Applications & Pathways
Greedy Energy Management Strategy and Sizing Method for a Stand-alone Microgrid with Hydrogen Storage
Nov 2021
Publication
This paper presents a greedy energy management strategy based on model predictive control (MPC) for a stand-alone microgrid powered by photovoltaic (PV) arrays and equipped with batteries and a power-to-hydrogen-to-power (P2H2P) system. The proposed strategy consists of a day-ahead plan and an intra-day dispatch method. In the planning stage the sequence of plan is to determine the power of each storage device for a certain period which is initially generated under the principle that PV arrays have the highest priority followed by the batteries and finally the P2H2P system using short-term forecast data of both load and solar irradiance. The initial plan can be optimized with objectives of harvesting more PV generation in storage and minimizing unmet load through rescheduling P2H2P system and batteries. Three parameters including reserved capacity of batteries predischarge coefficient of fuel cell (FC) and greedy coefficient of electrolyzer (EL) are introduced during plan optimization process to enhance the robustness against forecast errors. In the dispatching stage the energy dispatch is subject to the scheduled plan and the operational constraints. To demonstrate the capabilities of the proposed strategy a case study is performed for a hotel with a mean power consumption of 1567 kWh/day based on the system configuration optimized by HOMER software in comparison with the load following (LF) strategy and the global optimum solution solved by mixed integer linear programing (MILP). The simulation results show that the annual unmet load using the proposed strategy is reduced from 13434 kWh to 2370 kWh which is 528 kWh lower than the optimum solution. Meanwhile the cost of energy (COE) of the proposed strategy decreases by US$ 0.08/kWh compared to the LF strategy and is equal to the optimum solution. Finally the performance of configuration optimization employing genetic algorithm (GA) under different energy management strategies is investigated with the objective function of minimizing the net present cost (NPC). Furthermore the robustness of the proposed strategy is studied. The results show that the proposed strategy gives an NPC and COE of US$ 2.4 million (Mn) and US$ 0.43/kWh which are 23.4% and 9.7% lower than those of systems utilizing the SoC-based strategy and the LF strategy respectively. The results also demonstrate that the strategy is robust against forecast errors especially for overestimated forecast models.
Are Sustainable Aviation Fuels a Viable Option for Decarbonizing Air Transport in Europe? An Environmental and Economic Sustainability Assessment
Jan 2022
Publication
The use of drop-in capable alternative fuels in aircraft can support the European aviation sector to achieve its goals for sustainable development. They can be a transitional solution in the short and medium term as their use does not require any structural changes to the aircraft powertrain. However the production of alternative fuels is often energy-intensive and some feedstocks are associated with harmful effects on the environment. In addition alternative fuels are often more expensive to produce than fossil kerosene which can make their use unattractive. Therefore this paper analyzes the environmental and economic impacts of four types of alternative fuels compared to fossil kerosene in a well-to-wake perspective. The fuels investigated are sustainable aviation fuels produced by power-to-liquid and biomass-to-liquid pathways. Life cycle assessment and life cycle costing are used as environmental and economic assessment methods. The results of this well-towake analysis reveal that the use of sustainable aviation fuels can reduce the environmental impacts of aircraft operations. However an electricity mix based on renewable energies is needed to achieve significant reductions. In addition from an economic perspective the use of fossil kerosene ranks best among the alternatives. A scenario analysis confirms this result and shows that the production of sustainable aviation fuels using an electricity mix based solely on renewable energy can lead to significant reductions in environmental impact but economic competitiveness remains problematic.
Decarbonizing the German Industrial Thermal Energy Use with Solar, Hydrogen, and Other Options - Recommendations for the World
Nov 2022
Publication
This paper is based on a position paper of the German Industry Association Concentrated Solar Power e.V. to the German government and discusses options on how to decarbonize the heat demand of the domestic industry. Among other option concentration solar collectors are a suitable option in Germany which has not been expected by many experts. The paper derives requirements that are needed to ensure a quick and sustainable way to decarbonize industrial heat demand. They are considered to also be relevant for many other countries that follow the same ambition to become climate neutral in the next decades. They major statements are: A mix of different renewable energy technologies in conjunction with efficiency measures is needed to ensure a secure climate-friendly and cost-efficient heat supply for the industry; The different technology options for the provision of heat from renewable sources through electrification and through hydrogen can and must be combined and integrated with each other. In this context concentrating solar thermal represents an important part of the hybrid supply portfolio of a decarbonized industry This requires: The definition of an expansion target for process heat and the flanking measures; Ensuring the equivalence of renewable heat renewable electricity and green hydrogen - also as hybrid solutions; The promotion of concentrating solar thermal reference projects as an impetus for market ramp-up in Germany; The launch of an information campaign for heat consumers and the establishment of a pool of consultants.
