Safety
Safety Cost of a Large Scale Hydrogen System for Photovoltaic Energy Regulation
Sep 2011
Publication
Hydrogen can be used as a buffer for storing intermittent electricity produced by solar plants and/or wind farms. The MYRTE project in Corsica France aims to operate and test a large scale hydrogen facility for regulating the electricity produced by a 560 kWp photovoltaic plant.
Due to the large quantity of hydrogen and oxygen produced and stored (respectively 333 kg and 2654 kg) this installation faces safety issues and safety regulations constraints that can lead to extra costs. These extra costs may concern detectors monitoring barrier equipments that have to be taken into account for evaluating the system‘s total cost.
Relying on the MYRTE example that is an R&D platform the present work consists in listing the whole environmental and safety regulations to be applied in France on both Hydrogen and Oxygen production and storage. A methodology has been developed [1] [2] for evaluating safety extra costs. This methodology takes into account various hydrogen storage technologies (gaseous and solid state) and is applicable to other ways of storage (batteries etc.) to compare them. Results of this work based on a forecast of the operating platform over 20 years can be used to extrapolate and/or optimize future safety costs of next large scale hydrogen systems for further PV or wind energy storage applications.
Due to the large quantity of hydrogen and oxygen produced and stored (respectively 333 kg and 2654 kg) this installation faces safety issues and safety regulations constraints that can lead to extra costs. These extra costs may concern detectors monitoring barrier equipments that have to be taken into account for evaluating the system‘s total cost.
Relying on the MYRTE example that is an R&D platform the present work consists in listing the whole environmental and safety regulations to be applied in France on both Hydrogen and Oxygen production and storage. A methodology has been developed [1] [2] for evaluating safety extra costs. This methodology takes into account various hydrogen storage technologies (gaseous and solid state) and is applicable to other ways of storage (batteries etc.) to compare them. Results of this work based on a forecast of the operating platform over 20 years can be used to extrapolate and/or optimize future safety costs of next large scale hydrogen systems for further PV or wind energy storage applications.
CFD Simulations of the Effect of Ventilation on Hydrogen Release Behavior and Combustion in an Underground Mining Environment
Sep 2013
Publication
CFD simulations investigating the effect of ventilation airflow on hydrogen release behaviour in an underground mining tunnel were performed using FLACS hydrogen. Both dispersion and combustion scenarios of a hydrogen release coming from a severed distribution pipeline were investigated. Effects on the hydrogen dispersion such as ventilation strength and the mechanism of air flow supply (a pull or push fan) and mine opening surface roughness surface cavities and obstructions were explored. Results showing the effect of changing the position of the leak adding a cavity on the ceiling of the tunnel and changing the roughness of the walls are given. Overpressure sensitivity to the ignition delay was also considered. From the results for the varied ventilation regimes and spatial scenarios it is difficult to identify the optimal ventilation strategy giving the safest conditions for hydrogen distribution and refuelling in an underground mine.
Effect of Plastic Deformation at Room Temperature on Hydrogen Diffusion of Hot-rolled S30408
Sep 2017
Publication
The influence of plastic deformation on hydrogen diffusion is of critical significance for hydrogen embrittlement (HE) studies. In this work thermal desorption spectroscope (TDS) slow strain rate test (SSRT) feritscope transmission electron microscope (TEM) and TDS model are used to establish the relationship between plastic deformation and hydrogen diffusion aiming at unambiguously elucidating the effect of pre-existing traps on hydrogen diffusion of hot-rolled S30408. An effective way is developed to deduce hydrogen apparent diffusivity in this paper. Results indicate apparent diffusivities decrease firstly and then increase with increasing plastic strain at room temperature. Hydrogen diffusion changing with plastic deformation is a complicated process involving multiple factors. It is suggested to be divided into two processes controlled by dislocations and strain-induced martensite respectively and the transformation strain is about 20% demonstrated by experiments.
