Safety
Comparison of Two Simplified Models Predictions with Experimental Measurements for Gas Release Within an Enclosure
Sep 2009
Publication
In this work the validity of simplified mathematical models for predicting dispersion of turbulent buoyant jet or plume within a confined volume is evaluated. In the framework of the HYSAFE Network of Excellence CEA performed experimental tests in a full-scale Garage facility in order to reproduce accidental gas leakages into an unventilated residential garage. The effects of release velocities diameters durations mass flow rates and flow regimes on the vertical distribution of the gas concentration are investigated. Experimental data confirm the formation for the release conditions of an almost well-mixed upper layer and a stratified lower layer. The comparison of the measurements and the model predictions shows that a good agreement is obtained for a relatively long-time gas discharge for jet like or plume like flow behaviour.
Real-gas Equations-of-State for the GASFLOW CFD Code
Sep 2011
Publication
GASFLOW is a finite-volume computer code that solves the time-dependent two-phase homogeneous equilibrium model compressible Navier–Stokes equations for multiple gas species with turbulence. The fluid-dynamics algorithm is coupled with conjugate heat and mass transfer models to represent walls floors ceilings and other internal structures to describe complex geometries such as those found in nuclear containments and facilities. Recent applications involve simulations of cryogenic hydrogen tanks at elevated pressures. These applications which often have thermodynamic conditions near the critical point require more accurate real-gas Equations-of-State (EoS) and transport properties than the standard ideal gas EoS and classical kinetic-theory transport properties. This paper describes the rigorous implementation of the generalized real-gas EoS into the GASFLOW CFD code as well as the specific implementation of respective real-gas models (Leachman's NIST hydrogen EoS a modified van der Waals EoS and a modified Nobel-Abel EoS); it also includes a logical testing procedure based upon a numerically exact benchmark problem. An example of GASFLOW simulations is presented for an ideal cryo-compressed hydrogen tank of the type utilized in fuel cell vehicles.
The Possibility of an Accidental Scenario for Marine Transportation of Fuel Cell Vehicle-Hydrogen Releases from TPRD by Radiant Heat From Lower Deck
Oct 2015
Publication
In case fires break out on the lower deck of a car carrier ship or a ferry the fuel cell vehicles (FCVs) parked on the upper deck may be exposed to radiant heat from the lower deck. Assuming that the thermal pressure relief device (TPRD) of an FCV hydrogen cylinder is activated by the radiant heat without the presence of flames hydrogen gas will be released by TPRD to form combustible air-fuel mixtures in the vicinity. To investigate the possibility of this accident scenario the present study investigated the relationship between radiant heat and TPRD activation time and evaluated the possibility of radiant heat causing hydrogen releases by TPRD activation under the condition of deck temperature reaching the spontaneous ignition level of the tires and other automotive parts. It was found: a) the tires as well as polypropylene and other plastic parts underwent spontaneous ignition before TPRD was activated by radiant heat and b) when finally TPRD was activated the hydrogen releases were rapidly burned by the flames of the tires and plastic parts on fire. Consequently it was concluded that the explosion of air-fuel mixtures assumed in the accident scenario does not occur in the real world.
Numerical Investigation of Hydrogen Dispersion into Air
Sep 2009
Publication
Computational fluid dynamics (CFD) is used to numerically solve the sudden release of hydrogen from a high pressure tank (up to 70MPa) into air. High pressure tanks increase the risk of failure of the joints and pipes connected to the tank which results in release of Hydrogen. The supersonic flow caused by high pressure ratio of reservoir to ambient generates a strong Mach disk. A three dimensional in-house code is developed to simulate the flow. High pressure Hydrogen requires a real gas law because it deviates from ideal gas law. Firstly Beattie-Bridgeman and Abel-Noble real gas equation of states are applied to simulate the release of hydrogen in hydrogen. Then Abel-Noble is implied to simulate the release of hydrogen in air. Beattie-Bridgeman has stability problems in the case of hydrogen in air. A transport equation is used to solve the concentration of Hydrogen-air mixture. The code is second order accurate in space and first order in time and uses a modified Van Leer limiter. The fast release of Hydrogen from a small rupture needs a very small mesh therefore parallel computation is applied to overcome memory problems and to decrease the solution time. The high pressure ratio of the reservoir to ambient causes a very fast release which is accurately modelled by the code and all the shocks and Mach disk happening are observed in the results. The results show that the difference between real gas and ideal gas models cannot be ignored.
Flammability Limits and Laminar Flame Speed of Hydrogen–air Mixtures at Sub-atmospheric Pressures
Sep 2011
Publication
Hydrogen behavior at elevated pressures and temperatures was intensively studied by numerous investigators. Nevertheless there is a lack of experimental data on hydrogen ignition and combustion at reduced sub-atmospheric pressures. Such conditions are related to the facilities operating under vacuum or sub-atmospheric conditions for instance like ITER vacuum vessel. Main goal of current work was an experimental evaluation of such fundamental properties of hydrogen–air mixtures as flammability limits and laminar flame speed at sub-atmospheric pressures. A spherical explosion chamber with a volume of 8.2 dm3 was used in the experiments. A pressure method and high-speed camera combined with schlieren system for flame visualization were used in this work. Upper and lower flammability limits and laminar flame velocity have been experimentally evaluated in the range of 4–80% hydrogen in air at initial pressures 25–1000 mbar. An extraction of basic flame properties as Markstein length overall reaction order and activation energy was done from experimental data on laminar burning velocity.
Ignition of H2-NO2/N2O4 Mixtures Under Volumetric Expansion Conditions
Sep 2019
Publication
The competition between chemical energy release rate and volumetric expansion related to shock wave’s dynamics is of primary importance for a number of situations relevant to explosion safety. While studies have been performed on this topic over the years they have been limited to mixtures with monotonous energy release profile. In the present study the ignition of H2-NO2/N2O4 mixtures which exhibit a single-step or a two-step energy release rate profile depending on the equivalence ratio has been investigated under volumetric expansion conditions. The rate of expansion has been calculated using the Taylor-Sedov solution and accounted for using 0-D numerical simulations with time-dependent specific volume. The results were analyzed in terms of a Damkohler number defined as the ratio of the expansion to ignition times. For mixtures with non-monotonous energy release rate profiles two critical Damkohler numbers can be identified one for each of the steps of energy release. It was also shown that the fluid element which is the most likely to ignite corresponds to the one behind a shock propagating at the Chapman-Jouguet velocity. The thermo-chemical dynamics have been analyzed about the critical conditions using energy release rate per reaction rate of production and sensitivity analyses.
Wide Area and Distributed Hydrogen Sensors
Sep 2009
Publication
Recent advances in optical sensors show promise for the development of new wide area monitoring and distributed optical network hydrogen detection systems. Optical hydrogen sensing technologies reviewed here are: 1) open path Raman scattering systems 2) back scattering from chemically treated solid polymer matrix optical fiber sensor cladding; and 3) schlieren and shearing interferometry imaging. Ultrasonic sensors for hydrogen release detection are also reviewed. The development status of these technologies and their demonstrated results in sensor path length low hydrogen concentration detection ability and response times are described and compared to the corresponding status of hydrogen spot sensor network technologies.
Experimental Study of the Spontaneous Ignition of Partly Confined Hydrogen Jets
Sep 2011
Publication
The current study addresses the spontaneous ignition of hydrogen jets released into a confined oxidizer environment experimentally. The experiments are conducted in a shock tube where hydrogen gas is shock-accelerated into oxygen across a perforated plate. The operating conditions and hole dimension of the plate were varied in order to identify different flow field and ignition scenarios. Time resolved Schlieren visualization permitted to reconstruct the gasdynamic evolution of the release and different shock interactions. Time resolved self-luminosity records permitted us to record whether ignition was achieved and also to record the dimension of the turbulent mixing layer. The ignition limits determined experimentally in good agreement with the 1D diffusion ignition model proposed by Maxwell and Radulescu. Nevertheless the experiments demonstrated that the mixing layer is two to three orders of magnitude thicker than predicted by molecular diffusion which can be attributed to the observed mixing layer instabilities and shock-mixing layer interactions which provide a much more intense mixing rate than anticipated from previous and current numerical predictions. These observations further clarify why releases through partly confined geometries are more conducive to jet ignition of the jets.
Simulation of DDT in Hydrogen-Air Behind a Single Obstacle
Sep 2011
Publication
Two-dimensional numerical simulations of deflagration-to-detonation transition (DDT) in hydrogen–air mixtures are presented and compared with experiments. The investigated geometry was a 3 m long square channel. One end was closed and had a single obstacle placed 1 m from the end and the other end was open to the atmosphere. The mixture was ignited at the closed end. Experiments and simulations showed that DDT occurred within 1 m behind the obstacle. The onset of detonation followed a series of local explosions occurring far behind the leading edge of the flame in a layer of unburned reactants between the flame and the walls. A local explosion was also seen in the experiments and the pressure records indicated that there may have been more. Furthermore local explosions were observed in the experiments and simulations which did not detonate. The explosions should have sufficient strength and should explode in a layer of sufficient height to result in a detonation. The numerical resolution was 0.5 mm per square cell and further details of the combustion model used are provided in the paper.
Ignition Experiments of Hydrogen Mixtures by Different Methods and Description of the DRDC Test Facilities
Sep 2009
Publication
The paper will present results of hydrogen/oxygen mixtures ignited by using electric sparks electrostatic discharges a heating element and a flame. Measurements of the lower flammability limit (LFL) was done for each ignition method. The hydrogen mixtures of different concentrations were ignited at the bottom of a combustion chamber leading to an upward propagation of the resulting flame. At some level of concentration the combustion was partial due to the limited upward propagation. The complete combustion of the whole mixture was observed at concentration limits higher than the known LFL of 4% vol. for hydrogen in air. The paper will describe the test facilities and the resulting ignition probabilities for different ignition methods.
Modeling of the Flame Acceleration in Flat Layer for Hydrogen-air Mixtures
Sep 2011
Publication
The flame propagation regimes for the stoichiometric hydrogen-air mixtures in an obstructed semiconfined flat layer have been numerically investigated in this paper. Conditions defining fast or sonic propagation regime were established as a function of the main dimensions characterizing the system and the layout of the obstacles. It was found that the major dependencies were the following: the thickness of the layer of H2-air mixture the blockage ratio and the distance between obstacles and the obstacle size. A parametric study was performed to determine the combination of the above variables prone to produce strong combustions. Finally a criterion that separates experiments resulting in slow subsonic from fast sonic propagations regimes was proposed.
Comparison of NFPA and ISO Approaches for Evaluating Separation Distances
Sep 2011
Publication
The development of a set of safety codes and standards for hydrogen facilities is necessary to ensure they are designed and operated safely. To help ensure that a hydrogen facility meets an acceptable level of risk code and standard development organizations (SDOs) are utilizing risk-informed concepts in developing hydrogen codes and standards. Two SDOs the National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) and the International Organization for Standardization (ISO) through its Technical Committee (TC) 197 on hydrogen technologies have been developing standards for gaseous hydrogen facilities that specify the facilities have certain safety features use equipment made of material suitable for a hydrogen environment and have specified separation distances. Under Department of Energy funding Sandia National Laboratories (SNL) has been supporting efforts by both of these SDOs to develop the separation distances included in their respective standards. Important goals in these efforts are to use a defensible science-based approach to establish these requirements and to the extent possible harmonize the requirements. International harmonization of regulations codes and standards is critical for enabling global market penetration of hydrogen and fuel cell technologies.
Regulations and Research on RC&S for Hydrogen Storage Relevant To Transport and Vehicle Issues with Special Focus on Composite Containments
Sep 2011
Publication
Developers interested in high pressure storage of hydrogen for mobile use increasingly rely on composite cylinders for onboard storage or transport of dangerous goods. Thus composite materials and systems deserve special consideration. History gives interesting background information important to the understanding of the current situation as to regulations codes and standards.<br/>Based on this review origins of different regulations for the storage of hydrogen as dangerous good and as propellant for vehicles will be examined. Both categories started out using steel and sometimes aluminium as cylinder material. With composite materials becoming more common a new problem emerged: vital input for regulations on composite pressure systems was initially derived from decades of experience with steel cylinders. As a result both regulatory fields suffer somewhat from this common basis. Only recent developments regarding requirements for composite cylinders have begun to go more and more separate ways. Thus these differences lead to some shortcomings in regulation with respect to composite storage systems.<br/>In principle in spite of separate development these deficits are in both applications very much the same: there are uncertainties in the prediction of safe service life in retesting procedures of composite cylinders and in their intervals. Hence different aspects of uncertainties and relevant approaches to solutions will be explained.
Study of Potential Leakage on Several Stressed Fittings for Hydrogen Pressures Up To 700 Bar
Sep 2011
Publication
In order to improve risk analyses and influence the design of the future H2 systems an experimental study on “real” leaks qualification and quantification was performed. In H2 energy applications fittings appeared as a significant leakage potential and subsequently explosion and flame hazards. Thus as a part of the “Horizon Hydrogène Energie” French program four kinds of commercial fittings usually employed on H2 systems were tested thanks to a new high pressure test bench – designed setup and operated by INERIS – allowing experiments to be led for H2 pressures until 700 bar. The fittings underwent defined stresses representative of H2 systems lifetime and beyond. The associated leaks – when existing – are characterized in terms of flow rate.
