Publications

The performance of four Coriolis flow meters designed for use in hydrogen refuelling stations was evaluated with air and nitrogen by three members of the MetroHyVe JRP consortium; NEL METAS and CESAME EXADEBIT.<br/>A wide range of conditions were tested overall with gas flow rates ranging from (0.05–2) kg/min and pressures ranging from (20–86) bar. The majority of tests were conducted at nominal pressures of either 20 bar or 40 bar in order to match the density of hydrogen at 350 bar and 20 °C or 700 bar and −40 °C. For the conditions tested pressure did not have a noticeable influence on meter performance.<br/>When the flow meters were operated at ambient temperatures and within the manufacturer's recommended flow rate ranges errors were generally within ±1%. Errors within ±0.5% were achievable for the medium to high flow rates.<br/>The influence of temperature on meter performance was also studied with testing under both stable and transient conditions and temperatures as low as −40 °C.<br/>When the tested flow meters were allowed sufficient time to reach thermal equilibrium with the incoming gas temperature effects were limited. The magnitude and spread of errors increased but errors within ±2% were achievable at moderate to high flow rates. Conversely errors as high as 15% were observed in tests where logging began before temperatures stabilised and there was a large difference in temperature between the flow meter and the incoming gas.<br/>One of the flow meters tested with nitrogen was later installed in a hydrogen refuelling station and tested against the METAS Hydrogen Field Test Standard (HFTS). Under these conditions errors ranged from 0.47% to 0.91%. Testing with nitrogen at the same flow rates yielded errors of −0.61% to −0.82%.

The percentage of the population in urban areas has increased by ten points from 2000 (46%) to 2020 (56%); it is expected to reach up to 70% by 2050. This undoubtedly will encourage society to use alternative transports. On the other hand the widespread fear of pandemics seems to be here to stay and it is causing most people to leave public transport to use private cars and a few have chosen unipersonal electric vehicles. As a consequence the decision of using private cars negatively affects the air quality and consequently urban population health. This paper aims to demonstrate a sustainable solution for urban mobility based on a hydrogen powered unipersonal electric vehicle which as shown provides great advantages over the conventional battery powered unipersonal electric vehicle. To show this the authors have developed both vehicles in comparable versions using the same platform and ensuring that the total weight of the unipersonal electric vehicle was the same in both cases. They have been subjected to experimental tests that support the features of the hydrogen-based configuration versus the battery-based one including higher specific energy more autonomy and shorter recharge time.

Two electrolysis technologies fed with renewable energy sources are promising for the production of CO₂-free hydrogen and enabling the transition to a hydrogen society: Alkaline Electrolyte (AE) and Polymer Electrolyte Membrane (PEM). However limited information exists on the potential environmental impacts of these promising sustainable innovations when operating on a large-scale. To fill this gap the performance of AE and PEM systems is compared using ex-ante Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) technology analysis and exploratory scenarios for which a refined methodology has been developed to study the effects of implementing large-scale sustainable hydrogen production systems. Ex-ante LCA allows modelling the environmental impacts of hydrogen production exploratory scenario analysis allows modelling possible upscaling effects at potential future states of hydrogen production and use in vehicles in the Netherlands in 2050. A bridging tool for mapping the technological field has been created enabling the combination of quantitative LCAs with qualitative scenarios. This tool also enables diversity for exploring multiple sets of visions. The main results from the paper show with an exception for the “ozone depletion” impact category (1) that large-scale AE and PEM systems have similar environmental impacts with variations lower than 7% in all impact categories (2) that the contribution of the electrolyser is limited to 10% of all impact categories results and (3) that the origin of the electricity is the largest contributor to the environmental impact contributing to more than 90% in all impact categories even when renewable energy sources are used. It is concluded that the methodology was applied successfully and provides a solid basis for an ex-ante assessment framework that can be applied to emerging technological systems.