CO2 Emissions Reduction through Increasing H2 Participation in Gaseous Combustible—Condensing Boilers Functional Response
Apr 2022
Publication
Considering the imperative reduction in CO2 emissions both from household heating and hot water producing facilities one of the mainstream directions is to reduce hydrocarbons in combustibles by replacing them with hydrogen. The authors analyze condensing boilers operating when hydrogen is mixed with standard gaseous fuel (CH4 ). The hydrogen (H2 ) volumetric participation in the mixture is considered to vary in the range of 0 to 20%. The operation of the condensing boilers will be numerically modeled by computational programs and prior validated by experimental studies concluded in a European Certified Laboratory. The study concluded that an increase in the combustible flow with 16% will compensate the maximum H2 concentration situation with no other implications on the boiler’s thermal efficiency together with a decrease in CO2 emissions by approximately 7%. By assuming 0.9 (to/year/boiler) the value of CO2 emissions reduction for the condensing boiler determined in the paper and extrapolating it for the estimated number of boilers to be sold for the period 2019–2024 a 254700-ton CO2/year reduction resulted.
Performance Estimation of a Downsized SI Engine Running with Hydrogen
Jun 2022
Publication
Hydrogen is a carbon-free fuel that can be produced in many ways starting from different sources. Its use as a fuel in internal combustion engines could be a method of significantly reducing their environmental impact. In spark-ignition (SI) engines lean hydrogen–air mixtures can be burnt. When a gaseous fuel like hydrogen is port-injected in an SI engine working with lean mixtures supercharging becomes very useful in order not to excessively penalize the engine performance. In this work the performance of a turbocharged PFI spark-ignition engine fueled by hydrogen has been investigated by means of 1-D numerical simulations. The analysis focused on the engine behavior both at full and partial load considering low and medium engine speeds (1500 and 3000 rpm). Equivalence ratios higher than 0.35 have been considered in order to ensure acceptable cycle-to-cycle variations. The constraints that ensure the safety of engine components have also been respected. The results of the analysis provide a guideline able to set up the load control strategy of a SI hydrogen engine based on the variation of the air to fuel ratio boost pressure and throttle opening. Furthermore performance and efficiency of the hydrogen engine have been compared to those of the base gasoline engine. At 1500 and 3000 rpm except for very low loads the hydrogen engine load can be regulated by properly combining the equivalence ratio and the boost pressure. At 3000 rpm the gasoline engine maximum power is not reached but for each engine load lean burning allows the hydrogen engine achieving much higher efficiencies than those of the gasoline engine. At full load the maximum power output decreases from 120 kW to about 97 kW but the engine efficiency of the hydrogen engine is higher than that of the gasoline one for each full load operating point.
A Review on Industrial Perspectives and Challenges on Material, Manufacturing, Design and Development of Compressed Hydrogen Storage Tanks for the Transportation Sector
Jul 2022
Publication
Hydrogen fuel cell technology is securing a place in the future of advanced mobility and the energy revolution as engineers explore multiple paths in the quest for decarbonization. The feasibility of hydrogen-based fuel cell vehicles particularly relies on the development of safe lightweight and cost-competitive solutions for hydrogen storage. After the demonstration of hundreds of prototype vehicles today commercial hydrogen tanks are in the first stages of market introduction adopting configurations that use composite materials. However production rates remain low and costs high. This paper intends to provide an insight into the evolving scenario of solutions for hydrogen storage in the transportation sector. Current applications in different sectors of transport are covered focusing on their individual requirements. Furthermore this work addresses the efforts to produce economically attractive composite tanks discussing the challenges surrounding material choices and manufacturing practices as well as cutting-edge trends pursued by research and development teams. Key issues in the design and analysis of hydrogen tanks are also discussed. Finally testing and certification requirements are debated once they play a vital role in industry acceptance.