Hydrogen Tank Filling Experiments at the JRC-IE Gastef Facility
Sep 2011
Publication
Storage of gases under pressure including hydrogen is a well-known technique. However the use in vehicles of hydrogen at pressures much higher than those applicable in natural gas cars still requires safety and performance studies with respect to the verification of the existing standards and regulations. The JRC-IE has developed a facility GasTeF for carrying out tests on full-scale high pressure vehicle’s tanks for hydrogen or natural gas. Typical tests performed in GasTeF are static permeation measurements of the storage system and hydrogen cycling in which tanks are fast filled and slowly emptied using hydrogen pressurised up to 70 MPa for at least 1000 times according to the requirements of the EU regulation on type-approval of hydrogen-powered motor vehicles. Moreover the temperature evolution of the gas inside and outside the tank is monitored using an ad-hoc designed thermocouples array system. This paper reports the first experimental results on the temperature distribution during hydrogen cycling tests.
Simulation of High-pressure Liquid Hydrogen Releases
Sep 2011
Publication
Sandia National Laboratories is working with stakeholders to develop scientific data for use by standards development organizations to create hydrogen codes and standards for the safe use of liquid hydrogen. Knowledge of the concentration field and flammability envelope for high-pressure hydrogen leaks is an issue of importance for the safe use of liquid hydrogen. Sandia National Laboratories is engaged in an experimental and analytical program to characterize and predict the behaviour of liquid hydrogen releases. This paper presents a model for computing hydrogen dilution distances for cold hydrogen releases. Model validation is presented for leaks of room temperature and 80 K high-pressure hydrogen gas. The model accounts for a series of transitions that occurs from a stagnate location in the tank to a point in the leak jet where the concentration of hydrogen in air at the jet centerline has dropped to 4% by volume. The leaking hydrogen is assumed to be a simple compressible substance with thermodynamic equilibrium between hydrogen vapor hydrogen liquid and air. For the multi-phase portions of the jet near the leak location the REFPROP equation of state models developed by NIST are used to account for the thermodynamics. Further downstream the jet develops into an atmospheric gas jet where the thermodynamics are described as a mixture of ideal gases (hydrogen–air mixture). Simulations are presented for dilution distances in under-expanded high-pressure leaks from the saturated vapor and saturated liquid portions of a liquid hydrogen storage tank at 10.34 barg (150 PSIG).
Ignition and Heat Radiation of Cryogenic Hydrogen Jets
Sep 2011
Publication
In the present work release and ignition experiments with horizontal cryogenic hydrogen jets at temperatures of 35–65 K and pressures from 0.7 to 3.5 MPa were performed in the ICESAFE facility at KIT. This facility is specially designed for experiments under steady-state sonic release conditions with constant temperature and pressure in the hydrogen reservoir. In distribution experiments the temperature velocity turbulence and concentration distribution of hydrogen with different circular nozzle diameters and reservoir conditions was investigated for releases into stagnant ambient air. Subsequent combustion experiments of hydrogen jets included investigations on the stability of the flame and its propagation behaviour as function of the ignition position. Furthermore combustion pressures and heat radiation from the sonic jet flame during the combustion process were measured. Safety distances were evaluated and an extrapolation model to other jet conditions was proposed. The results of this work provide novel data on cryogenic sonic hydrogen jets and give information on the hazard potential arising from leaks in liquid hydrogen reservoirs.
Ignition of Flammable Hydrogen & Air Mixtures by Controlled Glancing Impacts in Nuclear Waste Decommissioning
Sep 2013
Publication
Conditions are examined under which mechanical stimuli produced by striking controlled blows can result in sparking and ignition of hydrogen in air mixtures. The investigation principally concerns magnesium thermite reaction as the ignition source and focuses on the conditions and thermomechanical parameters that are involved in determining the probability of ignition. It is concluded that the notion of using the kinetic energy of impact as the main criterion in determining whether an ignition event is likely or not is much less useful than considering the parameters which determine the maximum temperature produced in a mechanical stimuli event. The most influential parameter in determining ignition frequency or probability is the velocity of sliding movement during mechanical stimuli. It is also clear that the kinetic energy of a moving hammer head is of lesser importance than the normal force which is applied during contact. This explains the apparent discrepancy in previous studies between the minimum kinetic energy thought to be necessary to allow thermite sparking and gas ignition to occur with drop weight impacts and glancing blow impacts. In any analysis of the likelihood of mechanical stimuli to cause ignition the maximum surface temperature generated should be determined and considered in relation to the temperatures that would be required to initiate hot surface reactions sufficient to cause sparking and ignition.
Experimental Investigation of Flame and Pressure Dynamics after Spontaneous Ignition in Tube Geometry
Sep 2013
Publication
Spontaneous ignition processes due to high pressure hydrogen releases into air are known phenomena. The sudden expansion of pressurized hydrogen into a pipe filled with ambient air can lead to a spontaneous ignition with a jet fire. This paper presents results of an experimental investigation of the visible flame propagation and pressure measurements in 4 mm extension tubes of up to 1 m length attached to a bulk vessel by a rupture disc. Transparent glass tubes for visual observation and shock wave pressure sensors are used in this study. The effect of the extension tube length on the development of a stable jet fire after a spontaneous ignition is discussed.
Hydrogen Emergency Response Training for First Responders
Sep 2011
Publication
The U.S. Department of Energy supports the implementation of hydrogen fuel cell technologies by providing hydrogen safety and emergency response training to first responders. A collaboration was formed to develop and deliver a one-day course that uses a mobile fuel cell vehicle (FCV) burn prop designed and built by Kidde Fire Trainers. This paper describes the development of the training curriculum including the design and operation of the FCV prop; describes the successful delivery of this course to over 300 participants at three training centers in California; and discusses feedback and observations received on the course. Photographs and video clips of the training sessions will be presented.
Validation of CFD Models for Hydrogen Fast Filling Simulations
Sep 2011
Publication
High injection pressures are used during the re-fuelling process of vehicle tanks with compressed hydrogen and consequently high temperatures are generated in the tank potentially jeopardizing the system safety. Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) tools can help in predicting the temperature rise within vehicle tanks providing complete and detailed 3D information on flow features and temperature distribution. In this framework CFD simulations of hydrogen fast filling at different working conditions are performed and the accuracy of the numerical models is assessed against experimental data for a type 4 tank up to 70 MPa. Sensitivity analyses on the main modelling parameters are carried out in compliance with general CFD Best Practice Guidelines.
Fire Prevention Technical Rule for Gaseous Hydrogen Transport in Pipelines
Sep 2007
Publication
This paper presents the current results of the theoretical and experimental activity carried out by the Italian Working Group on the fire prevention safety issues in the field of the hydrogen transport in pipelines. From the theoretical point of view a draft document has been produced beginning from the regulations in force on the natural gas pipelines; these have been reviewed corrected and integrated with the instructions suitable to the use with hydrogen gas. From the experimental point of view a suitable apparatus has been designed and installed at the University of Pisa; this apparatus will allow the simulation of hydrogen releases from a pipeline with or without ignition of the hydrogen-air mixture. The experimental data will help the completion of the above-mentioned draft document with the instructions about the safety distances. However in the opinion of the Group the work on the text contents is concluded and the document is ready to be discussed with the Italian stakeholders involved in the hydrogen applications.
Development of Hydrogen Sensors and Recombiners
Sep 2005
Publication
Hydrogen energy is very promising as it ensures a high efficiency and ecological cleanliness of energy conversion. The goal of the present work is to provide the analysis of hydrogen safety aspects and to prescribe methods of safety operation with hydrogen. The authors conducted a hazard analysis of hydrogen operation and storage in comparison with other fuels. Good ventilation is the main hydrogen operation requirement. Besides an effective way of protection against propagation of hazards (for instance leaks) is neutralization of dangerous hydrogen-air mixtures by a method of controlled catalytic combustion inside special devices so-called recombiners [1-3]. The basis of these devices is a high porosity cell material (HPCM) activated by platinum deposition. Apart from recombiners HPCM was also applied for development of hydrogen detectors intended for measurement and analysis of hydrogen concentration for hydrogen-driven transport and objects of hydrogen infrastructure (including vapor-air media at high pressure and temperatures). A system of hydrogen safety based on hydrogen detectors and hydrogen catalytic recombiners was developed. Experimental and theoretical studies of hydrogen combustion processes heat- and mass transfer and also gas flows in catalytic-activated HPCM allowed for a design optimization of recombiners and their location. Pilot hydrogen detectors and hydrogen catalytic recombiners were fabricated and their laboratory tests were successfully performed. Thus it was indicated that on condition of following the appropriate passive and active safety measures hydrogen is just as safe as the other fuels. This conclusion represents another incentive for a transition to the hydrogen energy.
Physics of Spontaneous Ignition of High-Pressure Hydrogen Release and Transition to Jet Fire
Sep 2009
Publication
The main objective of this study is an insight into physical phenomena underlying spontaneous ignition of hydrogen at sudden release from high pressure storage and its transition into the sustained jet fire. This paper describes modelling and large eddy simulation (LES) of spontaneous ignition dynamics in a tube with a rupture disk separating high pressure hydrogen storage and the atmosphere. Numerical experiments carried out by a LES model have provided an insight into the physics of the spontaneous ignition phenomenon. It is demonstrated that a chemical reaction commences in a boundary layer within the tube and propagates throughout the tube cross-section after that. Simulated by the LES model dynamics of flame formation outside the tube has reproduced experimental observation of combustion by high-speed photography including vortex induced “flame separation". It is concluded that the model developed can be applied for hydrogen safety engineering in particular for development of innovative pressure relief devices.
Experimental Study of Hydrogen Release Accidents in a Vehicle Garage
Sep 2009
Publication
Storing a hydrogen fuel-cell vehicle in a garage poses a potential safety hazard because of the accidents that could arise from a hydrogen leak. A series of tests examined the risk involved with hydrogen releases and deflagrations in a structure built to simulate a one-car garage. The experiments involved igniting hydrogen gas that was released inside the structure and studying the effects of the deflagrations. The “garage” measured 2.72 m high 3.64 m wide and 6.10 m long internally and was constructed from steel using a reinforced design capable of withstanding a detonation. The front face of the garage was covered with a thin transparent plastic film. Experiments were performed to investigate extended-duration (20–40 min) hydrogen leaks. The effect that the presence of a vehicle in the garage has on the deflagration was also studied. The experiments examined the effectiveness of different ventilation techniques at reducing the hydrogen concentration in the enclosure. Ventilation techniques included natural upper and lower openings and mechanical ventilation systems. A system of evacuated sampling bottles was used to measure hydrogen concentration throughout the garage prior to ignition and at various times during the release. All experiments were documented with standard and infrared (IR) video. Flame front propagation was monitored with thermocouples. Pressures within the garage were measured by four pressure transducers mounted on the inside walls of the garage. Six free-field pressure transducers were used to measure the pressures outside the garage.
Processes of the Formation of Large Unconfined Clouds Following a Massive Spillage of Liquid Hydrogen on the Ground
Sep 2007
Publication
Because of hydrogen low volumetric energy content under its gaseous form transport and storage of liquid hydrogen will certainly play a major role in any future hydrogen economy. One of the obstacles to the expected development use of hydrogen is the poor state of knowledge on explosion risks in the event of an extensive spillage. INERIS set up a large-scale experiment to study the mechanisms of the formation of the gas cloud resulting from such a spillage and the associated mixing process and turbulence effects. Dispersion tests have been performed with cryogenic helium presenting similar dispersion characteristics than liquid hydrogen (buoyancy). Flowrates up to 3 kg/s have been investigated and the instrumentation allowed the observation and quantification of bouyancy effects including internal turbulence. Those results constitute an originals et of data which can be used as a basis for the development of dispersion software and reinterpretation of other existing databases ([10 11])
Risk Analysis of the Storage Unit in Hydrogen Refuelling Station
Sep 2007
Publication
Nowadays consumer demand for local and global environmental quality in terms of air pollution and in particular greenhouse gas emissions reduction may help to drive to the introduction of zero emission vehicles. At this regard the hydrogen technology appears to have future market valuablepotential. On the other hand the use of hydrogen vehicles which requires appropriate infrastructures for production storage and refuelling stages presents a lot of safety problems due to the peculiar chemicophysical hydrogen characteristics. Therefore safe at the most practices are essential for the successful proliferation of hydrogen vehicles. Indeed to avoid limit hazards it is necessary to implement practices that if early adopted in the development of a fuelling station project can allow very low environmental impact safety being incorporated in the project itself. Such practices generally consist in the integrated use of Failure Mode and Effect Analysis (FMEA) HAZard OPerability (HAZOP) and Fault Tree Analysis (FTA) which constitute well established standards in reliability engineering. At this regard however a drawback is the lack of experience and the scarcity of the relevant data collection. In this work we present the results obtained by the integrated use of FMEA HAZOP and FTA analyses relevant for the moment the high-pressure storage equipment in a hydrogen gas refuelling station. The study that is intended to obtain elements for improving safety of the system can constitute a basis for further more refined works.
Experimental Study of Hydrogen-Air Deflagrations in Flat Layer
Sep 2007
Publication
In the present paper the results of experiments on study of high-speed deflagrations in flat layer of hydrogen-air mixtures unconfined from below are presented. The experiments were performed in two different rectangular channels: small-scale with mixture volume up to 0.4 m3 and large-scale with volume up to 5.5 m3. The main goal of the experiments was to examine the possibility of the layer geometries to maintain high-speed deflagration and detonation. With the aim to study a range of combustion regimes the experiments were performed varying degree of channel obstruction hydrogen concentration and thickness of the layer. Depending on the experimental conditions all major combustion regimes were observed: slow flame fast – ‘choked’ flame and steady-state detonation. It was found that minimum layer layer thickness in the range of 8 to 15 detonation cell widths is required for sustainable detonations.