Natural and Forced Ventilation of Buoyant Gas Released In a Full-Scale Garage, Comparison of Model Predictions and Experimental Data
Sep 2011
Publication
An increase in the number of hydrogen-fuelled applications in the marketplace will require a better understanding of the potential for fires and explosion associated with the unintended release of hydrogen within a structure. Predicting the temporally evolving hydrogen concentration in a structure with unknown release rates leak sizes and leak locations is a challenging task. A simple analytical model was developed to predict the natural and forced mixing and dispersion of a buoyant gas released in a partially enclosed compartment with vents at multiple levels. The model is based on determining the instantaneous compartment over-pressure that drives the flow through the vents and assumes that the helium released under the automobile mixes fully with the surrounding air. Model predictions were compared with data from a series of experiments conducted to measure the volume fraction of a buoyant gas (at 8 different locations) released under an automobile placed in the center of a full-scale garage (6.8 m × 5.4 m × 2.4 m). Helium was used as a surrogate gas for safety concerns. The rate of helium released under an automobile was scaled to represent 5 kg of hydrogen released over 4 h. CFD simulations were also performed to confirm the observed physical phenomena. Analytical model predictions for helium volume fraction compared favourably with measured experimental data for natural and forced ventilation. Parametric studies are presented to understand the effect of release rates vent size and location on the predicted volume fraction in the garage. Results demonstrate the applicability of the model to effectively and rapidly reduce the flammable concentration of hydrogen in a compartment through forced ventilation.
Characterization of Hydrogen Transport Accidents in Japan Based on Network Theory
Sep 2019
Publication
Realizing the hydrogen economy in Japan entails a risk assessment of its domestic hydrogen supply especially hydrogen transport by road. The first step of the risk assessment is to characterize the hydrogen transport accidents from different energy carriers. However it is difficult to characterize the accidents because hydrogen transport systems have not been fully implemented in Japan. The aim of this study is to characterize the hydrogen transport accidents from different energy carriers in Japan. We studied three major energy carriers namely compressed hydrogen liquefied hydrogen and liquid organic hydride. The accident networks based on network theory were constructed to capture the comprehensive accident processes and quantitatively characterized the hydrogen transport accidents from different energy carriers. The results clarified the differences and similarities in the accident process amongst the energy carriers. Furthermore key accident events were identified. This study contributes to the development of comprehensive hydrogen transport accident scenarios for risk assessment.
A Study on the Continuous Spill with Limited Period of Release
Sep 2013
Publication
In this study the spread of cryogenic liquid due to a limited period of release is investigated for the first time to clarify the unclear conventional concept regarding two release types continuous and instantaneous release. In describing instantaneous release a discharge time has been assumed to be infinitesimally small; however such an assumption is unreal because there exists a finite period of release no matter how rapid it is. If the discharge time is less than the entire time domain the instantaneous release model should be added to the continuous model from the end of the time. This combined release that consists of the initial continuous model and subsequent instantaneous model is more realistic than the instantaneous release. The physical phenomenon is governed by three parameters: the evaporation rate per unit area release time and spill quantity. Third-order perturbation solutions are obtained and compared with a numerical solution to verify the perturbation solution. For the same spill quantity the combined model that consists of continuous and subsequent instantaneous model is necessary for small release times whereas the continuous model is only required for large release times. Additionally the combined release model is necessary for a small spill quantity at a fixed release time. These two release models are clearly distinguished using the perturbation solution.
