Safety

The National Renewable Energy Laboratory’s (NREL) Hydrogen Safety Research and Development (HSR&D) program in collaboration with the University of Maryland’s Systems Risk and Reliability Analysis Laboratory (SyRRA) are working to improve reliability and reduce risk in hydrogen systems. This approach strives to use quantitative data on component leaks and failures together with Prognosis and Health Management (PHM) and Quantitative Risk Assessment (QRA) to identify atrisk components reduce component failures and downtime and predict when components require maintenance. Hydrogen component failures increase facility maintenance cost facility downtime and reduce public acceptance of hydrogen technologies ultimately increasing facility size and cost because of conservative design requirements. Leaks are a predominant failure mode for hydrogen components. However uncertainties in the amount of hydrogen emitted from leaking components and the frequency of those failure events limit the understanding of the risks that they present under real-world operational conditions. NREL has deployed a test fixture the Leak Rate Quantification Apparatus (LRQA) to quantify the mass flow rate of leaking gases from medium and high-pressure components that have failed while in service. Quantitative hydrogen leak rate data from this system could ultimately be used to better inform risk assessment and Regulation Codes and Standards (RCS). Parallel activity explores the use of PHM and QRA techniques to assess and reduce risk thereby improving safety and reliability of hydrogen systems. The results of QRAs could further provide a systematic and science-based foundation for the design and implementation of RCS as in the latest versions of the NFPA 2 code for gaseous hydrogen stations. Alternatively data-driven techniques of PHM could provide new damage diagnosis and health-state prognosis tools. This research will help end users station owners and operators and regulatory bodies move towards risk-informed preventative maintenance versus emergency corrective maintenance reducing cost and improving reliability. Predictive modelling of failures could improve safety and affect RCS requirements such as setback distances at liquid hydrogen fueling sites. The combination of leak rate quantification research PHM and QRA can lead to better informed models enabling data-based decision to be made for hydrogen system safety improvements.

In the framework of the HYTUNNEL-CS European project sponsored by FCH-JU a set of preliminary tests were conducted in a real tunnel in France. These tests are devoted to safety of hydrogen-fueled vehicles having a compressed gas storage and Temperature Pressure Release Device (TPRD). The goal of the study is to develop recommendations for Regulations Codes and Standards (RCS) for inherently safer use of hydrogen vehicles in enclosed transportation systems. In these preliminary tests the helium gas has been employed instead of hydrogen. Upward and downward gas releases following by TPRD activation has been considered. The experimental data describing local behavior (close to jet or below the chassis) as well as global behavior at the tunnel scale are obtained. These experimental data are systematically compared to existing engineering correlations. The results will be used for benchmarking studies using CFD codes. The hydrogen pressure range in these preliminary tests has been lowered down to 20MPa in order to verify the capability of various large-scale measurement techniques before scaling up to 70MPa the subject of the second campaign.

The H2@Scale program of the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) Hydrogen and Fuel Cell Technologies Office (HFTO) is supporting work on the hydrogen compatibility of polymers to improve the durability and reliability of materials for hydrogen infrastructure. The hydrogen compatibility program (H-Mat) seeks “to address the challenges of hydrogen degradation by elucidating the mechanisms of hydrogen-materials interactions with the goal of providing science-based strategies to design materials (micro)structures and morphology with improved resistance to hydrogen degradation.” Previous work on ethylene propylene diene indicated hydrogen interaction with plasticizer increased its migration to the surface and coalescing within the elastomer compound. New research on nitrile butadiene (NBR) has found hydrogen and pressure interactions with a series model rubber-material compounds to behave similarly in some compounds and improved in other compounds that is demonstrated through volume change and compression-set differences in the materials. Further studies were conducted using a helium-ion microscope (HeIM) which revealed significant morphological changes in the plasticizer-incorporating compounds after static exposure and pressure cycling as evidenced by time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry. Additional studies using x-ray chromatography revealed that more micro-voids/-cracks developed after gas decompression in unfilled materials than in filled materials; transmission electron microscopy (TEM) probed at the nano-meter level showing change in filler distribution and morphology around Zinc-based particles.

Due to the simple structure and quick refueling process of the compressed hydrogen storage tank it is widely used in fuel cell vehicles at present. However temperature rise may lead to a safety problem during charging of a compressed hydrogen storage tank. To ensure the refueling safety the thermal effects need to be studied carefully during hydrogen refueling process. In this paper based on the mass and energy balance equations a general heat transfer model for refueling process of compressed hydrogen storage tank is established. According to the geometric model of the tank wall structure we have built three lumped parameter models: single-zone (hydrogen) dual-zone (hydrogen and tank wall) and triple-zone (hydrogen tank wall liner and shell) model. These three lumped parameter models are compared with U.S. Naval gas charging model and SAE MC method based refueling model. Under adiabatic and diathermic conditions four models are built in Matlab/Simulink software to simulate the hydrogen refueling process under corresponding conditions. These four models are: single-zone singletemperature (hydrogen) dual-zone single-temperature (hydrogen) dual-zone dual-temperature (hydrogen and tank wall temperatures) and triple-zone triple-temperature (hydrogen tank wall liner and tank wall shell temperatures). By comparing the analytical solution and numerical solution the temperature rise of the compressed hydrogen storage tank can be described. The analytical and numerical solutions on the heat transfer during hydrogen refueling process will provide theoretical guidance at actual refueling station so as to improve the refueling efficiency and to enhance the refueling safety.