Numerical Studies of Dispersion and Flammable Volume of Hydrogen in Enclosures
Sep 2007
Publication
Hydrogen dispersion in an enclosure is numerically studied using simple analytical solutions and a large-eddy-simulation based CFD code. In simple calculations the interface height and temperature rise of the upper layer are obtained based on mass and energy conservation and the centreline hydrogen volume fraction is derived from similarity solutions of buoyant jets. The calculated centreline hydrogen volume fraction using the two methods agree with each other; however discrepancies are found for the calculated total flammable volume as a result of the inability of simple calculations in taking into account local mixing and diffusion. The CFD model in contrast is found to be capable of correctly reproducing the diffusion and stratification phenomena during the mixing stage.
Fire Protection Strategy for Compressed Hydrogen-Powered Vehicles
Sep 2007
Publication
Virtually all major automotive companies are currently developing hydrogen-powered vehicles. The vast majority of them employ compressed hydrogen tanks and components as a means of storing the fuel onboard. Compressed hydrogen vehicle fuel systems are designed in the same way as compressed natural gas vehicles (NGV) i.e. the high pressure (up to 70 MPa) fuel is always contained within the system under all conditions with the exception of vehicular fire. In the event of a vehicle fire the fuel system is protected using a non-reclosing thermally activated pressure relief device (PRD) which safely vents the contents. Hydrogen fuel system PRDs are presently qualified to the performance requirements specified in draft hydrogen standards such ANSI/CSA HPRD 1 and EIHP Rev. 12b. They are also qualified with individual fuel tank designs in accordance with the engulfing bonfire requirements in various published/draft tank standards such as CSA B51 Part 2 JARI S001 SAE TIR J2579 ANSI/CSA HGV 2 ISO DIS 15869.2 and EIHP Rev. 12b. Since 2000 there have been over 20 documented NGV tank failures in service 11 of which have been attributed to vehicle fires. This paper will examine whether currently proposed hydrogen performance standards and installation requirements offer suitable fuel system protection in the event of vehicular fires. A number of alternative fire protection strategies will be discussed including:
- The requirement of an engulfing and/or localized fire test for individual tanks fuel systems and complete vehicles;
- The advantages/disadvantages of point source- surface area- and/or fuse-based PRDs
- The use of thermal insulating coatings/blankets for fire protection resulting in the NONventing of the fuel
- The specification of appropriate fuel system installation requirements to mitigate the effect of vehicular fires.
Explosion Hazard of Hydrogen-Air Mixtures in the Large Volumes
Sep 2007
Publication
The report deals with the investigation of non-stationary combustion of hydrogen-air mixtures extremely relevant to the issues of safety. Considered are the conditions of its formation and development in the tubes in the conic element and in the spherical 12-m diameter chamber. The report shows that at the formation of non-stationary combustion in the conic element in its top the pressure can develop exceeding 1000 atmospheres. It is also shown that in large closed volumes non-stationary combustion can develop from a small energy source in contrast to detonation for whose stimulation in large volumes significant power influences are required. Simultaneously in the volume a pressure can be formed by far exceeding the Chapman-Jouguet pressure in the front of stationary detonation.
Assessing the Durability and Integrity of Natural Gas Infrastructures for Transporting and Distributing Mixtures of Hydrogen and Natural Gas
Sep 2005
Publication
Extensive infrastructure exists for the transport of natural gas and it is an obvious step to assess its use for the movement of hydrogen. The Naturalhy project’s objective is to prepare the European natural gas industry for the introduction of hydrogen by assessing the capability of the natural gas infrastructure to accept mixtures of hydrogen and natural gas. This paper presents the ongoing work within both Durability and Integrity Work Packages of the Naturalhy project. This work covers a gap in knowledge on risk assessment required for delivering H2+natural gas blends by means of the existing natural gas grids in safe operation.<br/>Experiments involving several parts of the existing infrastructure will be described that are being carried out to re-examine the major risks previously studied for natural gas including: effect of H2 on failure behaviour and corrosion of transmission pipes and their burst resistance (link to the Work Package Safety) on permeability and ageing of distribution pipes on reliability and ageing of domestic gas meters tightness to H2 of domestic appliances and their connexions. The information will be integrated into existing Durability assessment methodologies originally developed for natural gas.<br/>An Integrity Management Tool will be developed taking account of the effect of hydrogen on the materials properties. The tool should enable a cost effective selection of appropriate measures to control the structural integrity and maintaining equipment. The main measures considered are monitoring non destructive examination (pigging and non pigging) and repair strategies. The tool will cover a number of parameters e.g.: percentage of hydrogen in the gas mixture material of construction operating conditions and condition of cathodic protection. Thus the Integrity Management Tool will yield an inspection and maintenance plan based on the specific circumstances.
Massive H2 Production With Nuclear Heating, Safety Approach For Coupling A VHTR With An Iodine Sulfur Process Cycle
Sep 2005
Publication
In the frame of a sustainable development investigations dealing with massive Hydrogen production by means of nuclear heating are carried out at CEA. For nuclear safety thermodynamic efficiency and waste minimization purposes the technological solution privileged is the coupling of a gas cooled Very High Temperature Reactor (VHTR) with a plant producing Hydrogen from an Iodine/Sulfur (I/S) thermochemical cycle. Each of the aforementioned facilities presents different risks resulting from the operation of a nuclear reactor (VHTR) and from a chemical plant including Hydrogen other flammable and/or explosible substances as well as toxic ones. Due to these various risks the safety approach is an important concern. Therefore this paper deals with the preliminary CEA investigations on the safety issues devoted to the whole plant focusing on the safety questions related to the coupling between the nuclear reactor and the Hydrogen production facility. Actually the H2 production process and the energy distribution network between the plants are currently at a preliminary design stage. A general safety approach is proposed based on a Defence In Depth (DID) principle permitting to analyze all the system configurations successively in normal incidental and accidental expected operating conditions. More precisely the dynamic answer of an installation to a perturbation affecting the other one during the previous conditions as well as the potential aggressions of the chemical plant towards the nuclear reactor have to be considered. The methodology presented in this paper is intended to help the designer to take into account the coupling safety constraints and to provide some recommendations on the global architecture of both plants especially on their coupling system. As a result the design of a VHTR combined to a H2 production process will require an iterative process between design and safety requirements.
Hydrogen Releases Ignited in a Simulated Vehicle Refuelling Environment
Sep 2007
Publication
If the general public is to use hydrogen as a vehicle fuel customers must be able to handle hydrogen with the same degree of confidence and with comparable risk as conventional liquid and gaseous fuels. The hazards associated with jet releases from leaks in a vehicle-refuelling environment must be considered if hydrogen is stored and used as a high-pressure gas since a jet release in a confined or congested area could result in an explosion. As there was insufficient knowledge of the explosion hazards a study was initiated to gain a better understanding of the potential explosion hazard consequences associated with high-pressure leaks from refuelling systems. This paper describes two experiments with a dummy vehicle and dispenser units to represent refuelling station congestion. The first represents a ‘worst-case’ scenario where the vehicle and dispensers are enveloped by a 5.4 m x 6.0 m x 2.5 m high pre-mixed hydrogen-air cloud. The second is an actual high-pressure leak from storage at 40 MPa (400 bar) representing an uncontrolled full-bore failure of a vehicle refuelling hose. In both cases an electric spark ignited the flammable cloud. Measurements were made of the explosion overpressure generated its evolution with time and its decay with distance. The results reported provide a direct demonstration of the explosion hazard from an uncontrolled leak; they will also be valuable for validating explosion models that will be needed to assess configurations and conditions beyond those studied experimentally.
Monitoring H2 Bubbles by Real Time H2 Sensor
Sep 2017
Publication
Portable H2 sensor was made by using mass spectrometer for the outside monitoring experiment: the leak test the replacement test of gas pipe line the combustion test the explosion experiment the H2 diffusion experiment and the recent issue of the exhaust gas of Fuel Cell Vehicle. In order to check the real time concentration of H2 in various conditions even in the highly humid condition the system volume of the sampling route was minimized with attaching the humidifier. Also to calibrate H2 concentration automatically the specific concentration H2 small cylinder was mounted in the system. In the experiment when H2 gas was introduced in the N2 flow or air in the tube or the high-pressure bottle highly concentrated H2 phases were observed by this sensor without diffusion. This H2 sensor can provide the real time information of the hydrogen molecules and the clouds. The basic characterization of this sensor showed 0-100% H2 concentrations within 2ms. Our observation showed the size of the high concentration phase of H2 and the low concentration phase after mixing process. The mixed and unmixed H2 unintended concentration of cloud gas the high speed small cluster of hydrogen molecules in purged gas were explored by this real time monitoring system.
Study of a Post-fire Verification Method for the Activation Status of Hydrogen Cylinder Pressure Relief Devices
Oct 2015
Publication
To safely remove from its fire accident site a hydrogen fuel cell vehicle equipped with a carbon fiber reinforced plastic composite cylinder for compressed hydrogen (CFRP cylinder) and to safely keep the burnt vehicle in a storage facility it is necessary to verify whether the thermally-activated pressure relief device (TPRD) of the CFRP cylinder has already been activated releasing the hydrogen gas from the cylinder. To develop a simple post-fire verification method on TPRD activation the present study was conducted on the using hydrogen densitometer and Type III and Type IV CFRP cylinders having different linings. As the results TPRD activation status can be determined by measuring hydrogen concentrations with a catalytic combustion hydrogen densitometer at the cylinder's TPRD gas release port.
Validation of Two-Layer Model for Underexpanded Hydrogen Jets
Sep 2019
Publication
Previous studies have shown that the two-layer model more accurately predicts hydrogen dispersion than the conventional notional nozzle models without significantly increasing the computational expense. However the model was only validated for predicting the concentration distribution and has not been adequately validated for predicting the velocity distributions. In the present study particle imaging velocimetry (PIV) was used to measure the velocity field of an underexpanded hydrogen jet released at 10 bar from a 1.5 mm diameter orifice. The two-layer model was the used to calculate the inlet conditions for a two-dimensional axisymmetric CFD model to simulate the hydrogen jet downstream of the Mach disk. The predicted velocity spreading and centerline decay rates agreed well with the PIV measurements. The predicted concentration distribution was consistent with data from previous planar Rayleigh scattering measurements used to verify the concentration distribution predictions in an earlier study. The jet spreading was also simulated using several widely used notional nozzle models combined with the integral plume model for comparison. These results show that the velocity and concentration distributions are both better predicted by the two-layer model than the notional nozzle models to complement previous studies verifying only the predicted concentration profiles. Thus this study shows that the two-layer model can accurately predict the jet velocity distributions as well as the concentration distributions as verified earlier. Though more validation studies are needed to improve confidence in the model and increase the range of validity the present work indicates that the two-layer model is a promising tool for fast accurate predictions of the flow fields of underexpanded hydrogen jets.
Validation and Recommendations for CFD and Engineering Modeling of Hydrogen Vented Explosions: Effects of Concentration, Stratification, Obstruction and Vent Area
Oct 2015
Publication
Explosion venting is commonly used in the process industry as a prevention solution to protect equipment or buildings against excessive internal pressure caused by an explosion. This article is dedicated to the validation of FLACS CFD code for the modelling of vented explosions. Analytical engineering models fail when complex cases are considered for instance in the presence of obstacles or H2 stratified mixtures. CFD is an alternative solution but has to be carefully validated. In this study FLACS simulations are compared to published experimental results and recommendations are suggested for their application.
Hydrogen-enhanced Fatigue Crack Growth in Steels and its Frequency Dependence
Jun 2017
Publication
In the context of the fatigue life design of components particularly those destined for use in hydrogen refuelling stations and fuel cell vehicles it is important to understand the hydrogen-induced fatigue crack growth (FCG) acceleration in steels. As such the mechanisms for acceleration and its influencing factors are reviewed and discussed in this paper with a special focus on the peculiar frequency dependence of the hydrogen-induced FCG acceleration. Further this frequency dependence is debated by introducing some potentially responsible elements along with new experimental data obtained by the authors.
This article is part of the themed issue ‘The challenges of hydrogen and metals’.
Link to document download on Royal Society Website
This article is part of the themed issue ‘The challenges of hydrogen and metals’.
Link to document download on Royal Society Website
Experimental Investigation of Unconfined Spherical and Cylindrical Flame Propagation in Hydrogen-air Mixtures
Sep 2019
Publication
This paper presents results of experimental investigations on spherical and cylindrical flame propagation in pre-mixed H2/air-mixtures in unconfined and semi-confined geometries. The experiments were performed in a facility consisting of two transparent solid walls with 1 m2 area and four weak side walls made from thin plastic film. The gap size between the solid walls was varied stepwise from thin layer geometry (6 mm) to cube geometry (1 m). A wide range of H2/air-mixtures with volumetric hydrogen concentrations from 10% to 45% H2 was ignited between the transparent solid walls. The propagating flame front and its structure was observed with a large scale high speed shadow system. Results of spherical and cylindrical flame propagation up to a radius of 0.5 m were analyzed. The presented spherical burning velocity model is used to discuss the self-acceleration phenomena in unconfined and unobstructed pre-mixed H2/air flames.