Solid oxide fuel cells (SOFC) have significant applications and performance and their integration into coupled and cascading energy systems can improve the overall performance of the process. Furthermore due to the constant time performance of the fuel cell the problem of fuel starvation may arise by changing the amount of load which can adversely affect the overall performance of the process. In the present study the excess heat of the SOFC is converted into electrical energy in two stages using different heat generators. The coupled energy system in the present article has a new configuration in which the relationship of its components is different from the systems reported in the literature. Furthermore since the use of an energy storage system can improve the overall reliability the energy produced by the coupled energy cycle is stored by a storage technology for peak consumption times. The introduced system can generate approximately 580 W of electrical power with an efficiency of 80%. The highest and lowest share in power generation is related to fuel cell with 82% and thermoelectric generator with 5%. The rest of the system power (i.e. 13%) is produced by thermionic generator. In addition the system requires 0.025 kg per hour of hydrogen fuel. It was also found that to operate the system for 5 h a day requires a storage system with a size of 3.3 m3 . Moreover two key issues to enhance the storage system performance are: adjusting the initial pressure of the system to values close to the peak (optimal) value and using turbines and/or pumps with higher efficiencies. With the aim of supplying 5 kWh of electrical energy five different scenarios based on the design of various effective parameters have been presented.

A consortium comprising Cadent Northern Gas Networks Keele University Health and Safety Laboratory ITM Power and Progressive Energy is undertaking the research project HyDeploy. The project funded under the UK Network Innovation Competition scheme aims to demonstrate that natural gas containing levels of hydrogen beyond the upper limit set out in Schedule 3 of in the Gas Safety (Management) Regulations (GSMR) can be distributed and utilised safely and efficiently in a section of the UK distribution network. It will conclude with a field trial in which hydrogen will be injected into part of a private gas distribution system owned and operated by Keele University. Dave Lander Consulting Limited and Kiwa Ltd are providing technical support to the HyDeploy project and this report presents the results of Quantified Risk Assessment (QRA) for the proposed field trial. The QRA is intended to support an application by Keele University for exemption from the legal requirement to only convey gas that is compliant with the requirements of Schedule 3 of the GSMR. The QRA is aimed at demonstrating that the field trial will not result in a material increase in risk to persons within Keele University affected by the proposed field trial.<br/>Check the supplements tab for the other documents from this report

We combine previously separate models of Northern European power markets local district heating and cooling (DHC²) systems and biomass supply in a single modelling framework to study local and system level impacts of bioenergy technologies in phasing out fossil fuels from a DHC system of the Finnish capital. We model multiple future scenarios and assess the impacts on energy security flexibility provision economic performance and emissions. In the case of Helsinki heat only boiler is a robust solution from economic and climate perspective but reduces local electricity self-sufficiency. Combined heat and power solution is more valuable investment for the system than for the city indicating a conflict of interest and biased results in system level models. Bringing a biorefinery near the city to utilize excess heat would reduce emissions and increase investment's profitability but biomass availability might be a bigger limiting factor. Our results show that the availability of domestic biomass resources constrains bio-based technologies in Southern Finland and further highlights the importance of considering both local and system level impacts. Novel option to boost biorefinery's production with hydrogen from excess electricity is beneficial with increasing shares of wind power.

The hydrogen economy has received resurging interest in recent years as more countries commit to net-zero CO₂ emissions around the mid-century. “Blue” hydrogen from natural gas with CO₂ capture and storage (CCS) is one promising sustainable hydrogen supply option. Although conventional CO₂ capture imposes a large energy penalty advanced process concepts using the chemical looping principle can produce blue hydrogen at efficiencies even exceeding the conventional steam methane reforming (SMR) process without CCS. One such configuration is gas switching reforming (GSR) which uses a Ni-based oxygen carrier material to catalyze the SMR reaction and efficiently supply the required process heat by combusting an off-gas fuel with integrated CO₂ capture. The present study investigates the potential of advanced La-Fe-based oxygen carrier materials to further increase this advantage using a gas switching partial oxidation (GSPOX) process. These materials can overcome the equilibrium limitations facing conventional catalytic SMR and achieve direct hydrogen production using a water-splitting reaction. Results showed that the GSPOX process can achieve mild efficiency improvements relative to GSR in the range of 0.6–4.1%-points with the upper bound only achievable by large power and H₂ co-production plants employing a highly efficient power cycle. These performance gains and the avoidance of toxicity challenges posed by Ni-based oxygen carriers create a solid case for the further development of these advanced materials. If successful results from this work indicate that GSPOX blue hydrogen plants can outperform an SMR benchmark with conventional CO₂ capture by more than 10%-points both in terms of efficiency and CO₂ avoidance.

