Germany
Hydrogen from Waste Gasification
Feb 2024
Publication
Hydrogen is a versatile energy vector for a plethora of applications; nevertheless its production from waste/residues is often overlooked. Gasification and subsequent conversion of the raw synthesis gas to hydrogen are an attractive alternative to produce renewable hydrogen. In this paper recent developments in R&D on waste gasification (municipal solid waste tires plastic waste) are summarised and an overview about suitable gasification processes is given. A literature survey indicated that a broad span of hydrogen relates to productivity depending on the feedstock ranging from 15 to 300 g H2/kg of feedstock. Suitable gas treatment (upgrading and separation) is also covered presenting both direct and indirect (chemical looping) concepts. Hydrogen production via gasification offers a high productivity potential. However regulations like frame conditions or subsidies are necessary to bring the technology into the market.
The Effects of Hydrogen Research and Innovation on International Hydrogen Trade
Feb 2024
Publication
Climate change and the pressure to decarbonize as well as energy security concerns have drawn the attention of policymakers and the industry to hydrogen energy. To advance the hydrogen economy at a global scale research and innovation progress is of significant importance among others. However previous studies have provided only limited quantitative evidence of the effects of research and innovation on the formation of a global hydrogen market. Instead they postulate rather than empirically support this relationship. Therefore this study analyzes the effects of research and innovation measured by scientific publications patents and standards on bilateral hydrogen trade flows for 32 countries between 1995 and 2019 in a gravity model of trade using regression analyses and Poisson Pseudo Maximum Likelihood (PPML) estimation. The main results of the PPML estimation show that research and innovation progress is indeed associated with increased trade especially with patenting and (international) standardization enhancing hydrogen export volumes. As policy implications we derive that increased public R&D funding can help increase the competitiveness of hydrogen energy and boost market growth along with infrastructure support and harmonized standards and regulations.
What will be the Hydrogen and Power Demands of the Process Industry in a Climate-neutral Germany?
Apr 2024
Publication
The defossilization of industry has far-reaching implications regarding the future demand for hydrogen and other forms of energy. This paper presents and applies a fundamental bottom-up model that relies on techno-economic data of industrial production processes. Its aim is to identify across a range of scenarios the most cost-effective low-carbon options considering a variety of production systems. Subsequently it derives the hydrogen and electricity demand that would result from the implementation of these least-cost low-carbon options in process industries in Germany. Aligning with the German government's target year for achieving climate neutrality this study’s reference year is 2045. The primary contribution lies in analyzing which hydrogen-based and direct electrification solutions would be cost-effective for a range of energy price levels under climate-neutral industrial production and what the resulting hydrogen and electricity demand would be. To this end the methodology of this paper comprises the following steps: selection of the relevant industries (I) definition of conventional reference production systems and their low-carbon options (II) investigation and processing of the techno-economic data of the standardized production systems (III) establishment of a scenario framework (IV) determination of the least-cost low-carbon solution of a conventional reference production system under the scenario assumptions made (V) and estimation of the resulting hydrogen and electricity demand (VI). According to the results the expected industrial hydrogen consumption in 2045 ranges from 255 TWh for higher hydrogen prices in or above the range of onshore wind-based green hydrogen supply costs to up to 542 TWh for very low hydrogen prices corresponding to typical blue hydrogen production costs. Meanwhile the direct electricity consumption of the process industries in the results ranges from 122 TWh for these rather low hydrogen prices to 368 TWh for the higher hydrogen prices in the region of or above the hydrogen supply costs from the electrolysis of energy from an onshore wind farm. Most of the break-even hydrogen prices that are relevant to the choice of low-carbon options are in the range of the benchmark purchase costs for blue hydrogen and green hydrogen produced from offshore wind power which span between €40 per MWh and €97 per MWh.