Freeze of Nozzle & Receptacle During Hydrogen Fueling
Oct 2015
Publication
We conducted a fuelling test with hydrogen gas for a safety evaluation of the nozzle/receptacle at a controlled temperature and humidity. Test results confirmed that the nozzle/receptacle froze under specific conditions. However freezing did not cause apparatus damage nor hydrogen leakage. The nozzle/receptacle is thus able to fuel safely even if the nozzle/receptacle is stuck due to ice. In addition we quantified the water volume that causes freezing.
Performance Tests of Catalysts for the Safe Conversion of Hydrogen Inside the Nuclear Waste Containers in Fukushima Daiichi
Sep 2019
Publication
The safe decommissioning as well as decontamination of the radioactive waste resulting from the nuclear accident in Fukushima Daiichi represents a huge task for the next decade. At present research and development on long-term safe storage containers has become an urgent task with international cooperation in Japan. One challenge is the generation of hydrogen and oxygen in significant amounts by means of radiolysis inside the containers as the nuclear waste contains a large portion of sea water. The generation of radiolysis gases may lead to a significant pressure build-up inside the containers and to the formation of flammable gases with the risk of ignition and the loss of integrity.
In the framework of the project “R&D on technology for reducing concentration of flammable gases generated in long-term waste storage containers” funded by the Japanese Ministry of Education Culture Sports Science and Technology of Japan (MEXT) the potential application of catalytic recombiner devices inside the storage containers is investigated. In this context a suitable catalyst based on the so-called intelligent automotive catalyst for use in a recombiner is under consideration. The catalyst is originally developed and mass-produced for automotive exhaust gas purification and is characterized by having a self-healing function of precious metals (Pd Pt and Rh) dissolved as a solid solution in the perovskite type oxides. The basic features of this catalyst have been tested in an experimental program. The test series in the REKO-4 facility has revealed the basic characteristics of the catalyst required for designing the recombiner system.
In the framework of the project “R&D on technology for reducing concentration of flammable gases generated in long-term waste storage containers” funded by the Japanese Ministry of Education Culture Sports Science and Technology of Japan (MEXT) the potential application of catalytic recombiner devices inside the storage containers is investigated. In this context a suitable catalyst based on the so-called intelligent automotive catalyst for use in a recombiner is under consideration. The catalyst is originally developed and mass-produced for automotive exhaust gas purification and is characterized by having a self-healing function of precious metals (Pd Pt and Rh) dissolved as a solid solution in the perovskite type oxides. The basic features of this catalyst have been tested in an experimental program. The test series in the REKO-4 facility has revealed the basic characteristics of the catalyst required for designing the recombiner system.
Update on Regulation Review for HRS Construction and Operations in Japan
Oct 2015
Publication
In 2005 the Japanese High-pressure Gas Safety Act the Fire Service Act and the Building Standards Act were revised to establish the requirements for 35 MPa hydrogen stations. And in 2012-2014 revisions were made to the High-pressure Gas Safety Act and the Fire Service Act to provide the regulatory requirements for 70 MPa hydrogen stations. We conducted a study on materials that may contribute to prepare technical standards concerning the major 4 items 12 additional items and 13 new items which may affect the costs from the point of view of promoting the hydrogen infrastructure.
An Experimental Study on Mechanism of Self-ignition of High-pressure Hydrogen
Oct 2015
Publication
In the present study the self-ignition of high-pressure hydrogen released in atmospheric air through a diaphragm is visualized under various test conditions. The experimental results indicate that the hydrogen that jets through the rupturing diaphragm is mixed with the heated air near the tube wall. The self-ignition event originated from this mixing. The self-ignition was strongly dependent on the strength of an incident shock wave generated at the diaphragm rupture. As a result a cylindrical flame that formed after the self-ignition shows a tendency to become longer as it propagates in the downstream direction. The head velocities of the hydrogen-air mixture and the cylindrical flame are consistent with that of a contact surface calculated from the measured shock speed. A modified self-ignition mechanism is proposed based on the experimental observations.
Steam Condensation Effect in Hydrogen Venting from a BWR Reactor Building
Oct 2015
Publication
In the accident of Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power plants hydrogen was accumulated in the reactor buildings and exploded. To prevent such explosions hydrogen venting from reactor buildings is considered. When the gas mixture is released to a reactor building through a reactor containment together with the hydrogen some amount of steam might also be released. The steam condenses if the building atmosphere is below the saturation temperature and it affects the hydrogen behaviour. In this study the condensation effect to the hydrogen venting is evaluated using CFD analyses by comparing the case where a hydrogen-nitrogen mixture is released and the case where a hydrogen-steam mixture is released.
On the Use of Hydrogen in Confined Spaces: Results from the Internal Project InsHyde
Sep 2009
Publication
Alexandros G. Venetsanos,
Paul Adams,
Inaki Azkarate,
A. Bengaouer,
Marco Carcassi,
Angunn Engebø,
E. Gallego,
Olav Roald Hansen,
Stuart J. Hawksworth,
Thomas Jordan,
Armin Keßler,
Sanjay Kumar,
Vladimir V. Molkov,
Sandra Nilsen,
Ernst Arndt Reinecke,
M. Stöcklin,
Ulrich Schmidtchen,
Andrzej Teodorczyk,
D. Tigreat,
N. H. A. Versloot and
L. Boon-Brett
The paper presents an overview of the main achievements of the internal project InsHyde of the HySafe NoE. The scope of InsHyde was to investigate realistic small-medium indoor hydrogen leaks and provide recommendations for the safe use/storage of indoor hydrogen systems. Additionally InsHyde served to integrate proposals from HySafe work packages and existing external research projects towards a common effort. Following a state of the art review InsHyde activities expanded into experimental and simulation work. Dispersion experiments were performed using hydrogen and helium at the INERIS gallery facility to evaluate short and long term dispersion patterns in garage like settings. A new facility (GARAGE) was built at CEA and dispersion experiments were performed there using helium to evaluate hydrogen dispersion under highly controlled conditions. In parallel combustion experiments were performed by FZK to evaluate the maximum amount of hydrogen that could be safely ignited indoors. The combustion experiments were extended later on by KI at their test site by considering the ignition of larger amounts of hydrogen in obstructed environments outdoors. An evaluation of the performance of commercial hydrogen detectors as well as inter-lab calibration work was jointly performed by JRC INERIS and BAM. Simulation work was as intensive as the experimental work with participation from most of the partners. It included pre-test simulations validation of the available CFD codes against previously performed experiments with significant CFD code inter-comparisons as well as CFD application to investigate specific realistic scenarios. Additionally an evaluation of permeation issues was performed by VOLVO CEA NCSRD and UU by combining theoretical computational and experimental approaches with the results being presented to key automotive regulations and standards groups. Finally the InsHyde project concluded with a public document providing initial guidance on the use of hydrogen in confined spaces.
A field explosion test of hydrogen-air mixtures
Sep 2005
Publication
This paper shows the experimental results and findings of field explosion tests conducted to obtain fundamental data concerning the explosion of hydrogen-air mixtures. A tent covered with thin plastic sheets was filled with hydrogen/air mixed gas and subsequently ignited by an electric-spark or explosives to induce deflagration and/or detonation. Several experiments with different concentrations and/or volumes of mixture were carried out. The static overpressure of blast waves was measured using piezoelectric pressure sensors. The recorded data show that the shape of the pressure-time histories of the resulting blast waves depends on the difference in the ignition method used. The pictures of the explosion phenomenon (deflagration and/or detonation) were taken by high-speed cameras.
Numerical Simulation of Hydrogen Explosion Tests with a Barrier Wall for Blast Mitigation
Sep 2005
Publication
We have investigated hydrogen explosion risk and its mitigation focusing on compact hydrogen refuelling stations in urban areas. In this study numerical analyses were performed of hydrogen blast propagation and the structural behaviour of barrier walls. Parametric numerical simulations of explosions were carried out to discover effective shapes for blast-mitigating barrier walls. The explosive source was a prismatic 5.27 m3 volume that contained 30% hydrogen and 70% air. A reinforced concrete wall 2 m tall by 10 m wide and 0.15 m thick was set 2 or 4 m away from the front surface of the source. The source was ignited at the bottom centre by a spark for the deflagration case and 10 g of C-4 high explosive for two detonation cases. Each of the tests measured overpressures on the surfaces of the wall and on the ground displacements of the wall and strains of the rebar inside the wall. The blast simulations were carried out with an in-house CFD code based on the compressive Euler equation. The initial energy estimated from the volume of hydrogen was a time-dependent function for the deflagration and was released instantaneously for the detonations. The simulated overpressures were in good agreement with test results for all three test cases. DIANA a finite element analysis code released by TNO was used for the structural simulations of the barrier wall. The overpressures obtained by the blast simulations were used as external forces. The analyses simulated the displacements well but not the rebar strains. The many shrinkage cracks that were observed on the walls some of which penetrated the wall could make it difficult to simulate the local behaviour of a wall with high accuracy and could cause strain gages to provide low-accuracy data. A parametric study of the blast simulation was conducted with several cross-sectional shapes of barrier wall. A T-shape and a Y-shape were found to be more effective in mitigating the blast.
An Intercomparison Exercise on the Capabilities of CFD Models to Predict Distribution and Mixing of H2 in a Closed Vessel.
Sep 2005
Publication
This paper presents a compilation and discussion of the results supplied by HySafe partners participating in the Standard Benchmark Exercise Problem (SBEP) V1 which is based on an experiment on hydrogen release mixing and distribution inside a vessel. Each partner has his own point of view of the problem and uses a different approach to the solution. The main characteristics of the models employed for the calculations are compared. The comparison between results together with the experimental data when available is made. Relative deviations of each model from the experimental values are also included. Explanations and interpretations of the results are presented together with some useful conclusions for future work.
Mixing of Dense or Light Gases with Turbulent Air- a Fast-Running Model for Lumped Parameter Codes
Sep 2005
Publication
The release of gases heavier than air like propane at ground level or lighter than air like hydrogen close to a ceiling can both lead to fire and explosion hazards that must be carefully considered in safety analyses. Even if the simulation of accident scenarios in complex installations and long transients often appears feasible only using lumped parameter computer codes the phenomenon of denser or lighter gas dispersion is not implicitly accounted by these kind of tools. In the aim to set up an ad hoc model to be used in the computer code ECART fluid-dynamic simulations by the commercial FLUENT 6.0 CFD code are used. The reference geometry is related to cavities having variable depth (2 to 4 m) inside long tunnels filled with a gas heavier or lighter than air (propane or hydrogen). Three different geometrical configurations with a cavity width of 3 6 and 9 m are considered imposing different horizontal air stream velocities ranging from 1 to 5 m/s. A stably-stratified flow region is observed inside the cavity during gas shearing. In particular it is found that the density gradient tends to inhibit turbulent mixing thus reducing the dispersion rate. The obtained data are correlated in terms of main dimensionless groups by means of a least squares method. In particular the Sherwood number is correlated as a function of Reynolds a density ratio modified Froude numbers and in terms of the geometrical parameter obtained as a ratio between the depth of the air-dense gas interface and the length of the cavity. This correlation is implemented in the ECART code to add the possibility to simulate large installations during complex transients lasting many hours with reasonable computation time. An example of application to a typical case is presented.
Phenomena of Dispersion and Explosion of High Pressurized Hydrogen
Sep 2005
Publication
To make “Hydrogen vehicles and refuelling station systems” fit for public use research on hydrogen safety and designing mitigative measures are significant. For compact storage it is planned to store under high pressure (40MPa) at the refuelling stations so that the safety for the handling of high-pressurized hydrogen is essential. This paper describes the experimental investigation on the hypothetical dispersion and explosion of high-pressurized hydrogen gas which leaks through a large scale break in piping and blows down to atmosphere. At first we investigated time history of distribution of gas concentration in order to comprehend the behaviour of the dispersion of high-pressurized hydrogen gas before explosion experiments. The explosion experiments were carried out with changing the time of ignition after the start of dispersion. Hydrogen gas with the initial pressure of 40MPa was released through a nozzle of 10mm diameter. Through these experiments it was clarified that the explosion power depends not only on the concentration and volume of hydrogen/air pre-mixture but also on the turbulence characteristics before ignition. To clarify the explosion mechanism the numerical computer simulation about the same experimental conditions was performed. The initial conditions such as hydrogen distribution and turbulent characteristics were given by the results of the atmospheric diffusion simulation. By the verification of these experiments the results of CFD were fully improved.
Testing of Hydrogen Safety Sensors in Service Simulated Conditions
Sep 2005
Publication
Reliable and effective sensors for the accurate detection of hydrogen concentrations in air are essential for the safe operation of fuel cells hydrogen fuelled systems (e.g. vehicles) and hydrogen production distribution and storage facilities. The present paper describes the activity on-going at JRC for the establishment of a facility that can be used for testing and validating the performance of hydrogen sensors under a range of conditions representative of those to be encountered in service. Potential aspects to be investigated in relation to the sensors performances are the influence of temperature humidity and pressure (simulating variations in altitude) the sensitivity to target gas and the cross sensitivity to other gases/vapours the reaction and recovery time and the sensors’ lifetime. The facility set up at JRC for the execution of these tests is described including the program for its commissioning. The results of a preliminary test are presented and discussed as an example.