The increasing ambition of climate targets creates a major role for hydrogen especially in achieving carbon-neutrality in sectors presently difficult to decarbonise. This work examines to what extent the currently carbon-intensive hydrogen production in Europe could be replaced by water electrolysis using electricity from renewable energy resources (RES) such as solar photovoltaic onshore/offshore wind and hydropower (green hydrogen). The study assesses the technical potential of RES at regional and national levels considering environmental constraints land use limitations and various techno-economic parameters. It estimates localised clean hydrogen production and examines the capacity to replace carbon-intensive hydrogen hubs with ones that use RES-based water electrolysis. Findings reveal that -at national level- the available RES electricity potential exceeds the total electricity demand and the part for hydrogen production from electrolysis in all analysed countries. At regional level from the 109 regions associated with hydrogen production (EU27 and UK) 88 regions (81%) show an excess of potential RES generation after covering the annual electricity demand across all sectors and hydrogen production. Notably 84 regions have over 50% excess RES electricity potential after covering the total electricity demand and that for water electrolysis. The study provides evidence on the option to decarbonize hydrogen production at regional level. It shows that such transformation is possible and compatible with the ongoing transition towards carbon–neutral power systems in the EU. Overall this work aims to serve as a tool for designing hydrogen strategies in harmony with renewable energy policies.

It is well-documented experimentally that the influence of hydrogen on the mechanical properties of structural alloys like austenitic stainless steels nickel superalloys and carbon steels strongly depends on temperature. A typical curve plotting any hydrogen-affected mechanical property as a function of temperature gives a temperature THEmax where the degradation of this mechanical property reaches a maximum. Above and below this temperature the degradation is less. Unfortunately the underlying physico-mechanical mechanisms are not currently understood to the level of detail required to explain such temperature effects. Though this temperature effect is important to understand in the context of engineering applications studies to explain or even predict the effect of temperature upon the mechanical properties of structural alloys could not be identified. The available experimental data are scattered significantly and clear trends as a function of chemistry or microstructure are difficult to see. Reported values for THEmax are in the range of about 200–340 K which covers the typical temperature range for the design of structural components of about 230–310 K (from −40 to +40 °C). That is the value of THEmax itself as well as the slope of the gradient might affect the materials selection for a dedicated application. Given the current lack of scientific understanding a statistical approach appears to be a suitable way to account for the temperature effect in engineering applications. This study reviews the effect of temperature upon hydrogen effects in structural alloys and proposes recommendations for test temperatures for gaseous hydrogen applications

Modern arc processes such as the modified spray arc (Mod. SA) have been developed for gas metal arc welding of high-strength structural steels with which even narrow weld seams can be welded. High-strength joints are subjected to increasingly stringent requirements in terms of welding processing and the resulting component performance. In the present work this challenge is to be met by clarifying the influences on hydrogen-assisted cracking (HAC) in a high-strength structural steel S960QL. Adapted samples analogous to the self-restraint TEKKEN test are used and analyzed with respect to crack formation microstructure diffusible hydrogen concentration and residual stresses. The variation of the seam opening angle of the test seams is between 30° and 60°. To prevent HAC the effectiveness of a dehydrogenation heat treatment (DHT) from the welding heat is investigated. As a result the weld metals produced at reduced weld opening angle show slightly higher hydrogen concentrations on average. In addition increased micro- as well as macro-crack formation can be observed on these weld metal samples. On all samples without DHT cracks in the root notch occur due to HAC which can be prevented by DHT immediately after welding.

