United Kingdom

Hydrogen may play a crucial part in delivering a net zero emissions future. Currently hydrogen production storage transport and utilisation are being explored to scope opportunities and to reduce barriers to market activation. One such barrier could be negative public response to hydrogen technologies. Previous research around socio-technical risks finds that public acceptance issues are particularly challenging for emerging remote technical sensitive uncertain or unfamiliar technologies - such as hydrogen. Thus while the hydrogen value chain could offer a range of potential environmental economic and social benefits each will have perceived risks that could challenge the introduction and subsequent roll-out of hydrogen. These potential issues must be identified and managed so that the hydrogen sector can develop adapt or respond appropriately. Geological storage of hydrogen could present challenges in terms of perceived safety. Valuable lessons can be learned from international research and practice of CO2 and natural gas storage in geological formations (for carbon capture and storage CCS and for power respectively). Here we explore these learnings. We consider the similarities and differences between these technologies and how these may affect perceived risks. We also reflect on lessons for effective communication and community engagement. We draw on this to present potential risks to the perceived safety of - and public acceptability of – the geological storage of hydrogen. One of the key lessons learned from CCS and natural gas storage is that progress is most effective when risk communication and public acceptability is considered from the early stages of technology development.

In this report for the first time it has been observed that proton-conducting oxide BaZr_0.1Ce_0.7Y_0.2O_3−δ (BZCY) has significant promotion effect on the catalytic activity of Ni towards ammonia synthesis from hydrogen and nitrogen. Renewable hydrogen can be used for ammonia synthesis to save CO₂ emission. By investigating the operating parameters of the reaction the optimal conditions for this catalyst were identified. It was found that at 620 °C with a total flow rate of 200 mL min−1 and a H₂/N₂ mol ratio of 3 an activity of approximately 250 μmol g⁻¹ h⁻¹ can be achieved. This is ten times larger than that for the unpromoted Ni catalyst under the same conditions although the stability of both catalysts in the presence of steam was not good. The specific activity of Ni supported on proton-conducting oxide BZCY is approximately 72 times higher than that of Ni supported on non-proton conductor M_gO-C_eO₂. These promotion effects were suspected to be due to the proton conducting nature of the support. Therefore it is proposed that the use of proton conducting support materials with highly active ammonia synthesis catalysts such as Ru and Fe will provide improved activity of at lower temperatures.

The Energy Technologies Institute (ETI) has developed an internationally peer-reviewed model of the UK’s national energy system extending across power heat transport and infrastructure. The Energy System Modelling Environment (ESME) is a policy neutral system-wide optimisation model. It models the key technology and engineering choices taking account of cost engineering spatial and temporal factors.

Key points:

• A system-wide perspective informed by modelling is highly relevant because complex energy systems are made more inter-dependent by emissions reduction objectives
• Efforts to cut emissions are substitutable across a national energy system encompassing power heat transport and infrastructure.
• Energy systems are subject to key decision points and it is important to make the right choices in major long lived investments
• Policy makers should place policy in a system-wide context.

The ETI’s current ESME-based analysis of the UK energy system shows that

• Decarbonisation can be achieved affordably (at around 0.6% of GDP) provided that the most cost effective technologies and strategies to reduce emissions are deployed
• A broad portfolio of technologies is needed to deliver emissions reductions with bio-energy and carbon capture and storage of particular system-wide importance

Policy makers can use energy system modelling to inform market and policy design increase understanding of pathways (including the impacts of ‘real world’ constraints and inertia in deploying technology) and identify key ‘contender’ technologies with particular system-wide value.

Austenitic stainless steels are used extensively in harsh environments including for high-pressure gaseous hydrogen service. However the tensile ductility of this class of materials is very sensitive to materials and environmental variables. While tensile ductility is generally insufficient to qualify a material for hydrogen service ductility is an effective tool to explore microstructural and environmental variables and their effects on hydrogen susceptibility to inform understanding of the mechanisms of hydrogen effects in metals and to provide insight to microstructural variables that may improve relative performance. In this study hydrogen precharging was used to simulate high-pressure hydrogen environments to evaluate hydrogen effects on tensile properties. Several austenitic stainless steels were considered including both metastable and stable alloys. Room temperature and subambient temperature tensile properties were evaluated with three different internal hydrogen contents for type 304L and 316L austenitic stainless steels and one hydrogen content for XM-11. Significant ductility loss was observed for both metastable and stable alloys suggesting the stability of the austenitic phase is not sufficient to characterize the effects of hydrogen. Internal hydrogen does influence the character of deformation which drives local damage accumulation and ultimately fracture for both metastable and stable alloys. While a quantitative description of hydrogen-assisted fracture in austenitic stainless steels remains elusive these observations underscore the importance of the hydrogen-defect interactions and the accumulation of damage at deformation length scales.

This paper presents the optimal design and operation of integrated wind-hydrogen-electricity networks using the general mixed integer linear programming energy network model STeMES (Samsatli and Samsatli 2015). The network comprises: wind turbines; electrolysers fuel cells compressors and expanders; pressurised vessels and underground storage for hydrogen storage; hydrogen pipelines and electricity overhead/underground transmission lines; and fuelling stations and distribution pipelines.<br/>The spatial distribution and temporal variability of energy demands and wind availability were considered in detail in the model. The suitable sites for wind turbines were identified using GIS by applying a total of 10 technical and environmental constraints (buffer distances from urban areas rivers roads airports woodland and so on) and used to determine the maximum number of new wind turbines that can be installed in each zone.<br/>The objective is the minimisation of the total cost of the network subject to satisfying all of the demands of the domestic transport sector in Great Britain. The model simultaneously determines the optimal number size and location of each technology whether to transmit the energy as electricity or hydrogen the structure of the transmission network the hourly operation of each technology and so on. The cost of distribution was estimated from the number of fuelling stations and length of the distribution pipelines which were determined from the demand density at the 1 km level.<br/>Results indicate that all of Britain's domestic transport demand can be met by on-shore wind through appropriately designed and operated hydrogen-electricity networks. Within the set of technologies considered the optimal solution is: to build a hydrogen pipeline network in the south of England and Wales; to supply the Midlands and Greater London with hydrogen from the pipeline network alone; to use Humbly Grove underground storage for seasonal storage and pressurised vessels at different locations for hourly balancing as well as seasonal storage; for Northern Wales Northern England and Scotland to be self-sufficient generating and storing all of the hydrogen locally. These results may change with the inclusion of more technologies such as electricity storage and electric vehicles.