Risk Assessment for Hydrogen Codes and Standards
Sep 2005
Publication
The development and promulgation of codes and standards are essential to establish a market-receptive environment for commercial hydrogen-based products and systems. The focus of the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) is to conduct the research and development (R&D) needed to strengthen the scientific basis for technical requirements incorporated in national and international standards codes and regulations. In the U.S. the DOE and its industry partners have formed a Codes and Standards Tech Team (CSTT) to help guide the R&D. The CSTT has adopted an R&D Roadmap to achieve a substantial and verified database of the properties and behaviour of hydrogen and the performance characteristics of emerging hydrogen technology applications sufficient to enable the development of effective codes and standards for these applications. However to develop a more structured approach to the R&D described above the CSTT conducted a workshop on Risk Assessment for Hydrogen Codes and Standards in March 2005. The purpose of the workshop was to attain a consensus among invited experts on the protocols and data needed to address the development of risk-informed standards codes and regulations for hydrogen used as an energy carrier by consumers. Participants at the workshop identified and assessed requirements methodologies and applicability of risk assessment (RA) tools to develop a framework to conduct RA activities to address for example hydrogen fuel distribution delivery on-site storage and dispensing and hydrogen vehicle servicing and parking. The CSTT was particularly interested in obtaining the advice of RA experts and representatives of standards and model code developing organizations and industry on how data generated by R&D can be turned into information that is suitable for hydrogen codes and standards development. The paper reports on the results of the workshop and the RA activities that the DOE’s program on hydrogen safety codes and standards will undertake. These RA activities will help structure a comprehensive R&D effort that the DOE and its industry partners are undertaking to obtain the data and conduct the analysis and testing needed to establish a scientific and technical basis for hydrogen standards codes and regulations.
Numerical Modelling of Hydrogen Release, Mixture and Dispersion in Atmosphere.
Sep 2005
Publication
The method of the numerical solution of a three-dimensional problem of atmospheric release dispersion and explosion of gaseous admixtures is presented. It can be equally applied for gases of different densities including hydrogen. The system of simplified Navie-Stocks equations received by truncation of viscous members (Euler equations with source members) is used to obtain a numerical solution. The algorithm is based on explicit finite-difference Godunov scheme of arbitrary parameters breakup disintegration. To verify the developed model and computer system comparisons of numerical calculations with the published experimental data on the dispersion of methane and hydrocarbons explosions have been carried out. Computational experiments on evaporation and dispersion of spilled liquid hydrogen and released gaseous hydrogen at different wind speeds have been conducted. The largest mass concentrations of hydrogen between the bottom and top limits of flame propagation and cloud borders have been determined. The problem of the explosion of a hydrogen-air cloud of the complex form generated by large-scale spillage of liquid hydrogen and instant release of gaseous hydrogen has been numerically solved at low wind speed. Shock-wave loadings affecting the buildings located on a distance of 52 m from a hydrogen release place have been shown.
Characterization of Materials in Pressurized Hydrogen Under Cyclic Loading at Service Conditions in Hydrogen Powered Engines
Sep 2005
Publication
A new testing device for cyclic loading of specimens with a novel shape design is presented. The device was applied for investigations of fatigue of metallic specimens under pressurized hydrogen up to 300 bar at temperatures up to 200 °C. Main advantage of the specimen design is the very small amount of medium here hydrogen used for testing. This allows experiments with hazardous substances at lower safety level. Additionally no gasket for the load transmission is required. Woehler curves which show the influence of hydrogen on the fatigue behaviour of austenitic steel specimens at relevant service conditions in hydrogen powered engines are presented. Material and test conditions are in agreement with the cooperating industry.
An Inter-Comparison Exercise on the Capabilities of CFD Models to Predict the Short and Long Term Distribution and Mixing of Hydrogen in a Garage
Sep 2007
Publication
Alexandros G. Venetsanos,
E. Papanikolaou,
J. García,
Olav Roald Hansen,
Matthias Heitsch,
Asmund Huser,
Wilfried Jahn,
Jean-Marc Lacome,
Thomas Jordan,
H. S. Ledin,
Dmitry Makarov,
Prankul Middha,
Etienne Studer,
Andrei V. Tchouvelev,
Franck Verbecke,
M. M. Voort,
Andrzej Teodorczyk and
M. A. Delichatsios
The paper presents the results of the CFD inter-comparison exercise SBEP-V3 performed within the activity InsHyde internal project of the HYSAFE network of excellence in the framework of evaluating the capability of various CFD tools and modelling approaches in predicting the physical phenomena associated to the short and long term mixing and distribution of hydrogen releases in confined spaces. The experiment simulated was INERIS-TEST-6C performed within the InsHyde project by INERIS consisting of a 1 g/s vertical hydrogen release for 240 s from an orifice of 20 mm diameter into a rectangular room (garage) of dimensions 3.78x7.2x2.88 m in width length and height respectively. Two small openings at the front and bottom side of the room assured constant pressure conditions. During the test hydrogen concentration time histories were measured at 12 positions in the room for a period up to 5160 s after the end of release covering both the release and the subsequent diffusion phases. The benchmark was organized in two phases. The first phase consisted of blind simulations performed prior to the execution of the tests. The second phase consisted of post calculations performed after the tests were concluded and the experimental results made available. The participation in the benchmark was high: 12 different organizations (2 non-HYSAFE partners) 10 different CFD codes and 8 different turbulence models. Large variation in predicted results was found in the first phase of the benchmark between the various modelling approaches. This was attributed mainly to differences in turbulence models and numerical accuracy options (time/space resolution and discretization schemes). During the second phase of the benchmark the variation between predicted results was reduced.
Safety Distances- Definition and Values
Sep 2005
Publication
In order to facilitate the introduction of a new technology as it is the utilization of hydrogen as an energy carrier development of safety codes and standards besides the conduction of demonstrative projects becomes a very important action to be realized. Useful tools of work could be the existing gaseous fuel codes (natural gas and propane) regulating the stationary and automotive applications. Some safety codes have been updated to include hydrogen but they have been based on criteria and/or data applicable for large industrial facilities making the realization of public hydrogen infrastructures prohibitive in terms of space. In order to solve the above mentioned problems others questions come out: how these safety distances have been defined? Which hazard events have been taken as reference for calculation? Is it possible to reduce the safety distances through an appropriate design of systems and components or through the predisposition of adequate mitigation measures? This paper presents an analysis of the definitions of “safety distances” and “hazardous locations” as well as a synoptic analysis of the different values in force in several States for hydrogen and natural gas. The above mentioned synoptic table will highlight the lacks and so some fields that need to be investigated in order to produce a suitable hydrogen standard.
Canadian Hydrogen Safety Program.
Sep 2005
Publication
This paper discusses the rationale structure and contents of the Canadian Hydrogen Safety Program developed by the Codes & Standards Working Group of the Canadian Transportation Fuel Cell Alliance consisting of representatives from industry academia government and regulators. The overall program objective is to facilitate acceptance of the products services and systems of the Canadian Hydrogen Industry by the Canadian Hydrogen Stakeholder Community to facilitate trade ensure fair insurance policies and rates ensure effective and efficient regulatory approval procedures and to ensure that the interests of the general public are accommodated. The Program consists of four projects including Comparative Quantitative Risk Assessment of Hydrogen and Compressed Natural Gas (CNG) Refuelling Stations; Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) Modelling Validation Calibration and Enhancement; Enhancement of Frequency and Probability Analysis and Consequence Analysis of Key Component Failures of Hydrogen Systems; and Fuel Cell Oxidant Outlet Hydrogen Sensor Project. The Program projects are tightly linked with the content of the IEA Task 19 Hydrogen Safety. The Program also includes extensive (destructive and non-destructive) testing of hydrogen components.
Simulation of Flame Acceleration and DDT in H2-air Mixture with a Flux Limiter Centred Method
Sep 2005
Publication
Flame acceleration and deflagration to detonation transition (DDT) is simulated with a numerical code based on a flux limiter centred method for hyperbolic differential equations. The energy source term is calculated by a Riemann solver for the in homogeneous Euler equations for the turbulent combustion and a two-step reaction model for hydrogen-air. The transport equations are filtered for large eddy simulation (LES) and the sub filter turbulence is modelled by a transport equation for the the turbulent kinetic energy. The flame tracking is handled by the G-equation for turbulent flames. Numerical results are compared to pressure histories from physical experiments. These experiments are performed in a closed circular 4m long tube with inner diameter of 0.107m. The tube is filled with hydrogen-air mixture at 1atm which is at rest when ignited. The ignition is located at one end of the tube. The tube is fitted with an obstruction with circular opening 1m down the tube from the ignition point. The obstruction has a blockage ratio of 0.92 and a thickness of 0.01m. The obstruction creates high pressures in the ignition end of the tube and very high gas velocities in and behind the obstruction opening. The flame experiences a detonation to deflagration transition (DDT) in the super sonic jet created by the obstruction. Pressure build-up in the ignition end of the tube is simulated with some discrepancies. The DDT in the supersonic jet is simulated but the position of the DDT is strongly dependent on the simulated pressure in the ignition end.
On Numerical Simulation of Liquefied and Gaseous Hydrogen Releases at Large Scales
Sep 2005
Publication
The large eddy simulation (LES) model developed at the University of Ulster has been applied to simulate releases of 5.11 m3 liquefied hydrogen (LH2) in open atmosphere and gaseous hydrogen (GH2) in 20-m3 closed vessel. The simulations of a spill of liquefied hydrogen confirmed the advantage of LES application to reproduce experimentally observed eddy structure of hydrogen-air cloud. The inclination angle of simulated cloud is close to experimentally reported 300. The processes of two phase hydrogen release and heat transfer were simplified by inflow of gaseous hydrogen with temperature 20 K equal to boiling point. It is shown that difference in inflow conditions geometry and grid resolution affects simulation results. It is suggested that phenomenon of air condensationevaporation in the cloud in temperature range 20-90 K should be accounted for in future. The simulations reproduced well experimental data on GH2 release and transport in 20-m3 vessel during 250 min including a phenomenon of hydrogen concentration growth at the bottom of the vessel. Higher experimental hydrogen concentration at the bottom is assumed to be due to non-uniformity of temperature of vessel walls generating additional convection. The comparison of convective and diffusion terms in Navie-Stokes equations has revealed that a value of convective term is more than order of magnitude prevail over a value of turbulent diffusion term. It is assumed that the hydrogen transport to the bottom of the vessel is driven by the remaining chaotic flow velocities superimposed on stratified hydrogen concentration field. Further experiments and simulations with higher accuracy have to be performed to confirm this phenomenon. It has been demonstrated that hydrogen-air mixture became stratified in about 1 min after release was completed. However one-dimensional models are seen not capable to reproduce slow transport of hydrogen during long period of time characteristic for scenarios such as leakage in a garage.
Hydrogen Detection- Visualisation of Hydrogen Using Non Invasive Optical Schlieren Technique BOS
Sep 2005
Publication
The detection of hydrogen after its accidental release is not only important for research purposes but will be much more important under safety aspects for future applications when hydrogen should be a standard energy resource. At Fraunhofer ICT two principally different approaches were made: first the new optical background-oriented schlieren method (BOS) is used for the visualization of hydrogen distribution and mixing processes at a rate of up to 1000 frames per second. The results from experiments with small scale injection of hydrogen/air–mixtures into air flows and free jets of hydrogen and hydrogen/air–mixtures emerging from 1” hoses simulating exhaust pipes will be discussed and interpreted with support from selected high speed videos. Finally mixing zones and safety distances can be determined by this powerful method.
Effect of Carbon Dioxide, Argon and Hydrocarbon Fuels on the Stability of Hydrogen Jet Flames
Sep 2005
Publication
Experimental studies were carried out to examine the lift-off and blow-out stability of H2/CO2 H2/Ar H2/C3H8 and H2/CH4 jet flames. The experiments were carried out using a burner with a 2mm inner diameter. The flame structures were recorded by direct filming and also by a schlieren apparatus. The experiments showed that the four gases affected the lift-off and blow-out stability of the hydrogen differently. The experiments showed that propane addition to an initially attached flame always produced lifted flame and the flame was blown out at higher jet velocity. The blow-out velocity decreased as the increasing in propane concentration. Direct blow-off of hydrogen/propane was never observed. Methane addition resulted in a relatively stable flame comparing with the carbon dioxide and propane addition. Comparisons of the stability of H2/C3H8 H2/CH4 and H2/CO2 flames showed that H2/C3H8 produced the highest lift-off height. Propane is much more effective in lift-off and blow out hydrogen flames. The study carried out a chemical kinetic analysis of H2/CO2 H2/Ar H2/C3H8 and H2/CH4 flames for a comparison of effect of chemical kinetics on flame stability.
Stress Corrosion Cracking Of Stainless Steels In High Pressure Alkaline Electrolysers
Sep 2005
Publication
Hydrogen-producing high-pressure electrolysers operating with 40% potassium hydroxide solution and an applied oxygen pressure up to 30 barg have been developed. Austenitic stainless steels of type AISI316L are deemed resistant to stress corrosion cracking (SCC) in concentrated KOH solutions. However SCC has on some occasions been observed on the oxygen side of the high-pressure electrolysers thereby representing a safety risk in the operation. Several materials have been tested for resistance to SCC using C-ring specimens in autoclaves under conditions similar to the high-pressure electrolysers and at temperatures up to 120°C. The tests confirmed the observed susceptibility of austenitic stainless steels to SCC in concentrated KOH solutions. Higher alloyed austenitic stainless steels also showed SCC. Duplex stainless steel and nickel based Alloy 28 showed good resistance to SCC in the given environment. Further tests are needed to define the optimum weld procedure.