Gas pipelines are exposed to operational loads combined with corrosive environment action during their long-term service. Complicated service conditions lead to a worsening of steel properties a reduction of serviceability of the whole object therefore a risk of its premature failure rises. Aware of the importance of the existing problem the aim of this study is the analysis of various mechanical properties of steels after their long-term operation on gas pipelines and detecting and evaluating fractographic signs of this degradation.<br/>Mechanical properties of operated pipe steels characterizing their brittle fracture resistance were significantly decreased. Delamination areas as one of a feature of brittle fracture were identified on the fracture surfaces of specimens after SSRT of the operated steels in corrosive environment. Fracture was initiated from the outer surface of the specimens along the boundaries of ferrite and pearlite grains with significant secondary cracking.<br/>The obvious texture in the steels affects noticeably the results of the impact tests. Higher KCV values for the specimens cut in the longitudinal direction relative to the pipe axis comparing with the specimens of transversal orientation were obtained. This was explained by different length of narrow pearlite strips alternated by wide ferrite bands and interrupted by individual ferrite grains depending on the orientation of the specimen fracture surface relative to the pipe axis. Thus a proper direction of specimen cutting to achieve the maximum sensitivity of KCV parameter to operational degradation of steels is discussed. The effect of specimen orientation on the results of the Charpy testing becomes much more pronounced with steel operation. Defects accumulated in steels during their service are preferentially oriented in the pipe axial direction along the boundaries between ferrite and pearlite strips. Analyzing the fracture surfaces of the Charpy specimens after their impact testing certain signs of embrittlement were found for long term operated steels in the form of delaminations varying in size and shape and some cleavage fragments. Furthermore their percentage of total fracture surface (generally formed by dimples) correlates well with a drop in the impact toughness. The established relationship could be the basis for the introduction of fractographic criteria of the steel serviceability.

Present work describes the failure analysis of cooling duct of a fighter aircraft. The analyzed chemical composition of cooling duct indicates that it is manufactured from Al-based alloy (AA 3003 or its equivalent). Microstructure of cooling duct displays the presence of two phases namely matrix and insoluble particles. The hardness values at different locations within damaged area of cooling duct reflect nearly same and consistent. The fracture surface of the cooling duct exhibits transgranular features and cracks with little branching. The analyzed hydrogen content in cooling duct is significantly higher (∼ 12 ppm) than the specified one (< 1 ppm). However the alloy used to fabricate cooling duct is not susceptible to typical hydrogen embrittlement. This shows hydrogen pick up during operation. The presence of cracks with branching does reflect features of hydrogen embrittlement. In addition striations indicative of fatigue features are also observed. It thus appears that the cooling duct has failed due to pick up of large amount of hydrogen as well as vibrational fatigue.

The realm of alkaline-based fuel cells has with the arrival of anionic exchange membrane fuel cells (AEMFCs) taken a great step to replace traditional liquid electrolyte alkaline fuel cells (AFCs). The following review summarises progress bottleneck issues and highlights the most recent research trends within the field. The activity of alkaline catalyst materials has greatly advanced however achieving long-term stability remains a challenge. Great AEMFC performances are reported though these are generally obtained through the employment of platinum group metals (PGMs) thus emphasising the importance of R&D related to non-PGM materials. Thorough design strategies must be utilised for all components to avoid a mismatch of electrochemical properties between electrode components. Lastly AEMFC optimisation challenges on the system-level will also have to be assessed as few application-size AEMFCs have been built and tested.