The 'Hydrogen for Heat' (Hy4Heat) programme aims to support the UK Government in its ambitions to decarbonise the UK energy sector in line with the targets of the Climate Change Act 2008 by attempting to evaluate and de-risk the natural gas to hydrogen network conversion option. The impact on the commercial sector is an important factor in understanding the feasibility of utilising hydrogen to decarbonise heat in the UK. The overall objective of the market research study Work Package 5 (WP5) was to determine if it is theoretically possible to successfully convert the commercial sector to hydrogen. This work will contribute to the understanding of the scale type and capacity of gas heating appliances within the sector providing a characterisation of the market and determining the requirements and feasibility for successfully transitioning them to hydrogen in the future.

This report and any attachment is freely available on the Hy4Heat website here. The report can also be downloaded directly by clicking on the pdf icon above 

To facilitate the transition to the hydrogen economy the EU project NATURALHY is studying the potential for the existing natural gas pipeline networks to transport hydrogen together with natural gas to end-users. Hydrogen may then be extracted for hydrogen fuel-cell applications or the mixture used directly by consumers in existing gas-fired equipment with the benefit of lower carbon emissions. The existing gas pipeline networks are designed constructed and operated to safely transport natural gas mostly methane. However hydrogen has significantly different properties that may adversely affect both the integrity of the network and thereby increase the likelihood of an accidental leak and the consequences if the leak finds a source of ignition. Consequently a major part of the NATURALHY project is focused on assessing how much hydrogen could be introduced into the network without adversely impacting on the safety of the network and the risk to the public. Hydrogen is more reactive than natural gas so the severity of an explosion following an accidental leak may be increased. This paper describes field-scale experiments conducted to measure the overpressures generated by ignition of methane/hydrogen/air mixtures in a congested but unconfined region. Such regions may be found in the gas handling and metering stations of the pipeline networks. The 3 m x 3 m x 2 m high congested region studied contained layers of pipes. The composition of the methane/hydrogen mixture used was varied from 0% hydrogen to 100% hydrogen. On the basis of the experiments performed the maximum overpressures generated by methane/hydrogen mixtures with 25% (by volume) or less hydrogen content are not likely to be much more than those generated by methane alone. Greater percentages of hydrogen did significantly increase the explosion overpressure.

If the general public is to use hydrogen as a vehicle fuel customers must be able to handle hydrogen with the same degree of confidence and with comparable risk as conventional liquid and gaseous fuels. The hazards associated with jet releases from leaks in a vehicle-refuelling environment must be considered if hydrogen is stored and used as a high-pressure gas since a jet release in a confined or congested area could result in an explosion. As there was insufficient knowledge of the explosion hazards a study was initiated to gain a better understanding of the potential explosion hazard consequences associated with high-pressure leaks from refuelling systems. This paper describes two experiments with a dummy vehicle and dispenser units to represent refuelling station congestion. The first represents a ‘worst-case’ scenario where the vehicle and dispensers are enveloped by a 5.4 m x 6.0 m x 2.5 m high pre-mixed hydrogen-air cloud. The second is an actual high-pressure leak from storage at 40 MPa (400 bar) representing an uncontrolled full-bore failure of a vehicle refuelling hose. In both cases an electric spark ignited the flammable cloud. Measurements were made of the explosion overpressure generated its evolution with time and its decay with distance. The results reported provide a direct demonstration of the explosion hazard from an uncontrolled leak; they will also be valuable for validating explosion models that will be needed to assess configurations and conditions beyond those studied experimentally.

Around 20% of the nation’s carbon emissions are generated by domestic heating. Analysis of the many ways the energy system might be adapted to meet carbon targets shows that the elimination of emissions from buildings is more cost effective than deeper cuts in other energy sectors such as transport. This effectively means that alternatives need to be found for domestic natural gas heating systems. Enhanced construction standards are ensuring that new buildings are increasingly energy efficient but the legacy building stock of around 26 million homes has relatively poor thermal performance and over 90% are expected to still be in use in 2050. Even if building replacement was seen as desirable the cost is unaffordable and the carbon emissions associated with the construction would be considerable.

YouTube link to accompanying video

Hydrogen is widely recognised as an important option for future road transportation but a widespread infrastructure must be developed if the potential for hydrogen is to be achieved. This paper and related appendices which can be downloaded as Supplementary material present a mixed-integer linear programming model (called SHIPMod) that optimises a hydrogen supply chains for scenarios of hydrogen fuel demand in the UK including the spatial arrangement of carbon capture and storage infrastructure. In addition to presenting a number of improvements on past practice in the literature the paper focuses attention on the importance of assumptions regarding hydrogen demand. The paper draws on socio-economic data to develop a spatially detailed scenario of possible hydrogen demand. The paper then shows that assumptions about the level and spatial dispersion of hydrogen demand have a significant impact on costs and on the choice of hydrogen production technologies and distribution mechanisms.