Reduction Replacement Programme. Controlled testing against a well-defined master testing plan with both natural gas and 100% hydrogen was then undertaken to provide the quantitative evidence to forecast any change to background leakage levels in a 100% hydrogen network.
Key Findings from Phase 1a:
The H21 NIC Phase 1 project delivered an optimally designed experimentation and testing programme supported by the HSE Science Division and DNV GL with the aim to collect quantifiable evidence to support that the UK distribution network of 2032 will be comparably as safe operating on 100% hydrogen as it currently is on
natural gas. This innovative project begins to fill critical safety evidence gaps surrounding the conversion of the UK gas network to 100% hydrogen. This will facilitate progression towards H21 Phase 2 Operational Safety Demonstrations and the H21 Phase 3 Live Trials to promote customer acceptability and ultimately aid progress towards a government policy decision on heat.
DNV GL and HSE Science Division were engaged to undertake the experimentation testing and QRA update programme of work. DNV GL and HSE Science Division also peer reviewed each other’s programme of work at various stages throughout the project undertaking a challenge and review of the experimental data and results to provide confidence in the conclusions.
A strategic set of tests was designed to cover the range of assets represented across the Great Britain gas distribution networks. The assets used in the testing were mostly recovered from the distribution network as part of the ongoing Iron Mains Risk Reduction Replacement Programme. Controlled testing against a well-defined master testing plan with both natural gas and 100% hydrogen was then undertaken to provide the quantitative evidence to forecast any change to background leakage levels in a 100% hydrogen network.
Key Findings from Phase 1a:
- Of the 215 assets tested 41 of them were found to leak 19 of them provided sufficient data to be able to compare hydrogen and methane leak rates.
- The tests showed that assets that were gas tight on methane were also gas tight on hydrogen. Assets that leaked on hydrogen also leaked
- on methane including repaired assets.
- The ratio of the hydrogen to methane volumetric leak rates varied between 1.1 and 2.2 which is largely consistent with the bounding values expected for laminar and turbulent (or inertial) flow which gave ratios of 1.2 and 2.8 respectively.
- None of the PE assets leaked; cast ductile and spun iron leaked to a similar degree (around 26-29% of all iron assets leaked) and the proportion of leaking steel assets was slightly less (14%).
- Four types of joint were responsible for most of the leaks on joints: screwed lead yarn bolted gland and hook bolts.
- All of the repairs that sealed methane leaks also were effective when tested with hydrogen.
Research Efforts for the Resolution of Hydrogen Risk
Jan 2015
Publication
During the past 10 years the Korea Atomic Energy Research Institute (KAERI) has performed a study to control hydrogen gas in the containment of the nuclear power plants. Before the Fukushima accident analytical activities for gas distribution analysis in experiments and plants were primarily conducted using a multidimensional code: the GASFLOW. After the Fukushima accident the COM3D code which can simulate a multi-dimensional hydrogen explosion was introduced in 2013 to complete the multidimensional hydrogen analysis system. The code validation efforts of the multidimensional codes of the GASFLOW and the COM3D have continued to increase confidence in the use of codes using several international experimental data. The OpenFOAM has been preliminarily evaluated for APR1400 containment based on experience from coded validation and the analysis of hydrogen distribution and explosion using the multidimensional codes the GASFLOW and the COM3D. Hydrogen safety in nuclear power has become a much more important issue after the Fukushima event in which hydrogen explosions occurred. The KAERI is preparing a large-scale test that can be used to validate the performance of domestic passive autocatalytic recombiners (PARs) and can provide data for the validation of the severe accident code being developed in Korea
ZnO@ZIF-8 Core-Shell Structure Gas Sensors with Excellent Selectivity to H2
Jun 2021
Publication
As the energy crisis becomes worse hydrogen as a clean energy source is more and more widely used in industrial production and people’s daily life. However there are hidden dangers in hydrogen storage and transportation because of its flammable and explosive features. Gas detection is the key to solving this problem. High quality sensors with more practical and commercial value must be able to accurately detect target gases in the environment. Emerging porous metal-organic framework (MOF) materials can effectively improve the selectivity of sensors as a result of high surface area and coordinated pore structure. The application of MOFs for surface modification to improve the selectivity and sensitivity of metal oxides sensors to hydrogen has been widely investigated. However the influence of MOF modified film thickness on the selectivity of hydrogen sensors is seldom studied. Moreover the mechanism of the selectivity improvement of the sensors with MOF modified film is still unclear. In this paper we prepared nano-sized ZnO particles by a homogeneous precipitation method. ZnO nanoparticle (NP) gas sensors were prepared by screen printing technology. Then a dense ZIF-8 film was grown on the surface of the gas sensor by hydrothermal synthesis. The morphology the composition of the elements and the characters of the product were analyzed by X-ray diffraction analysis (XRD) transmission electron microscope (TEM) scanning electron microscope (SEM) energy dispersive spectrometer (EDS) Brunauer-Emmett-Teller (BET) and differential scanning calorimetry (DSC). It is found that the ZIF-8 film grown for 4 h cannot form a dense core-shell structure. The thickness of ZIF-8 reaches 130 nm at 20 h. Through the detection and analysis of hydrogen (1000 ppm) ethanol (100 ppm) and acetone (50 ppm) from 150 °C to 290 °C it is found that the response of the ZnO@ZIF-8 sensors to hydrogen has been significantly improved while the response to ethanol and acetone was decreased. By comparing the change of the response coefficient when the thickness of ZIF-8 is 130 nm the gas sensor has a significantly improved selectivity to hydrogen at 230 °C. The continuous increase of the thickness tends to inhibit selectivity. The mechanism of selectivity improvement of the sensors with different thickness of the ZIF-8 films is discussed.