Compliance Measurements of Fuel Cell Electric Vehicle Exhaust
Sep 2019
Publication
The NREL Sensor Laboratory has been developing an analyzer that can verify compliance to the international United Nations Global Technical Regulation number 13 (GTR 13--Global Technical Regulation on Hydrogen and Fuel Cell Vehicles) prescriptive requirements pertaining to allowable hydrogen levels in the exhaust of fuel cell electric vehicles (FCEV) [1]. GTR 13 prescribes that the FCEV exhaust shall remain below 4 vol% H2 over a 3-second moving average and shall not at any time exceed 8 vol% H2 as verified with an analyzer with a response time (t90) of 300 ms or faster. GTR 13 has been implemented and is to serve as the basis for national regulations pertaining to hydrogen powered vehicle safety in the United States Canada Japan and the European Union. In the U.S. vehicle safety is overseen by the Department of Transportation (DOT) through the Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards (FMVSS) and in Canada by Transport Canada through the Canadian Motor Vehicle Safety Standard (CMVSS). The NREL FCEV exhaust analyzer is based upon a low-cost commercial hydrogen sensor with a response time (t90) of less than 250 ms. A prototype analyzer and gas probe assembly have been constructed and tested that can interface to the gas sampling system used by Environment and Climate Change Canada’s (ECCC) Emission Research and Measurement Section (ERMS) for the exhaust gas analysis. Through a partnership with Transport Canada ECCC will analyze the hydrogen level in the exhaust of a commercial FCEV. ECCC will use the NREL FCEV Exhaust Gas analyzer to perform these measurements. The analyzer was demonstrated on a FCEV operating under simulated road conditions using a chassis dynamometer at a private facility.
Micro-wrinkled Pd Surface for Hydrogen Sensing and Switched Detection of Lower Explosive Limit
Sep 2011
Publication
We report the development and testing of a novel hydrogen sensor that shows a very peculiar response to hydrogen exposure due to its micro-structured palladium surface. The fabrication of the wrinkled Pd surface is obtained using an innovative fast and cheap technique based on the deposition of a thin Pd film on to a thermo-retractable polystyrene sheet that shrinks to 40% of its original size when heated. The buckling of the Pd surface induced by shrinking of the substrate produces nano and micro-wrinkles on the sensor surface. The micro-structured sensor surface is very stable even after repeated hydrogen sorption/desorption cycles. The hydrogen sensing mechanism is based on the transitory absorption of hydrogen atoms into the Pd layer leading to the reversible change of its electrical resistance. Interestingly depending on hydrogen concentration the proposed sensor shows the concurrent effect of both the usually described behaviors of increase or decrease of resistance related to different phenomena occurring upon hydrogen exposure and formation of palladium hydride. The study reports and discusses evidences for an activation threshold of hydrogen concentration in air switching the behavior of sensor performances from e.g. poor negative to large positive sensitivity and from slow to fast detection.
Hydrogen Explosions in 20’ ISO Container
Oct 2015
Publication
This paper describes a series of explosion experiments in inhomogeneous hydrogen air clouds in a standard 20′ ISO container. Test parameter variations included nozzle configuration jet direction reservoir back pressure time of ignition after release and degree of obstacles. The paper presents the experimental setup resulting pressure records and high speed videos. The explosion pressures from the experiments without obstacles were in the range of 0.4–7 kPa. In the experiments with obstacles the gas exploded more violently producing pressures in order of 100 kPa.
Comparison of Solutions for a Liquid Pool Spreading Model with Continuous and Instantaneous Spills
Sep 2013
Publication
In this study a solution for a liquid pool spreading model with a continuous spill is compared with that for a liquid pool spreading model with an instantaneous spill under the same total release volume. As reducing spill time in completely releasing liquid from a tank it is evaluated whether the solution for a continuous spill approaches to that for an instantaneous spill or not. Also effects of the viscous term in the liquid pool spreading model with continuous and instantaneous spills on the liquid pool spreading behaviour are investigated.
QRA Including Utility for Decision Support of H2 Infrastructure Licensing
Sep 2011
Publication
Rational decision making in land use planning and licensing of H2 infrastructure surrounded by other industrial activities and population should take account of individual and societal risks. QRA produces a risk matrix of potential consequences versus event probabilities that is shrouded in ambiguity and lacking transparency. NIMBY and conflict are lurking. To counter these issues risk analysts should therefore also determine the utilities of decision alternatives which describe desirability of benefits on a single scale. Rationally weighing risks versus benefits results in more transparent and defendable decisions. Example risk analyses of two types of refuelling stations and three hydrogen supply transportation types applying Influence Diagram/BBNs are worked out. Keywords: risk assessment influence diagram decision making land use planning
Hypothetical Accident Scenario Modelling for Condensed Hydrogen Storage Materials
Sep 2011
Publication
Hydrogen is seen as an ideal energy carrier for stationary and mobile applications. However the use of high energy density condensed hydrogen storage materials such as NH3BH3 comes with risks associated with their high reactivity with water exposure and their decomposition products reactivity in air. To predict their behaviour under these circumstances idealized finite element models of hypothetical accident scenarios have been developed. Empirical thermodynamic calculations based on precise thermal gravimetric analysis (TGA) and calorimetric experiments have been performed in order to quantify the energy and hydrogen release rates and to quantify the reaction products resulting from water and air exposure.