Islanded Ammonia Power Systems: Technology Review & Conceptual Process Design
Aug 2019
Publication
Recent advances in technologies for the decentralized islanded ammonia economy are reviewed with an emphasis on feasibility for long-term practical implementation. The emphasis in this review is on storage systems in the size range of 1–10 MW. Alternatives for hydrogen production nitrogen production ammonia synthesis ammonia separation ammonia storage and ammonia combustion are compared and evaluated. A conceptual process design based on the optimization of temperature and pressure levels of existing and recently proposed technologies is presented for an islanded ammonia energy system. This process design consists of wind turbines and solar panels for electricity generation a battery for short-term energy storage an electrolyzer for hydrogen production a pressure swing adsorption unit for nitrogen production a novel ruthenium-based catalyst for ammonia synthesis a supported metal halide for ammonia separation and storage and an ammonia fueled proton-conducting solid oxide fuel cell for electricity generation. In a generic location in northern Europe it is possible to operate the islanded energy system at a round-trip efficiency of 61% and at a cost of about 0.30–0.35 € kWh−1 .
Fuel Cells for Shipping: To Meet On-board Auxiliary Demand and Reduce Emissions
Feb 2021
Publication
The reduction of harmful emissions from the international shipping sector is necessary. On-board energy demand can be categorised as either: propulsion or auxiliary services. Auxiliary services contribute a significant proportion of energy demand with major loads including: compressors pumps and HVAC (heating ventilation and air-conditioning). Typically this demand is met using the same fuel source as the main propulsion (i.e. fossil fuels). This study has analysed whether emissions from large scale ships could feasibly be reduced by meeting auxiliary demand by installing a hydrogen fuel cell using data from an LNG tanker to develop a case study. Simulations have shown that for a capacity of 10 x 40ft containers of compressed hydrogen the optimal fuel cell size would be 3 MW and this could save 10600 MWh of fossil fuel use equivalent to 2343 t of CO2. Hence this could potentially decarbonise a significant proportion of shipping energy demand. Although there are some notable technical and commercial considerations such as fuel cell lifetime and capital expenditure requirements. Results imply that if auxiliary loads could be managed to avoid peaks in demand this could further increase the effectiveness of this concept.
Photovoltaic and Hydrogen Plant Integrated with a Gas Heat Pump for Greenhouse Heating: A Mathematical Study
Feb 2018
Publication
Nowadays the traditional energy sources used for greenhouse heating are fossil fuels such as LPG diesel and natural gas. The global energy demand will continue to grow and alternative technologies need to be developed in order to improve the sustainability of crop production in protected environments. Innovative solutions are represented by renewable energy plants such as photovoltaic wind and geothermal integrated systems however these technologies need to be connected to the power grid in order to store the energy produced. On agricultural land power grids are not widespread and stand-alone renewable energy systems should be investigated especially for greenhouse applications. The aim of this research is to analyze by means of a mathematical model the energy efficiency of a photovoltaic (8.2 kW) hydrogen (2.5 kW) and ground source gas heat pump (2.2 kW) integrated in a stand-alone system used for heating an experimental greenhouse tunnel (48 m2 ) during the winter season. A yearlong energy performance analysis was conducted for three different types of greenhouse cover materials a single layer polyethylene film an air inflated-double layer polyethylene film and a double acrylic or polycarbonate. The results of one year showed that the integrated system had a total energy efficiency of 14.6%. Starting from the electric energy supplied by the photovoltaic array the total efficiency of the hydrogen and ground source gas heat pump system was 112% if the coefficient of the performance of the heat pump is equal to 5. The heating system increased the greenhouse air temperatures by 3–9 ◦C with respect to the external air temperatures depending on the greenhouse cover material used.
Source-to-sink Efficiency of Blue and Green District Heating and Hydrogen-based Heat Supply Systems
Apr 2022
Publication
Hydrogen is commonly mentioned as a future proof energy carrier. Hydrogen supporters 6 advocate for repurposing existing natural gas grids for a sustainable hydrogen supply. While the 7 long-term vision of the hydrogen community is green hydrogen the community acknowledges that 8 in the short term it will be to large extent manufactured from natural gas but in a decarbonized 9 way giving it the name blue hydrogen. While hydrogen has a role to play in hard to decarbonize 10 sectors its role for building heating demands is doubtful as mature and more energy efficient alter- 11 natives exist. As building heat supply infrastructures built today will operate for the decades to 12 come it is of highest importance to ensure that the most efficient and sustainable infrastructures are 13 chosen. This paper compares the source to sink efficiencies of hydrogen-based heat supply system 14 to a district heating system operating on the same primary energy source. The results show that a 15 natural gas-based district heating could be 267% more efficient and consequently have significantly 16 lower global warming potential than a blue hydrogen-based heat supply A renewable power-based 17 district heating could achieve above 440% higher efficiency than green hydrogen-based heat supply 18 system.