Dilution ventilation is the current basis of safety following a flammable gas leak within a gas turbine enclosure and compliance requirements are defined for methane fuels in ISO 21789. These requirements currently define a safety criteria of a maximum flammable gas cloud size within an enclosure. The requirements are based on methane explosion tests conducted during a HSE Joint Industry Project which identified typical pressures associated with a range of gas cloud sizes. The industry standard approach is to assess the ventilation performance of specific enclosure designs against these requirements using CFD modelling. Gas turbine manufacturers are increasingly considering introducing hydrogen/methane fuel mixtures and looking towards operating with hydrogen alone. It is therefore important to review the applicability of current safety standards for these new fuels as the pressure resulting from a hydrogen explosion is expected to be significantly higher than that from a methane explosion. In this paper we replicate the previous methane explosion tests for hydrogen and hydrogen/methane fuel mixtures using the explosion modelling tool FLACS CFD. The results are used to propose updated limiting safety criteria for hydrogen fuels to support ventilation CFD analysis for specific enclosure designs. It is found that significantly smaller gas cloud sizes are likely to be acceptable for gas turbines fueled by hydrogen however significantly more hydrogen than methane is required per unit volume to generate a stoichiometric cloud (as hydrogen has a lower stoichiometric air fuel ratio than methane). This effect results in the total quantity of gas in the enclosure (and as such detectability of the gas) being broadly similar when operating gas turbines on hydrogen when compared to methane.

There is worldwide interest in transporting hydrogen using both new pipelines and pipelines converted from natural gas service. Laboratory tests investigating the effect of hydrogen on the mechanical properties of pipeline steels have shown that even low partial pressures of hydrogen can substantially reduce properties such as reduction in area and fracture toughness and increase fatigue crack growth rates. However qualitative arguments suggest that the effects on pipelines may not be as severe as predicted from the small scale tests. If the trends seen in laboratory tests do occur in service there are implications for the assessment of damage such as volumetric corrosion dents and mechanical interference. Most pipeline damage assessment methods are semi-empirical and have been calibrated with data from full scale tests that did not involve hydrogen. Hence the European Pipeline Research Group (EPRG) commissioned a study to investigate damage assessment methods in the presence of hydrogen. Two example pipeline designs were considered both were assessed assuming a modern high performance material and an older material. From these analyses the numerical results show that the high toughness material will tolerate damage even if the properties are degraded by hydrogen exposure. However low toughness materials may not be able to tolerate some types of severe damage. If the predictions are realistic operators may have to repair more damage or reduce operating pressures. Furthermore damage involving cracking may not Page 2 of 22 satisfy the ASME B31.12 requirements for preventing time dependent crack growth. Further work is required to determine if the effects predicted using small scale laboratory test data will occur in practice.

The safety factor of a composite structure in relation to its mechanical rupture is an important criterion for the safety of a 70 MPa composite pressure vessel for hydrogen storage particularly for on-board applications (car bus truck train…). After an introduction of Type IV technology the contribution of carbon fibre composite material structure manufacturing process of pressure vessels and environmental effects on the safety factor are commented. Thanks to an experimental-based evaluation on composite material and H2 composite pressure vessel the safety margins are addressed.

Durability is the most pressing issue preventing the efficient commercialization of polymer electrolyte membrane fuel cell (PEMFC) stationary and transportation applications. A big barrier to overcoming the durability limitations is gaining a better understanding of failure modes for user profiles. In addition durability test protocols for determining the lifetime of PEMFCs are important factors in the development of the technology. These methods are designed to gather enough data about the cell/stack to understand its efficiency and durability without causing it to fail. They also provide some indication of the cell/stack’s age in terms of changes in performance over time. Based on a study of the literature the fundamental factors influencing PEMFC long-term durability and the durability test protocols for both PEMFC stationary and transportation applications were discussed and outlined in depth in this review. This brief analysis should provide engineers and researchers with a fast overview as well as a useful toolbox for investigating PEMFC durability issues.

The commercialization of eco-friendly hydrogen vehicles has elicited attempts to expand hydrogen refueling stations in urban areas; however safety measures to reduce the risk of jet fires have not been established. The RISKCURVES software was used to evaluate the individual and societal risks of hydrogen refueling stations in urban areas and the F–N (Frequency–Number of fatalities) curve was used to compare whether the safety measures satisfied international standards. From the results of the analysis it was found that there is a risk of explosion in the expansion of hydrogen refueling stations in urban areas and safety measures should be considered. To lower the risk of hydrogen refueling stations this study applied the passive and active independent protection layers (IPLs) of LOPA (Layer of Protection Analysis) and confirmed that these measures significantly reduced societal risk as well as individual risk and met international standards. In particular such measures could effectively reduce the impact of jet fire in dispensers and tube trailers that had a high risk. Measures employing both IPL types were efficient in meeting international standard criteria; however passive IPLs were found to have a greater risk reduction effect than active IPLs. The combination of RISKCURVES and LOPA is an appropriate risk assessment method that can reduce work time and mitigate risks through protective measures compared to existing risk assessment methods. This method can be applied to risk assessment and risk mitigation not only for hydrogen facilities but also for hazardous materials with high fire or explosion risk.

The Hy4Heat Safety Assessment has focused on assessing the safe use of hydrogen gas in certain types of domestic properties and buildings. The summary reports (the Precis and the Safety Assessment Conclusions Report) bring together all the findings of the work and should be looked to for context by all readers. The technical reports should be read in conjunction with the summary reports. While the summary reports are made as accessible as possible for general readers the technical reports may be most accessible for readers with a degree of technical subject matter understanding. All of the safety assessment reports have now been reviewed by the HSE.<br/><br/>This document is an overview of the Safety Assessment work undertaken as part of the Hy4Heat programme