Numerical Prediction of Cryogenic Hydrogen Vertical Jets
Sep 2019
Publication
Comparison of Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) predictions with measurements is presented for cryo-compressed hydrogen vertical jets. The stagnation conditions of the experiments are characteristic of unintended leaks from pipe systems that connect cryogenic hydrogen storage tanks and could be encountered at a fuel cell refuelling station. Jets with pressure up to 5 bar and temperatures just above the saturation liquid temperature were examined. Comparisons are made to the centerline mass fraction and temperature decay rates the radial profiles of mass fraction and the contours of volume fraction. Two notional nozzle approaches are tested to model the under-expanded jet that was formed in the tests with pressures above 2 bar. In both approaches the mass and momentum balance from the throat to the notional nozzle are solved while the temperature at the notional nozzle was assumed equal to the nozzle temperature in the first approach and was calculated by an energy balance in the second approach. The two approaches gave identical results. Satisfactory agreement with the measurements was found in terms of centerline mass fraction and temperature. However for test with 3 and 4 bar release the concentration was overpredicted. Furthermore a wider radial spread was observed in the predictions possibly revealing higher degree of diffusion using the k-ε turbulence model. An integral model for cryogenic jets was also developed and provided good results. Finally a test simulation was performed with an ambient temperature jet and compared to the cold jet showing that warm jets decay faster than cold jets.
The Spread of Fire from Adjoining Vehicles to a Hydrogen Fuel Cell Vehicle
Sep 2011
Publication
Two vehicle fire tests were conducted to investigate the spread of fire to adjacent vehicles from a hydrogen fuel cell vehicle (HFCV) equipped with a thermal pressure relief device (TPRD) : – 1) an HFCV fire test involving an adjacent gasoline vehicle 2) a fire test involving three adjoining HFCV assuming their transportation in a carrier ship. The test results indicated that the adjacent vehicles were ignited by flames from the interior and exterior materials of the fire origin HFCV but not by the hydrogen flames generated through the activation of TPRD.
Structural Health Monitoring Techniques for Damages Detection in Hydrogen Pressure Vessels
Sep 2013
Publication
Damages due to mechanical impacts on the structural integrity of pressure vessels in composite material to store compressed hydrogen can lead to disastrous failures if they are not detected and fixed on time. A wide variety of damage modes in composites such as delamination and fiber breakage introduced by impact is difficult to be detected by conventional methods. Structural Health Monitoring (SHM) provides a system with the ability to detect and interpret adverse changes in a structure like a pressure vessel. Different types of methods will be proposed for damage detection based on comparing signals to baseline recorded from the undamaged structure. Guided wave based diagnosis method is one of the most effective used techniques due to its sensitivity to small defects. The paper pretend to identify the more adequate inspection methods to classify by smart rules based in artificial intelligence the effect of an impact on the structural integrity of the pressure vessel thus improving the level of safety.
Comparison of Regulations Codes and Standards for Hydrogen Refueling Stations in Japan and France
Sep 2019
Publication
The states of Regulations Codes and Standards (RCS) of hydrogen refueling stations (HRSs) in Japan and France are compared and specified items to understand correspondence and differences among each RCSs for realizing harmonization in RCS. Japan has been trying to reform its RCSs to reduce HRS installation and operation costs as a governmental target. Specific crucial regulatory items such as safety distances mitigation means materials for hydrogen storage and certification of anti-explosion proof equipments are compared in order to identify the origins of the current obstacles for disseminating HRS.