Advanced Polymeric/inorganic Nanohybrids: An Integrated Platform for Gas Sensing Applications
Jan 2022
Publication
Rapid industrial development vehicles domestic activities and mishandling of garbage are the main sources of pollutants which are destroying the atmosphere. There is a need to continuously monitor these pollutants for the safety of the environment and human beings. Conventional instruments for monitoring of toxic gases are expensive bigger in size and time-consuming. Hybrid materials containing organic and inorganic components are considered potential candidates for diverse applications including gas sensing. Gas sensors convert the information regarding the analyte into signals. Various polymeric/inorganic nanohybrids have been used for the sensing of toxic gases. Composites of different polymeric materials like polyaniline (PANI) poly (4-styrene sulfonate) (PSS) poly (34-ethylene dioxythiophene) (PEDOT) etc. with various metal/metal oxide nanoparticles have been reported as sensing materials for gas sensors because of their unique redox features conductivity and facile operation at room temperature. Polymeric nanohybrids showed better performance because of the larger surface area of nanohybrids and the synergistic effect between polymeric and inorganic materials. This review article focuses on the recent developments of emerging polymeric/inorganic nanohybrids for sensing various toxic gases including ammonia hydrogen nitrogen dioxide carbon oxides and liquefied petroleum gas. Advantages disadvantages operating conditions and prospects of hybrid composites have also been discussed.
Analysis of the Environmental Degradation Effects on the Cables of “La Arena” Bridge (Spain)
Sep 2017
Publication
After nearly 25 years of service some of the wires of the tendons of “La Arena” bridge (Spain) started to exhibit the effects of environmental degradation processes. “La Arena” is cable-stayed bridge with 6 towers and a reference span between towers of about 100 meters. After a maintenance inspection of the bridge evidences of corrosion were detected in some of the galvanized wires of the cables. A more in-deep analysis of these wires revealed that many of them exhibited loss of section due to the corrosion process. In order to clarify the causes of this degradation event and to suggest some remedial actions an experimental program was designed. This program consisted of tensile and fatigue tests on some strand samples of the bridge together with a fractographic analysis of the fracture surfaces of the wires its galvanized layer thickness and some hydrogen measurements (hydrogen embrittlement could be another effect of the environmental degradation process).Once the type and extension of the flaws in the wires was characterized a structural integrity assessment of the strands was performed with the aim of quantifying the margins until failure and establishing some maintenance recommendations.
Hydrogen Jet Fire from a Thermally Activated Pressure Relief Device (TPRD) from Onboard Storage in a Naturally Ventilated Covered Car Park
Aug 2021
Publication
Hydrogen jet fires from a thermally activated pressure relief device (TPRD) on onboard storage are considered for a vehicle in a naturally ventilated covered car park. Computational Fluid Dynamics was used to predict behaviour of ignited releases from a 70 MPa tank into a naturally ventilated covered car park. Releases through TPRD diameters 3.34 2 and 0.5 mm were studied to understand effect on hazard distances from the vehicle. A vertical release and downward releases at 0° 30° and 45° for TPRD diameters 2 and 0.5 mm were considered accounting for tank blowdown. direction of a downward release was found to significantly contribute to decrease of temperature in a hot cloud under the ceiling. Whilst the ceiling is reached by a jet exceeding 300 °C for a release through a TPRD of 2 mm for inclinations of either 0° 30° or 45° an ignited release through a TPRD of 0.5 mm and angle of 45° did not produce a cloud with a temperature above 300 °C at the ceiling during blowdown. The research findings specifically regarding the extent of the cloud of hot gasses have implications for the design of mechanical ventilation systems.
Role of Grain Boundaries in Hydrogen Embrittlement of Alloy 725: Single and Bi-crystal Microcantilever Bending Study
Jan 2022
Publication
In situ electrochemical microcantilever bending tests were conducted in this study to investigate the role of grain boundaries (GBs) in hydrogen embrittlement (HE) of Alloy 725. Specimens were prepared under three different heat treatment conditions and denoted as solution-annealed (SA) aged (AG) and over-aged (OA) samples. For single-crystal beams in an H-containing environment all three heat-treated samples exhibited crack formation and propagation; however crack propagation was more severe in the OA sample. The anodic extraction of H presented similar results as those under the H-free condition indicating the reversibility of the H effect under the tested conditions. Bi-crystal micro-cantilevers bent under H-free and H-charged conditions revealed the significant role of the GB in the HE of the beams. The results indicated that the GB in the SA sample facilitated dislocation dissipation whereas for the OA sample it caused the retardation of crack propagation. For the AG sample testing in an H-containing environment led to the formation of a sharp severe crack along the GB path.
No more items...