Development of a Hydrogen Fuel Cell Prototype Vehicle Supported by Artificial Intelligence for Green Urban Transport
Mar 2024
Publication
In the automotive sector the zero emissions area has been dominated by battery electric vehicles. However prospective users cite charging times large batteries and the deployment of charging stations as a counter-argument. Hydrogen will offer a solution to these areas in the future. This research focuses on the development of a prototype three-wheeled vehicle that is named Neumann H2. It integrates state-of-the-art energy storage systems demonstrating the benefits of solar- battery- and hydrogen-powered drives. Of crucial importance for the R&D platform is the system’s ability to record its internal states in a time-synchronous format providing valuable data for researchers and developers. Given that the platform is equipped with the ROS2 Open-Source interface the data are recorded in a standardized format. Energy management is supported by artificial intelligence of the “Reinforcement Learning” type which selects the optimal energy source for operation based on different layers of high-fidelity maps. In addition to powertrain control the vehicle also uses artificial intelligence to detect the environment. The vehicle’s environment-sensing system is essentially designed to detect distinguish and select environmental elements through image segmentation using camera images and then to provide feedback to the user via displays.
Study of Heat Loss Mechanism in Argon-circulated Hydrogen Engine Combustion Chamber Wall Surface Conditions
Jul 2022
Publication
Hydrogen fuel in internal combustion engine gives a very big advantage to the transportation sector especially in solving the greenhouse emission problem. However there are only few research discovered the ability of argon as a working gas in hydrogen combustion in internal combustion engine. The high temperature rises from the argon compression tend to result in heat loss problem. This research aims to study the heat loss mechanism on wall surface condition in the combustion chamber. Experiments were conducted to study the effects of different heat flux sensor locations and the effect of ignition delay on heat flux. Local heat flux measurement was collected and images were observed using high speed shadowgraph images. The ignition delay that occurred near the combustion wall will result in larger heat loss throughout the combustion process. Higher ambient pressure results in a bigger amount of heat flux value. Other fundamental characteristics were obtained and discussed which may help in contributing the local heat loss data of an argon-circulated hydrogen engine in future engine operation.
On-Board Cold Thermal Energy Storage System for Hydrogen Fueling Process
Feb 2019
Publication
The hydrogen storage pressure in fuel cell vehicles has been increased from 35 MPa to 70 MPa in order to accommodate longer driving range. On the downside such pressure increase results in significant temperature rise inside the hydrogen tank during fast filling at a fueling station which may pose safety issues. Installation of a chiller often mitigates this concern because it cools the hydrogen gas before its deposition into the tank. To address both the energy efficiency improvement and safety concerns this paper proposed an on-board cold thermal energy storage (CTES) system cooled by expanded hydrogen. During the driving cycle the proposed system uses an expander instead of a pressure regulator to generate additional power and cold hydrogen gas. Moreover CTES is equipped with phase change materials (PCM) to recover the cold energy of the expanded hydrogen gas which is later used in the next filling to cool the high-pressure hydrogen gas from the fueling station.
Research on the Flexibility Margin of an Electric–Hydrogen Coupling Energy Block Based on Model Predictive Control
Apr 2022
Publication
Hydrogen energy plays an important role in the transformation of low-carbon energy and electric–hydrogen coupling will become a typical energy scenario. Aiming at the operation flexibility of a low-carbon electricity–hydrogen coupling system with high proportion of wind power and photovoltaic this work studies the flexibility margin of an electricity–hydrogen coupling energy block based on model predictive control. By analyzing the power exchange characteristics of heterogeneous energy the homogenization models of various heterogeneous energy sources are established. According to the analysis of power system flexibility margin three dimensions of flexibility margin evaluation indexes are defined from the dimension of system operation and an electricity–hydrogen coupling energy block scheduling model is established. The model predictive control algorithm is used to optimize the power balance operation of the electro–hydrogen coupling energy block and the flexibility margin of the energy block is quantitatively analyzed and calculated. Through the example analysis it is verified that the calculation method proposed in this article can not only realize the online power balance optimization of the electric–hydrogen coupling energy block but also effectively quantify the operation flexibility margin of the electric–hydrogen coupling energy block.