Hydrogen Explosion Hazards Limitation in Battery Rooms with Different Ventilation Systems
Sep 2019
Publication
When charging most types of industrial lead-acid batteries hydrogen gas is emitted. A large number of batteries especially in relatively small areas/enclosures and in the absence of an adequate ventilation system may create an explosion hazard. This paper describes full scale tests in confined space which demonstrate conditions that can occur in a battery room in the event of a ventilation system breakdown. Over the course of the tests full scale hydrogen emission experiments were performed to study emission time and flammable cloud formation according to the assumed emission velocity. On this basis the characteristics of dispersion of hydrogen in the battery room were obtained. The CFD model Fire Dynamic Simulator (NIST) was used for confirmation that the lack of ventilation in a battery room can be the cause of an explosive atmosphere developing and leading to a potential huge explosive hazard. It was demonstrated that different ventilation systems provide battery rooms with varying efficiencies of hydrogen removal. The most effective type appeared to be natural ventilation which proved more effective than mechanical means.
Computational Analysis of Hydrogen Diffusion in Polycrystalline Nickel and Anisotropic Polygonal Micro, Nano Grain Size Effects
Sep 2013
Publication
The effect of irregular polygonal grain size and random grain boundary on hydrogen diffusion in polycrystalline nickel is investigated. Hydrogen diffusion behavior in micropolycrystalline nickel is compared with that in nanopolycrystalline nickel through numerical analysis. The two dimensional computational finite element microstructural and nanostructural analyses are based on Fick's law corresponding to heterogeneous polycrystalline model geometry. The heterogeneous polycrystalline model consists of random irregular polygonal grains. These grains are divided into internal grain and grain boundary regions the size of which is determined from the grain size. The computational analysis results show that hydrogen diffusion in nanostructural irregular polycrystalline nickel is higher in magnitude than the microstructural irregular polycrystalline nickel. However models of voids traps and micro and nano clustered grains are yet to be included.
Hydrogen Fueling Standardization: Enabling ZEVs with "Same as Today" Fueling and FCEV Range and Safety
Oct 2015
Publication
Zero Emission Vehicles (ZEVs) are necessary to help reduce the emissions in the transportation sector which is responsible for 40% of overall greenhouse gas emissions. There are two types of ZEVs Battery Electric Vehicles (BEVs) and Fuel Cell Electric Vehicles (FCEVs) Commercial Success of BEVs has been challenging thus far also due to limited range and very long charging duration. FCEVs using H2 infrastructure with SAE J2601 and J2799 standards can be consistently fuelled in a safe manner fast and resulting in a range similar to conventional vehicles. Specifically fuelling with SAE J2601 with the SAE J2799 enables FCEVs to fill with hydrogen in 3-5 minutes and to achieve a high State of Charge (SOC) resulting in 300+ mile range without exceeding the safety storage limits. Standardized H2 therefore gives an advantage to the customer over electric charging. SAE created this H2 fuelling protocol based on modelling laboratory and field tests. These SAE standards enable the first generation of commercial FCEVs and H2 stations to achieve a customer acceptable fueling similar to today's experience. This report details the advantages of hydrogen and the validation of H2 fuelling for the SAE standards.
Status, Gaps and Recommendations Regarding Standardisation and the Use of Hydrogen in Sustainable Buildings
Sep 2013
Publication
The use of and interpretation of Regulations Codes and Standards is important input when developing hydrogen systems and applications. This paper presents the work related to standardisation undertaken by DNV as part of the EU supported project H2SusBuild. During the H2SusBuild project a renewable (solar and wind) based full scale energy system with components for hydrogen storage hydrogen production by electrolysis and hydrogen consumption by fuel cell and burner was built and integrated into an existing office building in Lavrion Greece. The relevant standards identified and applied the standardisation gaps identified and the recommendations made for further standardisation activities are presented.
No more items...