Design of Catalytic Recombiners for Safe Removal of Hydrogen from Flammable Gas Mixtures
Sep 2007
Publication
Several today’s and future applications in energy technology bear the risk of the formation of flammable hydrogen/air mixtures either due to the direct use of hydrogen or due to hydrogen appearing as a by-product. If there’s the possibility of hydrogen being released accidentally into closed areas countermeasures have to be implemented in order to mitigate the threat of an explosion. In the field of nuclear safety passive auto-catalytic recombiners (PAR) are well-known devices for reducing the risk of a hydrogen detonation in a nuclear power plant in the course of a severe accident. Hydrogen and oxygen react on catalyst materials like platinum or palladium already far below conventional flammability limits. The most important concern with regard to the utilization of hydrogen recombiners is the adequate removal of the reaction heat. Already low hydrogen concentrations may increase the system temperature beyond the self-ignition limit of hydrogen/air mixtures and may lead to an unintended ignition on hot parts of the PAR.<br/>Starting from the nuclear application since several years IEF-6 and LRST perform joint research in the field of passive auto-catalytic recombiners including experimental studies modelling and development of new design concepts. Recently approaches on specifically designed catalysts and on passive cooling devices have been successfully tested. In a design study both approaches are combined in order to provide means for efficient and safe removal of hydrogen. The paper summarizes results achieved so far and possible designs for future applications.
Collaborative Activities On Hydrogen Safety under the International Energy Agency’s Hydrogen Implementing
Sep 2005
Publication
In October 2004 the International Energy Agency Hydrogen Implementing Agreement (www.ieahia.org) approved the initiation of a collaborative task on hydrogen safety. During the past twelve months a work plan has been established and several member countries have committed to participate. Because of the nature of the International Energy Agency which is an international agreement between governments it is hoped that such collaboration will complement other cooperative efforts to help build the technology base around which codes and standards can be developed. In this way the new task on hydrogen safety will further the IEA Hydrogen Agreement in fulfilling its mission to accelerate the commercial introduction of hydrogen energy. This paper describes the specific scope and work plan for the collaboration that has been developed to date.
Lagrangian Reaction-Diffusion Model for Predicting the Ignitability of Pressurized Hydrogen Releases
Sep 2009
Publication
Previous experiments demonstrated that the accidental release of high pressure hydrogen into air can lead to the possibility of spontaneous ignition. It is believed that this ignition is due to the heating of the mixing layer between hydrogen and air that is caused by the shock wave driven by the pressurized hydrogen during the release. Currently this problem is poorly understood and not amenable to direct numerical simulation. This is due to the presence of a wide range of scales between the sizes of the blast wave driven and the very thin mixing layer. The present study addresses this fundamental ignition problem and develops a solution framework in order to predict the ignition event for given hydrogen storage pressures and dimension of the release hole. In this problem only the mixing layer between the hydrogen and air is considered. This permits us to use much higher resolution than previous studies. This mixing layer at the jet head is advected as a Lagrangian fluid particle. The key physical processes in the problem are identified to be the mixing of the two gases at the mixing layer the initial heating by the shock wave and a cooling effect due to the expansion of the mixing layer. The results of the simulations indicate that for every storage pressure there exists a critical hole size below which ignition is prevented during the release process. Close inspection of the results indicate that this limit is due to the competition between the heating provided by the shock wave and the cooling due to expansion. Furthermore the results also indicate that the details of the mixing process do not play a significant role to leading order. The limiting ignition criteria were found to be well approximated by the Homogeneous Ignition Model of Cuenot and Poinsot supplemented by a heat loss term due to expansion. Therefore turbulent mixing occurring in reality is not likely to affect the ignition limits derived in the present study. Comparison with existing experiments showed very good agreement.
Numerical Study of the Near-field of Highly Under-expanded Turbulent Gas Jets
Sep 2011
Publication
For safety issues related to the storage of hydrogen under high pressure it is necessary to determine how the gas is released in the case of failure. In particular there exist limited quantitative information on the near-field properties of the gas jets which are important for establishing proper decay laws in the far-field. This paper reports recent CFD results for air and helium obtained in the near-field of the highly under-expanded jets. The gas jets are released from a 30-bar tank with the same opening (orifice). The Reynolds number based on the diameter of the orifice and corresponding gas conditions at the exit was well beyond 106 . The 3D Compressible Multi-Component Navier-Stokes equations were solved directly without relying on the compressibility-corrected turbulence models. The numerical model was initially tested on a one-component (air-air) case where a few aerospace-driven data sets are available for validation. The shock geometry is characterized through the Mach disk position and diameter. These are compared to the results known from the literature and to the scaling laws developed based on the dimensional analysis. In the second two-component (helium-air) jet scenario the density field was validated and examined together with other fields in the attempt to suggest potential initial conditions for the forthcoming far-field simulations.
Blast Wave from Hydrogen Storage Rupture in a Fire
Oct 2015
Publication
This study addresses one of knowledge gaps in hydrogen safety science and engineering i.e. a predictive model for calculation of deterministic separation distances defined by the parameters of a blast wave generated by a high-pressure gas storage tank rupture in a fire. An overview of existing methods to calculate stored in a tank internal (mechanical) energy and a blast wave decay is presented. Predictions by the existing technique and an original model developed in this study which accounts for the real gas effects and combustion of the flammable gas released into the air (chemical energy) are compared against experimental data on high-pressure hydrogen tank rupture in the bonfire test. The main reason for a poor predictive capability of the existing models is the absence of combustion contribution to the blast wave strength. The developed methodology is able to reproduce experimental data on a blast wave decay after rupture of a stand-alone hydrogen tank and a tank under a vehicle. In this study the chemical energy is dynamically added to the mechanical energy and is accounted for in the energy-scaled non-dimensional distance. The fraction of the total chemical energy of combustion released to feed the blast wave is 5% and 9% however it is 1.4 and 30 times larger than the mechanical energy in the stand-alone tank test and the under-vehicle tank test respectively. The model is applied as a safety engineering tool to four typical hydrogen storage applications including onboard vehicle storage tanks and a stand-alone refuelling station storage tank. Harm criteria to people and damage criteria for buildings from a blast wave are selected by the authors from literature to demonstrate the calculation of deterministic separation distances. Safety strategies should exclude effects of fire on stationary storage vessels and require thermal protection of on-board storage to prevent dangerous consequences of high-pressure tank rupture in a fire.
Full Suppression of Hydrogen Explosion Using Phlegmatization Additives- Experimental Results
Sep 2011
Publication
The paper presents results of experimental investigations of different phlegmatizator substances and its binary compounds used for full hydrogen combustion suppression. The work was performed in experimental facilities of three different scales (small medium and large) at normal initial pressure and temperature range 20 ⎯ 120 °С. Ten individual substances and six binary compounds were tested in a small scale experiments. Three individual halogen containing substances capable of full suppression of hydrogen combustion were found in a series of small scale experiments (tube length – 1 m ID – 66 mm). The minimum concentration of the most effective substance was 11% at 20°С and 14% at 120°С in a small scale experiments. Medium scale confined and large scale unconfined experiments confirmed the possibility of full combustion suppression. The minimum concentration of the most effective binary mixture was found to be 12 % at 20°С in a large scale experiments.
Numerical Modelling of Unconfined and Confined Hydrogen Explosion
Sep 2019
Publication
Numerical studies were conducted with the objective of gaining a better understanding of the consequences of potential explosion that could be associated with release of hydrogen in a confined and unconfined environment. This paper describes the work done by us in modelling explosion of accidental releases of hydrogen using our Fire Explosion Release Dispersion (FRED) software. CAM and SCOPE models in FRED is used for validation of congested/uncongested unconfined and congested/uncongested confined vapour cloud explosion respectively. In the first step CAM is validated against experiments of varying gas cloud size blockage ratio equivalence ratio of the mixture and blockage configuration. The model predictions of explosion overpressure are in good agreement with experiments. The results obtained from FRED i.e. overpressure as a function of distance match well in comparison to the experiments. In the second step SCOPE is validated against vented explosion experiments available in open literature. In general SCOPE reproduces the maximum overpressure within the factor of 2. Moreover it well predicts the trends of increase in overpressure with change in type of the fuel increase in number of obstacles blockage ratio and decrease in the vent size.
Numerical Simulation of Hydrogen Release From High-Pressure Storage Vessel
Sep 2009
Publication
In this paper the deflagration region and characteristics of the hydrogen flow which was generated by high-pressure hydrogen discharge from storage vessels were studied. A 3-D analytic model is established based on the species transfer model and the SST k −ω turbulence model. The established model is applied to the research of the flow characteristics of the hydrogen under-expanded jet under different filling pressures of 30 MPa 35 MPa and 40 MPa respectively. The evolution process of hydrogen combustible cloud is analyzed under the filling pressure of 30 MPa. It is revealed that a supersonic jet is formed after the high-pressure hydrogen discharge outlet In the vicinity of the Mach disk the hydrogen jet velocity and temperature reach the maximum values and the variation of filling pressure has little effect on the peak values of the hydrogen jet flow velocity and temperature during the considered pressure range. In the rear of the Mach disk the variation rates of the hydrogen flow velocity and temperature are in inversely proportional to the hydrogen filling pressure. At the preliminary stage the discharged hydrogen is apple-shaped which expands along the radial and then the axial growth rate of the hydrogen cloud increases with the passage of time.
Experimental Study of Vented Hydrogen Deflagration with Ignition Inside and Outside the Vented Volume
Sep 2013
Publication
Experiments were carried out inside a 25 m3 vented combustion test facility (CVE) with a fixed vent area sealed by a plastic sheet vent. Inside the CVE a 0.64 m3 open vent box called RED-CVE was placed. The vent of the RED-CVE was left open and three different vent area were tested. Two different mixing fans one for each compartment were used to establish homogeneous H2 concentrations. This study examined H2 concentrations in the range between 8.5% vol. to 12.5% vol. and three different ignition locations (1) far vent ignition (2) inside the RED-CVE box ignition and (3) near vent ignition (the vent refers to the CVE vent). Peak overpressures generated inside the test facility and the smaller compartment were measured. The results indicate that the near vent ignition generates negligible peak overpressures inside the test facility as compared to those originated by far vent ignition and ignition inside the RED-CVE box. The experiments with far vent ignition showed a pressure increase with increasing hydrogen concentration which reached a peak value at 11% vol. concentration and then decreased showing a non-monotonic behaviour. The overpressure measured inside the RED-CVE was higher when the ignition was outside the box whereas the flame entered the box through the small vent.
Fire Prevention Technical Rule for Gaseous Hydrogen Refuelling Stations
Sep 2005
Publication
In the last years different Italian hydrogen projects provided for gaseous hydrogen motor vehicles refuelling stations. Motivated by the lack of suitable set of rules in the year 2002 Italian National Firecorps (Institute under the Italian Ministry of the Interior) formed an Ad Hoc Working Group asked to regulate the above-said stations as regards fire prevention and protection safety. This Working Group consists of members coming from both Firecorps and academic world (Pisa University). Throughout his work this Group produced a technical rule covering the fire prevention requirements for design construction and operation of gaseous hydrogen refuelling stations. This document has been approved by the Ministry’s Technical Scientific Central Committee for fire prevention (C.C.T.S.) and now it has to carry out the “Community procedure for the provision of information”. This paper describes the main safety contents of the technical rule.
Spontaneous Ignition of Hydrogen Leaks, a Review of Postulated Mechanisms
Sep 2005
Publication
Over the last century there have been reports of high pressure hydrogen leaks igniting for no apparent reason and several ignition mechanisms have been proposed. Although many leaks have ignited there are also reported leaks where no ignition has occurred. Investigations of ignitions where no apparent ignition source was present have often been superficial with a mechanism postulated which whilst appearing to satisfy the conditions prevailing at the time of the release simply does not stand up to rigorous scientific analysis. Some of these proposed mechanisms have been simulated in a laboratory under superficially identical conditions and appear to be rigorous and scientific but the simulated conditions often do not have the same large release rates or quantities mainly because of physical constraints of a laboratory. Also some of the release scenarios carried out or simulated in laboratories are totally divorced from the realistic situation of most actual leaks. Clearly there are gaps in the knowledge of the exact ignition mechanism for releases of hydrogen particularly at the high pressures likely to be involved in future storage and use. Mechanisms which have been proposed in the past are the reverse Joule-Thomson effect; electrostatic charge generation; diffusion ignition; sudden adiabatic compression; and hot surface ignition. Of these some have been characterized by means of computer simulation rather than by actual experiment and hence are not validated. Consequently there are discrepancies between the theories releases known to have ignited and releases which are known to have not ignited. From this postulated ignition mechanisms which are worthy of further study have been identified and the gaps in information have been highlighted. As a result the direction for future research into the potential for ignition of hydrogen escapes has been identified.
Worst Case Scenario for Delayed Explosion of Hydrogen Jets at a High Pressure: Ignition Position
Sep 2021
Publication
Delayed explosion of free field hydrogen releases at a high pressure is subject of multiple investigation performed by various authors in the past years. These studied considered various parameters such as pressures flow rates etc. and their influence on the resulting overpressure. However the influence of the ignition position on the maximum overpressure was not fully explored. Current investigation addressed by computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulations and experimental measurement fills this gap. This work demonstrates that the ignition positions corresponding to 55%-65% of H2/air mixture give the maximum overpressure. This observation initially observed numerically and afterword confirmed experimentally. A simple model is also suggested.