Keele University was chosen as the site for the HyDeploy project as it was seen as the site offered a high degree of control regarding safety functions high availability of operational data and minimal supply chain interfaces given that Keele University is the supplier transporter and distributer of natural gas at the site. The site was offered to the project as a living laboratory in line with the university's ambition to be at the forefront of energy innovation through the Smart Energy Network Demonstrator (SEND). Evidenced within this report is the supporting data that confirms the rationale for selecting Keele University and the necessary data to profile the section of the gas network which hydrogen will be injected into. The gas network at Keele University is segregated via the governor stations which regulate pressure within the network. The section of network which has been chosen for the HyDeploy project is the G3 network which is regulated by the G3 governor.

The widescale distribution of hydrogen through gas networks is promoted as a viable and cost-efficient option for optimising its application in heat industry and transport. It is a key step towards achieving decarbonisation targets in the UK. A key consideration before the injection of hydrogen into the UK gas networks is an assessment of the difference in hydrogen contaminants presence from different production methods. This information is essential for gas regulation and for further purification requirements. This study investigates the level of ISO 14687 Grade D contaminants in hydrogen from steam methane reforming proton exchange membrane water electrolysis and alkaline electrolysis. Sampling and analysis of hydrogen were carried out by the National Physical Laboratory following ISO 21087 guidance. The results of analysis indicated the presence of nitrogen in hydrogen from electrolysis and water carbon dioxide and particles in all samples analysed. The contaminants were at levels below or at the threshold limits set by ISO 14687 Grade D. This indicates that the investigated production methods are not a source of contaminants for the eventual utilisation of hydrogen in different applications including fuel cell electric vehicles (FCEV’s). The gas network infrastructure will require a similar analysis to determine the likelihood of contamination to hydrogen gas.

Interest in hydrogen fuel is growing for automotive applications; however safe dense solid-state hydrogen storage remains a formidable scientific challenge. Metal hydrides offer ample storage capacity and do not require cryogens or exceedingly high pressures for operation. However hydrides have largely been abandoned because of oxidative instability and sluggish kinetics. We report a new environmentally stable hydrogen storage material constructed of Mg nanocrystals encapsulated by atomically thin and gas-selective reduced graphene oxide (rGO) sheets. This material protected from oxygen and moisture by the rGO layers exhibits exceptionally dense hydrogen storage (6.5 wt% and 0.105 kg H₂ per litre in the total composite). As rGO is atomically thin this approach minimizes inactive mass in the composite while also providing a kinetic enhancement to hydrogen sorption performance. These multilaminates of rGO-Mg are able to deliver exceptionally dense hydrogen storage and provide a material platform for harnessing the attributes of sensitive nanomaterials in demanding environments.

In this paper we propose and verify a novel method to simulate crack propagation without propagating a crack by finite element method. We propose this method for elastoplastic analysis coupled with convection-diffusion. In the previous study we succeeded in performing elastoplastic analysis coupled with convection-diffusion of hydrogen for a material with a crack under tensile loading. This research extends the successful method to fatigue crack propagation. In convection-diffusion analysis in order to simulate the invasion and release of elements through the free surface the crack tip is expressed by using a notch with a sufficiently small radius. Therefore the node release method conventionally used to simulate crack propagation cannot be applied. Hence instead of crack propagation based on an analytical model we propose a novel method that can reproduce the influence of the vicinity of the crack tip on a crack. We moved the stress field near the crack tip in the direction opposite to that of crack propagation by an amount corresponding to the crack propagation length. When we extend the previous method to fatigue crack propagation simulation we must consider the difference in strain due to loading and unloading. This problem was solved by considering the strain due to loading as a displacement. Instead of moving the strain due to loading we moved the displacement. First we performed a simple tensile load analysis on the model and output the displacement of all the nodes of the model at maximum load. Then the displacement was moved in the direction opposite to that of crack propagation. Finally the stress field was reproduced by forcibly moving all the nodes by the displacement amount. The strain due to unloading was reproduced by removing the displacement. Furthermore we verified the equivalence of the crack propagation simulation and the proposed method.

E4tech’s 6th annual review of the global fuel cell industry is now available here. Using primary data straight from the main players and free to download it quantifies shipments by fuel cell type by application and by region of deployment and summarises industry developments over the year.