Recent Developments of Proton Exchange Membranes for PEMFC: A Review
Sep 2022
Publication
The decreasing abundance of conventional energy resources of nature such as crude oil natural gas and coal is putting forward the issues of energy shortcoming for the future. With a sentiment of this most researchers are now directing either on non-conventional resources that already prevail or invent it. The most promising non-conventional energy resource is the hydrogen energy which can be used in fuel cell to get electricity. Therefore a number of researchers are putting a light on developing the most efficient and affordable fuel cell. This review is mainly focused on the developments of proton exchange membranes (PEMs) in two parts as low and high temperature PEMs for proton exchange membrane fuel cell (PEMFC) and based on that some outperformed PEMs are mentioned in the respective tables. Most of the energy and automobile industries are concentrating to apply PEMFCs for power generation and to apply in vehicles. The cost of PEMFCs is higher due to the manufacturing cost of PEM. Therefore research works in PEMs are now in trend to reduce the cost to improve efficiency and to withstand particular operating conditions. In this review article recent developments in PEM by number of researchers and the importance of it in near future have been elicited.
A Prompt Decarbonization Pathway for Shipping: Green Hydrogen, Ammonia, and Methanol Production and Utilization in Marine Engines
Mar 2023
Publication
The shipping industry has reached a higher level of maturity in terms of its knowledge and awareness of decarbonization challenges. Carbon-free or carbon-neutralized green fuel such as green hydrogen green ammonia and green methanol are being widely discussed. However little attention has paid to the green fuel pathway from renewable energy to shipping. This paper therefore provides a review of the production methods for green power (green hydrogen green ammonia and green methanol) and analyzes the potential of green fuel for application to shipping. The review shows that the potential production methods for green hydrogen green ammonia and green methanol for the shipping industry are (1) hydrogen production from seawater electrolysis using green power; (2) ammonia production from green hydrogen + Haber–Bosch process; and (3) methanol production from CO2 using green power. While the future of green fuel is bright in the short term the costs are expected to be higher than conventional fuel. Our recommendations are therefore as follows: improve green power production technology to reduce the production cost; develop electrochemical fuel production technology to increase the efficiency of green fuel production; and explore new technology. Strengthening the research and development of renewable energy and green fuel production technology and expanding fuel production capacity to ensure an adequate supply of low- and zero-emission marine fuel are important factors to achieve carbon reduction in shipping.
Life-cycle Assessment of Hydrogen Utilization in Power Generation: A Systematic Review of Technological and Methodological Choices
Jul 2022
Publication
Interest in reducing the greenhouse gas emissions from conventional power generation has increased the focus on the potential use of hydrogen to produce electricity. Numerous life-cycle assessment (LCA) studies of hydrogen-based power generation have been published. This study reviews the technological and methodological choices made in hydrogen-based power generation LCAs. A systematic review was chosen as the research method to achieve a comprehensive and minimally biased overview of hydrogen-based power generation LCAs. Relevant articles published between 2004 and 2021 were identified by searching the Scopus and Web of Science databases. Electrolysis from renewable energy resources was the most widely considered type of hydrogen production in the LCAs analyzed. Fuel cell technology was the most common conversion equipment used in hydrogen-based electricity LCAs. A significant number of scenarios examine the use of hydrogen for energy storage and co-generation purposes. Based on qualitative analysis the methodological choices of LCAs vary between studies in terms of the functional units allocations system boundaries and life-cycle impact assessment methods chosen. These discrepancies were likely to influence the value of the environmental impact results. The findings of the reviewed LCAs could provide an environmental profile of hydrogen-based electricity systems identify hotspots drive future research define performance goals and establish a baseline for their large-scale deployment.