Flame Characteristics of Ignited under-expanded Cryogenic Hydrogen Jets
Sep 2021
Publication
The anticipated upscaling of hydrogen energy applications will involve the storage and transport of hydrogen in a cryogenic state. Understanding the potential hazard arising from small leaks in pressurized storage and transport systems is needed to assist safety analysis and development of mitigation measures. The current knowledge of the ignited pressurized cryogenic hydrogen jet flame is limited. Large eddy simulation (LES) with detailed hydrogen chemistry is applied for the reacting flow. The effects of ignition locations are considered and the initial development of the transient flame kernel from the ignition hot spots is analysed. The flame structures namely side flames and envelop flames are observed in the study which are due to the complex interactions between turbulence fuel-air mixing at cryogenic temperature and chemical reactions.
Some Fundamental Combustion Properties of "Cryogenic" Premixed Hydrogen Air Flames
Sep 2021
Publication
Because of the emergence of the U.E. “green deal” and because of the significant implication of national and regional authorities throughout Europe the “hydrogen” economy is emerging. And with it numerous questions and experimentations. One of them perhaps a key point is the storage and transport of hydrogen. Liquid hydrogen in cryogenic conditions is a possibility already used in the space industry but under a lot of constrains. What may be acceptable in a well-controlled and restrained domain may not be realistic in a wider application closer to the public. Safety should be ensured and there is a need for a better knowledge of the flammable and ignition properties of the “cold” hydrogen mixtures following a cryogenic spillage for instance to select adequate ATEX equipment. The purpose of PRESLHY project [4] is to investigate the ignition fire and explosion characteristics of cryogenic hydrogen spillages and to propose safety engineering methods. The present work is part of it and addresses the measurement of the laminar burning velocity (Sl) flammability limits (FL) minimum ignition energy (MIE)… of hydrogen air mixtures at atmospheric pressure but down to -150°C. To do this a special burner was designed with details given inside this paper together with the experimental results. It is found that the FL domain is reduced when the temperature drops that MIE increases slightly and Sl decreases.
An Innovative and Comprehensive Approach for the Consequence Analysis of Liquid Hydrogen Vessel Explosions
Oct 2020
Publication
Hydrogen is one of the most suitable solutions to replace hydrocarbons in the future. Hydrogen consumption is expected to grow in the next years. Hydrogen liquefaction is one of the processes that allows for increase of hydrogen density and it is suggested when a large amount of substance must be stored or transported. Despite being a clean fuel its chemical and physical properties often arise concerns about the safety of the hydrogen technologies. A potentially critical scenario for the liquid hydrogen (LH2) tanks is the catastrophic rupture causing a consequent boiling liquid expanding vapour explosion (BLEVE) with consequent overpressure fragments projection and eventually a fireball. In this work all the BLEVE consequence typologies are evaluated through theoretical and analytical models. These models are validated with the experimental results provided by the BMW care manufacturer safety tests conducted during the 1990’s. After the validation the most suitable methods are selected to perform a blind prediction study of the forthcoming LH2 BLEVE experiments of the Safe Hydrogen fuel handling and Use for Efficient Implementation (SH2IFT) project. The models drawbacks together with the uncertainties and the knowledge gap in LH2 physical explosions are highlighted. Finally future works on the modelling activity of the LH2 BLEVE are suggested.
Effect of Wind on Cryogenic Hydrogen Dispersion from Vent Stacks
Sep 2021
Publication
Liquid hydrogen vent stacks often release hydrogen for example due to pressure relief from an underutilized tank boiling off hydrogen or after hydrogen delivery and transfer (trucks often depressurize through the tank vent stack to meet pressure regulations for on-road transport).<br/>A rapid release of cryogenic hydrogen through a vent stack will condense moisture from the entrained air forming a visible cloud. It is often assumed that the extent of the cold hydrogen is concurrent with the cloud. In this work a laser-based Raman scattering diagnostic was used to map out the hydrogen location during a series of vent stack release experiments. A description of the diagnostic instrument is given followed by a comparison of hydrogen signals to the visible cloud for releases through a liquid hydrogen vent stack. A liquid hydrogen pump was used to vary the flowrate of hydrogen through the vent stack and tests were performed under low and high wind conditions as well as low and high humidity conditions. The hydrogen was observed only where the condensed moisture was located regardless of the humidity level or wind. These measurements are being used to validate models such as those included in Sanda’s HyRAM toolkit and inform safety codes and standards.
Velocity Measurements of Hydrogen Jets Using the Optical Flow Method
Sep 2021
Publication
Concentration and velocity measurements are crucial for developing and validating hydrogen jet models which provide scientific bases for hydrogen safety analyses. The concentration fields have been visualized and accurately measured using laser diagnostic methods based on lase Rayleigh and Raman scattering techniques. However the velocity measurements are more challenging. Particle image velocimetry (PIV) has been commonly used for measuring velocities in turbulent flows by seeding tracer particles into the flow and assuming the particles intimately following the flow. However sometimes the particle seeding is difficult or disturbs the flow. Moreover simultaneously concentration and velocity measurements are very difficult when using PIV systems to measure the velocities. Therefore the optical flow velocimetry (OFV) method was used to resolve the velocity fields from the scalar fields or particle images of hydrogen jets. In the present work the velocity field and particle images of hydrogen jets were simulated using FLUENT with the large eddy simulation (LES) model and the particle images were then used to resolve the velocity field by the OFV method. The OFV results were compared with the CFD simulations to verify their accuracy. The results show that the OFC method was an efficient low-cost way to extract the velocity fields from particle images. The OFV method accurately located the large vortices in the flow and the velocity distribution of the high-velocity gradients regions was consistent with the CFD results. The present study lays a foundation for using the OFV method to directly resolve the velocity fields from the concentration fields of hydrogen jets measured by laser diagnostics.
Effect of Deformation Microstructures on Hydrogen Embrittlement Sensitivity and Failure Mechanism of 304 Austenitic Stainless Steel: The Significant Role of Rolling Temperature
Feb 2022
Publication
Metastable austenitic stainless steels (ASSs) have excellent ductility but low strength so that their usage as load-bearing components is significantly limited. Rolling is an effective method of increasing strength whereas the effect of rolling temperature on microstructural evolution the hydrogen embrittlement (HE) sensitivity and fracture mechanisms is still unclear. In present study the effect of cold/warm rolling on detailed microstructural characteristics of 304 ASS was quantitatively investigated and the corresponding HE sensitivity was evaluated via slow strain rate test. The results suggest that cold-rolling led to high strength but poor plasticity and deteriorated HE sensitivity while warm-rolled samples provided combination of high strength and ductility and also superior HE resistance. Compared with 18% α′-martensite in cold -rolled steel warm-rolled specimens consisted of complete austenite less twins and lower dislocation density,moreover the favorable {112} ND and {110} ND textures replaced the harmful {001} ND texture. Based on in-situ EBSD observation during SSRT the HE sensitivity was governed by the combined effect of pre-deformation microstructures and the dynamic microstructural evolution. Advanced method of time-of-flight secondary ion mass spectrometry was used to observe the distribution of hydrogen and the hydrogen content of specimens was determined by the gas chromatograph thermal desorption analysis method. An exceedingly small amount of hydrogen entered the warm-rolled samples while a large amount of hydrogen was trapped at grain boundaries of cold-rolled sample leading to complete intergranular fracture. Therefore warm rolling is an effective pathway for obtaining high combination of strength and ductility together with excellent HE sensitivity.
Development of a Tangential Neutron Radiography System for Monitoring the Fatigue Cracks in Hydrogen Fuel Tanks
Jun 2016
Publication
Purpose- To present an overview of the research and development carried out in a European funded framework 7 (FP7) project called SafeHPower for the implementation of neutron radiography to inspect fatigue cracks in vehicle and storage hydrogen fuel tanks. Project background– Hydrogen (H2) is the most promising replacement fuel for road transport due to its abundance efficiency low carbon footprint and the absence of harmful emissions. For the mass market of hydrogen to take off the safety issue surrounding the vehicle and storage hydrogen tanks needs to be addressed. The problem is the residual and additional stresses experienced by the tanks during the continuous cyclic loading between ambient and storage pressure which can result in the development of fatigue cracks. Steel tanks used as storage containers at service stations and depots and/or the composite tanks lined with steel are known to suffer from hydrogen embrittlement (HE). Another issue is the explosive nature of hydrogen (when it is present in the 18-59% range) where it is mixed with oxygen which can lead to catastrophic consequences including loss of life. Monitoring systems that currently exist in the market impose visual examination tests pressure tests and hydrostatic tests after the tank installation [1] [2]. Three inspection systems have been developed under this project to provide continuous monitoring solutions. Approach and scope- One of the inspection systems based on the neutron radiography (NR) technology that was developed in different phases with the application of varied strategies has been presented here. Monte Carlo (MCNP) simulation results to design and develop a bespoke collimator have been presented. A limitation of using an inertial electrostatic Deuterium-Tritium (D-T) pulsed neutron generator for fast neutron radiography has been discussed. Radiographs from the hydrogen tank samples obtained using thermal neutrons from a spallation neutron source at ISIS Rutherford laboratory UK have been presented. Furthermore radiograph obtained using thermal neutrons from a portable D-T neutron generator has been presented. In conclusion a proof in principle has been made to show that the defects in the hydrogen fuel tank can be detected using thermal neutron radiography.
Deflagration Safety Study of Mixtures of Hydrogen and Natural Gas in a Semi-open Space
Sep 2007
Publication
In the transition to a hydrogen economy it is likely that hydrogen will be used or stored in close proximity to other flammable fuels and gases. Accidents can occur that result in the release of two or more fuels such as hydrogen and natural gas that can mix and form a hazard. A series of five medium-scale semi-open-space deflagration experiments have been conducted with hydrogen natural gas and air mixtures. The natural gas consisted of 90% methane 6% ethane 3% propane and 1% butane by volume. Mixtures of hydrogen and natural gas were created with the hydrogen mole fraction in the fuel varying from 1.000 to 0.897 and the natural gas mole fraction varying from 0.000 to 0.103. The hydrogen and natural gas mixture was then released inside a 5.27-m³ thin plastic tent. The stoichiometric fuel-air mixtures were ignited with a 40-J spark located at the bottom center of the tent. Overpressure and impulse data were collected using pressure transducers located within the mixture volume and in the free field. Flame front time-of-arrival was measured using fast response thermocouples and infrared video. Flame speeds relative to a fixed observer were measured between 36.2 m/s and 19.7 m/s. Average peak overpressures were measured between 2.0 kPa and 0.3 kPa. The addition of natural gas inhibited the combustion when the hydrogen mole fraction was less than or equal to 0.949. For these mixtures there was a significant decrease in overpressures. When the hydrogen mole fraction in the fuel was between 0.999 and 0.990 the overpressures were slightly higher than for the case of hydrogen alone. This could be due to experimental scatter or there may be a slight enhancement of the combustion when a very small amount of natural gas was present. From a safety standpoint variation in overpressure was small and should have little effect on safety considerations.
A Homogeneous Non-equilibrium Two-phase Critical Flow Model
Sep 2011
Publication
A non-equilibrium two-phase single-component critical (choked) flow model for cryogenic fluids is developed from first principle thermodynamics. Modern equations-of-state (EOS) based upon the Helmholtz free energy concepts are incorporated into the methodology. Extensive validation of the model is provided with the NASA cryogenic data tabulated for hydrogen methane nitrogen and oxygen critical flow experiments performed with four different nozzles. The model is used to develop a hydrogen critical flow map for stagnation states in the liquid and supercritical regions.
PRD Hydrogen Release and Dispersion, a Comparison of CFD Results Obtained from Using Ideal and Real Gas Law Properties.
Sep 2005
Publication
In this paper CFD techniques were applied to the simulations of hydrogen release from a 400-bar tank to ambient through a Pressure Relieve Device (PRD) 6 mm (¼”) opening. The numerical simulations using the TOPAZ software developed by Sandia National Laboratory addressed the changes of pressure density and flow rate variations at the leak orifice during release while the PHOENICS software package predicted extents of various hydrogen concentration envelopes as well as the velocities of gas mixture for the dispersion in the domain. The Abel-Noble equation of state (AN-EOS) was incorporated into the CFD model implemented through the TOPAZ and PHOENICS software to accurately predict the real gas properties for hydrogen release and dispersion under high pressures. The numerical results were compared with those obtained from using the ideal gas law and it was found that the ideal gas law overestimates the hydrogen mass release rates by up to 35% during the first 25 seconds of release. Based on the findings the authors recommend that a real gas equation of state be used for CFD predictions of high-pressure PRD releases.
Hydrogen Fuelling Station, CEP-Berlin – Safety Risk Assessment and Authority Approval Experience and Lessons Learned
Sep 2005
Publication
The CEP (Clean Energy Partnership) – Berlin is one of the most diversified hydrogen demonstration projects at present. The first hydrogen fuelling station serving 16 cars is fully integrated in an ordinary highly frequented Aral service station centrally located at Messedamm in Berlin. Hydro has supplied and is the owner of the electrolyser with ancillary systems. This unit produces gaseous hydrogen at 12 bar with use of renewable energy presently serving 13 of the cars involved. The CEP project is planned to run for a period of five years and is supported by the German Federal Government and is part of the German sustainability strategy. During the planning and design phase there have been done several safety related assessments and analyses:
- Hydro has carried out a HAZOP (HAZard and OPerability) analysis of the electrolyser and ancillary systems delivered by Hydro Electrolysers.