Model-based Analysis and Optimization of Pressurised Alkaline Water Electrolysis Powered by Renewable Energy
Jul 2023
Publication
Alkaline water electrolysis is a key technology for large-scale hydrogen production. In this process safety and efficiency are among the most essential requirements. Hence optimization strategies must consider both aspects. While experimental optimization studies are the most accurate solution model-based approaches are more cost and time-efficient. However validated process models are needed which consider all important influences and effects of complete alkaline water electrolysis systems. This study presents a dynamic process model for a pressurized alkaline water electrolyzer consisting of four submodels to describe the system behavior regarding gas contamination electrolyte concentration cell potential and temperature. Experimental data from a lab-scale alkaline water electrolysis system was used to validate the model which could then be used to analyze and optimize pressurized alkaline water electrolysis. While steady-state and dynamic solutions were analyzed for typical operating conditions to determine the influence of the process variables a dynamic optimization study was carried out to optimize an electrolyte flow mode switching pattern. Moreover the simulation results could help to understand the impact of each process variable and to develop intelligent concepts for process optimization
Life Cycle Net Energy Assessment of Sustainable H2 Production and Hydrogenation of Chemicals in a Coupled Photoelectrochemical Device
Feb 2023
Publication
Green hydrogen has been identified as a critical enabler in the global transition to sustainable energy and decarbonized society but it is still not economically competitive compared to fossil-fuel-based hydrogen. To overcome this limitation we propose to couple photoelectrochemical (PEC) water splitting with the hydrogenation of chemicals. Here we evaluate the potential of coproducing hydrogen and methyl succinic acid (MSA) by coupling the hydrogenation of itaconic acid (IA) inside a PEC water splitting device. A negative net energy balance is predicted to be achieved when the device generates only hydrogen but energy breakeven can already be achieved when a small ratio (~2%) of the generated hydrogen is used in situ for IA-to-MSA conversion. Moreover the simulated coupled device produces MSA with much lower cumulative energy demand than conventional hydrogenation. Overall the coupled hydrogenation concept offers an attractive approach to increase the viability of PEC water splitting while at the same time decarbonizing valuable chemical production.
Development of a Method for Evaluating H2-Filling Stations
Nov 2024
Publication
To expedite the development of the infrastructural expansion for hydrogen applications the research project “THEWA” was founded. Within this project the development of hydrogen-refueling stations is being advanced so that the hydrogen strategy for mobility in Germany can move forward. One development point of the project is to develop an evaluation model that recommends a concept for hydrogen-refueling stations for initial individual situations. In this work an evaluation method is developed that provides an appropriate recommendation. For this purpose basics such as the general structure of hydrogen-refueling stations their classification into functional areas and alreadyexisting evaluation methods for multi-criteria decisions are shown. The method for the evaluation of hydrogen-refueling stations will be developed in a component-based manner for which a selection of influencing factors of hydrogen-refueling stations will be explained and categorized. With the help of an expert workshop these are scaled so that the result is an evaluation method based on an expert assessment and the consideration of individual customer requirements. In addition the method is implemented in a tool so that it can be used more easily.
Evaluation of the Impact of Gaseous Hydrogen on Pipeline Steels Utilizing Hollow Specimen Technique and μCT
Feb 2024
Publication
The high potential of hydrogen as a key factor on the pathway towards a climate neutral economy leads to rising demand in technical applications where gaseous hydrogen is used. For several metals hydrogen-metal interactions could cause a degradation of the material properties. This is especially valid for low carbon and highstrength structural steels as they are commonly used in natural gas pipelines and analyzed in this work. This work provides an insight to the impact of hydrogen on the mechanical properties of an API 5L X65 pipeline steel tested in 60 bar gaseous hydrogen atmosphere. The analyses were performed using the hollow specimen technique with slow strain rate testing (SSRT). The nature of the crack was visualized thereafter utilizing μCT imaging of the sample pressurized with gaseous hydrogen in comparison to one tested in an inert atmosphere. The combination of the results from non-conventional mechanical testing procedures and nondestructive imaging techniques has shown unambiguously how the exposure to hydrogen under realistic service pressure influences the mechanical properties of the material and the appearance of failure.
Cost-optimal Design and Operation of Hydrogen Refueling Stations with Mechanical and Electrochemical Hydrogen Compressors
Sep 2024
Publication
Hydrogen refueling stations (HRS) can cause a significant fraction of the hydrogen refueling cost. The main cost contributor is the currently used mechanical compressor. Electrochemical hydrogen compression (EHC) has recently been proposed as an alternative. However its optimal integration in an HRS has yet to be investigated. In this study we compare the performance of a gaseous HRS equipped with different compressors. First we develop dynamic models of three process configurations which differ in the compressor technology: mechanical vs. electrochemical vs. combined. Then the design and operation of the compressors are optimized by solving multi-stage dynamic optimization problems. The optimization results show that the three configurations lead to comparable hydrogen dispensing costs because the electrochemical configuration exhibits lower capital cost but higher energy demand and thus operating cost than the mechanical configuration. The combined configuration is a trade-off with intermediate capital and operating cost.