Hybrid Renewable Hydrogen Energy Solution for Application in Remote Mines
Dec 2020
Publication
Mining operations in remote locations rely heavily on diesel fuel for the electricity haulage and heating demands. Such significant diesel dependency imposes large carbon footprints to these mines. Consequently mining companies are looking for better energy strategies to lower their carbon footprints. Renewable energies can relieve this over-reliance on fossil fuels. Yet in spite of their many advantages renewable systems deployment on a large scale has been very limited mainly due to the high battery storage system. Using hydrogen for energy storage purposes due to its relatively cheaper technology can facilitate the application of renewable energies in the mining industry. Such cost-prohibitive issues prevent achieving 100% penetration rate of renewables in mining applications. This paper offers a novel integrated renewable–multi-storage (wind turbine/battery/fuel cell/thermal storage) solution with six different configurations to secure 100% off-grid mining power supply as a stand-alone system. A detailed comparison between the proposed configurations is presented with recommendations for implementation. A parametric study is also performed identifying the effect of different parameters (i.e. wind speed battery market price and fuel cell market price) on economics of the system. The result of the present study reveals that standalone renewable energy deployment in mine settings is technically and economically feasible with the current market prices depending on the average wind speed at the mine location.
Trends in the Global Steel Industry: Evolutionary Projections and Defossilisation Pathways through Power-to-steel
Sep 2022
Publication
Steel production is a carbon and energy intensive activity releasing 1.9 tons of CO2 and requiring 5.17 MWh of primary energy per ton produced on average globally resulting in 9% of all anthropogenic CO2 emissions. To achieve the goals of the Paris Agreement of limiting global temperature increase to below 1.5 °C compared to pre-industrial levels the structure of the global steel production must change fundamentally. There are several technological paths towards a lower carbon intensity for steelmaking which bring with them a paradigm shift decoupling CO2 emissions from crude steel production by transitioning from traditional methods of steel production using fossil coal and fossil methane to those based on low-cost renewable electricity and green hydrogen. However the energy system consequences of fully defossilised steelmaking has not yet been examined in detail. This research examines the energy system requirements a global defossilised power-to-steel industry using a GDP-based demand model for global steel demands which projects a growth in steel demand from 1.6 Gt in 2020 to 2.4 Gt in 2100. Three scenarios are developed to investigate the emissions trajectory energy demands and economics of a high penetration of direct hydrogen reduction and electrowinning in global steel production. Results indicate that the global steel industry will see green hydrogen demands grow significantly ranging from 2809 to 4371 TWhH2 by 2050. Under the studied conditions global steel production is projected to see reductions in final thermal energy demand of between 38.3% and 57.7% and increases in total electricity demand by factors between 15.1 and 13.3 by 2050 depending on the scenario. Furthermore CO2 emissions from steelmaking can be reduced to zero.
Numerical Study on Hydrogen–Gasoline Dual-Fuel Spark Ignition Engine
Nov 2022
Publication
Hydrogen as a suitable and clean energy carrier has been long considered a primary fuel or in combination with other conventional fuels such as gasoline and diesel. Since the density of hydrogen is very low in port fuel-injection configuration the engine’s volumetric efficiency reduces due to the replacement of hydrogen by intake air. Therefore hydrogen direct in-cylinder injection (injection after the intake valve closes) can be a suitable solution for hydrogen utilization in spark ignition (SI) engines. In this study the effects of hydrogen direct injection with different hydrogen energy shares (HES) on the performance and emissions characteristics of a gasoline port-injection SI engine are investigated based on reactive computational fluid dynamics. Three different injection timings of hydrogen together with five different HES are applied at low and full load on a hydrogen– gasoline dual-fuel SI engine. The results show that retarded hydrogen injection timing increases the concentration of hydrogen near the spark plug resulting in areas with higher average temperatures which led to NOX emission deterioration at −120 Crank angle degree After Top Dead Center (CAD aTDC) start of injection (SOI) compared to the other modes. At −120 CAD aTDC SOI for 50% HES the amount of NOX was 26% higher than −140 CAD aTDC SOI. In the meanwhile an advanced hydrogen injection timing formed a homogeneous mixture of hydrogen which decreased the HC and soot concentration so that −140 CAD aTDC SOI implied the lowest amount of HC and soot. Moreover with the increase in the amount of HES the concentrations of CO CO2 and soot were reduced. Having the HES by 50% at −140 CAD aTDC SOI the concentrations of particulate matter (PM) CO and CO2 were reduced by 96.3% 90% and 46% respectively. However due to more complete combustion and an elevated combustion average temperature the amount of NOX emission increased drastically.
No more items...