- Hydro arranged with support from the partners a HAZOP analysis of the interface between the electrolyser and the compressor an interface with two different suppliers on each side.
- A QRA (Quantitative Risk Assessment) of the entire fuelling station has been carried out.
- Hydro has carried out a quantitative explosion risk analysis of the electrolyser container supplied by Hydro Electrolysers.
Explosion Characteristics of Hydrogen Gas in Varying Ship Ventilation Tunnel Geometries: An Experimental Study
Apr 2022
Publication
Hydrogen is widely regarded as a key element of prospective energy solutions for alleviating environmental emission problems. However hydrogen is classified as a high-risk gas because of its wide explosive range high overpressure low ignition energy and fast flame propagation speed compared with those of hydrocarbon-based gases. In addition deflagration can develop into detonation in ventilation or explosion guide tunnels if explosion overpressure occurs leading to the explosion of all combustible gases. However quantitative evidence of an increase in the explosion overpressure of ventilation tunnels is unavailable because the explosive characteristics of hydrogen gas are insufficiently understood. Therefore this study investigated an explosion chamber with the shape of a ventilation pipe in a ship compartment. The effect of tunnel length on explosion overpressure was examined experimentally. For quantitative verification the size of the hydrogen gas explosion overpressure was analyzed and compared with experimental values of hydrocarbon-based combustible gases (butane and LPG (propane 98%)). The experimental database can be used for explosion risk analyses of ships when designing ventilation holes and piping systems and developing new safety guidelines for hydrogen carriers and hydrogen-fueled ships.
Simulations of Hydrogen Releases from a Storage Tanks- Dispersion and Consequences of Ignition
Sep 2005
Publication
We present results from hydrogen dispersion simulations from a pressurized reservoir at constant flow rate in the presence and absence of a wall. The dispersion simulations are performed using a commercial finite volume solver. Validation of the approach is discussed. Constant concentration envelopes corresponding to the 2% 4% and 15% hydrogen concentration in air are calculated for a subcritical vertical jet and for an equivalent subcritical horizontal jet from a high pressure reservoir. The consequences of ignition and the resulting overpressure are calculated for subcritical horizontal and vertical hydrogen jets and in the latter case compared to available experimental data.
Vertical Turbulent Buoyant Helium Jet - CFD Modelling and Validation
Sep 2005
Publication
In this paper a vertical turbulent round jet of helium was studied numerically using the PHOENICS software package. The flow was assumed to be steady incompressible and turbulent. The jet discharge Froude number was 14000 and the turbulent Schmidt number was 0.7. The incompressible Reynolds average Navier-Stokes equations and helium transport equation expressed in 2-D axisymmetric domain were applied to model the underlying helium release. The k-e RNG turbulence model was used for the calculations of the corresponding turbulent viscosity diffusivity velocity and concentration fields in the domain. The simulation results are compared with the experimental measurements from the earlier published studies on helium jets in non-buoyant jet region (NBJ) intermediate region (I) and buoyant plume region (BP). The numerical results show that the radial profiles of mean velocity and mean concentration are consistent with the empirical data scaled by the effective diameter and density-ratio dependence. The mean velocity and concentration fields along the axis of the jet agree with the decay laws correlated from the previous experiments. The discrepancy between the numerical and experimental data is within 10% proving that the current CFD model for gas release and dispersion is robust accurate and reliable and that the CFD technique can be used as an alternative to the experiments with similar helium jets. The authors believe that the current CFD model is well validated through this study and can be further extended to predict similar hydrogen releases and dispersion if the model is properly applied with hydrogen properties.
Statistics, Lessons Learned and Recommendations from Analysis of HIAD 2.0 Database
Mar 2022
Publication
The manuscript firstly describes the data collection and validation process for the European Hydrogen Incidents and Accidents Database (HIAD 2.0) a public repository tool collecting systematic data on hydrogen-related incidents and near-misses. This is followed by an overview of HIAD 2.0 which currently contains 706 events. Subsequently the approaches and procedures followed by the authors to derive lessons learned and formulate recommendations from the events are described. The lessons learned have been divided into four categories including system design; system manufacturing installation and modification; human factors and emergency response. An overarching lesson learned is that minor events which occurred simultaneously could still result in serious consequences echoing James Reason's Swiss Cheese theory. Recommendations were formulated in relation to the established safety principles adapted for hydrogen by the European Hydrogen Safety Panel considering operational modes industrial sectors and human factors. This work provide an important contribution to the safety of systems involving hydrogen benefitting technical safety engineers emergency responders and emergency services. The lesson learned and the discussion derived from the statistics can also be used in training and risk assessment studies being of equal importance to promote and assist the development of sound safety culture in organisations.
Safe Storage of Compressed Hydrogen at Ambient and Cryogenic Temperatures in Flexible Glass Capillaries
Sep 2013
Publication
We have demonstrated that the strength of produced flexible quartz capillaries can be high enough to withstand the internal hydrogen pressure up to 233 MPa at normal and cryogenic temperature. According to the experimental results the cryo-compressed storage of hydrogen in the capillaries at moderate pressure can enable one to reach DOE 2015 aims for the gravimetric and volumetric capacities of vessels for the safe mobile hydrogen storage. Furthermore flexible capillaries in a bundle can probably serve as a high-pressure pipes for the transportation of gases over long distances. The developed technology of hydrogen storage can be applied to methane and hythane (H₂ - CH₄ mixture) which bridge the gap between conventional fossil fuels and the clean future of a hydrogen economy. It can be also applied to other gases i.e. air oxygen and helium-oxygen mixtures widely used in autonomic breathing devices.
Influence of Doping Element in Distributed Hydrogen Optical Fiber Densors with Brillouin Scattering
Sep 2013
Publication
Distributed hydrogen optical fiber sensor with Brillouin scattering is an innovative solution to measure hydrogen in harsh environment as nuclear industry. Glass composition is the key point to enhance the sensing parameter of the fiber in the target application. Several optical fiber with different doping element were used for measuring hydrogen saturation. Permeability of optical plays a major role to the kinetic of hydrogen diffusion. Fluorine doped fiber increase the sorption and the desorption of hydrogen.
Experimental Determination of Minimum Ignition Current (MIC) for Hydrogen & Methane Mixtures for the Determination of the Explosion Group Corresponding to IEC 60079-20-1
Sep 2017
Publication
Power to gas could get an important issue in future permitting the valorisation of green electric excess energy by producing hydrogen mixing it with natural gas (NG) and use the NG grid as temporary storage. NG grid stakeholders expect that blends up to 20% seem to be a realistic scenario. The knowledge of the explosion group for these hydrogen/NG (H2NG) mixtures is a necessary information for the choice of equipment and protective systems intended for the use in potentially explosive atmospheres of these mixtures. Therefore we determined experimentally the minimum ignition current (MIC) the MIC ratios referenced on MIC of pure methane corresponding to IEC 60079-20-1 standard. The results are compared to those obtained by maximum experimental safe gap (MESG) the second standardized method. The tested gas mixtures started from 2 vol.% volume admixture in methane rising in 2% steps up to 20 vol.% of hydrogen. The interpretation of these results could conduct to consider methane/hydrogen mixtures containing more than 14 vol.% of hydrogen as Group IIB gases.
Security Risk Analysis of a Hydrogen Fueling Station with an On-site Hydrogen Production System Involving Methylcyclohexane
Sep 2017
Publication
Although many studies have looked at safety issues relating to hydrogen fuelling stations few studies have analyzed the security risks such as deliberate attack of the station by threats such as terrorists and disgruntled employees. The purpose of this study is to analyze security risks for a hydrogen fuelling station with an on-site production of hydrogen from methylcyclohexane. We qualitatively conducted a security risk analysis using American Petroleum Institute Standard 780 as a reference for the analysis. The analysis identified 93 scenarios including pool fires. We quantitatively simulated a pool fire scenario unique to the station to analyze attack consequences. Based on the analysis and the simulation we recommend countermeasures to prevent and mitigate deliberate attacks.
Comparison of Two-layer Model for High Pressure Hydrogen Jets with Notional Nozzle Model Predictions and Experimental Data
Oct 2015
Publication
A two-layer reduced order model of high pressure hydrogen jets was developed which includes partitioning of the flow between the central core jet region leading to the Mach disk and the supersonic slip region around the core. The flow after the Mach disk is subsonic while the flow around the Mach disk is supersonic with a significant amount of entrained air. This flow structure significantly affects the hydrogen concentration profiles downstream. The predictions of this model are compared to previous experimental data for high pressure hydrogen jets up to 20 MPa and to notional nozzle models and CFD models for pressures up to 35 MPa using ideal gas properties. The results show that this reduced order model gives better predictions of the mole fraction distributions than previous models for highly underexpanded jets. The predicted locations of the 4% lower flammability limit also show that the two-layer model much more accurately predicts the measured locations than the notional nozzle models. The comparisons also show that the CFD model always underpredicts the measured mole fraction concentrations.
Regulations, Codes, and Standards (RCS) For Large Scale Hydrogen Systems
Sep 2017
Publication
Hydrogen has potential applications that require larger-scale storage use and handling systems than currently are employed in emerging-market fuel cell applications. These potential applications include hydrogen generation and storage systems that would support electrical grid systems. There has been extensive work evaluating regulations codes and standards (RCS) for the emerging fuel cell market such as the infrastructure required to support fuel cell electric vehicles. However there has not been a similar RCS evaluation and development process for these larger systems. This paper presents an evaluation of the existing RCS in the United States for large-scale systems and identifies potential RCS gaps. This analysis considers large-scale hydrogen technologies that are currently being employed in limited use but may be more widely used as large-scale applications expand. The paper also identifies areas of potential safety research that would need to be conducted to fill the RCS gaps. U.S. codes define bulk hydrogen storage systems but do not define large-scale systems. This paper evaluates potential applications to define a large-scale hydrogen system relative to the systems employed in emerging technologies such as hydrogen fuelling stations. These large-scale systems would likely be of similar size to or larger than industrial hydrogen systems.
An Analysis of the Experiments Carried Out by HSL in the HyIndoor European Project Studying Accumulation of Hydrogen Released into a Semi-confined Enclosure
Oct 2015
Publication
Experimental work on hydrogen releases consequences in a 31-m3 semi-confined enclosure was performed in the framework of the collaborative European Hyindoor project. Natural ventilation effectiveness on hydrogen build-up limitation in a confined area was studied for several configurations of ventilation openings and of release conditions in real environmental conditions [1]; influence of wind on gas build-up was observed as well. This paper proposes a critical analysis of these experiments carried out by HSL and compares results with analytical approaches available in open scientific literature. The validity of these models in presence of wind was broached.
An Inter-comparison Exercise on Engineering Models Capabilities to Simulate Hydrogen Vented Explosions
Sep 2013
Publication
A benchmark exercise on vented explosion engineering model was carried out against the maximum overpressures (one or two peaks) of published experiments. The models evaluated are Bauwens et al. (2012-1 and 2012-2) [4 7] models Molkov Vent Sizing Technology 1999 2001 and 2008 models [12 13 6]. The experiments in consideration are Pasman et al. experiments (1974) (30% H2 - 1m3) [1] Bauwens et al. (2012) experiments (64m3) [4] Daubech et al. (2011) experiments (10 to 30% H2 - 1 and 10 m3) [2] and Daubech et al. (2013) [5] experiments (4 m3 – H2 10 to 30%). On this basis recommendations and limits of use of these models are proposed.
Vented Hydrogen-air Deflagrations in Low Strength Equipment and Buildings
Sep 2013
Publication
This paper aims to improve prediction capability of the vent sizing correlation presented in the form of functional dependence of the dimensionless deflagration overpressure on the turbulent Bradley number similar to our previous studies. The correlation is essentially upgraded based on recent advancements in understanding and modelling of combustion phenomena relevant to hydrogen-air vented deflagrations and unique large-scale tests carried out by different research groups. The focus is on hydrogen-air deflagrations in low-strength equipment and buildings when the reduced pressure is accepted to be below 0.1 MPa. The combustion phenomena accounted for by the correlation include: turbulence generated by the flame front itself; leading point mechanism stemming from the preferential diffusion of hydrogen in air in stretched flames; growth of the fractal area of the turbulent flame surface; initial turbulence in the flammable mixture; as well as effects of enclosure aspect ratio and presence of obstacles. The correlation is validated against the widest range of experimental conditions available to date (76 experimental points). The validation covers a wide range of test conditions: different shape enclosures of volume up to 120 m3; initially quiescent and turbulent hydrogen-air mixtures; hydrogen concentration in air from 6% to 30% by volume; ignition source location at enclosure centre near and far from a vent; empty enclosures and enclosures with obstacles.
Hydrogen Combustion Experiments in a Vertical Semi-confined Channel
Sep 2017
Publication
Experiments in an obstructed semi-confined vertical combustion channel with a height of 6 m (cross-section 0.4 × 0.4 m) inside a safety vessel of the hydrogen test center HYKA at the Karlsruhe Institute of Technology (KIT) are reported. In the work homogeneous hydrogen-air-mixtures as well as mixtures with different well-defined H2-concentration gradients were ignited either at the top or at the bottom end of the channel. The combustion characteristics were recorded using pressure sensors and sensors for the detection of the flame front that were distributed along the complete channel length. In the tests slow subsonic and fast sonic deflagrations as well as detonations were observed and the conditions for the flame acceleration (FA) to speed of sound and deflagration-to-detonation transition (DDT) are compared with the results of similar experiments performed earlier in a larger semi-confined horizontal channel.
No more items...