2019 saw shipments globally grow significantly to 1.1 GW. Numbers grew slightly to around 70000 units. The growth in capacity came mainly from cars Hyundai with its NEXO and Toyota with its Mirai together accounting for around two-thirds of shipments by capacity. Unit numbers are still dominated by Japan’s ene-Farm cogeneration appliances at around 45000 shipments. Large numbers of trucks and buses are now manufactured and shipped in China though numbers deployed are limited by the availability of refuelling infrastructure. But growth in China is uncertain as policy changes are under discussion.



2020 looks like it will be an even bigger year again dominated by Hyundai and Toyota. The Japanese fuel cell market is expected also to grow partly on the back of the Tokyo ‘Hydrogen Olympics’. Korea is another growth story buoyed by its latest roadmap which aims to shift large swathes of its economy to hydrogen energy by 2040. Elsewhere much of the supply chain development is in heavy duty vehicles and big supply chain players like Cummins Weichai and Michelin are making significant investments.

Maritime transport faces increasing pressure to reduce its greenhouse gas emissions to be in accordance with the Paris Agreement. For this to happen low- and zero-carbon energy solutions need to be developed. In this paper we draw on sustainability transition literature and introduce the technological innovation system (TIS) framework to the field of maritime transportation research. The TIS approach analytically distinguishes between different innovation system functions that are important for new technologies to develop and diffuse beyond an early phase of experimentation. This provides a basis for technology-specific policy recommendations. We apply the TIS framework to the case of battery-electric and hydrogen energy solutions for coastal maritime transport in Norway. Whereas both battery-electric and hydrogen solutions have developed rapidly the former is more mature and has a strong momentum. Public procurement and other policy instruments have been crucial for developments to date and will be important for these technologies to become viable options for shipping more generally.

Electrifying energy-intensive processes is currently intensively explored to cut greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions through renewable electricity. Electrification is particularly challenging if fossil resources are not only used for energy supply but also as feedstock. Copper production is such an energy-intensive process consuming large quantities of fossil fuels both as reducing agent and as energy supply.

Here we explore the techno-economic potential of Power-to-Hydrogen to decarbonize copper production. To determine the minimal cost of an on-site retrofit with Power-to-Hydrogen technology we formulate and solve a mixed-integer linear program for the integrated system. Under current techno-economic parameters for Germany the resulting direct CO₂ abatement cost is 201 EUR/t CO₂-eq for Power-to-Hydrogen in copper production. On-site utilization of the electrolysis by-product oxygen has a substantial economic benefit. While the abatement cost vastly exceeds current European emission certificate prices a sensitivity analysis shows that projected future developments in Power-to-Hydrogen technologies can greatly reduce the direct CO₂ abatement cost to 54 EUR/t CO₂-eq. An analysis of the total GHG emissions shows that decarbonization through Power-to-Hydrogen reduces the global GHG emissions only if the emission factor of the electricity supply lies below 160 g CO2-eq/kWhel.

The results suggest that decarbonization of copper production by Power-to-Hydrogen could become economically and environmentally beneficial over the next decades due to cheaper and more efficient Power-to-Hydrogen technology rising GHG emission certificate prices and further decarbonization of the electricity supply.

A solid-state storage system is the most practical option for hydrogen because it is more convenient and safer. Metal hydrides especially MgH₂ are the most promising materials that offer high gravimetric capacity and good reversibility. However the practical application of MgH₂ is restricted by slow sorption kinetics and high stability of thermodynamic properties. Hydrogen storage performance of MgH₂ was enhanced by introducing the Mg–Na–Al system that destabilises MgH₂ with NaAlH₄. The Mg–Na–Al system has superior performance compared to that of unary MgH₂ and NaAlH₄. To boost the performance of the Mg–Na–Al system the ball milling method and the addition of a catalyst were introduced. The Mg–Na–Al system resulted in a low onset decomposition temperature superior cyclability and enhanced kinetics performances. The Al12Mg17 and NaMgH₃ that formed in situ during the dehydrogenation process modify the reaction pathway of the Mg–Na–Al system and alter the thermodynamic properties. In this paper the overview of the recent progress in hydrogen storage of the Mg–Na–Al system is detailed. The remaining challenges and future development of Mg–Na–Al system are also discussed. This paper is the first review report on hydrogen storage properties of the Mg–Na–Al system.