Experimental Study on the Ignition of Hydrogen Containing Atmospheres by Mechanical Impacts
Sep 2023
Publication
In international regulations on explosion protection mechanical friction impact or abrasion is usually named as one of 13 ignition sources that must be avoided in hazardous zones with explosive atmospheres. In different studies it is even identified as one of the most frequent ignition sources in practice. The effectiveness of mechanical impacts as ignition source is dependent from several parameters including the minimum ignition energy of the explosive atmosphere the properties of the material pairing the kinetic impact energy or the impact velocity. By now there is no standard procedure to determine the effectiveness of mechanical impacts as ignition source. In some previous works test procedures with poor reproducibility or undefined kinetic impact energy were applied for this purpose. In other works only homogeneous material pairings were considered. In this work the effectiveness of mechanical impacts with defined and reproducible kinetic impact energy as ignition source for hydrogen containing atmospheres was studied systematically in dependence from the inhomogeneous material pairing considering materials with practical relevance like stainless steel low alloy steel concrete and non-iron-metals. It was found that ignition can be avoided if non-iron metals are used in combination with different metallic materials but in combination with concrete even the impact of non-iron-metals can be an effective ignition source if the kinetic impact energy is not further limited. Moreover the consequence of hydrogen admixture to natural gas on the effectiveness of mechanical impacts as ignition source was studied. In many cases ignition of atmospheres containing natural gas by mechanical impacts is rather unlikely. No influence could be observed for admixtures up to 25% hydrogen and even more. The results are mainly relevant in the context of repurposing the natural gas grid or adding hydrogen to the natural gas grid. Based on the test results it can be evaluated under which circumstances the use of tools made of non-iron-metals or other non-sparking materials can be an effective measure to avoid ignition sources in hazardous zones containing hydrogen for example during maintenance work.
Levelised Cost of Hydrogen Production in Northern Africa and Europe in 2050: A Monte Carlo Simulation for Germany, Norway, Spain, Algeria, Morocco, and Egypt
May 2024
Publication
The production of green hydrogen through electrolysis utilizing renewable energies is recognized as a pivotal element in the pursuit of decarbonization. In order to attain cost competitiveness for green hydrogen reasonable generation costs are imperative. To identify cost-effective import partners for Germany given its limited green hydrogen production capabilities this study undertakes an exhaustive techno-economic analysis to determine the potential Levelized Cost of Hydrogen in Germany Norway Spain Algeria Morocco and Egypt for the year 2050 which represents a critical milestone in European decarbonization efforts. Employing a stochastic approach with Monte Carlo simulations the paper marks a significant contribution for projecting future cost ranges acknowledging the multitude of uncertainties inherent in related cost parameters and emphasizing the importance of randomness in these assessments. Country-specific Weighted Average Cost of Capital are calculated in order to create a refined understanding of political and economic influences on cost formation rather than using a uniform value across all investigated nations. Key findings reveal that among the evaluated nations PV-based hydrogen emerges as the most cost-efficient alternative in all countries except Norway with Spain presenting the lowest Levelized Cost of Hydrogen at 1.66 €/kg to 3.12 €/kg followed by Algeria (1.72 €/kg to 3.23 €/kg) and Morocco (1.73 €/kg to 3.28 €/kg). Consequently for economically favorable import options Germany is advised to prioritize PV-based hydrogen imports from these countries. Additionally hydrogen derived from onshore wind in Norway (2.24 €/kg to 3.73 €/kg) offers a feasible import alternative. To ensure supply chain diversity and reduce dependency on a single source a mixed import strategy is advisable. Despite having the lowest electricity cost Egypt shows the highest Levelized Cost of Hydrogen primarily due to a significant Weighted Average Cost of Capital.
Country Risks Analysis for the Development of Green Hydrogen and Synthetic Fuel Sectors in the MENA Region
Nov 2024
Publication
Hydrogen plays a pivotal role in global efforts to decarbonize energy and industrial sectors. The European Union particularly Germany anticipate a significant reliance on hydrogen imports in the medium to long term identifying the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region as a key potential producer and exporter of green hydrogen and its downstream products. Yet investment risks pose significant challenges to advancing the region’s green hydrogen and synthetic fuel industries. However systematic comparative risk analyses for these sectors across MENA countries remain limited. This study addresses the research gap by conducting a comparative risk assessment for renewable energy and green hydrogen and synthetic fuel development in 17 MENA countries. A comprehensive framework evaluating macro and micro risks was applied along with two contrasting risk scenarios to explore future developments under different risk conditions. The findings reveal that while MENA countries hold promise most face at least moderate risks underscoring the complexity of fostering these industries regionally.
No more items...