Hydrogen characterization techniques like melt extraction and thermal desorption spectroscopy (TDS) are useful tools in order to evaluate and understand the interaction between hydrogen and metals. These two techniques are used here on cold deformed ultra-low carbon (ULC) steel with and without hydrogen induced damage. The material is charged electrochemically in order to induce varying amounts of hydrogen and variable degrees of hydrogen induced damage. The aim of this work is to evaluate to which extent the hydrogen induced damage would manifest itself in melt extraction and TDS measurements.

Experimental evidence exists for the enhancement of the hydrogen storage capacity of porous carbons when these materials are doped with metal nanoparticles. One of the most studied dopants is palladium. Dissociation of the hydrogen molecules and spillover of the H atoms towards the carbon substrate has been advocated as the reason for the enhancement of the storage capacity. We have investigated this mechanism by performing ab initio density functional molecular dynamics (AIMD) simulations of the deposition of molecular hydrogen on Pd6 clusters anchored on graphene vacancies. The clusters are initially near-saturated with atomic and molecular hydrogen. This condition would facilitate the occurrence of spillover since our energy calculations based on density functional theory indicate that migration of preadsorbed H atoms towards the graphene substrate becomes exothermic on Pd clusters with high hydrogen coverages. However AIMD simulations show that the H atoms prefer to intercalate and absorb within the Pd cluster rather than migrate to the carbon substrate. These results reveal that high activation barriers exist preventing the spillover of hydrogen from the anchored Pd clusters to the carbon substrate.

The glass industry is part of the energy-intensive industry posing a major challenge to fulfill the CO₂ reduction targets of the Paris Climate Agreement. The segments of the glass industry e.g. container or flat glass are quite diverse and attribute to different glass products with different requirements to product quality and various process options. To address the challenge of decarbonizing the glass industry firstly an inventory of current glass products processes and applied technologies in terms of energy efficiency and CO₂ emissions is conducted. Secondly decarbonization options are identified and structured according to fuel substitution waste heat recovery and process intensification. Due to the high share of energy-related CO₂ emissions electrical melting and hydrogen combustion or a combination of both are the most promising options to decarbonize the glass industry but further research design adjustments and process improvements are necessary. Furthermore electricity and hydrogen prices have to decrease or fossil fuels must become more expensive to be cost-competitive relative to fossil fuels and respective infrastructures have to be constructed or adjusted. Various heat recovery options have great potential for CO₂ savings but can be technically challenging or have not yet been considered for techno-economic reasons.

Hydrogen technologies have received increased attention in research and development to foster the shift towards carbon-neutral energy systems. Depending on the specific production techniques transportation concepts and application areas hydrogen supply chains (HSCs) can be anything from part of the energy transition problem to part of the solution: Even more than battery-driven electric mobility hydrogen is a polyvalent technology and can be used in very different contexts with specific positive or negative sustainability impacts. Thus a detailed sustainability evaluation is crucial for decision making in the context of hydrogen technology and its diverse application fields. This article provides a comprehensive structured literature review in the context of HSCs along the triple bottom line dimensions of environmental economic and social sustainability analyzing a total of 288 research papers. As a result we identify research gaps mostly regarding social sustainability and the supply chain stages of hydrogen distribution and usage. We suggest further research to concentrate on these gaps thus strengthening our understanding of comprehensive sustainability evaluations for HSCs especially in social sustainability evaluation. In addition we provide an additional approach for discussion by adding literature review results from neighboring fields highlighting the joint challenges and insights regarding sustainability evaluation.